I think I've been ignoring the nighttime cycles and maybe that's where we need to start looking. How many people get killed each night, try to identify why they got killed? That sort of thing.
I have been keeping track to see if there were patterns or anything - there hasn't been much detail really sadly, so here you go...
.Night 1 WTF killed by animal of some sort .
Bandierose - 9 (petpony, katie8, orcagirl, squirrelseule, minnerbelle, dyachei, kakurubird, trematode, nstarz)
Day 2 Mauled Bandierose villager innocent
Night 2 Hedgiehog followed trail of blood. Grad (villager) killed. Blackdog618 found piece of fabric. SOV killed wounds similar to that of WTFs (SOV was a villain)
DVMDream-5 (Petpony, CFC, hedgiehog, kakurubird, squirrelsrule)
Day 3 DVMdream (villager) mauled had special item fairy godmother
Night 3 Kaydubs (villager) murdered, kakurubird (villager) murdered bloody message left on wall had item compass
Day 4 dyachei mauled villager
Night 4 minnerbelle villager poison apple - killed
Day 5 blackdog mauled villager
Night 5 Emiloo killed shredded villager, Sheepsdogpsu wolf killed
Day 6 Nstarz mauled villager
Night 6 katie8 - villager - killed
Day 7 Squrrelsrule mauled - .
Wicked Stepmother of Cinderella (a wolf).
.
Night 7 PetPony - villager - killed.
.
Day 8 mauled Orca2011 - villager.