A Lighthouse, A Man, A City...A BioShock WW Game

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
So... are you arguing that you don't think kata's play up to this point was sketchy?

I understand you're obviously saying that you come from a village point, now. But she's had very legitimate questioning throughout the game that didn't just have to do with her being quiet. If you hadn't taken over and I thought I could assess more of a read out of you in the next day or two my lynch would still be on her, for better or worse. *shrug*
To be totally honest in my review today I didn't ISO her. I just thought she seemed like an inactive player in tot chat and she wasn't someone I felt the need to review since I know she isn't wolfing now.
 
I also feel like maybe we declared too many quieter people village based on VCA and it's a deincentive to both villager and wolves in that group to participate.
I haven’t really used VCA too much this game because as someone mentioned, we can assume both wolves got notifs the morning of. The pack probably adjusted their votes accordingly.
 
Do
Tunnel is the wrong term mayo, the proper term is up the butthole.

Trilt is the other person who has been consistently pushing kata, but her posts read soooo village but her voting history is so bad.
I call that being on someone's dick.

As long as we don't mix it up with choosing to live in someone's butt as the way a villager chooses to live in someone's pocket without them trying to put them there.
 
Day 5 You Were Born To Do Great Things Vote Tally

Cyndia (6) - AM, LIS, Trilt, Lupin, pawprints, mayo
Chaostrodon ()
mayo ()
samac (3) - supershorty, Barks, Dina
pawprints (5) - jaboo, vetschoolsplz, Cyndia, MsP, Cray
LIS (1) - samac

15/17

winning: @Cyndia

Missing: @Lawpy @Chaostrodon

Deadline: 10pm EST on 3/10/21 (~30 minutes)

sqBBnr.gif
 
Last edited:
It's your predecessor's activities and your pushes today that are bothering me.
Well I hope you give me the chance to prove that I'm not howling this game. I think last time I villaged in apocalypse you were suspicious of me.
What I'm learning though is I'm apparently much better at appearing village when I'm a wolf than I am when I'm village. Which I find hilarious with how much I hated the pressure of wolfing.
 
Tunnel is the wrong term mayo, the proper term is up the butthole.

Trilt is the other person who has been consistently pushing kata, but her posts read soooo village but her voting history is so bad.


My apologies for incorrect verbiage

tunnel rat GIF by South Park
 
Weren’t they pawprints and chaos at your last post? I would still call chaos a low poster considering it’s the 9th or 10th real day and there’s 97 pages
I said paws was an ok choice and I preferred chaos vs LIS.
You're barking up the wrong tree here, barks.
 
Has anyone thrown out the idea that the cigarettes might be a reason for the double kills? I doubt that’s the case because then the item would be OP, but just an idea.
If they were, we'd mechanically have another wolf and that seems too good to be true.
 
Has anyone thrown out the idea that the cigarettes might be a reason for the double kills? I doubt that’s the case because then the item would be OP, but just an idea.
N1 had two kills with the same method I thought was wolfy, and I don't think there was any silencing the next day. Was there? When did Shorty have to gif post?
 
Has anyone thrown out the idea that the cigarettes might be a reason for the double kills? I doubt that’s the case because then the item would be OP, but just an idea.
We knew April, MKG, Alley, and Cray all had one. There is Cyndia possibly last night. So I don't think so.
 
Jaboo already mentioned this, but looking at the vote progression again makes me really wonder about this point that Trilt made about alley.

I can see 3 options: protecting kata, not seeing the tally before submitting her vote, or trying to take out 2 villagers with her in the event that all 3 died in the tie.
I realized I never went back to this train of thought.

Option 3 seems the most likely but I’m not confident in saying that was the case for sure.
 
We knew April, MKG, Alley, and Cray all had one. There is Cyndia possibly last night. So I don't think so.
I don't see a use of Cyndia using a cigarette if her ability is just to switch groups. That's why the silencing thing tonight confuses the piss out of me.
 
Is paws as noob as she has been letting on? I think she has played enough to not have the noob card, no?
I'd like either LIS or Chaos to flip.

Then tunneling thing is just semantics and I think you know that. I used the term as focusing on a player, I'll stick to up butthole from now on if that makes it more clear.
It's an easy target for a wolf to misyeet I'd say, no suspicious thrown on you for constantly pushing kata as she was relatively inactive and that's easy to target. I did this when I was a wolf.

Mm. Maye. Semantics matter because it's one glimpse into how a person is framing things in their mind.

If you think I'm a wolf, you would more likely have phrased it that way - something about me trying to mislynch Kata.

So on the one hand, yeah, I know what you mean. On the other ... the way people word things matters and is worth noting.

And, when people start to try and make the "oh you know what I meant" argument, it always sounds a bit sketchy, like they realize they said something weird and now want to just wave it away.

In this specific case, yeah, I think no big deal. Certainly not a flashing red warning sign or anything. But it's still reasonable of me to note it.
 
I don't see a use of Cyndia using a cigarette if her ability is just to switch groups. That's why the silencing thing tonight confuses the piss out of me.

Maybe Genny was right when she said Cynd used an item, not an ability.

Especially since we know Genny could send items and money to others.
 
