Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I mean, if there's actually 4 wolves (especially with one a convert) in this I lost from the start.
Lurking Beloww: Sea Monsters Sign Ups and Game Thread
Started by katashark
Get help with your application
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
I mean, if there's actually 4 wolves (especially with one a convert) in this I lost from the start.
sorta forgot lynch deadline was 8 PST, don't even ask, I'm exhausted. I went to bed as I stated earlier, and woke up not long before I came on thread after the cats kept waking me up all during my sleep.
I got paranoid and thought you guys were trying to close early
my bottom is just going straight to the party and not waiting to carpool with me, I'm so tired and since he's going without me anyway, I'm considering just not going, so here I am
Lol, okay. For real though. What times do you want PMs from. I'll copy paste them immediately.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
or possibly it's a w/v pair, in which case the defense pattern isn't so bold and all the more likely
I don't really care about time stamps, I just want to see if there were any questions about that afterwards
I guess, but if there is just one, I think Stagg would be the wolf, and right there in those posts I quoted, I think Bryndi looks more likely.
lynch everyone
Not that I am planning on moving from here. I just think we should be thinking about tomorrow, if there is one
unlynch BJ
I don't know who to lynch, I just want to be ready if we can waffle anywhere but me, as no matter who it is we have a better chance than if it's me
I don't know who to lynch, I just want to be ready if we can waffle anywhere but me, as no matter who it is we have a better chance than if it's me
We did not message during the time frame you gave. I PM'd at 8:35:
"SAR is still my top choice, but I agree about AM or DVMD. I'm actually thinking more DVMD at the moment, but I've got to get caught up. I didn't like her switch on the Genny vote, and SAR switched to Genny literally in the same minute. Just seemed like a very quick train to me. And when I went back and looked at her reasoning for her switch it wasn't very strong. It was basically "well if she would have been more open, maybe she wouldn't have gotten lynched" and a few other weak reasons. It just seemed like pretty weak logic for a switch like that.
Afterwards she was actually starting to sound more village to me and I buy her "I had a bad day" stuff to a certain extent, but today with the AM stuff it's setting off red flags for me again. AM is setting off some major red flags though and I think she may have had a Freudian slip with the "If I get lynched, you're all screwed" comment. So idk which one to think is wolfy at this point, which is why I'm sticking with SAR for now. If SAR flips wolf, I'll probably look into DVMD first. If SAR flips village, I'll be looking into AM more first."
Next message was from me at 10:03, BJ did not message between these:
"So what are your thoughts on dolphin and AM? I'm not liking that Dolphin was just defending SAR and saying that me and AM were contradicting each other, then voted for me and allowed SAR to get lynched. Logically just doesn't make sense to me..."
Bryndy's response at 10:26:
"*sigh*
Dolphin idk, she seems almost like she is playing the "I'm a lost nooblet" card, and I don't like that. AM I think is being truthful, and have no reason right now to have her high on my sketch list.
Nice catch on SAR though, I was pretty blindsided by her this game. Is dolphin your top suspect?"
Note: All times in CST.
"SAR is still my top choice, but I agree about AM or DVMD. I'm actually thinking more DVMD at the moment, but I've got to get caught up. I didn't like her switch on the Genny vote, and SAR switched to Genny literally in the same minute. Just seemed like a very quick train to me. And when I went back and looked at her reasoning for her switch it wasn't very strong. It was basically "well if she would have been more open, maybe she wouldn't have gotten lynched" and a few other weak reasons. It just seemed like pretty weak logic for a switch like that.
Afterwards she was actually starting to sound more village to me and I buy her "I had a bad day" stuff to a certain extent, but today with the AM stuff it's setting off red flags for me again. AM is setting off some major red flags though and I think she may have had a Freudian slip with the "If I get lynched, you're all screwed" comment. So idk which one to think is wolfy at this point, which is why I'm sticking with SAR for now. If SAR flips wolf, I'll probably look into DVMD first. If SAR flips village, I'll be looking into AM more first."
Next message was from me at 10:03, BJ did not message between these:
"So what are your thoughts on dolphin and AM? I'm not liking that Dolphin was just defending SAR and saying that me and AM were contradicting each other, then voted for me and allowed SAR to get lynched. Logically just doesn't make sense to me..."
Bryndy's response at 10:26:
"*sigh*
Dolphin idk, she seems almost like she is playing the "I'm a lost nooblet" card, and I don't like that. AM I think is being truthful, and have no reason right now to have her high on my sketch list.
