A Lighthouse, A Man, A City...A BioShock WW Game

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members don't see this ad.

...so you are wolfy? 🤔

In your dreams.

 

[Animal Midwife]

So what? If her theory is that wolves would want to hide in your vote, why not be first? They could easily anticipate you getting salt votes over last game. And even if she was wolf and didn't think others would vote you, still could be hiding behind a salt vote.

I'll come back to this when Lupin's gotten a chance to answer your original question.

 

[Crayola227]

Wolves just did that like 2 games ago. Who wants to be that derivative? Where’s the fun in that?

You make a good point, but that doesn't have to stop wolves from trying to deal with the scenario where AM randed wolf again.

 

[Crayola227]

Uh oh... AM remembered something incorrectly? Someone help me out, does this make AM wolfy? Because I can’t tell...

Definitely more of a wolf Wife thing.

 

[Lupin21]

I'll come back to this when Lupin's gotten a chance to answer your original question.

Oh, don't wait on me. Barks already asked me about that and I answered. There is no connection between april's vote itself, just that she posted first for that opinion presented.

 

[Crayola227]

Nah, that's still pocketing.

Correct.

That was a game I didn't play.

Well I still think for analysis' sake it's important to specify active vs passive pocketing. Active pocketing is more likely a wolf activity. Passive pocketing, where a villager just puts themselves unbidden into someone's pocket - is not necessary AI for the supposed pocketer. I don't call it pocketing if it's a choice to live in someone's butt.

 

[Crayola227]

Which exchange? I agree with pretty much everything he's said and I love how he came out swinging.

It was about past games which is probably why I didn't follow.

 

[Crayola227]

Nah, just saying the holes in memory are more common if I have no personal attachment to a game.

OK, well this is a legit point. Maybe.

 

[Crayola227]

I'll come back to this when Lupin's gotten a chance to answer your original question.

She already did.

 

[Crayola227]

Wolfiest read at the moment for me is Please.

##$### vote Please ##$$#

I have to go do life stuff but will keep checking in.

 

[Lawpy]

yeet shorty
The math works out. Me, april, alley, now it’s gotta be you. All my friends take turns being wolves 😂
Also I’m sad we aren’t in the same PM so here’s a special vote just for you 💕

I was questioning the sketchiness of this reasoning but I re-read it and it feels like genuine!schools

Genuine not in regards to the vote, but in regards to the way she sounds - doesn't sound like wolf!schools trying to force a village voice

Overexplainy. Which is in the please wolf meta.

Wolfiest read at the moment for me is Please.

##$### vote Please ##$$#

I have to go do life stuff but will keep checking in.

Hmm interesting one pleasy post led to 2 different and opposite reactions

 

[Animal Midwife]

So what? If her theory is that wolves would want to hide in your vote, why not be first? They could easily anticipate you getting salt votes over last game. And even if she was wolf and didn't think others would vote you, still could be hiding behind a salt vote.

From my perspective, there wasn't anything to analyze because it was one vote versus a bandwagon at that point. Thus no need for a comment about wolves hiding.

 

[Crayola227]

From my perspective, there wasn't anything to analyze because it was one vote versus a bandwagon at that point. Thus no need for a comment about wolves hiding.

That's fair, but once the observation was made that there was likely a wolf on your vote, made sense to me to consider everyone on the vote.

Or are you clearing April based on timing?

 

[Lupin21]

That's fair, but once the observation was made that there was likely a wolf on your vote, made sense to me to consider everyone on the vote.

Or are you clearing April based on timing?

You questioning me about the april vote is what she was referring to. I called her towny before anything was considered about AM votes, it made no sense to lump them together like you did.

 

[samac]

***********
im just commenting as I’m on the first page laughing at goat salt so I can get alerts as people comment as I tot along. Carry on.
****************

 

[Lawpy]

***********
im just commenting as I’m on the first page laughing at goat salt so I can get alerts as people comment as I tot along. Carry on.
****************

Yeet samacs

 

[kaydubs]

Official Day 1 A Man Chooses, A Slave Obeys Vote Tally

AM (3) - April, mkg, mayo
Dina (1) - shorty
genny () -
chaos (2) - genny, AM
April (1) - alley
shorty (1) - please
MsP (2) - Zenge, Barks
Trilt () -
LIS (1) - alissa
Vis (1) - Lawpy
vetschoolsplease (1) - Cray

13/26
Winning: @Animal Midwife
Missing: many
yeet close at 10pm EST on 3/2/21 (~30 hours)

 

[Zenge142]

Oh wait vissy's playing!

Silencing vissy + bussing vissy in past games = no good

unyeet trouts
yeet vissy

Lawpy is this a salt vote or is this real?

 

[Lawpy]

Lawpy is this a salt vote or is this real?

🧂🧂🧂🧂

The salt remains deep

 

[Crayola227]

You questioning me about the april vote is what she was referring to. I called her towny before anything was considered about AM votes, it made no sense to lump them together like you did.

That's not my point. Once there were votes, and the issue raised, why at that point would you not consider if one of the wolf votes on AM was April?

