This is not allowed. You can't convert and then "out" your new fellow wolves. I guess a veteran could have told you that, otherwise conversions would be useless. Oh well.
Well then, that's my fault. I'm the one that pushed for not converting, specifically because I couldn't find somebody that I felt we could be reasonably sure would convert (for starters), and secondly because I was concerned of the risk of them converting to find our identities, revealing us, and then taking a bullet for the villagers.
LIS and CFC, did you guys chat about wolfy stuff?
Negative! Minnerbelle really did share concerns about CFC with me (I don't believe she knew I was a wolf at the time, but maybe she did and was being tricksy.). I wasn't confident enough about him to share my identity until it was too late to make it worthwhile (i.e. by the time I was confident, I was better off letting him be lynched). She and I talked briefly about the apple, but I had no time to really think about it before the night cycle, and she died the next day or night.
Um. You were awesome, TW, but frankly - most of the villager victory came from two wolf-on-wolf kills. If those hadn't happened ... different outcome. And don't forget - you killed more villagers than wolves.
😉 (But -- congrats!)
Just a few random thoughts:
1) On taking 'experienced' players first. Sorry, but put yourselves in our shoes. We're new, you're not, and we have to pick *SOMEBODY*. Sucky as it is to be WTF ... I can't apologize for what I still think was a good decision. And you were a villager, too. So pbbbbt. As for SOV; yeah, that move backfired big for us. After that we were in a 'take a potshot at each group' mode for a little while until we had a better feel for who the villagers were.
2) On why we took devyn and krist the same night. (I took devyn, I think, and orcagirl took krist.) I was *positive* the other wolf out there would take TigerWillow, and I didn't want to waste a kill opportunity, so I gambled. Clearly a poorly played gamble!
3) Dead people need to try harder not to influence things. Momentum is HUGE in this game - that's obvious even to a n00b like me. To have dead people responding when a live player says 'Why would I lie?' may not seem like much - but it influences.... suddenly you have live players with that much bigger seed of doubt... one votes to lynch.... another....
4) I know it's not against the rules to check login times, but I'd definitely encourage people to mask their presence via the settings. It kinda sucks to get accused mostly on the basis of whether you were on or not because the default assumption is you were here but just afraid to talk. In fact, vet school life gets in the way. Frequently.
🙁
5) Lissa was amazing. Really amazing. I think she responded to every one of my PMs within 30 minutes through the entire game. I sent in one of our night kills and made some comment about wanting to eat our next victim - the Pug, and Lissa rolled with it. Sorry Percy!
🙂
6) This was my first game. Thank you to the experienced and other new players for a really fun time!!! I had a blast! Hope I didn't stink it up too much as a n00b!
7) I got a B (pretty sure, anyway) on my organology test today. I bet I could have gotten an A if it weren't for this game.
😉