Nice catch on SAR though, I was pretty blindsided by her this game. Is dolphin your top suspect?"
Note: All times in CST.
I would urge you guys to look at my analysis and in light of my autopsy consider my thoughts and definitely reconsider your village leans in light of it
I would be surprised if the wolves didn't off BJ or Stagg tonight in prep for lylo if now isn't it, if they both live that looks pretty bad, of course, it's getting pretty WIFOM
Lynch closed, results pending
You have her as strong village after that?
Captain's Log:
2/9/18– We are nearing the end of our journey. The passengers seemed to have enjoyed the ride, and we've made a lot of new scientific discoveries. Unfortunately, we may never find all of the evil sea monsters. I hope so. We dove into some very deep, dark waters today. Water quality analysis showed a very viscous consistency to this water. We are moving slowly through these parts. And with the bright lights from the Nautilus, we stunned a poor creature to death.
Dead is @Crayola227 - Creature from the Black Lagoon. She just wanted to be left alone.
Conditions
Current - too viscous for anything to move
Wind - diving
Swell - glass
Supplies
Air - 90%
Fuel - 90%
Rations - 22% (where's my fruit by the foot?!)
Signed,
Capt. Nemo
P.S. I love this movie.
P.P.S. Mission results pending.
ADJUST PMs ACCORDINGLY. You have until 0900 hours EDT.
Greenhorns
2. @Animal Midwife
7. @bryndiana.jones
8. @Stagg737
10. @Skimble
14. @PippyPony
In a Watery Grave
12. capri1722 - Giant squid
17. Melchizedek - Candiru (1 shot vigilante)
5. CoffeeQuestionMark - Scylla and Charybdis (village blocker)
16. WildZoo - Cthulhu
11. genny - Ahuitzotl (item maker)
15. johnnaboo - Rainbow Fish (send a message)
3. SnowshoeDog143 - Kappa (seer)
1. SARdoghandler - Hydra (wolf)
4. DVMDream - Moby Dick
9. kcoughli - Qalupalik (wolf)
18. StartingoverVet - Globster
13. dolphin106258 - Ogopogo
6. WildZoo/allieh - Loch Ness Monster
19. Crayola227 - Creature from the Black Lagoon
2/9/18– We are nearing the end of our journey. The passengers seemed to have enjoyed the ride, and we've made a lot of new scientific discoveries. Unfortunately, we may never find all of the evil sea monsters. I hope so. We dove into some very deep, dark waters today. Water quality analysis showed a very viscous consistency to this water. We are moving slowly through these parts. And with the bright lights from the Nautilus, we stunned a poor creature to death.
Dead is @Crayola227 - Creature from the Black Lagoon. She just wanted to be left alone.
Conditions
Current - too viscous for anything to move
Wind - diving
Swell - glass
Supplies
Air - 90%
Fuel - 90%
Rations - 22% (where's my fruit by the foot?!)
Signed,
Capt. Nemo
P.S. I love this movie.
P.P.S. Mission results pending.
ADJUST PMs ACCORDINGLY. You have until 0900 hours EDT.
Greenhorns
2. @Animal Midwife
7. @bryndiana.jones
8. @Stagg737
10. @Skimble
14. @PippyPony
In a Watery Grave
12. capri1722 - Giant squid
17. Melchizedek - Candiru (1 shot vigilante)
5. CoffeeQuestionMark - Scylla and Charybdis (village blocker)
16. WildZoo - Cthulhu
11. genny - Ahuitzotl (item maker)
15. johnnaboo - Rainbow Fish (send a message)
3. SnowshoeDog143 - Kappa (seer)
1. SARdoghandler - Hydra (wolf)
4. DVMDream - Moby Dick
9. kcoughli - Qalupalik (wolf)
18. StartingoverVet - Globster
13. dolphin106258 - Ogopogo
6. WildZoo/allieh - Loch Ness Monster
19. Crayola227 - Creature from the Black Lagoon
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Stagg, I think you're getting pocketed.
You know what's fun, guys?
KC stole genny's tinkerer ability and we still have not seen the repercussions of that, to my knowledge.
KC stole genny's tinkerer ability and we still have not seen the repercussions of that, to my knowledge.
He's not. I'll probably die tonight
Contingency lynch Bryndi, I think
Someone here is getting played.
Someone here is getting played.
If he's not, then you are.