 

[Crayola227]

From my perspective, there wasn't anything to analyze because it was one vote versus a bandwagon at that point. Thus no need for a comment about wolves hiding.

No, not then, but later, why not?

 

[Crayola227]

You questioning me about the april vote is what she was referring to. I called her towny before anything was considered about AM votes, it made no sense to lump them together like you did.

Yes but once you made your point, why would you or AM not consider if April's vote was wolfy? I seriously don't get it.

 

[Lupin21]

Yes but once you made your point, why would you or AM not consider if April's vote was wolfy? I seriously don't get it.

No one said I didn't. If you wanted to know if I still thought she was towny, you should have asked, not assumed.

 

[Zenge142]

@Ms Procrastinator I see you’re here, and you’re reacting to posts. Do you want to post anything? Thoughts maybe? Recipe for muffins? Anything?

 

[Animal Midwife]

It was about past games which is probably why I didn't follow.

Could you pull the quotes in question? Everything seemed topical to evaluating current interactions.

 

[Animal Midwife]

That's fair, but once the observation was made that there was likely a wolf on your vote, made sense to me to consider everyone on the vote.

Or are you clearing April based on timing?

No, I'm not clearing anyone. Just explaining why it made sense Lupin didn't comment on my wagon that quickly.

 

[Animal Midwife]

No, not then, but later, why not?

I thought she did?

 

[supershorty]

That's a surprise. Did you tot emojis?

Yeah it was with april in emojis which Lawpy modded (and I forgot )

You played emojis and didn't remember that it was Lawpy's game?

 

[Chaostrodon]

Hi Hi

Ive gathered up some quotes which I find to be AI so far , So here we go . Most of these are tone stuff so nothing that definitive



Scum :

Hmmmm. One of the Am votes likely wolfy.

You would expect someone that has this feeling to vote one of the voters , But (she?) hasnt so far , and on top of that the tone feels off in her filler posts . So this feels like a jokey attempt to cause a bit of chaos rather than scumhunting

>>When did AM start getting so saucy? And perhaps alissa is more an Enola.

This line also feels similiar

Why?

I support this vote 😛

Also getting scum tone vibes from this . One of my more subtle tells for scum is that humour tends to fly above their heads

Crayola also comes across as a lil scummy to me , similiar reasons to the ones above


Town:

Idk I still get noobish about yeeting vets. Especially since LIS is like one of the founders of WW on this server. This is me trying to get past this. Plus I’ve never played with LIS so I wanna see where this goes

The tone of this line reads town to me , find it unlikely for a cute reasoning like this to come from scum . Lawley also gives a bit of town vibes (What does hedging mean tho?) . Also some (very few) town points to AM for pointing that out


Thats all for my analysis so far.

Im just gonna Vote Lupin here .

I like how lots of you have images from Bioshock Infinite as pfps tho the game seems to be based on previous bioshock games , It brings me memories from when I played it


This is just unfair , you cannot post cute pictures of dogs to muddle peoples opinions about you

More from her coming later, in the middle of my work day

Spoiler: Featuring Atticus!

View attachment 331503

He’s nice so far he just gave me a low growl when I met him. Wanted to keep him honest🙂

 

[Lupin21]

AM, did your avvie always have those eyebrows, or did you draw them on for srz bzns horror vision video game?

 

[kaydubs]

Official Day 1 A Man Chooses, A Slave Obeys Vote Tally

AM (3) - April, mkg, mayo
Dina (1) - shorty
genny () -
chaos (2) - genny, AM
April (1) - alley
shorty (1) - please
MsP (2) - Zenge, Barks
Trilt () -
LIS (1) - alissa
Vis (1) - Lawpy
vetschoolsplease (1) - Cray
Lupin (1) - Chaos

14/26
Winning: @Animal Midwife
Missing: many
yeet close at 10pm EST on 3/2/21 (~29.5 hours)

 

[Lupin21]

Hi Hi

Ive gathered up some quotes which I find to be AI so far , So here we go . Most of these are tone stuff so nothing that definitive



Scum :



You would expect someone that has this feeling to vote one of the voters , But (she?) hasnt so far , and on top of that the tone feels off in her filler posts . So this feels like a jokey attempt to cause a bit of chaos rather than scumhunting

>>When did AM start getting so saucy? And perhaps alissa is more an Enola.

This line also feels similiar



Also getting scum tone vibes from this . One of my more subtle tells for scum is that humour tends to fly above their heads

Crayola also comes across as a lil scummy to me , similiar reasons to the ones above


Town:



The tone of this line reads town to me , find it unlikely for a cute reasoning like this to come from scum . Lawley also gives a bit of town vibes (What does hedging mean tho?) . Also some (very few) town points to AM for pointing that out


Thats all for my analysis so far.

Im just gonna Vote Lupin here .

I like how lots of you have images from Bioshock Infinite as pfps tho the game seems to be based on previous bioshock games , It brings me memories from when I played it


This is just unfair , you cannot post cute pictures of dogs to muddle peoples opinions about you

I use my vote various ways. Wasn't ready yet to put any more info on the board while I collected what was currently being offered.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

That's because goats ARE brutal. I tried to brush mine yesterday and it was like trying to wrangle toddlers

I love goats. especially baby ones. Kids are so cute!