Did we find anything against pawprints? I remember thinking her tone sounded alright
 
I don't see a use of Cyndia using a cigarette if her ability is just to switch groups. That's why the silencing thing tonight confuses the piss out of me.
Did anyone actually go and look to see if 2 people were moved last night? I know that she said it was only moving herself, but the cigarette may have let her move someone else, too.
 
Did anyone actually go and look to see if 2 people were moved last night? I know that she said it was only moving herself, but the cigarette may have let her move someone else, too.
I don't think anyone was moved. All the numbers but her are in order.
 
Did anyone actually go and look to see if 2 people were moved last night? I know that she said it was only moving herself, but the cigarette may have let her move someone else, too.
I saw Barks moved, but didn't stare at the others too closely.
 
I don't see a use of Cyndia using a cigarette if her ability is just to switch groups. That's why the silencing thing tonight confuses the piss out of me.
Yup. Lot's of mystery surrounding her. So do we vote her to put an end to it? Will it result in a wolf with the ol' college try at misdirection, or a well planned misvote successfully orchestrated by wolves? This is why we play! haha
 
I think at minimum he might be 3P. I'll take a sure 3P yeet over a possible villager misyeet any day of the week.

Hm. You're stretching your logic though. On the one hand, you think he "might be" 3P. But then you say you'll take a "sure 3P yeet over a possible villager."

I get either of those statements separately, but together it doesn't seem to add up to a Mayo vote because it (apparently) is not a "sure 3P yeet" like you're portraying?

I'd rather wolf hunt.

But I get that you have him neutral to wolf and not likely village. If I'm reading you right.
 
Did anyone actually go and look to see if 2 people were moved last night? I know that she said it was only moving herself, but the cigarette may have let her move someone else, too.
No one moved last night. Barks is in a different group now but it's post-rez, not post-N4.

D1:

End of N2 write up:

Neptune's Bounty
1. @Animal Midwife
2. @Barkley13
4. @Dinashadow
5. @pawprintsandponytails

Arcadia
6. @Trilt
7. @holdthemayo
8. @Crayola227
9. @vetschoolsletmeinplease

Fort Frolic
11. @supershorty
12. @Lawpy
14. @SportPonies

Hephaestus
15. @genny
16. @mkg323
17. @Cyndia

Olympus Heights
19. @Ms Procrastinator
20. @Viscernable
21. @alleycat03
22. LaineyLou ---> @jaboo

Point Prometheus
23. @katashark
24. @Chaostrodon
25. @LetItSnow
26. @Lupin21

Most recent:

Neptune's Bounty
1. @Animal Midwife
2. @Barkley13 Barks' move happened after her rez N2, not last night
4. @Dinashadow
5. @pawprintsandponytails
17. @Cyndia

Arcadia
6. @Trilt
7. @holdthemayo
8. @Crayola227
9. @vetschoolsletmeinplease

Fort Frolic
11. @supershorty
12. @Lawpy

Hephaestus
overcome by lava

Olympus Heights
19. @Ms Procrastinator
22. LaineyLou ---> @jaboo

Point Prometheus
23. katashark ---> @samac
24. @Chaostrodon
25. @LetItSnow
26. @Lupin21
 
Yup. Lot's of mystery surrounding her. So do we vote her to put an end to it? Will it result in a wolf with the ol' college try at misdirection, or a well planned misvote successfully orchestrated by wolves? This is why we play! haha
It would also satisfy my itch to know once and for all how wolves are split......
unyeet LIS
Yeet Cyndia
 
Hm. You're stretching your logic though. On the one hand, you think he "might be" 3P. But then you say you'll take a "sure 3P yeet over a possible villager."

I get either of those statements separately, but together it doesn't seem to add up to a Mayo vote because it (apparently) is not a "sure 3P yeet" like you're portraying?

I'd rather wolf hunt.

But I get that you have him neutral to wolf and not likely village. If I'm reading you right.
I think he's wolf, and if not, 3P. I meant as far as my philosophy goes, if I think someone is VERY likely non-village, and someone else is a coin-toss, I don't go for the weaker wolf read because I just don't happen to know the exact flavor of my much stronger non-village read. Go for whoever seems most non-village no matter what they actually are, as long as you DON'T think they're village. Vote for the least village person if that makes more sense.
 
Im gonna vote Cyndia , and read up and see what was scummy about pawprints
 
Day 5 You Were Born To Do Great Things Vote Tally

Cyndia (8) - AM, LIS, Trilt, Lupin, pawprints, mayo, samac, Chaostrodon
Chaostrodon ()
mayo ()
samac (3) - supershorty, Barks, Dina
pawprints (5) - jaboo, vetschoolsplz, Cyndia, MsP, Cray
LIS ()

16/17

winning: @Cyndia

Missing: @Lawpy

Deadline: 10pm EST on 3/10/21 (~15 minutes)

sqBBnr.gif
 
Im gonna vote Cyndia , and read up and see what was scummy about pawprints
Tl;dr her reads list are weird and may be manufactured. Having things like Dina as a village lean. I think that's where the majority of it is coming from.
 
Tl;dr her reads list are weird and may be manufactured. Having things like Dina as a village lean. I think that's where the majority of it is coming from.

I struggle with this (not Cyndia specifically). I know how busy I am - my reads are pretty superficial skims and gut reactions to the way people responded or that sort of thing. I can see Cyndia's being that way, too.
 
Top