A Lighthouse, A Man, A City...A BioShock WW Game

[Crayola227]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I didn’t call it a huge swing?
just called the last minute discussion of yeeting me today, a couple hours before yeet close when yesterday I said I might not make it to yeet close is sketch.



I’m here. I wouldn’t have been if there weren’t so many clouds and we could watch the sunset over the canyon.

Feels like wolfy reactivity, perhaps.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

If they were wolves and they did know, don't you think they would act like they didnt?

There's probably a chance Barks did (since it was on thread), but not Lupin. She was the one that brought up the whole "decoy stood in for a kill" thing with pleasy. Why put the spotlight on herself like that?

 

[Lupin21]

They don't have a lot of content, but they have some pretty good reads

which reads though? Pretty sure it's been kata/samac, lis and you for his choices. lol

 

[supershorty]

Much as Cyndia got sketch points for going after mkg the noob on a flimsy reason, flimsy reasoning to declare someone village really wigs me out.

Thinking about this and looked back at katashark's posts because I thought I remembered something like this sketching me out.

She listed Cyndia as one of her 4 village reads, with no explanation, and no follow up even when she said that she would. 2 of the 3 wolf reads she had flipped village.

 

[Crayola227]

I

means you start to speak up when people read you wolfy and work hard to get a village read so you're not misvoted. One doesn't have to wait to get bothered until there are enough votes to be an actual threat of ending your turn in the game.

I see your point. That said, one has to try to tell this apart from wolfy reactivity. It's tough.

 

[Lupin21]

I
I see your point. That said, one has to try to tell this apart from wolfy reactivity. It's tough.

Yes, that's why actual defending makes this game much more fun!

 

[Crayola227]

I

There's probably a chance Barks did (since it was on thread), but not Lupin. She was the one that brought up the whole "decoy stood in for a kill" thing with pleasy. Why put the spotlight on herself like that?

I don't know that it puts a spotlight on her, but she's smart enough a wolf to try to play dumb like that and get village points for it. Not really sure Lupin's a wolf, but I like to think these things through.

 

[supershorty]

Thinking about this and looked back at katashark's posts because I thought I remembered something like this sketching me out.

She listed Cyndia as one of her 4 village reads, with no explanation, and no follow up even when she said that she would. 2 of the 3 wolf reads she had flipped village.

To add on to this, the other wolf read was Zenge, and it was after he would have been seered.

 

[samac]

"last minute push against me" makes it sound like there were more than just 2 votes

Fair. Sometimes I’m over dramatic and get annoyed when I have votes on me and I’m village. I try my best and when I get told I’m wolfy I get overly defensive.
If anyone wants to go back to apocolypse I got sus points there for the same.

I mostly ignored your votes on me last game.

unfortunately it’s time for me to get dinner and I guess I’ll be back after and see what happened.

if you all flip me tonight remember MsP’s numbers were identical to mine. Either lupin told her or she’s likely truthful.
Lawpy remains in my POE even though no one else is on it.
if someone in my group is a wolf I think chaos is the most likely.
Jaboo/barks should be watched with the res but barks hasn’t read as wolf to me.
Hopefully I’m around, but if I’m not It was a good game.

 

[LetItSnow]

Hm.

unlynch MsP

lynch Chaos

 

[supershorty]

Whoever the watcher is, if you’re village, if someone visited Lawpy last night and it’s someone you’ve had suspicions of and it may have been a conversion please let us know.
I don’t want to convert hunt just yet because I’m pretty sure there’s an og wolf yet, but I wanted this noted, if I was a wolf and I was going to convert someone it would have been AM, shorty, or Lawpy because their village cred is through the damn roof. Maybe we got lucky...?

@samac I'm curious, you've had Lawpy in your POE, but then in this post, you also had him as someone who had "village cred through the damn roof," so my question is either what changed on your previous read or what has changed since you made this post?

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

which reads though? Pretty sure it's been kata/samac, lis and you for his choices. lol

I liked how they were one of the first persons to go after zenge. It's also been mentioned that their play was a lot different than when they wolfed.

