My Little Pony WW Official Game Thread

[orca2011]

---

Members do not see this ad.

If the seer result specifies villager, I don't think that would be faked. Still thinking about who to lynch now...

Hate to say it, but I'm always skeptical of fully trusting seer results after I had a role where I would be seered as a villager but was actually a wolf.
I'm willing to accept the results for now though, especially since I read that Discord was reformed later on so that his magic could be used for good.

 

[DVMDream]

The consensus on the thread yesterday as a result of investigation was that you were Discord. Which I find hard to believe is a villager role, despite what anyone might get as a seer result.

My lynch vote is mostly to get any info out in the open early in the day, so we can move on to other things if necessary.

I'm always willing to change my vote if warranted. But right now it's justified on the basis of what we know already.

Sorry, still sticking with my vote. I understand the reason for lynching, but the whole statement of why DocE had not started the "wagon" yet is what caught my eye. There was not even an attempt by you to wait for results, it was a straight vote with the mention of "starting the wagon". My vote stays unless I am give very good reason to change it otherwise.

 

[DVMDream]

*given..... darn no editing

 

[DocEspana]

While the director of MLP: FiM says he went from a true villain to a "unreliable ally" Its not particularly convincing for DVM being villager in the absence of proof otherwise.

Especially given this is the wiki article for discords powers

"His power is chaos, and so chaos he sows, and does not seem to have an easily determinable limit to what he can alter, though he was shown to have a limited range when he attacked Ponyville, all his antics caught within its limits."

 

[equineconstant]

Hate to say it, but I'm always skeptical of fully trusting seer results after I had a role where I would be seered as a villager but was actually a wolf.
I'm willing to accept the results for now though, especially since I read that Discord was reformed later on so that his magic could be used for good.

I believe that on wolves for sure, but it seems a little much for a chaos character to have false results with a seer that clearly sees alignment. Until and unless I see evidence of her play otherwise, I'll trust the seer results on DVMD.

 

[equineconstant]

While the director of MLP: FiM says he went from a true villain to a "unreliable ally" Its not particularly convincing for DVM being villager in the absence of proof otherwise.

Especially given this is the wiki article for discords powers

"His power is chaos, and so chaos he sows, and does not seem to have an easily determinable limit to what he can alter, though he was shown to have a limited range when he attacked Ponyville, all his antics caught within its limits."

That's what I said before, but I don't really think a mod would make Chaos seer as Villager if they were playing not for the villagers.

 

[LetItSnow]

This works for me.... and if some people do not let this one go with seer results then I will jump to lynch them

looks at @DocEspana and @Samoa

I still see some chance if it not being right .... maybe the seer isn't 100% accurate, maybe the seer is a wolf (seer?) who lied, maybe DVMD is chaos with the best built-in seer protection ever.... but those seem less likely than the results just plain being correct.

 

[DocEspana]

DVMD investigated as dischord "a villager" last night. Not saying the seer results are necessarily accurate, but until I see reason to suspect they aren't, I'm ok letting this one go.

Just saw this. DVMD gets a *very* short leash for now.

Unlynch DVM. Lynch devyn.

Have to read the two messages in my inbox, but I don't think they'll change my mind. I need time to think and devtn is an excellent choice in my.mind.

 

[LetItSnow]

Why is Devyn suddenly an excellent choice? I've no reason not to lynch her, but I don't have any reason TO lynch her either.

Or are you just trying to get the "the lump a few feet above your arse" comment out early in the game?

 

[thedrjojo]

I have reason to believe Devyn has been cleared

 

[dyachei]

lynch doce

 

[devyn]

I have people who can vouch for me

lynch DocE

cause he is still bothering me and he is not helpful as a wolf or villager

 

[equineconstant]

Lynch ffm just minor suspicions

 

[DocEspana]

Why is Devyn suddenly an excellent choice? I've no reason not to lynch her, but I don't have any reason TO lynch her either.

Or are you just trying to get the "the lump a few feet above your arse" comment out early in the game?

My reasoning: Devyn pushed for NOT lynching a suspected chaos character. It was the right move apparently (the inbox message I referenced still having to read had more info on her. I bite. She is good), but was the wrong move yesterday.

She is pre-emptively announcing she will lynch me for going after someone who appeared to be chaos.

I'm either totally fine with Devyn or want her dead immediately. Its not a villager/wolf thing. Its just however I feel going into the game. This game I feel like I dont know whats going on, so I want her completely dead for my own regardless-of-game feeling that she can turn the corner on me if I'm not well versed in the topic.

