- Joined
- Jun 17, 2014
- Messages
- 63,099
- Reaction score
- 154,760
I thought it was 45 people died last night, correct? I thunk we need to be a lot more careful with claiming affiliations from now
WZ, poppy, samacs, pshelty/PSV
I thought it was 45 people died last night, correct? I thunk we need to be a lot more careful with claiming affiliations from now
Did she claim that it was specifically the same reason SAR vouched for her?
The reason SAR vouched for you was not affiliation/faction/alignment based. I believe they specifically clarified this. SAR vouched for you for a role-based reason, which is the same thing Zenge was referring to.I did and I’m not lying. I don’t know what Zenge is talking about.
I clarified why alley instead of the other two. You read village to me and Zenge already reads sus, so I'm just feeling out alleycat. No guarantees I will keep the vote on her, just wanted to force a response.Huh, interesting choice. I'm feeling village vibes on Alley
SAR said she didn’t know if I’m a wolf or not. I’m pretty sure she knows I’m church, which is why she vouched for me. I vouched for Nate for the same reason. I wasn’t 100% sure he wasn’t a wolf but I knew he was church. With Poppy’s flip being Those Who Slither in the Dark I’m even more confident SAR is not a wolf just like Nate wasn’t.The reason SAR vouched for you was not affiliation/faction/alignment based. I believe they specifically clarified this. SAR vouched for you for a role-based reason, which is the same thing Zenge was referring to.
You are vouching for Nate because he's of your same affiliation/faction/alignment (which, given all the flavor, I take to mean you're both Church).
You're also vouching for SAR because they're Church, right? But SAR did base their vouch on that (at least not publicly).
Is this a drunken lie?Last night someone sent me a tropical tea blend that I consumed and got intoxicated by it. In order to not be eliminated from the game, I claim that I resurrected Nate, and that was my only 1-shot ability.
Drunken truth plsIs this a drunken lie?
What do you make of SAR and Zenge’s discussion that once SAR dies, we can go ahead and yeet you and/or there’s a time in the future when it would be appropriate to yeet you?SAR said she didn’t know if I’m a wolf or not. I’m pretty sure she knows I’m church, which is why she vouched for me. I vouched for Nate for the same reason. I wasn’t 100% sure he wasn’t a wolf but I knew he was church. With Poppy’s flip being Those Who Slither in the Dark I’m even more confident SAR is not a wolf just like Nate wasn’t.
I don’t comprehend it.What do you make of SAR and Zenge’s discussion that once SAR dies, we can go ahead and yeet you and/or there’s a time in the future when it would be appropriate to yeet you?
Agreed.II’ll say it again. I trust that the church exists. I don’t trust that they’re good.
Hmmm, I'm shocked at the double resurrections of Nate and Vis. Unsure if we can trust them.I'm at a weird spot regarding my reads where my top suspicionseither aren't able to be voted or are being given a grace period.
@VeggieTrex and @miranda920 Could you let me know where you head is at today?
why?Thinking but i think i want to
Yeet mirandas
I'm surprise by your assumption that Nate must be a villager and Vis must be a wolf when villagers have rezzed wolves multiple times and vice versa. And the disregarding of genny is pretty eh. I still don't understand how fluff is confirmed village but no one seems willing to explain that to me.Time for a long post.
First, I have to assume Viz is resurrected wolf. Wouldn’t lynch them now because we can always get ‘em later, but they are strong wolf in my mind.
fwiw, the wolf being revealed and not in a faction, and the wrongful lynch of Nate have me comfortable saying if you know a faction member, they are village for now. I think there are 5 factions as some have said. Seems like there are faction leaders who seem to know more than others and this dissymmetry of information is leading to bad lynches from people. I think there are non affiliated villagers as well to keep it harder to find the wolves.
strong village reads,
Nate: rezzed by a villager,
Fluff: definitely villager to me.
wisp: definitely villager
SOV: 100% villager and others have made it clear
very likely villager
sars: based on play and faction vouching,
zuri.lawpy: just Seems like another person who is in a faction so has some knowledge and is flamed for it. Lawpy play is very villagery,
santy: based mainly on play. Makes some errors but village like to me.
