There's a WW in Michigan Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Well since dy was a wolf, that lowers mel from being wolfy imo. So back to craycray

unlynch mel
lynch cray

But also noting the mel/cowgirl/pippy stuff because if mel's not a wolf, he's probably not lying so is pippy? But she hasn't really seemed wolfy today. Would be weird for her to come back chaos... (just trying to figure out what I think of this situation)
Click to expand...
Why would one of us have to be lying in this situation?
 
LyraGardenia said:
In Finny's How to Get Away With Murder game when I was a wolf, we were given cover roles, so I don't know that I'd put much stock into role claims..
Click to expand...

Coopah said:
Even though it will be detrimental to me, I don't think allie is a wolf. I just don't think it would've happened the way it did. She has a role claim that yes might be a cover but might be the truth. I don't think we should go that way.
Click to expand...

SportPonies said:
This reads to me in the same tone that I felt at the end of Genesis and being lynched for revealing my vig kill. I'm certainly not defending allie, but it maybe gives her a village point in my (hypothetical) book. At this point in the game, it probably can't hurt to lynch her (besides losing a possible villager), and see if there really are cover roles if she's a wolf... But I'm not buying it as well as other people seem to be.
.
Click to expand...

Karabiner13 said:
Have we really established this or is it just an idea that someone floated that caused confusion in the allieh lynch? All I've seen is a wolf who didn't respond and a wolf who gave ability but not name. Seems less like cover roles to me
Click to expand...
Kara, please see above. Probably agree that established was too strong a word after going back and looking at these. I really just meant that crayola giving some one their role name might not mean anything.
 
PippyPony said:
Why would one of us have to be lying in this situation?
Click to expand...

Sigh. I thought you guys were saying opposite things happened, but tbh it was really confusing so not even sure if thats right. If you subtract all that kerfuffle, I would lean all three you towards village.
 
So if the wolves wanted to narrow down where johnna got her info from, they'd go after me or vmh. I think FTB has been misconstruing my participation level today. Yeah, I know I've been away, but I did post about being skeptical of dy's role claim today, not just a single post about having a posting restriction that FTB seems to have latched onto.

lynch FTB
 
Karabiner13 said:
Weren't you the one in KD's game who was saying the rezzer needed to sit down and talk to the vig about timing? Seems like you're going against that thought in this post. I could be recalling incorrectly. You did end up on a good vote though
Click to expand...
That was when the vigilante did not kill Jil after she had been tied for at least one lynch and also then had a lynch avoidance. Was much further into the game, was absolutely a scenario when I would advocate taking a shot at someone.

This was N2 and Coop was virtually off the board yesterday -- not exactly a long-standing village question that needed to be resolved more quickly with an assassin kill. Super different scenarios.

Also rezzes in that game happened late. This one happened at appropriately village time -- as soon as possible.
 
TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo said:
Where is this Dy/Mel interaction that people are referring to?
Click to expand...

Page 1 and 2. I mean it could be contrived wolf/wolf, but being so early into D1 it sounds more genuine just like two people who have played a lot but not with each other ever - like both don't know each other's afflilation if that makes sense.
 
SportPonies said:
I'm not convinced Cray is a wolf.

All I've read all day is the same convoluted, cyclical thinking that she usually falls into, and she sent me a huge, frustrated PM about this lynch push. It seems like normal Cray to me, and the PM seemed sincere.

I'm certainly not putting my vote there today unless something completely blows up.
Click to expand...
Things we encouraged her to do as a wolf when she was a wolf with us:
- Post as much volume as possible
- Push back like hell on anyone who was pressuring her, including retaliatory voting them
- Complain about being lynched as part of aforementioned long windy posts and PMs

She has enough soft vouches for greenies and flip flops on dy built into those long posts that it is still super duper weirding me out.

ETA: and those kill targets, bruh...she would want me and LIS gone. Am pretty certain of that, almost to the point where I am giving her half a village point because it could look like framing.
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
she seemed to want to die, so either wolf brag or goal was to get lynched? I think that was a chaos goal in one of the last 4 games but that person screwed it up before getting themselves lynched?
Click to expand...
The Bar game that Trilt and I modded. Chaos had to lynch a wolf, a villager, and then get themselves lynched.
 
