Addressing PE

  • Thread starter Thread starter AnatomyGrey12
  • Start date Start date
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Alkaidius said:
Everyone prepare the torches and pitchforks just in case lol.
Click to expand...
This was a joke in 2019 but an actual suggestion in 2021

1615394416351.png
 
Our school messaged us - they are going to make us do a virtual “PE.” Less than 2 hours total. We have to write 1 soap note. We will get training before we do it. If we fail, we do it again and again till we pass, though the school “expects us all to pass easily and without stress on the first try” and the “training sessions” that they will hold before the virtual “PE” will be highly beneficial
 
OverlyRomantic said:
Our school messaged us - they are going to make us do a virtual “PE.” Less than 2 hours total. We have to write 1 soap note. We will get training before we do it. If we fail, we do it again and again till we pass, though the school “expects us all to pass easily and without stress on the first try” and the “training sessions” that they will hold before the virtual “PE” will be highly beneficial
Click to expand...
Get the pitch forks ready. Just on principle that is absolutely ridiculous.
 
OverlyRomantic said:
Our school messaged us - they are going to make us do a virtual “PE.” Less than 2 hours total. We have to write 1 soap note. We will get training before we do it. If we fail, we do it again and again till we pass, though the school “expects us all to pass easily and without stress on the first try” and the “training sessions” that they will hold before the virtual “PE” will be highly beneficial
Click to expand...
angry ron swanson GIF
 
OverlyRomantic said:
Our school messaged us - they are going to make us do a virtual “PE.” Less than 2 hours total. We have to write 1 soap note. We will get training before we do it. If we fail, we do it again and again till we pass, though the school “expects us all to pass easily and without stress on the first try” and the “training sessions” that they will hold before the virtual “PE” will be highly beneficial
Click to expand...

Like your school is doing this? Or the NBOME.... because our school says they have heard boo from the NBOME regarding the announcement tomorrow
 
The giant pre-PE exam my school did to prep for the real PE better count for my class. Here’s to hoping tomorrow’s announcement doesn’t make us do anything else.

if any of you guys end up high up in academic medicine or on the NBOME/NBME board please don’t forget to bring your common sense.
 
OverlyRomantic said:
Our school messaged us - they are going to make us do a virtual “PE.” Less than 2 hours total. We have to write 1 soap note. We will get training before we do it. If we fail, we do it again and again till we pass, though the school “expects us all to pass easily and without stress on the first try” and the “training sessions” that they will hold before the virtual “PE” will be highly beneficial
Click to expand...
this has to be an freaking joke. If this is true really NBOME is delusional, and probably charging 1k for such POS test too.... these guys
are unbelievable
 
TXKnight said:
this has to be an freaking joke. If this is true really NBOME is delusional, and probably charging 1k for such POS test too.... these guys
are unbelievable
Click to expand...

I want to clarify that this is from the school, I don't know if this is what the NBOME is talking about or if they will have something different.
 
My school thinks so highly of their PE prep that they encourage all students to take it right away during 3rd year (I forgot to schedule and couldn't lol). I really hope they realize they should just pass us since they think/know the results of their preparation. Doing otherwise kind of goes against their advice to take it immediately and saying we are ready.
 
OverlyRomantic said:
Our school messaged us - they are going to make us do a virtual “PE.” Less than 2 hours total. We have to write 1 soap note. We will get training before we do it. If we fail, we do it again and again till we pass, though the school “expects us all to pass easily and without stress on the first try” and the “training sessions” that they will hold before the virtual “PE” will be highly beneficial
Click to expand...
Our school is doing something similar for M3s. We normally have an in-person OSCE type thing to be approved to take the PE; they made it a virtual telehealth thing this year. 2 patients, 2 notes. Separate OMM project to check the box for that since we can't do it virtually. I have an inkling suspicion they suspect NBOME might come out with something like this and either want to prepare us or want to see if they can just use it to count as our PE. This doesn't include fourth years, though, who I believe did their PE checkoff before everything went crazy.
 
If they try to get every fourth year in the country to sign up for some 'virtual' PE in under 2 months it just won't happen. We all are so mentally checked out and anxious about match too. I think they use our OSCE checkoffs we all had to do through our schools for this year, then maybe institute something next year for the rest of the students. Won't put anything past Gimpel et al though. If they're smart they'll just call our class a wash, because trying to shove something in last second will be even more of a death knell than is already there, because then it's painfully obvious its purely about profits (even more than it already was)
 
I find it a bit odd that they chose to word it as eligibility for level 3 as opposed to eligibility for licensure. No mention of whether a full license will be able to be obtained without the PE.

Edit: found something buried in the FAQ-- "We will annotate COMLEX-USA transcripts to note that the COMLEX-USA Level 2-PE was suspended on March 7, 2020 due to the pandemic, that temporary alternate pathways were provided, and that eligible candidates who complete the COMLEX-USA series of examinations via any of these pathways will be considered to have successfully completed the NBOME COMLEX-USA licensing examination program."
 
Steve_Zissou said:
WTF, why is there no mention for the class of 2022???? Are they going to try and bring it back next year????
Click to expand...
Wouldn't be surprised if they pulled a stunt like that.

This is good, puts the ball in the Dean's court. Thankfully, I think most schools won't want to deal with yet another evaluation 2 months before graduation, if they haven't already.
 
fldoctorgirl said:
Our update isn't due until April 30th.
Click to expand...
Hopefully they do the same for 2022, NBOME sent out a survey a month or so ago where they were asking what was acceptable for PE replacement. I indicated that I thought SP evaluation was nonsense and that students should be evaluated by schools and preceptors. I am fairly certain most others did as well who got it. So gl guys.
 