I did. At that point literally half the people in the game were defending SAR saying she didn't seem like wolfy SAR, including you (I can find those posts if you'd like). And in general she hasn't seemed like wolf BJ in PMs at all to me.
Then why didn't he kill me last night? If I'm pocketed then he did a fantastic job of keeping consistent with his village play
I really, really hope not. Although Mel pocketed me hard in Colorado (he was a convert though and had been hard cleared earlier) and I was also PM'ing with wolf Kara. I just don't see it with Bryndy though.
I think he is very, very smart.
Why would he kill someone who he could continue to successfully manipulate?
But I think you should probably track him tonight all the same, if you are even actually a village tracker.
You know what? It's probably AM and pippy as the wolves and AM made up the whole protector business and pippy even played along with the "please protect yourself tonight"
Anyway, for now
Contingency lynch Pippy
Because I don't see any other valid options.
Contingency lynch Pippy
Because I don't see any other valid options.
I am. If I'm wrong then he gets major props
In which thread did this happen?
This one
@Animal Midwife , can we get an updated lynch tracker?
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Uhh.. can we wait until we get lynch results? The game might be over (I hope!)
Edit: never mind… I didn't see we already got them...
No? We already have result.
Ummm. @PippyPony , why are you liking this comment?
And actually, if you are dead tomorrow, bryndi, I am going to push his lynch very hard, so he had better leave you alive again 🙂
You may track me or AM or skim or him, and we'll see if there is someone dead tomorrow, shall we? If there is someone dead, then you can go ahead and clear whatever person was not doing the kill.
Though, I do wish there were notifications given for your action, because it will still be just your word that you tracked who you said you did.
You may track me or AM or skim or him, and we'll see if there is someone dead tomorrow, shall we? If there is someone dead, then you can go ahead and clear whatever person was not doing the kill.
Though, I do wish there were notifications given for your action, because it will still be just your word that you tracked who you said you did.
... because it's funny?
Bryndi is right -- I did tell AM in this thread to protect herself again a couple nights ago, I liked the post for the return volley sass.
Yeah... I somehow missed that. It was buried in the "see more replies" (or whatever it says).
Well, the same could be said for AM
Ooooh is it a protection night btw? That makes things even more interesting
If protection is only certain nights, why is AM still alive?
And sure, but again -- I will be fine with losing to AM if she is solo wolfing like this all of a sudden
Because she could be bull****ting on that part.
Have you seen evidence that there are other even/odd night roles?
********
maybe not the place for this, I should wait until end game but...
thanks a lot to @katashark & @kaydubs for the late add! I like to think I showed the game the effort it deserves here towards the end of my time, but the point is I did get to really play even if for a short time, for which I am glad.... Most importantly, I'm really grateful that Kata and Kaydubs made that possible. The game flavor (sorry didn't catch mechanics) has been painstakingly detailed and just beautiful, so thanks for that too. I wouldn't normally have as much said here as a recent deadite and I don't think it influences the game, but I had to say a big thank you for all of it right away.
Also, yes, as usual, die village die you deserve what you get for killing me! Carry on.
********
maybe not the place for this, I should wait until end game but...
thanks a lot to @katashark & @kaydubs for the late add! I like to think I showed the game the effort it deserves here towards the end of my time, but the point is I did get to really play even if for a short time, for which I am glad.... Most importantly, I'm really grateful that Kata and Kaydubs made that possible. The game flavor (sorry didn't catch mechanics) has been painstakingly detailed and just beautiful, so thanks for that too. I wouldn't normally have as much said here as a recent deadite and I don't think it influences the game, but I had to say a big thank you for all of it right away.
Also, yes, as usual, die village die you deserve what you get for killing me! Carry on.
********
I love the compliment, but I'll love it even more if you tell it to me sometime when you're not a wolf.
Nope. Would you say she and I are on equal sketch levels in terms of roles?
Edit. Spelling
Aw. Well you'll find out in about a day that that time is now
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I'm looking pretty hard at stagg tomorrow.