 

[holdthemayo]

Hm.

unlynch MsP

lynch Chaos

I'll bite

Unyeet Cray
Yeet Chaos

 

[Lawpy]

Hm.

unlynch MsP

lynch Chaos

I'll bite

Unyeet Cray
Yeet Chaos

How do you respond to AM's derpclear of chaos?

 

[Lupin21]

jaboo still need to vote too?

 

[LetItSnow]

How do you respond to AM's derpclear of chaos?

Derpclear can be a little wifom.

But thanks for reminding me. I really want to go back and look at AM's leading suspicions. Dammit.

Trying to work on a wall project and make dinner and keep track of this all at the same time.

 

[holdthemayo]

How do you respond to AM's derpclear of chaos?

I'll need to go back and reread it.

At the time it didn't do much for me. We've seen plenty of wolves play out not understanding things as part of their gameplay.

 

[jaboo]

lol am I the only one that thought the decoy would protect against kills

That was my thought as well

 

[Barkley13]

some thoughts while staring at the tallies:

Day 1 Final Tally:

genny (3) - AM, Zenge, supershorty
April (2) - katashark, Cyndia
MsP (1) - pawprints
Trilt (1) - sunshinefl
Visc (1) - Lawpy
vetschoolsplease (4) - Cray, Barks, MsP, trilt
Lupin (1) - Chaos
mayo (1) - Lupin
Zenge (3) - April, genny, Sporty
katashark (2) - LIS, alissa
alleycat (1) - Dina
alissa (6) - vetschoolsplease, alleycat, mayo, Viscernable, mkg, jaboo

the three wolves that have flipped so far have been spread out across the board on D1... so if this was intentional then would it make sense for cyndia and wolf kata to vote together? or would the other wolf/wolves also be spread out like the ones on please or chaos

Day 2 Final Tally

Zenge (14) - jaboo, Dina, vetschoolsplz, supershorty, mayo, LIS, genny, Lawpy, Sporty, Viscernable, Lupin , AM, alleycat, mkg
katashark (1) - pawprints
genny (1) - Cyndia
vetschoolsplz (3) - Cray, MsP, Zenge
mkg (1) - Chaostrodon
Viscernable (2) - Trilt, kata

We've been saying the whole time that the wolves may have started bussing zenge early but so far the only one bussing him was alley who voted for him pretty late. Almost makes me feel worse about jaboo

Day 5 Final Tally

Cyndia (8) - AM, LIS, Trilt, Lupin, pawprints, mayo, samac, Chaostrodon
samac (4) - supershorty, Barks, Dina, Lawpy
pawprints (5) - jaboo, vetschoolsplz, Cyndia, MsP, Cray

mostly just wondering if someone bussed cyndia

 

[supershorty]

Derpclear can be a little wifom.

But thanks for reminding me. I really want to go back and look at AM's leading suspicions. Dammit.

Trying to work on a wall project and make dinner and keep track of this all at the same time.

Her most recent POE posted was:

Regardless, POE is still please/Trilt/samac +/- Cray/MsP.

 

[jaboo]

I’m fine to go with chaos, but I will admit that MsP buying that decoy doesn’t make me feel great.

 

[kaydubs]

Day 8: Tombstones for Paving Tiles Vote Tally

samac (2) - MsP, Lawpy
MsP (6) - supershorty, Chaostrodon, Cray, Trilt, samac, Barks
cray (1) - Lupin
Chaostrodon (2) - LIS, mayo

11/12

Winning: @Ms Procrastinator

Missing: @jaboo

Deadline: 10pm EST on 3/16/21 (~25 minutes)

 

[jaboo]

We've been saying the whole time that the wolves may have started bussing zenge early but so far the only one bussing him was alley who voted for him pretty late. Almost makes me feel worse about jaboo

My vote was a contingency, before Z would have gotten a notification of being seered

 

[jaboo]

mostly just wondering if someone bussed cyndia

I’m thinking no given the other wagons were semi-close

 

[Barkley13]

My vote was a contingency, before Z would have gotten a notification of being seered

oh shoot it was

 

[holdthemayo]

I’m fine to go with chaos, but I will admit that MsP buying that decoy doesn’t make me feel great.