She makes me cry with her harsh words 😛

 

[equineconstant]

Are we lynching docE off anything more than going after chaos? Cause I'm not far from agreeing with him, so I don't think that's much of a reason to lynch, especially if his role is as useful as he says.

 

[DocEspana]

well she has been seered. F*** that. Sigh. I'm going to make a game with zero seers. Z-E-R-O. and I am going to love it. People have to make mistakes and actually either hunt wolves or get themselves tripped up (villager or wolf) by stupid comments they cant justify.

unlynch Devyn

 

[dyachei]

Are we lynching docE off anything more than going after chaos? Cause I'm not far from agreeing with him, so I don't think that's much of a reason to lynch, especially if his role is as useful as he says.

please quote for me where he says his role is useful. I could have sworn he just claimed HE is useful because he's doce.

 

[thedrjojo]

My reasoning: Devyn pushed for NOT lynching a suspected chaos character. It was the right move apparently (the inbox message I referenced still having to read had more info on her. I bite. She is good), but was the wrong move yesterday.

She is pre-emptively announcing she will lynch me for going after someone who appeared to be chaos.

I'm either totally fine with Devyn or want her dead immediately. Its not a villager/wolf thing. Its just however I feel going into the game. This game I feel like I dont know whats going on, so I want her completely dead for my own regardless-of-game feeling that she can turn the corner on me if I'm not well versed in the topic.

She makes me cry with her harsh words 😛

Hmm, she knew who I was talking about before I said anything... maybe, just maybe, she had a strong enough reason to have us hear out DVMD?

 

[DocEspana]

And lynching me is a phenominally stupid decision. What do you think I mean when I say my role is super ironic given how last game went? Being a wolf would not be ironic.

My manehattanites all know who I am. Lynching me would lead to a facepalm by everyone involved that blows through the back of your head.

 

[DocEspana]

please quote for me where he says his role is useful. I could have sworn he just claimed HE is useful because he's doce.

Nope I actually said *I* will be rather non-useful this game. But my *role* is more useful than I am. So keeping me alive is probably a good move until I get less busy.

Read closer. Take less painkillers.

 

[dyachei]

Nope I actually said *I* will be rather non-useful this game. But my *role* is more useful than I am. So keeping me alive is probably a good move until I get less busy.

Read closer. Take less painkillers.

I'm sorry, it's just that you type so much crap it's hard to root out the important stuff. 😛

unlynch DocE, lynch TRH.

 

[DocEspana]

Nope I actually said *I* will be rather non-useful this game. But my *role* is more useful than I am. So keeping me alive is probably a good move until I get less busy.

Read closer. Take less painkillers.

The first half I'd been saying since the sign up as a reason I didnt want to get into the game, so its not a convenient excuse (to pre-empt the comments that I usually lay low as a wolf. Which is true. But I also periodically lay low as a villager because residency blows)

 

[thedrjojo]

Are we lynching docE off anything more than going after chaos? Cause I'm not far from agreeing with him, so I don't think that's much of a reason to lynch, especially if his role is as useful as he says.

i think the push to lynch doce was for him being himself and obtuse in thinking at times... at least that's what I interpreted it as, not that i voted for him.

STL seemed to have been about to make some sort of major point and then disappeared...

 

[DocEspana]

Hmm, she knew who I was talking about before I said anything... maybe, just maybe, she had a strong enough reason to have us hear out DVMD?

Is this apparently true?

Was any of this made clear beforehand?

Do I enjoy lynching Devyn whenever possible and never trust her barring seering her myself?

Am I having too much fun with gifs, especially considering I have no post restriction right now?

I apologize for this entire nonsense as well as the four gifs (unless you like them, then hell yea). But if you do not understand my logic for DVMDream you actually *should* be lynched because I think its the only logical move right up until they were both seered and I got additional information backing up their good nature. Devyn, on the other hand, is just for the reasons I said. Somewhere something is fishy with the whole thing that happened yesterday (even if it was right) and she is my favorite target of the three obvious people involved.

am I having too much fun with gifs without any restriction requiring them?
am I having too much fun with gifs without any restriction requiring them?

 

[Flim Flam Man]

I have people who can vouch for me

lynch DocE

cause he is still bothering me and he is not helpful as a wolf or villager

I disagree. DocE can be very helpful as a villager. You just have to put up with (or be entertained) by his pompous nature.

