- Joined
- Dec 12, 2013
- Messages
- 7,580
- Reaction score
- 6,796
There's our Mage, now to find our mech.
There's our Mage, now to find our mech.
So very glad I stuck with my vote.
A Mage.What are you, again?
gennyWho was it that vouched for shelter as being an odd duck on rabbit and thus my interpretations were wrong?
genny
but i don't know if i can blame her
I mean, she asked us what meta meant on rabbit...I'm gonna need some time to recover from all the egg on my face
Realistically looking back now, you don't see the inconsistencies with the assumptions about wolves vs. where she doesn't make assumptions?Yeah. So. Shelter, if that conversation with STL was real (i.e. if he's not a wolf and that was all collusion), you pretty much aced it. I think three of us all read it and shrugged it off. Super well-played.
It does make me hem and haw on STL. I mean, he did come out saying "See this conversation! Shelter is a wolf!" ..... but then he backed away without a whole lotta effort. I suppose soft-clear, but.... that kind of deep super spy move would be in his wheelhouse.
Realistically looking back now, you don't see the inconsistencies with the assumptions about wolves vs. where she doesn't make assumptions?
I never said your end result was wrong. 😛Who was it that vouched for shelter as being an odd duck on rabbit and thus my interpretations were wrong?
That's like, the definition of his idiot savanting haha right conclusion, wrong reasonsI never said your end result was wrong. 😛
Just that I didn't agree with the way you arrived at it via the PM conversation.
Eh I had 6 people all say I was seriously overreaching (with zero agreeing) thinking and I knew in my heart that I had a fair amount of bias based off the formatting of her "role". And I have been screwed going for village code reasons in the past, so I switched because I assumed I was overly biased. Because I am always overly biased, but if it's for a village code reason...And, I felt like you switched away without much convincing, which isn't like you... you're very much a stick-to-my-conclusions player.
That's like, the definition of his idiot savanting haha right conclusion, wrong reasons
Eh I had 6 people all say I was seriously overreaching (with zero agreeing) thinking and I knew in my heart that I had a fair amount of bias based off the formatting of her "role". And I have been screwed going for village code reasons in the past, so I switched because I assumed I was overly biased. Because I am always overly biased, but if it's for a village code reason...
If you hadn't said you didn't want to continue talking about villager code I was going to post that her role description was formatted opposite of mine lolEh I had 6 people all say I was seriously overreaching (with zero agreeing) thinking and I knew in my heart that I had a fair amount of bias based off the formatting of her "role". And I have been screwed going for village code reasons in the past, so I switched because I assumed I was overly biased. Because I am always overly biased, but if it's for a village code reason...
I have such a hard time ever deciding what STL would or wouldn't do in any role, but I was reading him village before, and I can't reasonably switch my read based on what has happened todayI get it. Really, I do.
But you HAVE to admit that it would be exactly the kind of thing you'd do to set something like that up as an elaborate way to throw shelter under the bus. The calculus to wSTL would say "sooner or later people are going to lynch shelter, might as well get some mileage from it."
But I don't think you'd switch off of him/her in that case. I think you'd sit on the vote. So... *shrug*
I agree that I would 100% bus her, and wouldn't have a second thought about it. I would say that I would have 100% went with a strong position, but realistically, that would be expected of me as a wolf. So I would have done this exact approach as a wolf. It's just a matter of what you feel about me otherwise, as there is very little I wouldn't do as a wolf. Insert all of the WIFOM and all that jazzI get it. Really, I do.
But you HAVE to admit that it would be exactly the kind of thing you'd do to set something like that up as an elaborate way to throw shelter under the bus. The calculus to wSTL would say "sooner or later people are going to lynch shelter, might as well get some mileage from it."
But I don't think you'd switch off of him/her in that case. I think you'd sit on the vote. So... *shrug*
Almost said too that the only time I was as willing to share with STL as she was there was when I was a wolf, but like, she played the noob card so well!Good job shelter. I didn't find anything too weird about the exchange except that she was so willing to share.
WIFOM
Off of this, I feel someone gave her some instruction on how to approach the "I'm a poor noob" stance.@Karabiner13 Any chance your former shadow got some wolf tutelage from you? I remember another fairly new player who easily pulled the wool over my eyes 😉
100% agreeOff of this, I feel someone gave her some instruction on how to approach the "I'm a poor noob" stance.
Off of this, I feel someone gave her some instruction on how to approach the "I'm a poor noob" stance.
Starting to sound more and more like the post office. Short hours...high prices...bad serviceTrading Posts will open at the top of the hour.
I can just keep them closed permanently. no prob.Starting to sound more and more like the post office. Short hours...high prices...bad service
And I think a better question, why did you move?@amgoose319 What did you have to give up to move?
🙄 better?And I think a better question, why did you move?
if it was a Wolfy role ability and AM is not a wolf, she would call her out. If it's an item then not sure on the benefit of knowing, unless you feel AM is Wolfy.🙄 better?
The answer is not nothing, can verify. I tried moving to keep AM honest.Maybe I do
There are at least two other possible answers to the question.
Well, thanks for telling goose that.The answer is not nothing, can verify. I tried moving to keep AM honest.
You do realize that AM can verify whatever it is, yeah? And if you are claiming they are both wolves, then Goose would know if AM was at her post.Well, thanks for telling goose that.
I'm just not even going to have this stupid argument this morning. If you're too obtuse to see why my question was relevant before you gave all the answers, then it's not worth explaining. And it just moves you higher on my wolf list for throwing out answers for another player.You do realize that AM can verify whatever it is, yeah? And if you are claiming they are both wolves, then Goose would know if AM was at her post.
😱I can just keep them closed permanently. no prob.
@amgoose319 What did you have to give up to move?
Not fully committing yourself to any candidate/opinion. I feel like the things you've been saying are half-hearted.