I think both are equally typically village but potentially minimally useful for wolves
Day 1 Election Tally
allie (2) - allie, DVMD
Pippy (5) - Pippy, Skim, AM, SAR, capri
AM () -AM
genny (6) - genny, bryndi, Coffee?, Stagg, jboo, dolphin
Mel (2) - Mel, WZ
15/18
Missing: kc, SOV, Snowy
Day 2 Lynch Tally
SAR (4) - AM,genny, Skim, Pippy, genny, DVMD
kc (1) - Coffee?,Pippy
DVMD () -Pippy
bj (1) -Skim, WZ
Coffee? (5) - jboo, SOV,bj, Stagg, Snowy, SAR
Pippy () -kc
genny (1) -SAR, allie
jboo (2) - dolphin, Pippy
dolphin (1) - kc
Stagg () -genny
WZ (1) - bj
16/16
Day 3 Lynch Tally
Pippy (1) -DVMD, kc
Stagg () -jboo, genny
bj () -Pippy
Snowy () -AM
jboo (3) -Pippy, dolphin, SAR, bj, kc, allie, genny
dolphin (2) - Snowy, AM
allie () -Stagg
SAR (1) - Skim
genny (5) - Pippy, jboo, DVMD, SAR, Stagg
12/14
Missing: allie, SOV
Day 4 Lynch Tally
DVMD (1) -Pippy, SOV
SAR (4) - AM, Stagg, Skim, jboo
Snowy () -jboo
Pippy (1) - kc
kc () -Pippy
jboo (5) - Snowy, dolphin, SAR, bryndi, Pippy
dolphin () -SAR
11/14
Missing: Cray, allie, DVMD
Day 5 Lynch Tally
SAR (5) -DVMD, AM, bj, Stagg, DVMD, Cray, Skim, bj
DVMD (1) -Pippy, bj
AM (3) -DVMD, SAR, Skim, DVMD, SOV, kc, bj
dolphin (1) - Pippy
Pippy () -DVMD
Stagg (1) - dolphin
Skim () -bj
11/12
Missing: allie
Day 6 Lynch Tally
dolphin (3) - kc, bj, AM
kc (5) -Pippy, WZ, Pippy, dolphin, Skim, Stagg
WZ () -Stagg
Cray (1) - SOV
bj () -Skim
9/10
Missing: Cray
Day 7 Lynch Tally
AM (1) - Cray
dolphin (3) - WZ, bryndi,Pippy, AM, Stagg
Cray (2) -Pippy, AM, Pippy
bj (2) - dolphin, Skim
8/8
Day 8 Lynch Tally
Cray (4) - AM,Pippy, Pippy, bj, Skim
Pippy (1) - Stagg
AM () -Cray
bj (1) - Cray,Pippy, Skim
6/6
allie (2) - allie, DVMD
Pippy (5) - Pippy, Skim, AM, SAR, capri
AM () -
genny (6) - genny, bryndi, Coffee?, Stagg, jboo, dolphin
Mel (2) - Mel, WZ
15/18
Missing: kc, SOV, Snowy
Day 2 Lynch Tally
SAR (4) - AM,
kc (1) - Coffee?,
DVMD () -
bj (1) -
Coffee? (5) - jboo, SOV,
Pippy () -
genny (1) -
jboo (2) - dolphin, Pippy
dolphin (1) - kc
Stagg () -
WZ (1) - bj
16/16
Day 3 Lynch Tally
Pippy (1) -
Stagg () -
bj () -
Snowy () -
jboo (3) -
dolphin (2) - Snowy, AM
allie () -
SAR (1) - Skim
genny (5) - Pippy, jboo, DVMD, SAR, Stagg
12/14
Missing: allie, SOV
Day 4 Lynch Tally
DVMD (1) -
SAR (4) - AM, Stagg, Skim, jboo
Snowy () -
Pippy (1) - kc
kc () -
jboo (5) - Snowy, dolphin, SAR, bryndi, Pippy
dolphin () -
11/14
Missing: Cray, allie, DVMD
Day 5 Lynch Tally
SAR (5) -
DVMD (1) -
AM (3) -
dolphin (1) - Pippy
Pippy () -
Stagg (1) - dolphin
Skim () -
11/12
Missing: allie
Day 6 Lynch Tally
dolphin (3) - kc, bj, AM
kc (5) -
WZ () -
Cray (1) - SOV
bj () -
9/10
Missing: Cray
Day 7 Lynch Tally
AM (1) - Cray
dolphin (3) - WZ, bryndi,
Cray (2) -
bj (2) - dolphin, Skim
8/8
Day 8 Lynch Tally
Cray (4) - AM,
Pippy (1) - Stagg
AM () -
bj (1) - Cray,
6/6
Care to explain why?
What do you think the odds of me successfully protecting would be?
