My WWittle Pony: Friendship is MMagic Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Her contributions to the thread have struck me as coming from a village frame of mind. I’m not really seeing much in the way of what I would call “Wolfy”.

Can anyone who’s cast doubt or suspicion on Trilt, lay out a sold case or reasoning? I could be missing something but I don’t currently see a wolf!Trilt here.

I just don't think anything she's said/done is outside of her wolf range. Granted, she still could be village. It's just something I need more flip information for.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Dubz says she's good at reading Zenge? I thought it was other way round

It's both. Which is why I'm suprised you didn't target one of them even if you weren't going to the immediate POE.

 

[Zenge142]

I just don't think anything she's said/done is outside of her wolf range. Granted, she still could be village. It's just something I need more flip information for.

Do you think she’s said or done anything outside of her village range?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Do you think she’s said or done anything outside of her village range?

Not particularly. The two are pretty similar after years of playing.

 

[Crayola227]

...so do you realize that leaves only a few people other than you that you're considering village?? Rather, 5/10 players in this game are in your POE in some way?
When did I go from being an uncertain question mark to a wolf read?

I think having 3 people as village, 2 as neutral, and 5 as suspects is pretty standard for me at the point where I was in the game. I also have been kicking around if we're dealing with 2-3 scum, and I don't follow AM or other people's rules on size of POE. I read early on it should be about 2x the size of the # of scum you think are in the game. So 4-6 is spot on for me.

Seems really odd that you would try to use the size of my POE to shade me.

 

[Crayola227]

Can you narrow down a titch here?

Because you're basically saying you feel like WZ, Zenge, me, PSV and stoat are your wolf reads (with asterisks on WZ and Zenge) but that's literally half the field.

No, I never said this to be clear. I said WZ and Zenge were neutrals, and that they often ping me wolf, mistakenly often, and pinging me a bit here too, but the only one I have ever read with any accuracy is Wolf Dubz but that is rare when I do.

At the time, I had PSV, stoat, MJ, trilt, and alissa in the POE. By then end of D1 I can't see how I could have more than half the roster out of my immediate POE but I acknowledge my approach to the game is very different than others'.

 

[Crayola227]

I thought they hedged the read of wolfyness in wz and zenge. Like, the part of dont remembering being correct there. So them are neutral.

If I didnt misunderstood that is lol. The direct PoE would be Stoat/psv , then MJ/Trilt > alisa

This is an accurate summary of reads at the time.

 

[alissa14]

Her contributions to the thread have struck me as coming from a village frame of mind. I’m not really seeing much in the way of what I would call “Wolfy”.

Can anyone who’s cast doubt or suspicion on Trilt, lay out a sold case or reasoning? I could be missing something but I don’t currently see a wolf!Trilt here.

Ok I’m glad I’m not the only one who is confused by trilt sus

 

[Animal Midwife]

Ok I’m glad I’m not the only one who is confused by trilt sus

Have you looked into Trilt yet? Like Trilt's the only other one in your POE but you seem laregly disinterested in any suspicion on her.

 

[Truenamer]

Day 2: Elements of Disharmony

Trilt (1) - Santy
Crayola (3) - WildZoo, alissa, AM
4/8

Crayola is in the lead.

Missing: Half of y'all
Vote closes at 9pm Central / 10pm EST tomorrow (Thursday September 8th 2022), approximately 29 hours from now.

I'm positive I missed a contingency vote or two or four, so do me a favor and either quote them or vote again, properly

 

[Truenamer]

Best mod ever, only took me most of a day to make a vote post

 

[alissa14]

Have you looked into Trilt yet? Like Trilt's the only other one in your POE but you seem laregly disinterested in any suspicion on her.

I just honestly haven’t had time

 

[Crayola227]

Oh, I haven't seen where AM voted me.

 

[Crayola227]

I'm outposting Dubz right now and that's spooky, but tbf it's like 60% memes.

Ugh I don't know how you guys don't see that so much of what PSV is doing is scummy as heck. I feel like this is a replay of what happened with TN. Was I misyeeted that game? Thought that was how I died.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Interesting. I’m getting strong village vibes from Trilt? Was this your read yesterday too, or did it evolve today?