Unofficial Day 3 Lynch Tally
staff () -
SoFlo (2) - Lyra, kata
Mel (3) - Sporty, Jil, Fern
Cray (8) - Kara, Coop, Pippy, jboo, Paws, 3m, DVMD, Snowy
Pippy (1) - Cray
genny (2) - kc, vmh
kc (1) - FTB
Coop (1) - SoFlo
FTB (2) - cowgirl, genny
Snowy (2) - Mel, AM

22/23
lynch close in 45 minutes
 
So I think Snowy is the village redirector, and I hope the wolves kill her, unless I'm wrong and she's one of them. They should, since as a neutral redirector I killed 3/4 wolves. So yeah, wolves, if you figure out the redirector you should kill them rather than bank on them causing more harm than good for village (unlike say, a vig, maybe). Villager redirects usually aren't lethal, wolf ones are. Don't die in your own crossfire.

I am basing this off the chat between her and Pippy about the redirects and roles, and I think Pippy tried to guess her role, and she made some comment with a wink, and that's when I thought she might be the redirector, otherwise I was with Mel all the way about her sketchiness, although I was also convinced about Mel. But just because you agree with someone that someone else is sketchy doesn't clear them, hence why agreeing with Mel to lynch Snowy, I still wanted to lynch Mel. And this was my always talked about plan to lynch Mel and then Snowy. I also had Dy and KC up on that list, but what-the-**** ever. Day 1 they were TOP, o ye of short memory. I admit I backburnered them for various reasons that was mostly "they don't sound as sketch now, and oh lookie, Mel/Snowy/Pippy/Cowgirl."

I'm not going to go dig up the posts that made me think Snowy was redirector for you guys, this was more than I wanted to say anyway, because I wasn't trying to get her killed by wolves. Until now. I'm not putting more work into this game than I have already.

I'm surprised no one thought Pippy coming back and no longer having it out for Mel was odd. She also really danced around answering about that, and I did in fact mention that before the Dy info. Funny how it was literally on the tails of me pressuring her for that, that she called me out.

Where I stood on Pippy and Mel really stood around how I read the Mel/Dy exchange earlier and what happened with Pippy. I said more than once, that of the 3, Mel/Pippy/Cowgirl, I felt AT LEAST one had to be a wolf. Mel came on with a good defense post AND Dy was wolf AND I didn't read it as wolf/wolf. So I voted for my next wolf/surely must die eventually candidate. It's all in black and white. See what you want.

Go ahead. Trust those 4. I told you why I moved off Snowy and Mel, but that's not ironclad. I don't trust the rez. Cowgirl just isn't reading wolf to me, I'm putting the chances of that around the chances it was just Mel's hint on thread that did it. Still don't trust Pippy. My point isn't that I'm right about any of it; my point is that none of this makes me wolfy. Just potentially wrong.

For all I know, this is a plot between Mel and Pippy that is not in the village's favor.

Also,

CrayCray - You are Bronner's Christmas Wonderland Do you like Christmas? Wally Bronner obviously did because he founded "the World's Largest Christmas Store"--Bronner's Christmas Wonderland--in 1945. Bronner's personalizes 400,000+ ornaments every year and has billboards in seven different states, the most distant one being located near Ocala, Florida. With a little (or a lot) of Christmas magic, you are able to survive one night kill attempt.

Now, watch as this does nothing to save me, as I can't prove the ability, and even if I wasn't lynched, the wolves will not bother to night kill me, knowing I have no good power role, and that every day I live my ability is unconfirmed, I look sketch, they look good, and that it takes 2 kills to kill me. It's not the end of the world for you guys to lynch me, except that if you weren't set on lynching me and had left me to the wolves, that's an extra night to hunt wolves.

Good job on the bandwagon on me to hide the wolves and silent players.

Unlynch Pippy

Lynch Crayola

The only other time I ever wanted the wolves to win this much was when I wolfed.