 

[that redhead]

DocE, I don't really see anyone in your group coming forward to speak up on your behalf like you seemed sure they would do yesterday. Why is that?

 

[thedrjojo]

Is this apparently true?

Was any of this made clear beforehand?

Do I enjoy lynching Devyn whenever possible and never trust her barring seering her myself?

Am I having too much fun with gifs, especially considering I have no post restriction right now?

I apologize for this entire nonsense as well as the four gifs (unless you like them, then hell yea). But if you do not understand my logic for DVMDream you actually *should* be lynched because I think its the only logical move right up until they were both seered and I got additional information backing up their good nature. Devyn, on the other hand, is just for the reasons I said. Somewhere something is fishy with the whole thing that happened yesterday (even if it was right) and she is my favorite target of the three obvious people involved.

am I having too much fun with gifs without any restriction requiring them?
am I having too much fun with gifs without any restriction requiring them?

Well, i didn't lynch you, did i?

i was just pointing out that the second i mentioned that there was someone with multiple skills, and then mentioned that DVMD was silenced, she immediately responding saying that we should let a person defend themselves before we lynch them when it is ambiguous, and that she very well could be a villager. Granted, I knew who we were talking about and thus picked up on it right away, but it became obvious around 5:15-5:30pm est yesterday that we were all saying the same thing, and how else would Devyn have known we were talking about DVMD?

 

[DVMDream]

I disagree. DocE can be very helpful as a villager. You just have to put up with (or be entertained) by his pompous nature.

I disagree. DocE is only helpful in his own head. He will lie as a villager or a wolf just to make people follow what he says and do what he wants. He can and has been a dangerous villager before. Also, I'm not seeing anyone sticking up for him currently. All he says is his role is useful, nothing more anyone can make that claim.

 

[DocEspana]

DocE, I don't really see anyone in your group coming forward to speak up on your behalf like you seemed sure they would do yesterday. Why is that?

I don't think theyve even checked in yet, but I'm posting between traumas, which never seem to stop. As usual.

 

[Escalla]

I'm going to go with Lynch Samoa for now.

 

[DocEspana]

I disagree. DocE is only helpful in his own head. He will lie as a villager or a wolf just to make people follow what he says and do what he wants. He can and has been a dangerous villager before. Also, I'm not seeing anyone sticking up for him currently. All he says is his role is useful, nothing more anyone can make that claim.

Ladies and gentlemen, my negative hypewoman. Facts don't matter and any history she references is all made up, but hell can she sell it. Let's hear a round of applause for her!

 

[SummerTheLynx]

jojo - exam, hold on

 

[thedrjojo]

Ladies and gentlemen, my negative hypewoman. Facts don't matter and any history she references is all made up, but hell can she sell it. Let's hear a round of applause for her!

of course when I can speak, you don't call her a hymen... boo

 

[thedrjojo]

jojo - exam, hold on

noted, will wait to make any decisions until you can check in, since you seem to be the best lead we have thus far

 

[SummerTheLynx]

will talk through cyndia

 

[devyn]

Is this apparently true?

Was any of this made clear beforehand?

Do I enjoy lynching Devyn whenever possible and never trust her barring seering her myself?

Am I having too much fun with gifs, especially considering I have no post restriction right now?

I apologize for this entire nonsense as well as the four gifs (unless you like them, then hell yea). But if you do not understand my logic for DVMDream you actually *should* be lynched because I think its the only logical move right up until they were both seered and I got additional information backing up their good nature. Devyn, on the other hand, is just for the reasons I said. Somewhere something is fishy with the whole thing that happened yesterday (even if it was right) and she is my favorite target of the three obvious people involved.

am I having too much fun with gifs without any restriction requiring them?
am I having too much fun with gifs without any restriction requiring them?

So you want to lynch/kill me because I am me.... and that is your only good reason....

and yet I have been cleared as good...

and yet you have an issue with me lynching you for you being you and you have not been cleared at all...

also do remember you claimed a useful roll last game where you were a lying sack of ****e wolf....

I am a villager..... and it would be very silly to lynch me

also I knew who DVM was prior to rojo coming out on list with the info which is why I felt she needed to be heard before you all jump on the lynch bandwagon.... so I had good reason for responding the way I did yesterday and not wanting to lynch what you thought was chaos

 

[Flim Flam Man]

and sounds like devyn is doubly clear. I used the star

Ladies and gentlemen, my negative hypewoman. Facts don't matter and any history she references is all made up, but hell can she sell it. Let's hear a round of applause for her!