village leans
chica: good call on poppy. Agreed with her day 2 list. Didn’t know about factions but has a win condition. Not sure what if anything that means, but I am good with her.
wondalfy: has ok reads. contributes doesn’t stand out.
mayo: good call on poppy. Seems to be trying from the get go.
clem: faction related support. But somehow doesn’t resonate as strongly with me.
strong not wolf read
April: could be neutral, more likely unaligned villager doesn’t matter plays like a villager
confused
zenge: don’t understand how they fit in the fluff sars etc alignment, but seems clued in on factions. Lean more village.
mother: bad reads and , seems to be overplaying it as a dumb wolf, but Nate for some reason had her strong village, would like to hear more why from him. so for now I move her from lean wolfy to confused..
not sure but lean wolfy
miranda: seems to overplay lack of knowledge. doesnt read thread fully IMO, maybe busy wolfing. Defended poppy in her reads.
veggie: defended by poppy. Makes finding factions seem, wolfy when unrelated. Just don’t get a great village feel. Doesn’t help AM thinks she is villager.
stronger wolf feels
alley: she mostly plays same as wolf or village so hard to read. I didn’t like her showing up late 1/2 hour until close to join the bandwagon. That is a wolf thing: Just showing up for Lynch. first day everything was Mostly useless posts.
wolfy
AM: tunneling too much, been way off on zuri and fluff, Nate and me.
viz: looks to have been rezzed by a wolf.
Ignore until further notice
genny: honestly didn’t feel as much alpha wolf second time around. If she were alpha I would think she would have more fun with it.
my vote is going to be AM, alley, vegg or Miranda unless something major changes, or we get more info.
also, poppy a couple of times gave the “don’t vote for noobs” comment, so that makes me want to yeet a noob.
I need a break. I have been at this all day.
Edit: the categories from top to bottom go more village to more wild (except genny - she is her own world). Within categories order is irrelevant. Randomly from my notes. And fixed some grammatical errors
Fair enough, Not in a rush to act on that but wouldn’t trust them with my dogs (IRL joke).It's very likely that multiple factions have a revive so I wouldn't auto assume just because we saw one dead wolf revive, that Viz is a wolf
Alley a few times. Don’t recall much tbh.I'm surprise by your assumption that Nate must be a villager and Vis must be a wolf when villagers have rezzed wolves multiple times and vice versa. And the disregarding of genny is pretty eh. I still don't understand how fluff is confirmed village but no one seems willing to explain that to me.
Could you remind me if you played with alley before btw? I don't recall that.
Okay. I seem to remember this being your first game togther.Alley a few times. Don’t recall much tbh.
The lack of explaining is reminding me why village struggles in basics game.fluff is 100% village. Some things can’t be explained.
Yes. I can think of three from games I played off the top of my head. Like let's see what people post and who they push before labeling them.as for Nate, a village rez a wolf? Multiple times? News to me. If so I guess he drops down a bit.
A villager uses their rez. The rezzed villager converts to wolf upon revival. The end.How does a villager rez a wolf, at some point I want to know that context
That's sounds very grossA villager uses their rez. The rezzed villager converts to wolf upon revival. The end.
All conversion is, but that's what I'm used to. So I've come to at least be grateful that it's the easiest to interpret VCA-wise over vs the living types.That's sounds very gross
I react to everythinghow common is it for alleycat to solely react to posts for like 4 pages, and then finally officially enter the thread around the 240 post marker, and just fluff? its just weird to me that they were clearly reading, and entered with nothing
unless its common practice for them to mindlessly react to posts
OK how did u end up Poppy in general, I honestly didn't mean to imply EoD when I wrote that post
Poppy is square inside my POE and so far I don't have any village points for her. Something about her posts yesterday didn't sit right with me. I am not caught up and haven't read almost any posts that don't quote or tag me since this morning so none of my reads have been revised since then
Wish I had more to add to what I've already said but I didn't catch up at all last night, couldn't even keep up with the new posts. The read was mostly vibes and partly POE since I have a lot more village reads than scum readsPoppy's posts just felt a bit disorganized and wishy washy yesterday and I wasn't vibing with her in the way that I've been vibing with my many village reads. Hoping I can read more of what she's said today to get a better feel
wasn’t there another allie then who played a lot? Maybe I am confusing them. if she is less than a year or so player then my error.Okay. I seem to remember this being your first game togther.
