CHOOSE YOUR OWWN IV - Game Thread

[beans2020]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

I'm tempted to go ahead and throw my vote on barks too even though it will bring us closer to hammer. I feel like we're not going to be able to move on until we've flipped her.
Also my village reads are voting there and I feel ok about them sooo...

 

[apoptosis09]

Dubz being scum makes my head hurt. Can we revisit this later?

I still dont think she is fwiw, I'm mostly trying to work out how many scum we have in play

 

[beans2020]

@Zenge142 who are you planning on voting for today? Barks or someone else?

 

[apoptosis09]

was just saying so to try to get people to pause on yeeting a potential useful PR

This is what I'm leaning towards

 

[beans2020]

I still dont think she is fwiw, I'm mostly trying to work out how many scum we have in play

In my mind it has to be at least 2 factions still since 2 NK - I just don't know if there's a remaining wolf plus mafia/something else or if the wolves are wiped out and its two different factions we haven't flipped anyone from yet.
And that's not including whatever happened to fruit...

 

[beans2020]

Also this is completely unrelated but I'm curious - my other vet student friends, do you have classes/exams next week? We don't have our finals until next week (even though we had 3 exams this week ugh) and only get two weeks off for Christmas and I'm slightly salty.

 

[Zenge142]

I miss @SARdoghandler 😢

Also I need her to answer my question about how she's reading Barks

 

[kitzsuna]

Also this is completely unrelated but I'm curious - my other vet student friends, do you have classes/exams next week? We don't have our finals until next week (even though we had 3 exams this week ugh) and only get two weeks off for Christmas and I'm slightly salty.

Not in vet school yet, but that’s my schedule too. One final, have to survive work next week then im off for two for university closure (actually had to take 1.5 days off to get the full 2 weeks 🙄)

 

[WildZoo]

You know what, **** it. I'm throwing it down.

SAR IS VILLAGE AND YES THIS IS THE SOUL READ

 

[apoptosis09]

Also this is completely unrelated but I'm curious - my other vet student friends, do you have classes/exams next week? We don't have our finals until next week (even though we had 3 exams this week ugh) and only get two weeks off for Christmas and I'm slightly salty.

We have "true" finals week next week, but we had two final exams between lecture days this week 🥲 so we're not out for good until the 18th, but we also don't go back until the second week of Jan

 

[apoptosis09]

You know what, **** it. I'm throwing it down.

SAR IS VILLAGE AND YES THIS IS THE SOUL READ

Just vibes or?

 

[Zenge142]

You know what, **** it. I'm throwing it down.

SAR IS VILLAGE AND YES THIS IS THE SOUL READ

Well then I think I have a problem with the Barks vote.

Day 3 Yeet Tally
Barks (3) - Dubz, alissa, kitz

3/10
yeet close in ~20.5 hours

Imma hold off the hammer but I'm with y'all in spirit

So I guess I'm at apop, barks, and sar.

I’m down for a barks yeet

Anyways my poe is sar/barky/beans/zenge/apop ( 🙁 )

Because assuming SAR is village and not aligned with Barks pack, then literally every single person in this game is okay with a Barks yeet (SAR being an unknown but if we assume village, then the argument is the same).

It gives me pause that not a single person is defending what could readily be described as low hanging fruit due to lack of activity. I did find Barks early scum read on Spurs to be genuine. It really looks like she came to a scum read there and pushed it, which reads more villagy.

Barks could be Scum, but based on this gamestate, she'd basically have to be a serial killer, because there's no one in this game aligned with Barks.

 

[WildZoo]

Just vibes or?

I reread

I can't really explain my SAR soul read. I understand that makes it difficult for everyone else. But in years and years of playing with her, I have something very close to a 100% accurate read rate on her (when I'm village). I just know her pure soul when I see it. I went back through some of her earlier posts and it's there.

There's actually other stuff that supports this read in this game in particular but I'm not at a point where I'm inclined to talk about that yet, outside of being fairly confident that she wouldn't choose to scum again.

 

[WildZoo]

Well then I think I have a problem with the Barks vote.







Because assuming SAR is village and not aligned with Barks pack, then literally every single person in this game is okay with a Barks yeet (SAR being an unknown but if we assume village, then the argument is the same).

It gives me pause that not a single person is defending what could readily be described as low hanging fruit due to lack of activity. I did find Barks early scum read on Spurs to be genuine. It really looks like she came to a scum read there and pushed it, which reads more villagy.

Barks could be Scum, but based on this gamestate, she'd basically have to be a serial killer, because there's no one in this game aligned with Barks.

