GGoats!! - An aMAAAAAHzing WW thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Who are your other wolf reads?

my next best wolf read is April, but the two big unshifting wagons also scare me a bit as previously mentioned, so i don't know if i'm comfy voting that way either (also risking a tie if my count is correct? ties scare me after emoji game)

I'm gonna go reanalyze my full list/review some people i haven't looked at closely yet and see if that helps bring me any clarity
 
Savage.
1613440197224.jpeg
 
my next best wolf read is April, but the two big unshifting wagons also scare me a bit as previously mentioned, so i don't know if i'm comfy voting that way either (also risking a tie if my count is correct? ties scare me after emoji game)

I'm gonna go reanalyze my full list/review some people i haven't looked at closely yet and see if that helps bring me any clarity
There's still a significant portion of non-voters though + 1 hour until yeet close. Can you clarify what's scaring you between the two wagons?
 
Also, if I was a wolf or chaos with the explode-y bits, I would definitely just act sketchy until yeet close and not role reveal, because why give people an option to es-cap-é?
 
Official D1 Who Let the GOATS Out Tally
April (4) - sunshine, Dina, mayo, Barks
Doggo () -
alissa () -
Barks (1) - Doggo
shorty () -
Pippy (5) - shorty, AM, Lainey, Cray, Zenge
mayo (1) - April
AM () -
samac () -
dubz (1) - Pippy
Enigma (1) - samac

13/17 voting
Missing: @WildZoo @alissa14 @TelemarketingEnigma @mkg323
Yeet close at 11pm AST/10pm MST/9pm CST/8pm MST/7pm PST today
~1 hour

Meh Goat GIF by MOODMAN


(If I missed any votes, please let me know asap, that was a real fast scrolling job to get ya'll an updated tally)
 
There's still a significant portion of non-voters though + 1 hour until yeet close. Can you clarify what's scaring you between the two wagons?
In the previous games i've played, it seems like two strong wagons without much movement often means the wolves are happy because a non-wolf is going to get yeeted either way, so they either settle comfortably in a wagon or stay on whatever lone vote they landed on early (usually with the pack distributed in different places). I haven't been in a game yet where a wolf got successfully yeeted D1 though, so it might just be my bias scaring me. You're also right that there's still time for movement
 
In the previous games i've played, it seems like two strong wagons without much movement often means the wolves are happy because a non-wolf is going to get yeeted either way, so they either settle comfortably in a wagon or stay on whatever lone vote they landed on early (usually with the pack distributed in different places). I haven't been in a game yet where a wolf got successfully yeeted D1 though, so it might just be my bias scaring me. You're also right that there's still time for movement
So you're not wolfreading either?
 
In the previous games i've played, it seems like two strong wagons without much movement often means the wolves are happy because a non-wolf is going to get yeeted either way, so they either settle comfortably in a wagon or stay on whatever lone vote they landed on early (usually with the pack distributed in different places). I haven't been in a game yet where a wolf got successfully yeeted D1 though, so it might just be my bias scaring me. You're also right that there's still time for movement
I know it hasn't happened in the games you've played yet, but in the last game, there were 2 strong wagons and they were BOTH wolves, plus an initial smaller wagon on a third one. Just keep that in mind.
 
Wow that was a lot to catch up on. Some of my thoughts

Barks is reading village to me, her tone and content are a lot different from when she was a wolf in Emojis.

AM is reading village lean for me. Don't want to dump her in the village pile cause she is a good wolf.

April is on the wolf side of the pile. Somethings just have not added up.

Lainey, I was reading wolfie, but want to hear a little more from her before I put her in the wolf pile. Wolf lean pile

Shorty is in the village lean pile. Been making a lot of sense to me and following what she(?) is thinking.

Cray is in my neutral pile. Have not gotten any village or wolfie feels.

Pippy is reading very frustrated to me. I do not think she is a wolf, and am willing to believe her 3P claim, but I really do not know what to do. She is a good player, even if she doesnt think she is. Neutral pile while I reread some more and try to make sense of things.

Alissa been pretty absent. Of the few posts I remember, pretty echoey on the whole me/Barks voting each other thing.

TE is in my neutral pile. Been posting some good posts and reads and have been following her thoughts, but havent gotten a village feel there yet.

Mayo I need to reread his posts. Neutral pile.

Mkg is in my neutral pile. Is a noob, but making some really good posts.

Zenge is also in my neutral pile. Need to reread his posts too.



Consolidated lists since above is very random:

Village/Village lean:
Barks
AM
Shorty

Neutral:
Pip
TE
Alissa
Zenge
mkg
Cray

Wolf/Wolf Lean:
April
Lainey
 
Wow that was a lot to catch up on. Some of my thoughts

Barks is reading village to me, her tone and content are a lot different from when she was a wolf in Emojis.

AM is reading village lean for me. Don't want to dump her in the village pile cause she is a good wolf.

April is on the wolf side of the pile. Somethings just have not added up.

Lainey, I was reading wolfie, but want to hear a little more from her before I put her in the wolf pile. Wolf lean pile

Shorty is in the village lean pile. Been making a lot of sense to me and following what she(?) is thinking.

Cray is in my neutral pile. Have not gotten any village or wolfie feels.

Pippy is reading very frustrated to me. I do not think she is a wolf, and am willing to believe her 3P claim, but I really do not know what to do. She is a good player, even if she doesnt think she is. Neutral pile while I reread some more and try to make sense of things.