It's more a process of elimination. I do think Trilt has a village tone but village tone isn't impossible to fake as a wolf.

I read early on

Not everything you read on the internet is true, Cray.

Ugh I don't know how you guys don't see that so much of what PSV is doing is scummy as heck. I feel like this is a replay of what happened with TN. Was I misyeeted that game? Thought that was how I died.

"That game" being...?
Curious why your tunnel of me deepened so much today.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Well, come to think of it, is Trilt any more inherently sus than Santy? Or are they both potential Cray partners?
Or is Cray not even a wolf and she's just being the wolfiest villager of all time?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Why was Zenge outgoing D1 and now lurky D2?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Well, come to think of it, is Trilt any more inherently sus than Santy? Or are they both potential Cray partners?
Or is Cray not even a wolf and she's just being the wolfiest villager of all time?

Santy doesn't seem super compatible with Cray. Nor does he seem compatible with Trilt. If you're not thinking this is a wolf!Cray though, both Trilt and Santy are still independently viable candidates.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Why was Zenge outgoing D1 and now lurky D2?

I'm still waiting on an answer to my dubz question.

 

[Crayola227]

L

It's more a process of elimination. I do think Trilt has a village tone but village tone isn't impossible to fake as a wolf.

Not everything you read on the internet is true, Cray.

"That game" being...?
Curious why your tunnel of me deepened so much today.

The game where TN and Fluff were wolves and I got misyeeted.

 

[WildZoo]

Her contributions to the thread have struck me as coming from a village frame of mind.

Tell me why

 

[Zenge142]

Well, come to think of it, is Trilt any more inherently sus than Santy? Or are they both potential Cray partners?
Or is Cray not even a wolf and she's just being the wolfiest villager of all time?

I’m more inclined to think it’s a Santy/Cray pack than a Trilt/Cray pack.

Why was Zenge outgoing D1 and now lurky D2?

I’ve been working all day/busy. May or may not have Covid. Schrodinger’s Covid.

I'm still waiting on an answer to my dubz question.

I’m not prepared to answer. I wasn’t ready to move her out of neutrals at the end of D1. With this post restriction obfuscation I’m not sure. Gun to my head, I’d say village, but I was hoping to get more of a feel this cycle.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I’m more inclined to think it’s a Santy/Cray pack than a Trilt/Cray pack.

Why?

I’m not prepared to answer. I wasn’t ready to move her out of neutrals at the end of D1. With this post restriction obfuscation I’m not sure. Gun to my head, I’d say village, but I was hoping to get more of a feel this cycle.

That's a weird answer.

 

[Crayola227]

I don't know what relevance this has to the current game.

??? Why are you fixated on this? Feels a lot like the stump argument in 10th anniversary.

If you think jokiness is AI in any way for me then you just haven't paid any attention to me in any game we've played together, or in the one I modded.

Dude the relevance is the way Dubz called out alissa for her vote on Zenge, and DUBZ was the one that brought up last game to call her out for it. And I'm the one saying, I am so sick and tired of acting like certain D1 votes on certain players are somehow off the table. It isn't productive.

And shelty if you think the only reason I find you sus is the typo you are not paying attention. Too much time in wolf chat.

Does anyone else think PSV and Dubz are compatible?

 

[WildZoo]

I wasn’t ready to move her out of neutrals at the end of D1.

Shot through the heart, and you're to blame

 

[Crayola227]

Oh
Um
I can't get behind that d1. I haven't played with him in years

Noting the 180

 

[Zenge142]

Why?

I could see a world where Santy got on the Cray vote first to create distance without meaning for it to take off, and then took the first chance they had to hop off. I really don’t see Cray/Santy as incompatible.

Stoat’s death and Santy’s reaction to it too, had me concerned. Seemed like Stoat was the only one willing to go after Santy a little bit.

That's a weird answer.