1) Why couldn't she be mafia or alien? It's not disallowed for them to exist solo afaik

2) I still think she and beans could be aligned. Rule of threes on that post you quoted.

3) she's gotten enough scrutiny that it would be very unusual for a partner to try to defend her at this stage.

 

[Zenge142]

1) Why couldn't she be mafia or alien? It's not disallowed for them to exist solo afaik

Why couldn't she be town?

2) I still think she and beans could be aligned. Rule of threes on that post you quoted.

You think Beans is hard bussing Barks here?

3) she's gotten enough scrutiny that it would be very unusual for a partner to try to defend her at this stage.

You'd expect someone to propose alternative yeet options.

 

[alissa14]

I reread

I can't really explain my SAR soul read. I understand that makes it difficult for everyone else. But in years and years of playing with her, I have something very close to a 100% accurate read rate on her (when I'm village). I just know her pure soul when I see it. I went back through some of her earlier posts and it's there.

There's actually other stuff that supports this read in this game in particular but I'm not at a point where I'm inclined to talk about that yet, outside of being fairly confident that she wouldn't choose to scum again.

Eh *shrug* good enough for me

 

[WildZoo]

Why couldn't she be town?

You think Beans is hard bussing Barks here?

You'd expect someone to propose alternative yeet options.

1) I just don't think she is I found her assertion that she's unpartnered from Spurs disingenuine based on the posts I saw, and I felt the same way about beans' comment in her interaction post. Like I mentioned before, I don't think that necessarily means she IS a werewolf, but I do think she was making it seem like there was more there than there actually was after the fact, to try to wriggle out of POEs.

2) Why wouldn't she at this point?

3) I would not expect that today, no, unless her partner had so much village equity that they wouldn't be hurt by it if barks still flipped. Who here do you think could get away with that?


I don't think looking at today is particularly helpful for this argument. You'd need to bring evidence from before barks was clearly the next consensus vote of the blocc.

 

[alissa14]

Zenge
Dubz
SAR
kitz
rae
apop
Clem
beans
Barks

 

[WildZoo]

If we were talking about a 3-4 scum pack, sure. That's not likely to be the case here though.

If barks has ONE partner, you really think they're gonna stick their neck out to save her? Did you do that for mayo in CYO III?

 

[kaydubs]

Day 3 Yeet Tally
Barks (4) - Dubz, alissa, kitz, rae

4/10
yeet close in ~10 hours

 

[WildZoo]

I lost my spot in my reread smh

 

[Zenge142]

I found her assertion that she's unpartnered from Spurs disingenuine based on the posts I saw,

I mean if she's scum and I have cold feet, that's one thing. If she's partnered with Spurs and PSV I'll be shook to my core.

 

[WildZoo]

I mean if she's scum and I have cold feet, that's one thing. If she's partnered with Spurs and PSV I'll be shook to my core.

Have you played with scum Barks before?

 

[apoptosis09]

I reread

I can't really explain my SAR soul read. I understand that makes it difficult for everyone else. But in years and years of playing with her, I have something very close to a 100% accurate read rate on her (when I'm village). I just know her pure soul when I see it. I went back through some of her earlier posts and it's there.

There's actually other stuff that supports this read in this game in particular but I'm not at a point where I'm inclined to talk about that yet, outside of being fairly confident that she wouldn't choose to scum again.

I'll take your word for it for now unless something new comes up 😅

 

[WildZoo]

The rest of what I said in that comment is important anyway.

 

[Zenge142]

Have you played with scum Barks before?

That's a loaded question

 

[WildZoo]

That's a loaded question

Why? I'm just asking so I have context

 

[Zenge142]

Why? I'm just asking so I have context

You know I have!

 

[Zenge142]

Why? I'm just asking so I have context

EMOJIS RING ANY BELLS DUBZ??

 

[WildZoo]

Beans isn't even voting for barks, where's the hard bussing

 

[WildZoo]

EMOJIS RING ANY BELLS DUBZ??

Oh right look it's been long enough since that game, I forgot she was in that pack (sorry Barks)

 

[Zenge142]

Beans isn't even voting for barks, where's the hard bussing

I've been town reading Beans all game, so I'm less interested in pre-flipping Barks scum, and pre-flipping Beans as an obvious scum partner.

I could be wrong. But for the purpose of this discussion and trying to solve Barks, I'm not going to pre-flip Beans as an obvious Barks scum partner.

 

[WildZoo]

I've been town reading Beans all game, so I'm less interested in pre-flipping Barks scum, and pre-flipping Beans as an obvious scum partner.

