Once Upon A Time WW Game Thread

[StartingoverVet]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I thought this was really interesting....



and



Is there some reason you just basically identified Snow and Charming for the wolves? Like, perhaps, you want the wolves to kill them? Because, perhaps, you have an independent win condition and need the wolves to off a few villagers for you as you whittle away at the players?

I may be stupid for doing that, but you are a ***** for pointing it out. Or a wolf yourself. Nice job throwing suspicion on me AND pointing it out for the world in case anyone missed it.

Here is a quote for you to study:
"We have met the enemy and he is us"

🙄

 

[LetItSnow]

I may be stupid for doing that, but you are a ***** for pointing it out. Or a wolf yourself. Nice job throwing suspicion on me AND pointing it out for the world in case anyone missed it.

Here is a quote for you to study:
"We have met the enemy and he is us"

🙄

Nice try, dude. You posted the info, and if I saw it, it's a given the wolves did. So don't even try that nonsense of "oh, yeah, I guess I did sorta post something indiscriminate, but it's all YOUR fault."

You posted it. You own the responsibility. I'm trying to wake the rest of the villagers up to the fact that you aren't on their side.

 

[Dwindlin]

Nice try, dude. You posted the info, and if I saw it, it's a given the wolves did. So don't even try that nonsense of "oh, yeah, I guess I did sorta post something indiscriminate, but it's all YOUR fault."

You posted it. You own the responsibility. I'm trying to wake the rest of the villagers up to the fact that you aren't on their side.

Yeah no. I'm with SOV, pointing it out was incredibly stupid. Not that SOV posting it in the first place was smart either.

 

[LetItSnow]

Yeah no. I'm with SOV, pointing it out was incredibly stupid. Not that SOV posting it in the first place was smart either.

No, it wasn't. Because this entire time SOV's been selling a lie that he's on our side. He's not. This was the only way to demonstrate it. Everyone's just been accepting his word - his completely unverified word - that he's really trying to help the villagers. Here's some great evidence that he's not.

 

[shortnsweet]

***********

*********

 

[StartingoverVet]

Nice try, dude. You posted the info, and if I saw it, it's a given the wolves did. So don't even try that nonsense of "oh, yeah, I guess I did sorta post something indiscriminate, but it's all YOUR fault."

You posted it. You own the responsibility. I'm trying to wake the rest of the villagers up to the fact that you aren't on their side.

I admitted I was stupid to post it. But no one ELSE noticed it but you. If you can't see that, then you have been working to hard or are a wolf.

I doubt most of the wolves were reading carefully who we think are wolves.
And if I had a win condition why would I care which villagers are killed?

 

[LetItSnow]

I admitted I was stupid to post it. But no one ELSE noticed it but you. If you can't see that, then you have been working to hard or are a wolf.

I doubt most of the wolves were reading carefully who we think are wolves.
And if I had a win condition why would I care which villagers are killed?

How on earth can you rationally say I'm the only one to notice it? Noticing it and speaking up are two different things, first. And second, do you expect the wolves to jump in and say "Oh, hey, thanks, we were looking for Snow!"? So how do you know who noticed it?

As to your second question, my presumption is that you are concerned that you weren't going to be able to get those two lynched, so you wanted to guide the wolves to them.

You don't post things indiscriminately, because you're too damn smart. I don't buy the "I was stupid" thing, because you aren't.

 

[thedrjojo]

I admitted I was stupid to post it. But no one ELSE noticed it but you. If you can't see that, then you have been working to hard or are a wolf.

I doubt most of the wolves were reading carefully who we think are wolves.
And if I had a win condition why would I care which villagers are killed?

are you admitting you purposely tried to do it?

LIS wasn't the only one to catch it... just the only one to say it... so thanks for that too...

 

[StartingoverVet]

are you admitting you purposely tried to do it?

.

absolutely not.

I came up with 2 separate ideas.... compiled the info while I was working and didn't see the link between the 2. Completely a stupid boner. Not planned at all.

 

[StartingoverVet]

You don't post things indiscriminately, because you're too damn smart. I don't buy the "I was stupid" thing, because you aren't.

Gee, now I know LIS has heat stroke.

