Ice Cream WW Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Gone and eaten is @Barkley13 , Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream and a Vanilla Townie

mint-chocolate-chip-ice-cream-9Q2B0295-600x900.jpg
It is now Day 3.

Player Roster

0. @Dr. ForgotToFlush
1. @kraskadva
3. @Ms Procrastinator
4. @mizchiefmanaged
5. @nyanko
7. @WildZoo
8. @genny
10. @Stagg737
12. @mypetmoose
13. @StayingPositive2017 (previously Coops)

Eaten
11. Navs, cherry and vanilla townie
2. AM, chocolate chip and unjester
6. Sporty, cotton candy and vanilla townie
9. Barky, mint chocolate chip and vanilla townie
 
Need to see more contributions from kras and MsP today, I have next to nothing to evaluate them on at the moment. Most of MsP's posts have been to pop in and say she's been busy and promise reads later, and then those reads never materialize. kras at least posted reads at some point.
 
Process of elimination based on my village reads leaves me with genny, Msp, kras, stagg, +/- ny so going in one of those directions today, most likely among the first three, unless i see something really concerning when I look back at lynch tallies.
 
I will be sparse today but then am on fall break all week so more content throughout the week, hence the sub in.

Not sure why people are feeling village on miz
Leaning slightly wolf FTF - I think he hardcore pocketed AM

Slight vill Ny and genny

want to iso WZ, kras, and mpm

neutral on MsP and stagg

felt like stagg would kill AM N1, but had been suspecting Sporty over him until she flipped village
 
I will be sparse today but then am on fall break all week so more content throughout the week, hence the sub in.

Not sure why people are feeling village on miz
Leaning slightly wolf FTF - I think he hardcore pocketed AM

Slight vill Ny and genny

want to iso WZ, kras, and mpm

neutral on MsP and stagg

felt like stagg would kill AM N1, but had been suspecting Sporty over him until she flipped village
How do you feel about WZ calling out the wolves for killing the previous mod? I did a re-read this morning, and that was one of the things that pushed her out of wolf territory for me today. What puts genny and ny in village territory?
 
Process of elimination based on my village reads leaves me with genny, Msp, kras, stagg, +/- ny so going in one of those directions today, most likely among the first three, unless i see something really concerning when I look back at lynch tallies.
Can you (or someone else) give me a quick summary of what is normal for kras? What I'm seeing is long periods of nothing at all, then popping on for a quick comment and leaving again soon after
 
Can you (or someone else) give me a quick summary of what is normal for kras? What I'm seeing is long periods of nothing at all, then popping on for a quick comment and leaving again soon after
I don't know. First game I played with them was last game and I was killed n1 and didn't really follow the game after that point.
 
How do you feel about WZ calling out the wolves for killing the previous mod? I did a re-read this morning, and that was one of the things that pushed her out of wolf territory for me today. What puts genny and ny in village territory
I lean towards believing WZ on the mod thing. It would be a purposeful kill to clear herself or her not being present to change it if she's a wolf. Now she might do it, but its similar to me never killing AM early, I could, but I likely wouldn't.

Ny and genny are just feels. I need to reread when I have free time to comment as a real player not just skimming as a tot. I know last night before I was playing I had a thought on a pack but I didn't write it down and now I've forgotten so gotta go back and read.
 
Can you (or someone else) give me a quick summary of what is normal for kras? What I'm seeing is long periods of nothing at all, then popping on for a quick comment and leaving again soon after

i think last game was kras's first game and she basically got sacrificed by wolf miz going after her

prior to that she had some decent insight iirc

as far as her patterns of activity i think they were similar last game too
 
I lean towards believing WZ on the mod thing. It would be a purposeful kill to clear herself or her not being present to change it if she's a wolf. Now she might do it, but its similar to me never killing AM early, I could, but I likely wouldn't.

Ny and genny are just feels. I need to reread when I have free time to comment as a real player not just skimming as a tot. I know last night before I was playing I had a thought on a pack but I didn't write it down and now I've forgotten so gotta go back and read.
I'm planning on looking at stagg and genny more closely today and tomorrow.

I haven't completely removed miz and flushy from my list, but they are less of a priority now that my feelings have changed on WZ, and I need to re-read their stuff too to see how entangled my reads on them really got. At one point I thought you and WZ may be in a pack together too, but I feel like I doubt that now, so I need to look at you now too under the lens of wz not being a bad guy.
 
Quote some ****ing posts
I asked because I cannot find what you're ****ing talking about
If you're basing that read on activity patterns it's a **** ****ing read
 
In case I need to break this down any bloody further
You said Kras feels like last game
I just wanna know how
Pointing me to your unevidenced blanket statements isn't what I ****ing asked for
 
Do you lot understand now that it's easier to post gifs than to actually have to communicate with you insufferable pigeons
God as soon Coop subs out it's like a whole new issue appears
 
How are you feeling about her affiliation?
It still weirds me out that the word affiliation and alignment changed here. Not sure why either of them would have changed it, and AM was village and dead so likely not going to get any info on this
How are you feeling about my alignment
 
IDK exactly... maybe a little of this v...