Alissa been pretty absent. Of the few posts I remember, pretty echoey on the whole me/Barks voting each other thing.

TE is in my neutral pile. Been posting some good posts and reads and have been following her thoughts, but havent gotten a village feel there yet.

Mayo I need to reread his posts. Neutral pile.

Mkg is in my neutral pile. Is a noob, but making some really good posts.

Zenge is also in my neutral pile. Need to reread his posts too.



Consolidated lists since above is very random:

Village/Village lean:
Barks
AM
Shorty

Neutral:
Pip
TE
Alissa
Zenge
mkg
Cray

Wolf/Wolf Lean:
April
Lainey
Why do you think Pippy is 3p?
 
So you're not wolfreading either?
no I'm wolfreading both lol (probably not in the same pack, but both high on sketch list, maybe w/3p), but my fear is making me second guess myself
I know it hasn't happened in the games you've played yet, but in the last game, there were 2 strong wagons and they were BOTH wolves, plus an initial smaller wagon on a third one. Just keep that in mind.
oh dear...
 
Also, if I was a wolf or chaos with the explode-y bits, I would definitely just act sketchy until yeet close and not role reveal, because why give people an option to es-cap-é?
I dunno, why'd you start saying "wow this seems too easy" about my vote during the speed game? You like to play with your food :shrug:
 
She did her wolf tell, which I am absolutely not posting on the thread even under threat of death.

Dubz knows what it is though, so look to her if cray flips wolf when I go kablooey
And if you guys are wrong?

And if I've done it, why don't we look to Dubz now?

I'm starting to wonder if both of you are non-village now.
 
She did her wolf tell, which I am absolutely not posting on the thread even under threat of death.

Dubz knows what it is though, so look to her if cray flips wolf when I go kablooey
Uh...I actually have no idea what you're talking about. Also if I had a wolf tell for cray I'd tell her what it was lol
 
And if you guys are wrong?

And if I've done it, why don't we look to Dubz now?

I'm starting to wonder if both of you are non-village now.
Why are you dragging me into pip's nonsense

Actually, why is pip dragging me into her nonsense
 
Unofficial D1 Who Let the GOATS Out Tally
April (5)
- sunshine, Dina, mayo, Barks, Doggo
Doggo () -
alissa () -
Barks () -
shorty () -
Pippy (5) - shorty, AM, Lainey, Cray, Zenge
mayo (1) - April
AM () -
samac () -
dubz (1) - Pippy
Enigma (1) - samac

13/17 voting
Missing: @WildZoo @alissa14 @TelemarketingEnigma @mkg323
Yeet close at 11pm AST/10pm MST/9pm CST/8pm MST/7pm PST today
~ 55 min

Meh Goat GIF by MOODMAN
 
You think there are different packs?
no, i just don't know if i see them both in the same pack (so if one is wolf, i feel less strongly about the other). I don't think it's an impossibility though, since pippy has been defending april. It just feels a little blatant for someone at risk of being yeeted (if pippy gets yeeted and flips wolf, that defense might make april look more sus)

If pippy is a 3p as claimed, then i don't know that her defense of april matters since she could be as right or wrong about her reads as any of us, and she likely doesn't have any actual knowledge of april's role with her own claimed role ability
 
If pippy is a 3p as claimed, then i don't know that her defense of april matters since she could be as right or wrong about her reads as any of us, and she likely doesn't have any actual knowledge of april's role with her own claimed role ability
Correct, I'm also a terrible villager these days despite what shorty suddenly seems to believe
 
Correct, I'm also a terrible villager these days despite what shorty suddenly seems to believe
What is it I seem to believe? I don't think we've ever played in the same game, I've just read other games you were in, and I didn't find you super sketchy. Which is why today is confusing me.
 
no, i just don't know if i see them both in the same pack (so if one is wolf, i feel less strongly about the other). I don't think it's an impossibility though, since pippy has been defending april. It just feels a little blatant for someone at risk of being yeeted (if pippy gets yeeted and flips wolf, that defense might make april look more sus)

If pippy is a 3p as claimed, then i don't know that her defense of april matters since she could be as right or wrong about her reads as any of us, and she likely doesn't have any actual knowledge of april's role with her own claimed role ability
Have you finished reading up on the other players?
 
Right, but why does that make more sense than her being a wolf?
She very well could be, but that is not how I've read her this game, hence the neutral pile. Her lack of answering questions is starting to make me raise an eyebrow though
 
1. @Animal Midwife
Village
2. @alissa14
Need more. Mayo defended. Pip defended Mayo.
3. @Zenge142
Village
4. @Aprilthearab
Sketch. Need more.
5. @PippyPony
The world's biggest liar.
6. @mkg323
Too good to be village noob.
7. @WildZoo
Sketch. Need more. Pip has tried really hard to shade.
8. @sunshinefl
Need more. Quiet is sketch.
10. @Doggo Labs
Neutral.
13. @Barkley13
Neutral.
14. @Dinashadow
Village.
17. @supershorty
Village.
22. @LaineyLou
Sketch. Need more.
23. @samac
Village-ish but need more.
36. @TelemarketingEnigma
Village.
127. @holdthemayo
My next vote. Pip/Mayo interactions make them look like packmate lovers.

In case Pip can carry out her threat and I'm not long for this world.
 
Top