I could be wrong. But for the purpose of this discussion and trying to solve Barks, I'm not going to pre-flip Beans as an obvious Barks scum partner.

I'm just saying it's a possibility, I'm not pre-flipping anyone. You said she'd have to be hard bussing barks, she's not even voting for her so that's inaccurate.

 

[WildZoo]

You've been upset by it every time I've voted for barks. Who would you rather be voting for today?

 

[WildZoo]

I just want to draw your attention to this tally from WWedding and you can tell me again how it would be so impossible for barks to be partners with Spurs, or how her vote for him in this game is clearing enough for her to make that assertion

Day One Please Take Your Seats Vote Tally

please (5) - AM, shorty, Bread, Dina, sloth
dina () -
shorty () -
Barks () -
AM (1) - genny
genny () -
cheezit (1) - alley
bread (3) - cyndia, cubs, please
cray () -
cubs () -
alley (1) - cheezit
sloth (3) - barks, Zenge, cray


14/14 votes
Leading: @vetschoolsletmeinplease
Missing: No one!
Deadline: TODAY (12/14) at 10pm EST/9pm CST/8pm MST/7pm fantasyland (6 minutes!)

SEND IN YOUR NIGHT ACTIONS, FOLKS

 

[apoptosis09]

I just want to draw your attention to this tally from WWedding and you can tell me again how it would be so impossible for barks to be partners with Spurs, or how her vote for him in this game is clearing enough for her to make that assertion

I genuinely thought that was the d1 tally with made up names 😂

 

[WildZoo]

I genuinely thought that was the d1 gallery with made up names 😂

Sorry, I just wanted to be clear why barks's vote for Spurs does nothing for me

 

[Zenge142]

You've been upset by it every time I've voted for barks. Who would you rather be voting for today?

I was upset by you not voting PSV. The barks of that was irrelevant.

Honestly I don’t feel strongly enough about anyone else, that I’ll be able to make a compelling enough case to get people to vote anyone else, and it would feel like just as much of a shot in the dark.

I’ll probably vote for Barks at EOD just for the sake of being on the vote.

I wouldn’t want to not at least talk about the thread state though.

 

[Zenge142]

Yeet Barks

@Animal Midwife @Dr. ForgotToFlush

 

[Clem J]

What i do 🥺

Be someone who might pick scum 🙁

 

[WildZoo]

I was upset by you not voting PSV. The barks of that was irrelevant.

Honestly I don’t feel strongly enough about anyone else, that I’ll be able to make a compelling enough case to get people to vote anyone else, and it would feel like just as much of a shot in the dark.

I’ll probably vote for Barks at EOD just for the sake of being on the vote.

I wouldn’t want to not at least talk about the thread state though.

It wasn't irrelevant to me

I for sure could be wrong about Barks, I'm often wrong about stuff, but if you don't even have another option you'd rather go for then like...

What is the point you are trying to make?

 

[Clem J]

Can you explain zenge pls

I can!

 

[beans2020]

Do you guys want hammer? Or do you want to have the rest of the cycle to chat? Bc I don't see the point in continuing to hold my vote to avoid hammer if there isn't anything else to discuss rn.

 

[beans2020]

We should be at 5 now with rae and zenge's votes for barks.

 

[WildZoo]

Yeet Barks

@Animal Midwife @Dr. ForgotToFlush

I think this puts us one away from hammer and I really would like to give barks a chance to respond

Unyeet barks

 

[Clem J]

I did find Barks early scum read on Spurs to be genuine. It really looks like she came to a scum read there and pushed it, which reads more villagy.

Insert multiball meme

 

[Clem J]

I reread

I can't really explain my SAR soul read. I understand that makes it difficult for everyone else. But in years and years of playing with her, I have something very close to a 100% accurate read rate on her (when I'm village). I just know her pure soul when I see it. I went back through some of her earlier posts and it's there.

There's actually other stuff that supports this read in this game in particular but I'm not at a point where I'm inclined to talk about that yet, outside of being fairly confident that she wouldn't choose to scum again.

This is unfortunate because I really want to kill Sar lol

 

[WildZoo]

I did find Barks early scum read on Spurs to be genuine. It really looks like she came to a scum read there and pushed it, which reads more villagy.

Where did she push it? I might have missed that but I thought I'd read all her posts

 

[Clem J]

OH GOD DAMN IT I MISSED A HAMMER CHANCE

 

[WildZoo]

This is unfortunate because I really want to kill Sar lol

You can do as you please, I'll just make fun of you when I'm right