Hell if I know. Like I said, I wanted to throw him into the neutrals but we know there’s 3 total and if I had to choose, this pinged me.
I'm not a huge fan of the backtracking now that this reasoning isn't working out for you
I disagree that there was anything inherently wrong with Mayo's previous play, people can play however they want and we were all adjusted to the way he played
Why genny over bob or bread?
Why are you talking about yourself in the 3rd person lol
Keep things interesting.
I was wondering who was going to give me **** for that lol.
Also to add to that, I feel the shakiest about Bread. So I would choose between Genny and Bob.
I'm assuming this is what you're referring to in regards to bread
I don't really blame him for thinking you and mayo felt w/v, a lot of other people thought that too. It seems he hopped onto the thread before hitting the road and probably saw that interaction going down and everyone talking about it and didn't have the time to go back and consider someone else. I'd like to see how he feels once he's done driving and can catch up on the thread
Seemed normal to dubz
The cojones it takes to put Mel at the top of your village reads despite never having played with him before.... wow.
This doesn't really give me a good inclination of whether or not they could be wolfing together but here's what I found, lol
Like I’ve said, knowing there’s three total, if I had to pick one, he’s my pick, but he’s the shakiest of my picks.
Yeah, I think so.
I specified the groups weren’t in order, so Mel isn’t “at the top”. Mel’s thread presence and contributions read village to me.
Were you also wondering if anyone would give you **** for leaving your v/ status up in the air in that post?
Distancing. Got to separate those wolf thoughts in the brain from the village thoughts.
... why?
Thats my problem. All wolf-brain...all the time....
This is incongruent with me changing my style and attracting more attention. I'm a good, experienced wolf, adept at hiding, so you figured me out right away. Yes, makes sense.
Because I'm stubborn and don't feel like moving.
Ok this makes sense
I think his point is that if we think an experienced person is wolfing it's probably a better bet to yeet them over a noob who we think is wolfing
Can you be more specific? Who?
I don't know about Zenge's reasons, but I feel like the incongruence lies with you right now. Your voting and joke posts aren't really lining up with who you're suspicious of.
The way people are declaring ppl village this game is making my skin crawl
I think it's baseline for Sunny. There comes a point where it's wolfy and AI for her, but that can be tough to call.awww is someone a little jealous?
You know what you’ve also done as a wolf? Pushed bad logic on thread (I.e. voting dubz based on an emoji), and then doubled down on it and tunneled when people started poking holes in your theory.
Besides her, what two other players would you consider voting today and why?
my n=1 on wolf!sunny is from the last game I played, so I recognize the tendency for recall bias. Does anyone have more data? Is this AI or just baseline?
I would appreciate expansion on what specifically pinged your radar.
Who else is on your suspicious list right now?
@Viscernable what are your thoughts on April?
Oh? How do you know I'm not right?
That's not what I said, and it's not what I meant. I think you are much more free with play style advice/opinions/etc when you're a villager. You also tend to aim that advice at people who match you in terms of being vocal and confident in their own style. Unfortunately that sometimes means you sometimes end up sussing people who are not afraid to say wolfy stuff.
This reads list reads kinda wolfy. Full of truisms and less with AI
Agreed.
... because I still don't know why you're voting for Vis but throwing shade everywhere else?
Agreed
Well one day they may not, maybe another game, may as well develop the right habits now.
Yes. But also your play so far feels pocket-y
believe it or not I've been waiting for you to say this so I can move you into my village pile.
Nah. I would almost assume that person doesn't have a PR (and if they really give a damn about village team's wincon wouldn't be skirting death on purpose) and that they might make a great misyeet if they aren't NK'd, sus may build on them and they may be too checked out to defend well. That plus likely lack of PR makes such a player possibly great for end game or safe to leave alive for a bit. I know this implicates me, but a wolf could invoke LIS rule and vote them with impunity. I'm not doing that, yet, I have wolfier concerns elsewhere besides inappropriate wishes for death (if coming from a villager).
Half the time I can't make out what he really thinks, but sure. I can think of lots of other players that are communicative and have fun too, and good reads. Dubz, genny, April, come to mind right away. Mayo is quite far from best villager in my mind just because of his constant BS. He regularly almost gets yeeted just for posting nonsense, and the worst thing he does is not answer *direct* questions when he's a villager ffs. Playing one game well as a neutral 3P also hardly qualifies one for best villager either. But yanno, people can nom or vote whoever they want.
Fine fine, you got me, it was all a reaction test. As long as I'm gone by approximately Wednesday, mmk?
🤷🏼♀️ I just think you're wrong. I got to see his logic & evaluation process behind the scenes in England and imo it's one of the main reasons why village won that game.
It only backfires if we're wrong, that could mean killing off an experienced villager, and keeping noob villagers. But point taken
Sigh. I don't feel lately, especially with decently experienced players, that we've had much luck playing this little reaction test game where we try to draw out who seems overly convinced some other player is village.
You literally just said 40 min ago that you're creeped out by people saying others are village
Ah well I like this and think it's a good read of my meta. No matter how well/not well I may cover it up, I definitely subjectively always feel a pressure not to rock the boat too much when I wolf.
Eh, not quite. I'll let you know if I see it. It's not always just a single post but a flavor in general. I think she was hinting that she was intentionally changing her tone up a bit anyway for MU srs bizness reasons (whether that's true or just to cover wolfiness,
) so might not be useful this game.
Yes, but the game where someone tries to draw it out of someone vs just noting where it happens is different. I feel like wolfy slips happen most where a known (to the wolf) villager DOESN'T say "Oh gee how can you be so sure they're village?" Like, when a wolf is put on the spot to read someone and they know they're on the spot they know to be more careful than that.