SOV doesn't do stupid things?
Like send a wolf PM to the wrong Orca?
Or 1000 other mistakes I have made without thinking...

Not strategy.. .but for fun, let's all post their favorite SOV boner!!!!
Open season on SOV.. Make me laugh!

 

[wildcatj]

absolutely not.

I came up with 2 separate ideas.... compiled the info while I was working and didn't see the link between the 2. Completely a stupid boner. Not planned at all.

******************
Like all the awkward boners in this world...
******************

 

[wildcatj]

*****************
You are apparently using boner in a way I'm not familiar with. As I'm laughing hysterically over here.
*****************

 

[LetItSnow]

Gee, now I know LIS has heat stroke.

SOV doesn't do stupid things?
Like send a wolf PM to the wrong Orca?
Or 1000 other mistakes I have made without thinking...

Not strategy.. .but for fun, let's all post their favorite SOV boner!!!!
Open season on SOV.. Make me laugh!

Ok, this particular argument aside ... I don't actually know the "wolf PM to the wrong Orca" story. Either I forgot, or sat out that game. Tell.

It IS hot here in MN right now. But I still think yer foc. 🙂

 

[LetItSnow]

let's all post their favorite SOV boner!!!!

... and I'm petrified to see where this goes, since you chose to use 'boner'. 🙂

 

[that redhead]

I didn't notice it, but I'm not the brightest crayon in the box in these games. I think it was stupid for LIS to call it out, though, and out of character for him 👎

 

[thedrjojo]

Re-summarizing the players:

Roles I have been told are good by investigation or a dead villager or by implication:
Rojo (me)
EC (SOV)

Top roles of the show (in order of listing on google).

Snow - known to me.
Charming - known to me.

Top roles of the show (in order of listing on google). Update #3

Snow - known to SOV.
Charming - known to me.

absolutely not.

I came up with 2 separate ideas.... compiled the info while I was working and didn't see the link between the 2. Completely a stupid boner. Not planned at all.

See, I first noticed it because you used the same SOV/me difference in update #3 as you did in the group listing (which was odd to me)... i didn't notice until LIS posted his way that in the first two updates, it wasn't listed as SOV/Me, it was just me/me... So, i ask you, if you weren't trying to purposely point that out, then why did it change in the 3rd list? I was hoping I was just being paranoid at first...

I'm not sure which of the two of you i should be more upset about this about... but something smells rotten in all of this...

 

[hedgiehog]

I have a solution to the Rumple problem. It involves a magical dagger...

 

[tuckervet]

Wow, I missed a lot of drama today.
Seems like weird behavior for both LIS and SOV ( even though this is my first time playing, I followed a few recently, and based on what everyone says, they both seem like experienced players).
LIS, couldn't you have PMed someone you trust to point out SOV's sketchy post, instead of drawing attention to it for anyone not paying attention?

 

[StartingoverVet]

... I don't actually know the "wolf PM to the wrong Orca" story. Either I forgot, or sat out that game. Tell.

🙂

I am pretty sure that was one of the first couple of games in pre-vet.. Might actually have been the first one after I modded the initial game.

I was a wolf... and sent a message to my fellow wolves.
Didn't realize there was an orcagirl and an orca2011 and sent a PM with all the wolves name on it to the wrong one.

Luckily my next pm said not to open it (as did the mod, I believe Lissarae)...

Got away with that one. 😀

 

[Escalla]

Night deadline extended to 11 PM EST. Mod needs an extra hour.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Been thinking about this.... If LIS is right and I did this on purpose because I am so smart...what was the plan... Do an incredibly subtle outing of 2 roles that the wolves might not notice or was it so obvious that the wolves see it but so does everyone else and I make myself look guilty of something. Either I am just stupid or I had no plan. Either way I am not some criminal mastermind

 

[LetItSnow]

Been thinking about this.... If LIS is right and I did this on purpose because I am so smart...what was the plan... Do an incredibly subtle outing of 2 roles that the wolves might not notice or was it so obvious that the wolves see it but so does everyone else and I make myself look guilty of something. Either I am just stupid or I had no plan. Either way I am not some criminal mastermind

Unless the plan was "play dumb and pretend it was a mistake." Which is exactly what you've done. It's a pretty perfect way to do it, actually. You got the info out, but it wasn't so blatant you couldn't claim it was a mistake, but it was obvious enough that it'd be noticed. Super slick move.