Why? I’m saying I wasn’t sure at the end of D1 and was hoping to get a better idea this cycle but the post restriction is making that challenging. If I had to make a snap decision right this second, I’d say probably village. I’d rather not stake my reading card on it quite yet though.

 

[Crayola227]

YES GIVE ME YOUR ANGERIES, THEY TASTE BETTER THAN YOUR LICORICE

Fake red licorice is the only licorice worth eating. Come at me bros.

 

[WildZoo]

Noting the 180

Y'all gon make me lose my mind, up in here up in here

 

[Animal Midwife]

I could see a world where Santy got on the Cray vote first to create distance without meaning for it to take off, and then took the first chance they had to hop off. I really don’t see Cray/Santy as incompatible.

idk staying on until Cray is forced to claim, followed by repeatedly tagging her to vote on a counter (when that could quickly and easily be discussed in wolfchat) is very unrealistic to me.

Stoat’s death and Santy’s reaction to it too, had me concerned. Seemed like Stoat was the only one willing to go after Santy a little bit.

What about the reaction? He still had Cray in the POE in that post.

Why? I’m saying I wasn’t sure at the end of D1 and was hoping to get a better idea this cycle but the post restriction is making that challenging. If I had to make a snap decision right this second, I’d say probably village. I’d rather not stake my reading card on it quite yet though.

If you think Cray is wolf, dubz should be confirmed from your eyes. So what is making you unsure?

 

[Crayola227]

Am still catching up but were people satisfied with stoat's explanation of why she found MJ villagey? Because I still don't get it.

The subtle push here on stoat

 

[Crayola227]

Rule of threes...

Not really in that I don't read it as villagey but I don't think it feels like wolfy defense necessarily.

Omg you're bringing up the rule of 3s nonsense? One, you're not even applying it correctly, it has nothing to do with just having a group of 3 and had everything to do with SYMMETRY, so it should be called the rule of symmetry, and two, I made symmetrical groupings in the very game I said it was a silly and easy to beat theory, proving my point that villagers will do it, and three, that game I pointed out that experienced wolves can look over their reads list to watch for that. So it's a total WIFOM argument to try to use against me.

 

[Crayola227]

We can still talk or nah?

Literally the only reason I have not left the site is that they generally allow night talk on thread and I need that to play, I have to play when my baby sleeps and before I had a baby at night in any case.

 

[Zenge142]

idk staying on until Cray is forced to claim, followed by repeatedly tagging her to vote on a counter (when that could quickly and easily be discussed in wolfchat) is very unrealistic to me.

Forced to claim? Do you believe the claim? The claim was a reason to get off the vote, and if you don’t believe the claim, then I think you have your answer.

What about the reaction? He still had Cray in the POE in that post.

These just struck me as Wolfy

Spoiler

Like, Stoat WolfHunting energy rn its very real I think and thats a pretty good look regardless of Cray alignment

Yeet Trilt

GOing to relook at stuff, I just woke up.

But @bluestoat you did really well and in Kinda after EoD managed to go from PoE to one of the most towny people , sorry for not finding you earlier!

Going to quote myself on the Cray stuff now.

Sad that now that I am in thread to do it Blue cant reply to me tho ;-;

If you think Cray is wolf, dubz should be confirmed from your eyes. So what is making you unsure?

I’d like to actually see Cray flip wolf first.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Forced to claim? Do you believe the claim? The claim was a reason to get off the vote, and if you don’t believe the claim, then I think you have your answer.

I don't understand what that has to do with Santy staying on her under she claimed. He didn't have to stay on her that long in the first place.

These just struck me as Wolfy

The first one was made when stoat was still alive. I don't see the issue with the second. Could you clarify? The third just is an extention of the second post.

I’d like to actually see Cray flip wolf first.

It doesn't make sense to hedge on dubz without also hedging on Cray. What's your v!Cray POE look like?

 

[Santygrass]

I just Iso'd Trilt, and now I am even doubting if they are a viable partner for Cray even, wowee.

I am just kinda leaning more that Cray could be threadspewed V and we are ignoring it or smth lol.