When have we played a game together before this one?she mostly plays same as wolf or village so hard to read
Allieh.wasn’t there another allie then who played a lot? Maybe I am confusing them. if she is less than a year or so player then my error.
As far as I know I've never played with him before. I could be wrong but I don't recall playing any games with SOV. I've only been playing since the December 2020 noob game (cartoons).Okay. I seem to remember this being your first game togther.
The lack of explaining is reminding me why village struggles in basics game.
Yes. I can think of three from games I played off the top of my head. Like let's see what people post and who they push before labeling them.
It’s possible, but if so, she didn’t know what aff I would come back as. I do believe the fluff/Nate stuff. They could still be a harmful faction but I don’t believe they’re wolves. Or I guess it’s technically possible aff after rez is randomized and Nate was randomized to wolf, but I don’t have reason to believe that.Hmm
So poppy rezzed vissy?
Oops. This was is definitely a mea culpa. Allieh. They both have the same style though. Lol.Allieh.
Alley is from 3 noob games ago
****You’re right, I just haven’t had the chance to really sit down and understand the arguments. I will do this at the airport!
I will say yesterday was arguably the most stressful/important day of my life, so I really haven’t had a chance to truly analyze the responses. I am doing my best!
Maybe “random” wasn’t the best choice of words. I recognize there are cases and arguments being made, but haven’t read into them enough to form a real opinion.
Fluff is ALWAYS wolfy to me. Pretty sure I thought she was a wolf during her first noob game and I'm fairly confident I misyeeted her before because I thought she was a wolf at least once, probably twice (anniversary? some other game? idk). Not sure if she was a wolf in any games I've played with her.1000 words may have been an inflated figure....
I was responding to this answer from Fluff
Basically I was saying I thought Alley's thought process seemed genuine? Like she found Fluff wolfy. but she also recognized that she read her as wolfy in the noob game and was wrong there...
Which sent me down this rabbit hole of "was she wrong there????" Because Fluff was scum siding as a 3p, so reading her as wolfy is totally valid in the noob game.
But then why be hesitant here? Alley read her as wolfy, she was wolf siding, so essentially she was right.
But then if Alley was right, why would there be any hesitation here? Like is Fluff right, and she's being hedgy?
But then if Alley was right there on her Fluff read, maybe she's right here and doubting herself?
It was a lot of ping ponging on that. And then the forum ate it and I got grumpy and went to bed.
quoting this because I don't remember those that slither in the dark being mentioned before Poppy's flip. Slip?agreed. I think the wolves are their own thing. They're gonna be Those Who Slither in the Dark
![]()
You might be onto something. Hold plsquoting this because I don't remember those that slither in the dark being mentioned before Poppy's flip. Slip?
I searched "slither" in SDN's search engine and this is the very first mention:quoting this because I don't remember those that slither in the dark being mentioned before Poppy's flip. Slip?
I recall someone being like "I don't think that wasn't the exact wording in the write up though?"I think the wolves are part of "Those who slither in the Dark" based on the intro write up.
This is the flavor that was used in the intro post. No slitheringthe darkness on the outskirts
Zuri was the one who pointed out the slithering thingAlso totally beside the point, but nowhere does it say the darkness slithers.
*******
Did you fly out of KCI or mhk's airport? If it was KCI we might've been there at the same time!
****
Ah nice I was going to analyze the whole who mentioned slither/who didn't/who agreed later. I'll still give my thoughts/analysis laterI searched "slither" in SDN's search engine and this is the very first mention:
I recall someone being like "I don't think that wasn't the exact wording in the write up though?"
Hmmm
Thinking
Well Miranda died night 2 so there's not much to go on. It seems relatively similarCan the people who played in the noob game comment on how Miranda sounds here compared to the noob game? Same, different? And what was her alignment in the previous game?
@Wondalfy @motheatenlysis @VeggieTrex @justafluff @chicandtoughness
Oh she was village btwWell Miranda died night 2 so there's not much to go on. It seems relatively similar
Wait. What? I didn't think Miranda diedWell Miranda died night 2 so there's not much to go on. It seems relatively similar