...but more pressuring folks that kinda gives me a sheepdog vibe.
Wolfish
FTF - as much as I enjoy the gifs, this feels different from last game, so...
WZ - always suspect 😛
Coop - I'm feeling some sketch
miz - similar style to last game

Townish
kras - obviously
ny - reads similar to last game for me

IDK, need to keep reading
Barks
Stagg
MPM
MsP
Sporty
genny
burden of proof isn't on me but for the hell of it here you go
the only "insight" from kras
which isn't insight, just some observations that kras grouped together
is that ai for kras? don't know

Is it possible someone can look at this and say that they tr kras for it? of course

can you look at this and say that this is similar to kras from last game?
You'd have to do a lot of mental gymnastics to get that far

Nyanko's presumptuous leading statement already arrived at that conclusion
It's planting the idea of a kras tr without the justification actually being there
which is why I'm ****ing asking to justify

but instead i get "lol ur dumb read my posts"
HEY [redacted]
I ****ING DID
WHICH IS WHY IM ASKING

pull that ****ing [redacted] out your ****ing [redacted] before I ****ing [redacted] I swear to ****ing [redacted]
 
anyway the barks kill is fine for my poe I guess
a very weird kill to make but i'll see after breakfast how things are shaping up
im getting closer and closer to feeling like im being pocketed somewhereeee
also why are people still giving MsP all this free time jesus

every single interaction ive seen involving her has been
"im waiting for MsP to post more"
how long are you gonna wait?
 
burden of proof isn't on me but for the hell of it here you go
the only "insight" from kras
which isn't insight, just some observations that kras grouped together
is that ai for kras? don't know

Is it possible someone can look at this and say that they tr kras for it? of course

can you look at this and say that this is similar to kras from last game?
You'd have to do a lot of mental gymnastics to get that far

Nyanko's presumptuous leading statement already arrived at that conclusion
It's planting the idea of a kras tr without the justification actually being there
which is why I'm ****ing asking to justify

but instead i get "lol ur dumb read my posts"
HEY [redacted]
I ****ING DID
WHICH IS WHY IM ASKING

pull that ****ing [redacted] out your ****ing [redacted] before I ****ing [redacted] I swear to ****ing [redacted]
You seem a little worked up
 
It still weirds me out that the word affiliation and alignment changed here. Not sure why either of them would have changed it, and AM was village and dead so likely not going to get any info on this
My guess would be I misread AM's post lol
 
D1 Lynch progression
Coop (1) - AM
Miz (1) - Barkley
WZ (1) - Sporty
Stagg (1) - genny
Wz (2) - sport, kras
MPM (1) - miz
FTF (1) - coop
AM (1) - Ny
AM (2) - Ny, Nav
Coop () - AM
Nav (1) - AM
Nav
(2) - AM, FTF
FTF () - coop
AM (3) - ny, nav, coop
AM (2) - ny, nav, coop
Unlynch MsP - miz <-----------this was weird
MPM () - miz
Miz () - bark
FTF (1) - bark
Nav
(3)- AM, FTF, WZ
Barks (1)- coop
Wz (1) - sporty, kras
FTF (1) - bark, sporty
Sporty
(1) - Stagg

end of page 4. will come back to finish, but baby woke up from nap so im out.
 
Building a case for genny, but interested in hearing the other side. I've seen that some people have her on their village list so I'd be interested to hear from them on why.

I forgot lynch close was yesterday until after close.
This was in reference to not moving off of her joke vote one day. That vote was for Stagg, another person who I am looking into. Voting for a packmate D1 is a way to "interact" with each other without really calling each other out into the danger zone really. Plus then if things get sketchy later on, you can either subtley move off it, or stay on and "catch a wolf"

I just reread everything over lunch.

I still don’t have a lynch vote. Everyone just sounds so village to me.
I made a point on this post yesterday about the whole "everyone can sound village if you know who village is". And my own personal preference for starting people not in village, but in neutral. Probably not everyone does it that way, but if you start people in neutral, it is I think easier for me to see when people are coasting. This was early on, but just something that stuck out to me.

I'm uncomfortable with the lead that Sporty has in voting.
Yes, but also because I feel like village has a poor track record for lynching villagers when they've held a large lead most of the day.
Maybe she did feel like Sporty was village, or maybe she was just trying to stir the pot... But--- and this is actually a village point for her, why would she stir the pot at that point as a wolf if a non-villager and a villager lynch is happening? Unless it is to say, "told ya this was a bad lynch". WIFOM'y.

Genny I have at potentially wolfy. She says everyone just sounds so village. This I dislike, because it is easy to feel that way when you know that they are village. I feel like the first few days I normally just have an "eh" attitude towards everyone because who knows, and then I drop people to wolf or move them up to village. Not a huge wolfy point, but a wolfy point nonetheless... it is just a list structuring thing and I get that people do it differently, but starting people at village and moving them down feels like a scary thought...
This is my post from yesterday summarizing that concern.

Just overall, I want to hear what stagg thinks of genny and what genny thinks of stagg. In my opinion they could be a pack or it could just be one of them. Still puzzling that part out.

@Stagg737 @genny
 
burden of proof isn't on me but for the hell of it here you go
the only "insight" from kras
which isn't insight, just some observations that kras grouped together
is that ai for kras? don't know

Is it possible someone can look at this and say that they tr kras for it? of course

can you look at this and say that this is similar to kras from last game?
You'd have to do a lot of mental gymnastics to get that far

that's literally the same thing that kras did last game tho?
 
Looking at this particular case of gaslighting though
Nyanko: kras feels the same as last time
FTF: How
Nyanko: Because I said so
FTF: Here's why this doesn't hold up
Nyanko: Because I said so
 
So yeah
Anyone else wanna tag in for nyan to be the resident dingus for the day
Because I'm already tired of them
 
Top