To the DocE naysayers, I agree DocE has his moments, and he does seem to have a habit of getting on one track and not letting go, no matter if it's wrong or not. However, he can be useful, and he has an ability, which is more than I can say. Plus...

 

[tuckervet]

Lynch DocE

 

[DVMDream]

Ladies and gentlemen, my negative hypewoman. Facts don't matter and any history she references is all made up, but hell can she sell it. Let's hear a round of applause for her!

What am I making up? You being full of yourself... nope that is quite obvious.

The fact you lie? Nope you have admitted that yourself before.

The fact that your lying can be dangerous to villagers.... nope, that also is true.

The fact that basically you will just think everyone is a wolf then when a wolf is found, claim it as your doing... well, that was proven in the game devyn and I modded. When Mrs.SOV was found to be wolf by rojo and someone else and then you claimed all game it was your doing... 🙄 Oh and who were you wanting to lynch? dyachei, who was not a wolf...

Also, where is your backup, that is not untrue either. None of your group is sticking their heads out there for you.

Also, any player can claim, "I have a valuable role". So yup that is true too.

So, what is made up here? You just don't like that I speak the truth and haven't fallen into the "everyone praise the all mighty DocE".... 🙄

 

[Flim Flam Man]

anyone else hate how the draft stuff you decide not to post sneaks in your post without you noticing? I do as well.

I was going to post that I checked devyn with the star swirl last night, and she doens't seem like a wolf to me, imo. I decided not to post that, but too late now.

 

[Chillbo Baggins]

I'm very entertained rn.

 

[Samoa]

Guise, guise. I work. I only just now got back to the thread to read the responses to my post. So someone did in fact check DVMDs allegiance. unlynch DVMD

Though if she's Discord, odds are high that the wolves will want to convert her.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Also, where is your backup, that is not untrue either. None of your group is sticking their heads out there for you.

I am about to.

 

[Chillbo Baggins]

Official Lynch Tally

nyanko - 1 (STL)
Samoa - 2 (DVMD, Escalla)
DocE - 3 (nyanko, devyn, TV)
FFM - 1 (EC)
TRH - 1 (dyachei)

8/21 votes cast

 

[thedrjojo]

Hate to say it, but I'm always skeptical of fully trusting seer results after I had a role where I would be seered as a villager but was actually a wolf.
I'm willing to accept the results for now though, especially since I read that Discord was reformed later on so that his magic could be used for good.

common mechanism for a wolf to be partially unseerable. less common that chaos would come back as villager.

noob mod may have new twists we have never seen, but i dunno if this is one of them...

 

[Cyndia]

Hey everyone, I have a message for you all,
Sent on from STL, since restrictions keep his posts small.

STL here,

So I am not a seer or anything, but I have a fair amount of information on the two groups I was in. I have not 100% seered anyone, as I said, b/c I am not a seer, but I kind of tested a few people for their wolfiness. I led DVMD to believe that she was being protected, but by protecting her, left myself, who was immune, open to only her. She knows I can be very dangerous to wolves with my "abilities," so last night would have been an opportune time for her to go for me. To be completely honest, I didn't actually heal her, but I did not need to use my protection. So I highly doubt DVMD is a wolf. I can vouch for devyn based on a reaction to the group thread that is 100% not wolfy, and was trying to avoid dissemination of information to the wolves. Lissa, I think we should all know at this point, is not a wolf and was protected. Cyndia has a very believable role, with the rhyming, and does not know about MLP, and posted about her posting restriction at the very beginning (right about when roles were released), so I strongly feel that Cyndia is not a wolf. That leaves between the two groups I was in FFM, nyanko, and DocE. DocE is claiming a main character role that would be very hard to bs, so I am going to have to say unless he has direct knowledge that a very main character from MLP is not in the game, then he is clean. So, I am perfectly happy lynching nyanko or FFM, b/c the chance that two groups do not have a wolf in it highly unlikely IMO.

For now, I am going to not state anything more about the newly added benefits of my role, to let the wolves have fun with that.

Specifically DVMD, to answer your question from last night, it is now a double apple 😉

 

[thedrjojo]

What am I making up? You being full of yourself... nope that is quite obvious.

The fact you lie? Nope you have admitted that yourself before.

The fact that your lying can be dangerous to villagers.... nope, that also is true.