Have fun guys.
 
vetmedhead said:
Mod write up literally said LIS barely avoided a mod smiting only to die anyway... On a night that we now have confirmed to be a night where wolves had two kills. Pls recalibrate your random threats about village incompetence to be more accurate
Click to expand...
Thank god someone else said this because I just noticed that part of that comment and was about to go bananas lol
 
Crayola227 said:
So I think Snowy is the village redirector, and I hope the wolves kill her, unless I'm wrong and she's one of them. They should, since as a neutral redirector I killed 3/4 wolves. So yeah, wolves, if you figure out the redirector you should kill them rather than bank on them causing more harm than good for village (unlike say, a vig, maybe). Villager redirects usually aren't lethal, wolf ones are. Don't die in your own crossfire.

I am basing this off the chat between her and Pippy about the redirects and roles, and I think Pippy tried to guess her role, and she made some comment with a wink, and that's when I thought she might be the redirector, otherwise I was with Mel all the way about her sketchiness, although I was also convinced about Mel. But just because you agree with someone that someone else is sketchy doesn't clear them, hence why agreeing with Mel to lynch Snowy, I still wanted to lynch Mel. And this was my always talked about plan to lynch Mel and then Snowy. I also had Dy and KC up on that list, but what-the-**** ever. Day 1 they were TOP, o ye of short memory. I admit I backburnered them for various reasons that was mostly "they don't sound as sketch now, and oh lookie, Mel/Snowy/Pippy/Cowgirl."

I'm not going to go dig up the posts that made me think Snowy was redirector for you guys, this was more than I wanted to say anyway, because I wasn't trying to get her killed by wolves. Until now. I'm not putting more work into this game than I have already.

I'm surprised no one thought Pippy coming back and no longer having it out for Mel was odd. She also really danced around answering about that, and I did in fact mention that before the Dy info. Funny how it was literally on the tails of me pressuring her for that, that she called me out.

Where I stood on Pippy and Mel really stood around how I read the Mel/Dy exchange earlier and what happened with Pippy. I said more than once, that of the 3, Mel/Pippy/Cowgirl, I felt AT LEAST one had to be a wolf. Mel came on with a good defense post AND Dy was wolf AND I didn't read it as wolf/wolf. So I voted for my next wolf/surely must die eventually candidate. It's all in black and white. See what you want.

Go ahead. Trust those 4. I told you why I moved off Snowy and Mel, but that's not ironclad. I don't trust the rez. Cowgirl just isn't reading wolf to me, I'm putting the chances of that around the chances it was just Mel's hint on thread that did it. Still don't trust Pippy. My point isn't that I'm right about any of it; my point is that none of this makes me wolfy. Just potentially wrong.

For all I know, this is a plot between Mel and Pippy that is not in the village's favor.

Also,

CrayCray - You are Bronner's Christmas Wonderland Do you like Christmas? Wally Bronner obviously did because he founded "the World's Largest Christmas Store"--Bronner's Christmas Wonderland--in 1945. Bronner's personalizes 400,000+ ornaments every year and has billboards in seven different states, the most distant one being located near Ocala, Florida. With a little (or a lot) of Christmas magic, you are able to survive one night kill attempt.

Now, watch as this does nothing to save me, as I can't prove the ability, and even if I wasn't lynched, the wolves will not bother to night kill me, knowing I have no good power role, and that every day I live my ability is unconfirmed, I look sketch, they look good, and that it takes 2 kills to kill me. It's not the end of the world for you guys to lynch me, except that if you weren't set on lynching me and had left me to the wolves, that's an extra night to hunt wolves.

Good job on the bandwagon on me to hide the wolves and silent players.

Unlynch Pippy

Lynch Crayola

The only other time I ever wanted the wolves to win this much was when I wolfed.

Have fun guys.
Click to expand...
This is like the least wolfy role name imaginable given who one of these mods is, but I literally do not understand the reasoning behind the rest of this post at all.
 
StayingPositive2017 said:
Kara, please see above. Probably agree that established was too strong a word after going back and looking at these. I really just meant that crayola giving some one their role name might not mean anything.
Click to expand...

Thank you, finding who started this was one of the things I was wanting to run down

PippyPony said:
That was when the vigilante did not kill Jil after she had been tied for at least one lynch and also then had a lynch avoidance. Was much further into the game, was absolutely a scenario when I would advocate taking a shot at someone.

This was N2 and Coop was virtually off the board yesterday -- not exactly a long-standing village question that needed to be resolved more quickly with an assassin kill. Super different scenarios.

Also rezzes in that game happened late. This one happened at appropriately village time -- as soon as possible.
Click to expand...