 

[Flim Flam Man]

***********
My fave SOV oops was when he said he couldn't be killed by wolves, and was killed the first night.
***********

 

[thedrjojo]

***********
My fave SOV oops was when he said he couldn't be killed by wolves, and was killed the first night.
***********

by LIS if i recall correctly

 

[LetItSnow]

by LIS if i recall correctly

*bow* It was just too perfect. Although I did feel guilty taking him out N1 because even when I'm playing as a wolf I don't like killing the good players.... makes the game boring.

 

[StartingoverVet]

by LIS if i recall correctly

Who also got me killed in Greek mythology. 🙁

 

[thedrjojo]

Been thinking about this.... If LIS is right and I did this on purpose because I am so smart...what was the plan... Do an incredibly subtle outing of 2 roles that the wolves might not notice or was it so obvious that the wolves see it but so does everyone else and I make myself look guilty of something. Either I am just stupid or I had no plan. Either way I am not some criminal mastermind

Unless the plan was "play dumb and pretend it was a mistake." Which is exactly what you've done. It's a pretty perfect way to do it, actually. You got the info out, but it wasn't so blatant you couldn't claim it was a mistake, but it was obvious enough that it'd be noticed. Super slick move.

I'm still not satisfied with either of you, but this is getting a whole lot of no where... SOV, still didn't address my last set of quotes, and LIS, I agree with TRH, there were better ways of trying to get people against SOV, that, um, didn't point out the error, purposeful or not...

 

[LetItSnow]

Who also got me killed in Greek mythology. 🙁

Yeah. That turned out to be a boner move. 🙁

 

[thedrjojo]

Who also got me killed in Greek mythology. 🙁

you two will always have that magical evening...

 

[LetItSnow]

BTW, just in case anyone thinks some of our SDN WW night deaths are over-the-top gruesome ... I give you .... real life in the soccer world.

 

[StartingoverVet]

I have a solution to the Rumple problem. It involves a magical dagger...

There is no problem... And there is no rush to decide what to do with me. Use me until I am no longer needed. Then you know how to kill me. I am sure the wolves will kill me as soon as they get the dagger anyway. In fact, seeing who kills me is the best way to find a wolf. Villagers can wait....wolves can't afford to let my power to help stay in game.

 

[StartingoverVet]

I'm still not satisfied with either of you, but this is getting a whole lot of no where... SOV, still didn't address my last set of quotes, and LIS, I agree with TRH, there were better ways of trying to get people against SOV, that, um, didn't point out the error, purposeful or not...

I answered you in a pm to your love. Was trying to move on...
And I only keep posting because I am waiting for results....which now being delayed probably means tomorrow for me. 🙁

I think we have narrowed down the potential original wolf list well. Would like to nail Cora and Regina and move on to the conversions already.

 

[LetItSnow]

There is no problem... And there is no rush to decide what to do with me. Use me until I am no longer needed. Then you know how to kill me. I am sure the wolves will kill me as soon as they get the dagger anyway. In fact, seeing who kills me is the best way to find a wolf. Villagers can wait....wolves can't afford to let my power to help stay in game.

How are we supposed to see who kills you? And do we know the dagger can kill you, or have we just been assuming it?

 

[StartingoverVet]

Fwiw....I am hoping wolves may have already had a good idea of who is important.....there are 17 players plus me. With maybe 4 wolves that leaves 13. Roles have been made public on 3. Leaves 10. Honestly wolves must know about 1/2 of those from pm-ing or educated guesses.....I might have accelerated their knowledge a day or two at most if at all. .anyway that is what I think when I consider it.

 

[StartingoverVet]

How are we supposed to see who kills you? And do we know the dagger can kill you, or have we just been assuming it?

Some people might know of a way to answer the first question. As for the second....I don't think anyone knows what happens in this game when the dagger is used. I presume I die, and the user loses their affiliation and becomes neutral like I was. There has to be some sort of transformation like in the show. My guess is, like all magic, someone will have to pay a price.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Night deadline extended to 11 PM EST. Mod needs an extra hour.

