My WWittle Pony: Friendship is MMagic Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Seriously, can you just go through every post and translate because I've been useless.
Trying Daniel Radcliffe GIF
 
THEN IT SHOULDN'T BE USED TO AFFECT READS
More than half of the game is having soft details or feels or niggles, it's not hard to imagine things that affect a read but don't need to be shared with the class immediately. It's only because people kept harassing that it became a whole thing.
 
Then

Why

Did

You

Wait


Until

The

Last

Hour

To


Do


It
Because Cray is also not an unreasonable vote. And I’d rather not derail a wagon when it has momentum
 
This is not a great time for the manifesto I was going to drop about metas so I won't do it now.
 
I'm going to say, if someone wanted the info on thread, it'd be here.
And I'm done talking about it.
 
More than half of the game is having soft details or feels or niggles, it's not hard to imagine things that affect a read but don't need to be shared with the class immediately. It's only because people kept harassing that it became a whole thing.
I think it's a bit different in a game this small where we are literally trying to decide whether or not to vote out a claimed seer and evaluate who might be partnered with her. Like, a major part of why I struggled today was because there are a lot of unpartnering interactions between Cray and almost everyone else in the game.

And in any case if someone is going to bring up that there are behind the scenes/mechanical reasons to change a read, I've always said they should be prepared to share details. If they want it to stay secret, come up with a different reason.
 
Then

Why

Did

You

Wait


Until

The

Last

Hour

To


Do


It
I don't disagree with this, though. Not even the last hour. Y'all decided to **** around with a well established yeet in the last half hour, basically, and I gotta be honest that's obnoxious and makes me eyebrow raise.
 
Because Cray is also not an unreasonable vote. And I’d rather not derail a wagon when it has momentum
I just didn't understand why you stayed there after like, shooting down Cray/Alissa with your comment to me about Alissa bussing Cray into the ground, and then deciding you also didn't think she was partnered with PSV
 
In disarray. Somewhat pondering Trilt and having paranoia attacks about Santy potentially being compatible with Cray.

Not so sure I agree with that last sentence? Picking AM feels like the strangest choice imo.
I'm chasing my tail over village!Cray being so paranoid as to seer her number one village read just to be safe? But then why would wolf!Cray not pick someone who's in the POE but isn't a wolf?

Santy/Zenge in paranoia land, Cray/Trilt? in realistic land.

I think Zenge is sending shivers down my spine.
 
No actually, here's the thing.
What I find fun about the game is figuring someone out. It's like that "eureka!" feeling when you suddenly are struck by lightning and it's like !!!! I've cracked it! samac is a wolf!
I don't find it as fun when that feeling is reduced because the game is solved by mechanics or by "x player doesn't bus so they're lock village".
Whatever. Everyone can play how they want.
But I think it's more fun when I feel like Sherlock Holmes.
 
What I wanted to ilustrate that there is no wsy that psv cleared mlre Zenge from something that happened in the night
 
I think it's a bit different in a game this small where we are literally trying to decide whether or not to vote out a claimed seer and evaluate who might be partnered with her. Like, a major part of why I struggled today was because there are a lot of unpartnering interactions between Cray and almost everyone else in the game.

And in any case if someone is going to bring up that there are behind the scenes/mechanical reasons to change a read, I've always said they should be prepared to share details. If they want it to stay secret, come up with a different reason.
I mean, I don't disagree that PSV could have been more subtle or made up a reason, but those have risks too and with how much AM was on her ass I suspect we would have ended up in a similar place.
 
No actually, here's the thing.
What I find fun about the game is figuring someone out. It's like that "eureka!" feeling when you suddenly are struck by lightning and it's like !!!! I've cracked it! samac is a wolf!
I don't find it as fun when that feeling is reduced because the game is solved by mechanics or by "x player doesn't bus so they're lock village".
Whatever. Everyone can play how they want.
But I think it's more fun when I feel like Sherlock Holmes.
That's great but part of that is sharing your deductions with others. Particularly when the next cycle could be mylo.
 
In already feeling the green flip Villa.

If they flip Wolf I volunteer to be the yeet and eat a shoe
 
That's great but part of that is sharing your deductions with others. Particularly when the next cycle could be mylo.
No. Whatever did or didn't happen, the person that did or didn't do the action is the one who can and should disclose what happened.
 
Okay. You know what. If Cray flips wolf, I'll give PSV another cycle to actually vote a wolf. Otherwise, I'm actually going to leave the thread for the rest of the night because I'm beyond infuriated and doubt I'll be helpful until I cool down.
 
Anyway I was always going back to Cray, I just switched to Zenge because he was driving me nuts and I wanted to fully convey my frustration.

Brief PSV flip was just to see if he'd try to save her. Had the vote to move back to Cray queued up.
 
I stole it from someone else prob, not sure if it was shorty or someone else tho
 
Okay. You know what. If Cray flips village, I'll give PSV another cycle to actually vote a wolf. Otherwise, I'm actually going to leave the thread for the rest of the night because I'm beyond infuriated and doubt I'll be helpful until I cool down.
Do you mean if Cray flips wolf? Because if Cray flips village I think we're a tiny bit ****ed.
 
Should've vote for me before, it was the optimal move from your pov and didnt push for it fwiw
 
Okay. You know what. If Cray flips wolf, I'll give PSV another cycle to actually vote a wolf. Otherwise, I'm actually going to leave the thread for the rest of the night because I'm beyond infuriated and doubt I'll be helpful until I cool down.
I'm borderline hoping she flips village just so I don't have to continue with this niggle about "what the **** was that" from you.

Cray has been the leader ALL CYCLE why the hell did all that motion happen in the last half hour with NO INPUT from her??
 
Day 2

Eventually, all good things must come to an end. And sometimes that means tragically killing off your main character. In certain fandoms, this seems to drag on....

and on....

for a good half dozen seasons until you finally have to end your cash cow. And then, you know, maybe you just need to kill off your beloved main character tragically for a final time after a much longed-for confession of love.

I guess some people would phrase that as AND IIIIIIII WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOUUUUUUUUU.

Thankfully for some people, that was not the case for this Mane Character, and everyone could get some relief before our episodes went on for far too many dry and repetitive seasons. Unfortunately for others, this may mean we never do quite learn the meaning of friendship....

mlp-my-little-pony.gif


Dead is @Crayola227 - Twilight Sparkle, WOLF Affiliation seer

The Roster:

1. @Animal Midwife
2. @Santygrass
4. @potentialsheltervet
7. @WildZoo
8. @Zenge142
9. @Trilt
10. @alissa14

Dead:
6. @Mad Jack - Spitfire, Jailor
5. @bluestoat - Trixie, vanilla
3. @Crayola227 - Twilight, WOLF Affiliation seer
 
skill-issue-skill-issue-gif.gif


This will be my full defense after Cray flips V tomorrow is someone votes for me lr something fwiw. I spent the whole die trying to explain why Cray was towny and you guys were misreading and basing it on something that should be NAI at best.
 
And then, you know, maybe you just need to kill off your beloved main character tragically for a final time after a much longed-for confession of love.
Idk what this is actually referring to but it's always a Supernatural reference for me, smh
 
Top