BorntobeDO? said:
Hopefully they do the same for 2022, NBOME sent out a survey a month or so ago where they were asking what was acceptable for PE replacement. I indicated that I thought SP evaluation was nonsense and that students should be evaluated by schools and preceptors. I am fairly certain most others did as well who got it. So gl guys.
Click to expand...
If they get rid of PE for good, think of the people that failed out of medical school in the past due to failing this stupid test. Some lawsuit might be in the horizon.
 
DrStephenStrange said:
If they get rid of PE for good, think of the people that failed out of medical school in the past due to failing this stupid test. Some lawsuit might be in the horizon.
Click to expand...
How many people failed out of medical school because of that? Not trying to be rude at all, I imagine it's > then 1 but wouldn't imagine it being a large number.
 
68wdogdad said:
How many people failed out of medical school because of that? Not trying to be rude at all, I imagine it's > then 1 but wouldn't imagine it being a large number.
Click to expand...
Well, if I go with last year's numbers alone, 12.5% of 599 retakers didn't pass it. That's ~75 students for one year that probably failed out because many schools won't allow more than 2 tries on any board exam.

"Performance Data — NBOME" Performance Data — NBOME
 
Last edited:
fldoctorgirl said:
I find it a bit odd that they chose to word it as eligibility for level 3 as opposed to eligibility for licensure. No mention of whether a full license will be able to be obtained without the PE.

Edit: found something buried in the FAQ-- "We will annotate COMLEX-USA transcripts to note that the COMLEX-USA Level 2-PE was suspended on March 7, 2020 due to the pandemic, that temporary alternate pathways were provided, and that eligible candidates who complete the COMLEX-USA series of examinations via any of these pathways will be considered to have successfully completed the NBOME COMLEX-USA licensing examination program."
Click to expand...
Don't care. I absolutely do not trust them to not majorly screw over the class of '22 in some way with Level 3. I am not applying to any programs in the 5 or 6 weird states that require the full COMLEX series. I am taking Step 3 no matter what.
 
DrStephenStrange said:
Well, if I go with last year's numbers alone, 12.5% of 599 retakers didn't pass it. That's ~75 students for one year that probably failed out because many schools won't allow more than 2 tries on any board exam.

"Performance Data — NBOME" Performance Data — NBOME
Click to expand...
the USMLE cancelled their version clinical skills exam, and we will see how many people will file lawsuits from the MD side.

Also, it is stupid not to make a positive change because of the past or people who might sue against the organization. By that logic, the government should have never implemented the seatbelt law since there might be family memebers of the ppl who died because no mandated seatbelt law in the old days might file lawsuits against them.

The comlex PE does not accurately assess, it is subjective, and costs so much burden. It needs to go
 
penpineappleapplepen said:
the USMLE cancelled their version clinical skills exam, and we will see how many people will file lawsuits from the MD side.

Also, it is stupid not to make a positive change because of the past or people who might sue against the organization. By that logic, the government should have never implemented the seatbelt law since there might be family memebers of the ppl who died because no mandated seatbelt law in the old days might file lawsuits against them.

The comlex PE does not accurately assess, it is subjective, and costs so much burden. It needs to go
Click to expand...
I wasn't implying that it was bad to cancel the exam because people might sue. They can sue the nbome all day every day for all I care. The nbome shouldn't even exist anymore at this point. I was just thinking of all the people that could have probably been doctors if this stupid test didn't exist.
 
Alkaidius said:
I wouldn’t count on them keeling over just yet. You what they say about cockroaches and nuclear holocausts. Gotta remember to keep the outrage going next year for whatever garbage they cook up.
Click to expand...
I plan on staying active against them. But at the moment i'm spazzing out over match week. lol
Nervous Mental Health GIF by GIPHY Studios Originals
 
Alkaidius said:
I wouldn’t count on them keeling over just yet. You what they say about cockroaches and nuclear holocausts. Gotta remember to keep the outrage going next year for whatever garbage they cook up.
Click to expand...
Agreed. I won’t be surprised a bit if they find a way to institute a virtual setup version of PE. And they’re still getting money from Level 1, 2ce, and 3.
 
How would you try to contact reps and osteopathic boards in the weird states that require full COMLEX? There are a LOT of programs in those states...
 
Jackaleauxpe said:
How would you try to contact reps and osteopathic boards in the weird states that require full COMLEX? There are a LOT of programs in those states...
Click to expand...
Correct me if I'm wrong but my understanding is that they won't require the PE for licensure for class of 2021. Who know's what will happen for class of 2020 but hopefully people push to eliminate the PE for good
 
ritts said:
Correct me if I'm wrong but my understanding is that they won't require the PE for licensure for class of 2021. Who know's what will happen for class of 2020 but hopefully people push to eliminate the PE for good
Click to expand...
I'm talking about the ones where Level 3 is required and you can't take Step 3 instead.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

wxman
COMLEX Level 2 PE
Replies
9
Views
2K
EDThoracotomy
EDThoracotomy
J
NBOME - COMLEX PE
Replies
8
Views
2K
PandaBaer
PandaBaer
D
The return of the Level 2-PE in a year?
Replies
4
Views
1K
Goro
Goro
W
How is your school addressing aways?
Replies
17
Views
2K
Scrubs101
Scrubs101
C
Permanent Address for Residency Application
Replies
4
Views
717
Coltuna
C
Top