Don't you know mods are not allowed a life?

 

[thedrjojo]

Don't you know mods are not allowed a life?

👍

 

[that redhead]

BTW, just in case anyone thinks some of our SDN WW night deaths are over-the-top gruesome ... I give you .... real life in the soccer world.

I saw that today. Holy pickles...

 

[NStarz]

I'm not sure what to make of this whole SOV/LIS business. So I'm just going to pretend it didn't happen for now. Hehehe.

I think we need to stick to the list.

 

[Escalla]

Don't you know mods are not allowed a life?

👍

😛 12 mins early, just for you.

Night closed, results pending.

 

[Escalla]

It had been a long day at the diner for wld. With Red gone, who else does she have to wait tables? She has been run off her feet for too many days in a row. The aches and pains she gets with these hours are just not worth it. Not for a lady getting up there in years.

She heads into the back room to start counting cash for the night when she hears the tinkle of the door opening and closing. Who would be coming in at this hour? They were closed. She must have forgotten to lock the door. Maybe they forgot something. She heads out to see who it is.

"Can I help you?", wld asks as she's walking out of the back. "We're closed."

Immediately there's a mechanical click and a bolt whizzes across the room. Shock and pain register on her features. Wld brings her blood-soaked fingers up to her face. Is this real? She collapses to her knees. Looking around, she sees no one. Ripping the cross-bow bolt from her chest, she gasps in pain. They couldn't have at least shot her in the head and ended her life efficiently? No. This was meant to be torture. Shot with her very own weapon. She falls to her side and stares blankly at the wall, the pool of blood slowly expanding around her. With a last ragged breath, wld's body relaxes, not to rise again.

Wldlfstdnt, Granny/Widow Lucas, your mayor, is now dead. Who is going to pay for this terrible tragedy?

It is now Day 11. You need to elect a new mayor. Lynch/election deadline 2 PM EST.

There are 17 players remaining.

Clock Tower
1. Rojo
3. dyachei
5. Alors
6. Dwin
8. cuit

Mary Margaret's Apartment
4. FantasyFlyer
5. Hedgie
6. Tuckervet
7. bbeventer

Sheriff's Department
2. that redhead
5. Minnerbelle
6. The LIS
8. NStarz

Granny's Diner
2. Swings
6. Fancy

Mr. Gold's Pawn & Antiques Shop
5. equineconstant
6. SOV

Cemetery kayd:
Lissarae06 - Grumpy/Leroy
FFM - Tamara
nohika - Belle/Lacey
SV88 - Mad Hatter/Jefferson
Frozenshades - Captain Killian "Hook" Jones
FH - Red Riding Hood/Ruby
SnS - Emma Swan
Jamr0ckin - Owen Flynn/Greg Mendell
WS - Prince Phillip
Allie - Maleficent
devyn - Dr. Frankenstein/Dr. Whale
wildcatj - Genie/Magic Mirror/Sidney Glass
DVMD - Jiminy Cricket/Archie Hopper
Lupin21 - Peter Pan/The Shadow
wldlfstdnt - Granny/Widow Lucas

 

[wldlfstdnt]

*******************
Whoever did this, you suck.
*******************

 

[tuckervet]

nominate rojo

lynch SOV

 

[556535]

Nominate Rojo

 

[AlorsOnDanse]

****elect rojo*****

 

[equineconstant]

elect rojo, lynch swings

 

[thedrjojo]

👍

Elect Rojo

Going to wait to hear if anything was discovered overnight before I cast any vote...

 

[AlorsOnDanse]

👍

Elect Rojo

Going to wait to hear if anything was discovered overnight before I cast any vote...

Agreed I know it's late but I'm anxious to hear if anyone got any good results.

 

[wolfspeaker]

*************

***********

 

[tuckervet]

it may just be the paranoia of making it this far in my first game, but should we be suspicious that Snow has been converted, since Granny was killed with a bow?


also, to add to the lists made by SOV, I have reason to believe that Cinderella is in the game (I forget what her Storyville name is).