I just realized MsP is playing this game. I probably would have been blissfully unaware too, until 5 minutes to yeet close when she comes on with a flurry of posts to meet requirements, a suspicious amount of thread knowledge, and vote to make a tie. I’m not sure my stomach lining can take the chaos that is MsP.

UNYEET AM
YEET MsP

Hey! I'm not that chaotic. What do you mean by "suspicious amount of thread knowledge"? I was village that game. Since I was village that game your reasoning for voting me because of how I played previously is kind of flawed. You're obviously not aiming for a wolf.

Yeet MsP 🙂

Awwww! Just like old times

Literally the last two sparse times we played together, I didn't vote her at the start. Your surprise is delayed.

There are times when AM doesn't vote me off the bat. She eventually gets there if I don't post enough to please her after a certain point.

Now also considering if there's a wolf vote on AM, and considering if maybe she randed wolf and they're gonna make a show of salt vote bussing her D1 and hoping to pull off later. Will be interesting to see this evolve.

Bussing a wolf D1, especially AM kinda seems crazy (for lack of a better word)

@Ms Procrastinator I see you’re here, and you’re reacting to posts. Do you want to post anything? Thoughts maybe? Recipe for muffins? Anything?

I'm reading through the thread and catching up. Chill

 

[Zenge142]

Unyeet MsP

Now that she’s posting and I know it won’t be a repeat of last time I saw her play.

 

[Crayola227]

No one said I didn't. If you wanted to know if I still thought she was towny, you should have asked, not assumed.

First I wanted to know why you thought she was town to begin with, and I asked. Then you brought up the notion a wolf was hiding in the vote, and then I asked if what that meant for April. Not sure I assumed anything.

AM is seemingly questioning that by your logic, shouldn't we consider April on that vote as well?

Not sure why so much traction on this point, but I think it doesn't read well for you, AM, or April.

 

[Lupin21]

First I wanted to know why you thought she was town to begin with, and I asked. Then you brought up the notion a wolf was hiding in the vote, and then I asked if what that meant for April. Not sure I assumed anything.

AM is seemingly questioning that by your logic, shouldn't we consider April on that vote as well?

Not sure why so much traction on this point, but I think it doesn't read well for you, AM, or April.

Basically, you didn't transition into a point for me to say that my read on April has changed and she could very well be a wolf just like any of them. That's all this is. lol

You only asked me why I had her as towny when I later noted a wolf vote was likely on AM. It was completely separate.

 

[supershorty]

Bussing a wolf D1, especially AM kinda seems crazy (for lack of a better word)

Happened in the basics game.

 

[Aprilthearab]

Unyeet MsP

Now that she’s posting and I know it won’t be a repeat of last time I saw her play.

Are you worried about this being wolf!MsP stepping up her game? I know it very well could be NAI but given the history of inactivity people have told me about, it makes me wonder.

 

[Barkley13]

🧂🧂🧂🧂

The salt remains deep

What’s the salt for?

 

[Barkley13]

Also getting scum tone vibes from this . One of my more subtle tells for scum is that humour tends to fly above their heads

Im confused about what joke I apparently missed

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Are you worried about this being wolf!MsP stepping up her game? I know it very well could be NAI but given the history of inactivity people have told me about, it makes me wonder.

Have we played other games together? Can't remember

 

[Barkley13]

Are you worried about this being wolf!MsP stepping up her game? I know it very well could be NAI but given the history of inactivity people have told me about, it makes me wonder.

Sometimes as village she’ll post more too so I’m not concerned about her being here earlier

 

[Aprilthearab]

Have we played other games together? Can't remember

Yes. Once. It was the same game Zenge was referring to where you showed up at the last second just in time to not get mod killed

 

[Animal Midwife]

Also getting scum tone vibes from this . One of my more subtle tells for scum is that humour tends to fly above their heads

What humor?

The tone of this line reads town to me , find it unlikely for a cute reasoning like this to come from scum . Lawley also gives a bit of town vibes (What does hedging mean tho?) . Also some (very few) town points to AM for pointing that out

Hedging is avoiding taking a stance on someone; arguing for why they can be both village and wolf without saying which they believe to be more likely.

 

[Crayola227]

What humor?

Hedging is avoid taking a stance on someone; arguing for why they can be both village and wolf without saying which they believe to be more likely.

Comes from the term "hedging your bets."

 

[Animal Midwife]

AM, did your avvie always have those eyebrows, or did you draw them on for srz bzns horror vision video game?

It's a recent change. The end goal was to align my avvie more closely with my general salt on here and my irl rbf.

 

[Lawpy]

What’s the salt for?

The silencing from noob game + the bussing when i village read her in tot chat

 

[Lawpy]

Guys i watched youtube videos to read more about the lore

I have a tinfoil

 

[supershorty]

Guys i watched youtube videos to read more about the lore

I have a tinfoil

What’s your tinfoil?

 

[Lawpy]

I think @Zenge142 @holdthemayo and others know more about the game story than a 20 min youtube video but here goes. It's D1 but i want to lay it out before i forget