All I really remembered was you saying that and then Sporty quoting it in her mod pm and pretty much going whoops :laugh:
 
Crayola227 said:
So I think Snowy is the village redirector, and I hope the wolves kill her, unless I'm wrong and she's one of them. They should, since as a neutral redirector I killed 3/4 wolves. So yeah, wolves, if you figure out the redirector you should kill them rather than bank on them causing more harm than good for village (unlike say, a vig, maybe). Villager redirects usually aren't lethal, wolf ones are. Don't die in your own crossfire.

I am basing this off the chat between her and Pippy about the redirects and roles, and I think Pippy tried to guess her role, and she made some comment with a wink, and that's when I thought she might be the redirector, otherwise I was with Mel all the way about her sketchiness, although I was also convinced about Mel. But just because you agree with someone that someone else is sketchy doesn't clear them, hence why agreeing with Mel to lynch Snowy, I still wanted to lynch Mel. And this was my always talked about plan to lynch Mel and then Snowy. I also had Dy and KC up on that list, but what-the-**** ever. Day 1 they were TOP, o ye of short memory. I admit I backburnered them for various reasons that was mostly "they don't sound as sketch now, and oh lookie, Mel/Snowy/Pippy/Cowgirl."

I'm not going to go dig up the posts that made me think Snowy was redirector for you guys, this was more than I wanted to say anyway, because I wasn't trying to get her killed by wolves. Until now. I'm not putting more work into this game than I have already.

I'm surprised no one thought Pippy coming back and no longer having it out for Mel was odd. She also really danced around answering about that, and I did in fact mention that before the Dy info. Funny how it was literally on the tails of me pressuring her for that, that she called me out.

Where I stood on Pippy and Mel really stood around how I read the Mel/Dy exchange earlier and what happened with Pippy. I said more than once, that of the 3, Mel/Pippy/Cowgirl, I felt AT LEAST one had to be a wolf. Mel came on with a good defense post AND Dy was wolf AND I didn't read it as wolf/wolf. So I voted for my next wolf/surely must die eventually candidate. It's all in black and white. See what you want.

Go ahead. Trust those 4. I told you why I moved off Snowy and Mel, but that's not ironclad. I don't trust the rez. Cowgirl just isn't reading wolf to me, I'm putting the chances of that around the chances it was just Mel's hint on thread that did it. Still don't trust Pippy. My point isn't that I'm right about any of it; my point is that none of this makes me wolfy. Just potentially wrong.

For all I know, this is a plot between Mel and Pippy that is not in the village's favor.

Also,

CrayCray - You are Bronner's Christmas Wonderland Do you like Christmas? Wally Bronner obviously did because he founded "the World's Largest Christmas Store"--Bronner's Christmas Wonderland--in 1945. Bronner's personalizes 400,000+ ornaments every year and has billboards in seven different states, the most distant one being located near Ocala, Florida. With a little (or a lot) of Christmas magic, you are able to survive one night kill attempt.

Now, watch as this does nothing to save me, as I can't prove the ability, and even if I wasn't lynched, the wolves will not bother to night kill me, knowing I have no good power role, and that every day I live my ability is unconfirmed, I look sketch, they look good, and that it takes 2 kills to kill me. It's not the end of the world for you guys to lynch me, except that if you weren't set on lynching me and had left me to the wolves, that's an extra night to hunt wolves.

Good job on the bandwagon on me to hide the wolves and silent players.

Unlynch Pippy

Lynch Crayola

The only other time I ever wanted the wolves to win this much was when I wolfed.

Have fun guys.
Click to expand...
Bitter much? Get over it. This happens so much, it's not personal it's WW your play has been distracting af and not helpful to the village. I wouldn't be surprised if you flipped wolf still. Your logic hasn't made any sense. Improve your play or take it less seriously. Finn = Fiiiiiinnne
 
Coopah said:
your play has been distracting af and not helpful to the village
Click to expand...
Agreed. I noted this early on in the game as well.
johnnaboo said:
Cray: the whole convo with kcough and with Cray forgetting to put in “lynch” was slightly weird, but what is moreso weird to me is the rambling that followed. Haven’t played with Cray (or anyone) before, so it’s hard to say whether that’s normal or not. But to a new player, the rambling wasn’t very helpful in addressing village concerns and more felt like defensiveness mixed in with really weak speculation.
Click to expand...
 