I'm fine with any of my top three reads. It would be nice to hear from Chaos more earlier in the next cycle if it's not him.

 

[Barkley13]

I’m thinking no given the other wagons were semi-close

but that would eliminate chaos and samac from the POE which I don't feel great about doing

 

[holdthemayo]

but that would eliminate chaos and samac from the POE which I don't feel great about doing

Who would that leave for you?

 

[jaboo]

I’m trying not to read too much into katamac since kata is known to post sparingly (and therefore it’s not a great tell), but I get the nervousness there.

 

[LetItSnow]

Her most recent POE posted was:

For real thanks

 

[supershorty]

but that would eliminate chaos and samac from the POE which I don't feel great about doing

I don't think we should eliminate anyone from the POE based on a single day's voting.

 

[holdthemayo]

@jaboo why do you hold your vote so late every cycle? It's been sketching me out and is very sus.

Put a vote down to let us know where you are thinking.

 

[jaboo]

@jaboo why do you hold your vote so late every cycle? It's been sketching me out and is very sus.

Put a vote down to let us know where you are thinking.

Yeah yeah yeah, I know, I’m just trying to find a smoking gun somewhere in the write-ups

 

[jaboo]

Yeet chaos

I’ve been fairly vocal that he’s weirded me out most of this game

 

[Barkley13]

Who would that leave for you?

probably MsP and cray

I don't think we should eliminate anyone from the POE based on a single day's voting.

yeah I think it's too soon to tell if anyone bussed cyndia or not. Especially since cyndia voted for alley D4 when it was a tie

 

[kaydubs]

Day 8: Tombstones for Paving Tiles Vote Tally

samac (2) - MsP, Lawpy
MsP (6) - supershorty, Chaostrodon, Cray, Trilt, samac, Barks
cray (1) - Lupin
Chaostrodon (3) - LIS, mayo, jaboo

12/12

Winning: @Ms Procrastinator

Missing: n/a

Deadline: 10pm EST on 3/16/21 (~10 minutes)

 

[jaboo]

I feel like this MsP vote is not gunna budge given how quiet it is

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

My brain can't deal with vote trackers but staring at these help sometimes

Day 1 Final Tally:

genny (3) - AM, Zenge, supershorty
April (2) - katashark, Cyndia
MsP (1) - pawprints
Trilt (1) - sunshinefl
Visc (1) - Lawpy
vetschoolsplease (4) - Cray, Barks, MsP, trilt
Lupin (1) - Chaos
mayo (1) - Lupin
Zenge (3) - April, genny, Sporty
katashark (2) - LIS, alissa
alleycat (1) - Dina
alissa (6) - vetschoolsplease, alleycat, mayo, Viscernable, mkg, jaboo

25/26

Day 2 Final Tally

Zenge (14) - jaboo, Dina, vetschoolsplz, supershorty, mayo, LIS, genny, Lawpy, Sporty, Viscernable, Lupin , AM, alleycat, mkg
katashark (1) - pawprints
genny (1) - Cyndia
vetschoolsplz (3) - Cray, MsP, Zenge
mkg (1) - Chaostrodon
Viscernable (2) - Trilt, kata

22/22

Day 3 Final Tally

Viscernable (10) - Cray, Dina, genny, Trilt, AM, MsP, katashark, pawprints, Barks, jaboo
Cyndia (1) - Sporty
alleycat (4) - Lupin, LIS, mkg, Lawpy
LIS (1) - Chaostrodon
pawprintsandponytails (1) - Cyndia
AM (5) - supershorty, mayo, Viscernable, vetschoolsplz, alleycat

22/22

Day 4 Final Tally

katashark (6) - Lawpy, LIS, Trilt, pawprints, jaboo, shorty
alleycat (6) - Lupin, genny, MsP, Cyndia, vetschoolsplz, cray
Cray (6) - Dina, Barks, AM, mayo, chaos, alley