Also the Zenge read on Trilt is super weird, specially how they are ignoring the timing of Trilt vote in MJ, but then having tinfoil on me to be Cray partner. Like, this could be biased, but I think I have more villagery content than Trilt and have less equity with Cray than Trilt but /shrug.
Not going to argue against why I couldnt be Cray partner now cuz its pointless. I have like 18 quotes rn so prolly better to spend my time on that.

 

[Crayola227]

Hmmm. If I were not me I’d almost lean my action wolfy

Yah same

Spoiler

View attachment 359309
View attachment 359310

A woman of my own heart🥰

Spoiler

No just a final for this one class. We have a blocked schedule. We are tested roughly every 7-10 days (though almost all vet schools have this testing frequency). But it’s nice to not have a ton of finals at once at the end of each semester.

Why the sad react sporty 🙁

Hi I was studying with my study group

So let me get this straight, you're wolf leaning me because I didn't wolf lean you for something you did?

Honestly I can't remember the last time a wolf said "Woe is me, this thing I did makes me look bad," seems like most wolves save that sort of pity party (and pointing out something they did makes them look wolfy) in pack chat rather than commiserating on thread. Wolves don't have to commiserate on thread, they have sympathetic wolves to commiserate with in pack chat. I find it's more often villagers that say openly "whoa that is getting me heat instant regret". Because they have less to lose with inviting that scrutiny.

That isn't to say wolves don't use pity and the like for emotional manip, but it has a different flavor. I dunno it's different to say "woe is me I'm getting wolf read" vs "woe is me let me publicly bemoan this in a way that is making it very obvious I am considering my own optics."

Basically I think what I mean is that wolves tend to be, somewhat more close to the vest about their own optics and leave talk about their own optics to chat rather than thread.

That's my own take.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

And shelty if you think the only reason I find you sus is the typo you are not paying attention. Too much time in wolf chat.

Thanks for this non-answer. Sorry, it's hard to tell what you're saying when you shade everyone all the time.

I am just kinda leaning more that Cray could be threadspewed V

Honestly that's her default state which is why I'm trying to figure out whether she's wolfing here or not.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I'm getting increasingly paranoid about Santy's existence because of him pocketing shorty in champs. I'm concerned I wouldn't know it if he's scumming here.

 

[WildZoo]

I remember when, I remember, I remember when I lost my mind

 

[Animal Midwife]

I wonder what NateTheLesser thinks about all this.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

What would be productive now, I think, is to check and compare with Assassination Classroom, where village!Cray was misyoten, and 10th Ann, where wolf! Cray was yoten. I think comparing tone would be enlightening.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I wonder what NateTheLesser thinks about all this.

I wonder what NateTheGreat thinks about it.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I think Zenge is sending shivers down my spine.

 

[WildZoo]

Assassination Classroom, where village!Cray was misyoten

Far away, for far too long

 

[WildZoo]

I think Zenge is sending shivers down my spine.

Tell me more, tell me more

 

[Zenge142]

I think Zenge is sending shivers down my spine.

PSV pls. I’m a good egg.

 

[Zenge142]

Yeet Cray

 

[Zenge142]

I wonder what NateTheGreat thinks about it.

We don’t talk about Bruno NateTheGreat No no no

 

[Zenge142]

I don't understand what that has to do with Santy staying on her under she claimed. He didn't have to stay on her that long in the first place.

Idk. Agree to disagree. I think there’s a decent possibility that they are paired.

The first one was made when stoat was still alive. I don't see the issue with the second. Could you clarify? The third just is an extention of the second post.

i just found them Wolfy. I felt like the first one was saying “I know exactly who I’m going to kill tonight…” and the others were just…Wolfy. They pinged me. It was a big enough shift in tone from Santy’s previous interactions with stoat that I was pinged.

It doesn't make sense to hedge on dubz without also hedging on Cray. What's your v!Cray POE look like?

I am hedging on Cray. I could see a world where village Cray made the decisions she did. If we flip Cray and Cray does somehow flip village I’ll run through my POE in a Village!Cray world, with the full D2 cycle behind me.