Unofficial Day 3 Lynch Tally
staff () -
SoFlo (2) - Lyra, kata
Mel (3) - Sporty, Jil, Fern
Cray (9) - Kara, Coop, Pippy, jboo, Paws, 3m, DVMD, Snowy, Cray
Pippy () -
genny (2) - kc, vmh
kc (1) - FTB
Coop (1) - SoFlo
FTB (2) - cowgirl, genny
Snowy (2) - Mel, AM

22/23
lynch close in 30 minutes
 
genny said:
Seems like she thinks redirector is a neutral role? If I'm reading it from the perspective that she's village.
If she's wolfy then who knows what she hoped to accomplish with that.
Click to expand...

No, my point is that wolves should not underestimate a redirector and let them live because they seem sketch and kick up chaos. My point was look how much damage a neutral redirector did to wolves.

So message to wolves: kill the redirector. I think it's Snowy.
 
Crayola227 said:
CrayCray - You are Bronner's Christmas Wonderland Do you like Christmas? Wally Bronner obviously did because he founded "the World's Largest Christmas Store"--Bronner's Christmas Wonderland--in 1945. Bronner's personalizes 400,000+ ornaments every year and has billboards in seven different states, the most distant one being located near Ocala, Florida. With a little (or a lot) of Christmas magic, you are able to survive one night kill attempt.
Click to expand...
For the general interest of everyone, I did just look this up -- it is a real place and is probably Ski's version of Heaven

Bronner's Christmas Wonderland - Wikipedia
 
Animal Midwife said:
Unofficial Day 3 Lynch Tally
staff () -
SoFlo (2) - Lyra, kata
Mel (3) - Sporty, Jil, Fern
Cray (9) - Kara, Coop, Pippy, jboo, Paws, 3m, DVMD, Snowy, Cray
Pippy () -
genny (2) - kc, vmh
kc (1) - FTB
Coop (1) - SoFlo
FTB (2) - cowgirl, genny
Snowy (2) - Mel, AM

22/23
lynch close in 30 minutes
Click to expand...
did we scare away staff? there is no vote here for them...
 
PippyPony said:
This is like the least wolfy role name imaginable given who one of these mods is, but I literally do not understand the reasoning behind the rest of this post at all.
Click to expand...

I am setting the record straight about who I wanted to lynch and why, and why I backed off some of those people.
 
Crayola227 said:
No, my point is that wolves should not underestimate a redirector and let them live because they seem sketch and kick up chaos. My point was look how much damage a neutral redirector did to wolves.

So message to wolves: kill the redirector. I think it's Snowy.
Click to expand...
This is abysmal play if you're a villager. Do the wolves have a restriction about PMing during the day?
 
Coopah said:
Bitter much? Get over it. This happens so much, it's not personal it's WW your play has been distracting af and not helpful to the village. I wouldn't be surprised if you flipped wolf still. Your logic hasn't made any sense. Improve your play or take it less seriously. Finn = Fiiiiiinnne
Click to expand...

Quit it. I wouldn't be surprised if you flipped something.
 
Crayola227 said:
I am setting the record straight about who I wanted to lynch and why, and why I backed off some of those people.
Click to expand...
But there's like...internal contradictions up the wazoo in that post.

I really do not mean to push you this hard; I do actually like you as a player (+ person), but in my personal opinion you have legit gone off the deep end this game. :shrug:
 
genny said:
This is abysmal play if you're a villager. Do the wolves have a restriction about PMing during the day?
Click to expand...

Not a wolf. Just, people were upset I wasn't sharing enough with the class. I want it crystal why I moved off Snowy but wouldn't say before. I want it crystal why I said what I said about my ability.

The abysmal play is trying to use villager code after Allie, and people making a stink about some of my mistakes. The shyte logic and long posts you guys detest, sure. That I didn't know how ties always resolve? When Kara points out I'm newer than Snowy??
 
kcoughli said:
Gonna be honest, still don't see the redirects as wolfy (and no, I'm not the redirector). They feel 100% to me like when Crayola was the redirector back in the game where she took out 80% of the wolf pack on her own using redirection (as a wolf in that game, the devastating accuracy of her plays was just astonishing). She redirected people she thought had power roles onto players she thought were fishy (so pip with a reasonable suspicion of a power role thanks to defense by Mel onto staff who was definitely fishy). The moves make sense to me. I could be 100% wrong, but I also don't think I've seen a wolf redirector in... ever? If the redirector is wolfy then I'll concede that chili doesn't have to have beans, but I just don't feel it.