18/19
Missing: kata

Day 5 Final Tally

Cyndia (8) - AM, LIS, Trilt, Lupin, pawprints, mayo, samac, Chaostrodon
samac (4) - supershorty, Barks, Dina, Lawpy
pawprints (5) - jaboo, vetschoolsplz, Cyndia, MsP, Cray

17/17

Day 6 Final Tally

samac (2) - Barks, Chaostrodon
Chaostrodon (1) - Cray
Trilt (2) - AM, Lawpy
pawprints (8) - Trilt, Lupin, MsP, vetschoolsplz, supershorty, samac, jaboo, mayo
mayo (1) - LIS

14/15
Missing: pawprints

Day 7 Final Tally

vetschoolsplz (8) - MsP, AM, mayo, Lupin, Barks, Trilt, samac, jaboo
mayo (1) - Cray
MsP (4) - Lawpy, supershorty, vetschoolsplz, Chaostrodon

13/14
Missing: LIS

I feel like there has to be a wolf on Cyndia's yeet

 

[Crayola227]

##### unyeet MsP #####
##### yeet Chaos #####

See what happens

 

[supershorty]

I'm really struggling because going off VCA (from final votes), MsP and katamac are almost identical in terms of number of times they voted for village vs wolf. I feel like I can make an argument for either one of them. I feel like the ISOs that I did on MsP relied on really reading into a few interactions. This evening, I've gotten more village feels from MsP and more wolf feels from samac.

 

[Crayola227]

I feel like this MsP vote is not gunna budge given how quiet it is

It's now only one or two off now

 

[Lawpy]

The sudden chaos counterwagon is interesting

 

[jaboo]

I feel like there has to be a wolf on Cyndia's yeet

I think Trilt makes the most sense to me

 

[Trilt]

I feel like this MsP vote is not gunna budge given how quiet it is

I forget how she defended herself quickly and gave us lots of time to discuss.

Oh wait

Actually she waited despite being around SDN until she was directly called out several times and any counter wagon was guaranteed to have to be somewhat rushed...

 

[kaydubs]

vote closed

 

[kaydubs]

Day 8: Tombstones for Paving Tiles *FINAL* Vote Tally

samac (2) - MsP, Lawpy
MsP (5) - supershorty, Chaostrodon, Trilt, samac, Barks
cray (1) - Lupin
Chaostrodon (4) - LIS, mayo, jaboo, Cray

12/12

Winning: @Ms Procrastinator

Missing: n/a

Deadline: 10pm EST on 3/16/21

 

[Trilt]

I forget how she defended herself quickly and gave us lots of time to discuss.

Oh wait

Actually she waited despite being around SDN until she was directly called out several times and any counter wagon was guaranteed to have to be somewhat rushed...

Like, this could easily be her village play. But you can't really bitch about difficulties working up a counter wagon or other options when she literally had 36 hours to respond to questions and criticisms and choose to do it three hours to close.

 

[LetItSnow]

This is going to maybe come out all sorts of sketch, but it's just a reflection of me skimming the surface of the game.

In case it helps put things together, I believe I was attacked N3. There was protection in place.

Should have said something a while back.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Like, this could easily be her village play. But you can't really bitch about difficulties working up a counter wagon or other options when she literally had 36 hours to respond to questions and criticisms and choose to do it three hours to close.

***********
Sdn lets the word *itch go through? Interesting. I can see that going bad on the premed side.
**************

 

[Barkley13]

This is going to maybe come out all sorts of sketch, but it's just a reflection of me skimming the surface of the game.

In case it helps put things together, I believe I was attacked N3. There was protection in place.

Should have said something a while back.

This almost sounds like someone extra was attacked (if I'm reading it right?):

He caught sight of a large figure among the plants, and positioned himself behind a tree. Took aim and...BOOM. The blast knocked the big guy back. He shook his helmeted head, stunned, and then growled, turning to find the source of the attack. But in a moment, another figure had his attention. This one sprinted around behind the Big Daddy, eyes trained on the small figure he was protecting. But he was too slow, and was soon under fire.

Weird though that two other people already died that night