The fact that basically you will just think everyone is a wolf then when a wolf is found, claim it as your doing... well, that was proven in the game devyn and I modded. When Mrs.SOV was found to be wolf by rojo and someone else and then you claimed all game it was your doing... 🙄 Oh and who were you wanting to lynch? dyachei, who was not a wolf...

Also, where is your backup, that is not untrue either. None of your group is sticking their heads out there for you.

Also, any player can claim, "I have a valuable role". So yup that is true too.

So, what is made up here? You just don't like that I speak the truth and haven't fallen into the "everyone praise the all mighty DocE".... 🙄

To be fair, i didn't get MrsSOV, i saved EC by switching everyone to MrsSOV...

I got SnS though... nailed that slore! 😉

 

[DVMDream]

To be fair, i didn't get MrsSOV, i saved EC by switching everyone to MrsSOV...

I got SnS though... nailed that slore! 😉

One of those with an "s" name.... Doc still walked all over you and claimed it as his.

Oh well, I am sticking with my Samoa vote unless I have very good reason not to lynch her

 

[DocEspana]

What am I making up? You being full of yourself... nope that is quite obvious.

I don't deny it. But it brings results.

The fact you lie? Nope you have admitted that yourself before.

I admitted lying as a wolf. As a villager? Last time I did it was 18 months ago with true blood. A game where I was largely invulnerable and a seer. I lied about my results twice and took pride in it. One because I got an unseerable wolf by lying and once because dinnertime seered the same way the unseerablke wolf did and I was super suspicious. Thus why I must always apologize to LIS (or was it SOV) for my instincts being off. But the idea of a villager lying, even though it paid dividends (and had in previous games as well) made me stop. If you can find a single lie or misrepresentation from me since the summer of 2012 you're reading a game where I was a wolf or chaos at the time of the comment.

So yes. I l lavished about lying as a villager.... Almost two years ago.

The fact that your lying can be dangerous to villagers.... nope, that also is true.

Name one person who has ever died as a villager because I suggested to lynch them when I was a villager. You will literally find zero since true blood. LITERALLY. I've pushed for lynches and backed off when they vindicated themselves. But it's quite a stringent standard to hold me responsible for having suspicions that I don't follow through fully on in a game about paranoia and suspicions. Especially when I tell everyone that I will accuse you of stuff and I will push you.... And then I'll back off if you're innocent. It's not like I don't disclose this publicly Evey single game.

The fact that basically you will just think everyone is a wolf then when a wolf is found, claim it as your doing... well, that was proven in the game devyn and I modded. When Mrs.SOV was found to be wolf by rojo and someone else and then you claimed all game it was your doing... 🙄 Oh and who were you wanting to lynch? dyachei, who was not a wolf...

So funny thing about that. Any through the game thread from page 19 to the end just right now. Rojo posts how the contentious manner of mrsSOVs Lynch should be marked down since it was a clear wolf Lynch that almost didn't happen because of a tie until the last minute. From that point on I make 7 references to mrsSOV. In five of them in defending myself saying that if I were a wolf (people still floated that idea) or chaos, no way would I have switched my vote last minute to lunch the wolf. The other two posts? Thanking Rojo for convincing me to change my vote and the second one is me explicitly denying I had anything to do with mrsSOVs lynch except that I trusted the right people.

Never once in any way shape or form did I take credit for that lynch or even indirectly imply I did. I only defended my villager bend by sliding that I was on the right side of history compared to dyachei.

Speaking of her. She had, unequivocally, the worst game of WW anyone had ever had. She DESERVED to die for making so many horrific votes and for repeatedly defending wolves. But she was a villager having a bad game. And look.... I didn't Lynch her. I also never left my vote to lunch her as my final vote at any point. Accusing her without voting for her is rather toothless, so i vote for her temporarily. but never leaving my vote sort of speaks to my willingness to believe she was just that of target that game.

One again, you're amazing ability to remember things that contradict the written record never ceases to amaze.

Also, where is your backup, that is not untrue either. None of your group is sticking their heads out there for you.

Also, any player can claim, "I have a valuable role". So yup that is true too.

Clearly I imagine it's coming. Haha.

But for real... It's coming right? Cause the role is useful. More useful than me spending my while lunch looking up stuff for this post.

So, what is made up here? You just don't like that I speak the truth and haven't fallen into the "everyone praise the all mighty DocE".... 🙄

 

[DocEspana]

^----- what's made up? Pretty much most to all of your negative thoughts about me.