If dy is a wolf with an every even night bonus kill... I don't really want to wait around for her to use it again.
Click to expand...
Redirecters have very often been wolves. I feel like you should know that.

Crayola227 said:
Lol, that's the thing about my gameplay. As a villager I don't worry about trying not to sound like a wolf. I mean, I've tried because people get upset, but people find me sketch no matter what I try, so I gotta just be me.

I was much more conservative as a wolf, something which people used to tag me. I talked out of it, but ask @Jilary because she seemed the only one who was never really fooled in the slightest. Unless she's a wolf this game trying to mislynch me. Not that I think that's likely, but ya never know.

Could I, with only one more game under my belt (and I died D1) have figured out a new master wolf strategy that plays on being totally wolftastic in a new flavor? All while not seeming my usual villager self? By coming up with bizarre mistakes? Playing as a wolf cub dropped on her head, on purpose??
Click to expand...
I thought you made some really weird (for you) comments earlier in the game, but if you are saying what I think you are saying about your role (in a super non-subtle way) then yeah, you are likely village.
cowgirl92 said:
Cray told me about her ability in PM. I won't say what since she doesn't want to, but it made me more inclined to think she was village. And I fully realize she could have lied to me and if she turns up wolf I'll probably be next, but it seemed fair to speak up.
Click to expand...
So what is your ww experience? Do you know what roles are wolfy and which aren’t?

vetmedhead said:
Oh man, my brain mixed up vanilla ice and outkast somehow. My brain has been quietly shutting down for the past hour or so so I'm not responsible for what references I ruin here
Click to expand...
What?! How could you confuse those two?!

Crayola227 said:
Revealing my ability will not save me, and it will only ruin the ability if for some reason I wasn't lynched.

I've already said my death is going to be like Allie's - totally shyte logic driving it. I'm not telling my role to the ass hats that couldn't follow directions and had to not only get a villager killed, but I suspect LIS' death was in some way related to mod-smiting for not only using villager code as verboten, but then mocking the Michigan amore restriction. I'm not putting fuel on that village fire for my own burning at the stake. You should thank me for not giving you more rope to hang yourselves with, AGAIN.

Rather die with a little dignity.
Click to expand...
I think you missed a major event that clearly accounts for why there were two kills last night. I’m pretty sure it won’t happen again though (thanks coop!)
SoFloGryffindor said:
Lynch Co op!
Click to expand...
I think you may have missed a really big event today.
 
genny said:
So if the wolves wanted to narrow down where johnna got her info from, they'd go after me or vmh. I think FTB has been misconstruing my participation level today. Yeah, I know I've been away, but I did post about being skeptical of dy's role claim today, not just a single post about having a posting restriction that FTB seems to have latched onto.

lynch FTB
Click to expand...
Can you share this please? My laptop is having trouble connecting to the internet.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
 
Crayola227 said:
Not a wolf. Just, people were upset I wasn't sharing enough with the class. I want it crystal why I moved off Snowy but wouldn't say before. I want it crystal why I said what I said about my ability.

The abysmal play is trying to use villager code after Allie, and people making a stink about some of my mistakes. The shyte logic and long posts you guys detest, sure. That I didn't know how ties always resolve? When Kara points out I'm newer than Snowy??
Click to expand...
When I say abysmal, I'm only referring to you pointing to another player as having a power role and asking the wolves to kill them. Your long posts, interesting logic, weird way of making connections, all just part of how you play, and I wouldn't judge someone for style.
 
Crayola227 said:
Not a wolf. Just, people were upset I wasn't sharing enough with the class. I want it crystal why I moved off Snowy but wouldn't say before. I want it crystal why I said what I said about my ability.

The abysmal play is trying to use villager code after Allie, and people making a stink about some of my mistakes. The shyte logic and long posts you guys detest, sure. That I didn't know how ties always resolve? When Kara points out I'm newer than Snowy??
Click to expand...
Jesus girl, it's not personal it's a game!

