I am attending LUCOM and I think you make valid points. On a sidenote, I think that LUCOM does belong as part of the equation if it is where you had an acceptance letter from. There are LUCOM students who chose LUCOM over established and well known schools, like PCOM and UNECOM. There's a factor you fail to realize. It's about where you feel you fit as and individual. If you get swept up too much into the "it's a better school" mentality and you aren't happy with the school... it's a waste. If any student should understand this, it would be the osteopathic student.
Also, I know program directors. I am friends with them. They don't really care where you are from or whether you are a DO, MD, MBBS, or foreign grad. Maybe the ivy league's do, but most residencies don't... and I've worked at very big trauma centers that are very well known. Yes, they like the board scores... but it isn't everything. I know people who have been rejected with extremely high board scores, but they were not a good character fit into the programs. These programs want normal acting and hard working people who can communicate to patients and staff. No residency wants a douchy resident who is extremely bright for 3-7 years... TRUST ME! I know people who had really low board scores, who were MD's, and failed STEP 1 (and retook)... and still got the very competitive residency at the medical center they wanted to be at. Residencies want real people... not just a number. That is useful info for when you apply.
One last thing touchpause13, congrats on your acceptance to DMU-COM. I wish you luck.