Also it was painfully obvious what ability you were hinting at (the only logical role that only works if wolves don't know what it is). I think dropping a role name by itself might've been enough, but now you're endorsing a village power role death... Not cool.

We all get mislynched eventually. It totally sucks and sometimes feels like the rest of the village must be *****s because obviously you're village right? But here's the thing, we all accidentally lynch villagers sometimes too. Just the way the game goes.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
 
Jilary said:
So what is your ww experience? Do you know what roles are wolfy and which aren’t?
Click to expand...
This is my first game. I don't know which roles are wolfy and which aren't, I'll freely admit that. That said, I can't think of any way the ability Cray told me would benefit wolves.
 
kcoughli said:
Where you said you were suspicious of dy

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

genny said:
I think Dy’s use of a vig kill is appropriate, just speaking in broad terms of whether to kill vs. not kill. There are too many times when vig abilities go unused. I might have picked coop as a target had I been the vig this game.

However, I’m not sure I believe her ability claim.
Click to expand...

genny said:
Also think it’s interesting that pip and Dy were both redirected. That redirector is pretty good at choosing people with abilities. :thinking:
Click to expand...

I said I was skeptical of her role claim. And I implied I thought she was lying about being redirected.
 
Unofficial Day 3 Lynch Tally
staff () -
SoFlo (3) - Lyra, kata, Fern
Mel (2) - Sporty, Jil
Cray (9) - Kara, Coop, Pippy, jboo, Paws, 3m, DVMD, Snowy, Cray
Pippy () -
genny (2) - kc, vmh
kc (1) - FTB
Coop (1) - SoFlo
FTB (2) - cowgirl, genny
Snowy (2) - Mel, AM

22/23
lynch close in 5 minutes
 
Jilary said:
Redirecters have very often been wolves. I feel like you should know that.
Click to expand...
Literally just went and opened all my old spreadsheets from when I was more motivated and only 2 games had redirectors and both were village (HP by k-dubs and Trilt's faves). So... :shrug:
Possible? Of course. Very often? I wouldn't say so. It feels like a sketch ability, which I think is why it's so often a village one.
 
kcoughli said:
Literally just went and opened all my old spreadsheets from when I was more motivated and only 2 games had redirectors and both were village (HP by k-dubs and Trilt's faves). So... :shrug:
Possible? Of course. Very often? I wouldn't say so. It feels like a sketch ability, which I think is why it's so often a village one.
Click to expand...
There was just a wolf redirector in one of the most recent games, iirc.
 
Melchizedek said:
Oh well in that case :naughty:


It was a dumba** move because by your own logic of there has to be a wolf in cowgirl/me/Pippy and me being cleared, the logical vote would have been Cowgirl because Pippy is the one who practically drove the Dy lynch today. Highly doubtful that she came back rezzed as a wolf and then proceeded to bus a fellow wolf when she could have stuck to lynching me and driving that wagon based on how suspect I was.

If Cray DOES flip wolf I'd be strongly convinced that Cowgirl is worth lynching next because this could have been cray not thinking and reactively lynching Pippy because the other option was a wolf-buddy.

Also the gif was in reference to any game that you were a redirector regardless of alignment, you consistently made **** hit the fan and made me want to duck and cover haha

Michigan good
Click to expand...

See, when you explain it that way... makes sense what was wrong with my move to Pippy.
 
LYNCH CLOSED

--------------------
Day 3 Lynch Tally
staff () -
SoFlo (3) - Lyra, kata, Fern
Mel (2) - Sporty, Jil
Cray (9) - Kara, Coop, Pippy, jboo, Paws, 3m, DVMD, Snowy, Cray
Pippy () -
genny (2) - kc, vmh
kc (1) - FTB
Coop (1) - SoFlo
FTB (2) - cowgirl, genny
Snowy (2) - Mel, AM

CHECK YO VOTEZ
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
26K
Clem J
Clem J
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
23K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
42 43 44 45 46
Replies
2K
Views
14K
samac
samac
kaydubs
Lucky 7777777 WW Game Thread-Non Champs April 2024
9 10 11 12 13
Replies
622
Views
12K
WildZoo
WildZoo
Top