Persistence of Minecraft WW Game Thread

[allyphoe]

Part of the problem with that theory is that they had to know it wouldn't work long term.

Well, it worked (and possibly would have continued to work) as long as there was a close-ish lynch and genny wasn't one of two. If she'd been around to defend, we could possibly still be here scratching our heads over how the lynch runner up kept dying.

And even in the long term, I don't see any harm to the wolves beyond the harm from losing one. Keeping the village confused early on sounds like good wolf strategy to me. Or genny was a lone wolf and didn't have the experience to look long-term.

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[KCgophervet]

After last game i will always suspect Abney (welcome) but I'm satisfied with my lynch choice for today.

Sent from my VS876 using SDN mobile

 

[Abnerrs]

After last game i will always suspect Abney (welcome) but I'm satisfied with my lynch choice for today.

Sent from my VS876 using SDN mobile

Lol honestly I don't blame you. Even though you did it to me!

 

[Promethean]

Lynch MQ, then.

I really don't like the BBC lynch.

Finn is a no-go. Genny's apparently sincere attempt to lynch Finn on D2... I don't think that Genny was a subtle enough new wolf to pull that off as cover.

I still kinda want to go Abney, but maybe another day.

 

[Trilt]

Day 4 Officialish Lynch Tally

PBC (1) - MQ
Abney (2) - Dy, Deva
Mq (2) - Kcough, Promo
Kcough ()
Dy (2) - Ally, STL
Hayley (0) -
Promo (1) - DVMD
Finn (3) - Kam, Jilary, SOV
BBC (5) - Abney, WZ, Finn, Hayley, Ny

16/18 Voting. 10pm EST Deadline

 

[Skimble]

Lynch MQ, then.

I really don't like the BBC lynch.

Finn is a no-go. Genny's apparently sincere attempt to lynch Finn on D2... I don't think that Genny was a subtle enough new wolf to pull that off as cover.

I still kinda want to go Abney, but maybe another day.

But what if she was a lone wolf?


Finn, are you claiming fill vanillager?

 

[finnickthedog]

But what if she was a lone wolf?


Finn, are you claiming fill vanillager?

No. I'm claiming I don't have an active ability. I do have a passive one.

Edit: Or at least I assume I do. Nothing has come of it yet, so I could be wrong.

 

[dyachei]

Well, it worked (and possibly would have continued to work) as long as there was a close-ish lynch and genny wasn't one of two. If she'd been around to defend, we could possibly still be here scratching our heads over how the lynch runner up kept dying.

And even in the long term, I don't see any harm to the wolves beyond the harm from losing one. Keeping the village confused early on sounds like good wolf strategy to me. Or genny was a lone wolf and didn't have the experience to look long-term.

You're making assumptions about how ties are handled here and that somehow it would make that person die the next day?

Or conflating the 2?

 

[Abnerrs]

Lynch MQ, then.

I really don't like the BBC lynch.

Finn is a no-go. Genny's apparently sincere attempt to lynch Finn on D2... I don't think that Genny was a subtle enough new wolf to pull that off as cover.

I still kinda want to go Abney, but maybe another day.

It's funny you say that because I don't really get villager vibes from you either my friend!

 

[Abnerrs]

Though honestly, promo's blustery posts had me thinking he was a wolf early game last time

 

[allyphoe]

You're making assumptions about how ties are handled here and that somehow it would make that person die the next day?

Or conflating the 2?

No, I'm saying that the speculation was that ties / close lynches resulted in the overnight death of the survivor. Genny used that speculation as cover. My assumption was that genny acted intentionally to take advantage of village confusion.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Lynch MQ, then.

I really don't like the BBC lynch.

Finn is a no-go. Genny's apparently sincere attempt to lynch Finn on D2... I don't think that Genny was a subtle enough new wolf to pull that off as cover.

I still kinda want to go Abney, but maybe another day.

I don't have time to reread the D2 lynch comments by Genny, but that sounds reasonable enough that I don't want to lynch finn for now.

unlynch Finn.

I don't have another candidate for now so will abstain for now (and too tired to think).

 

[allyphoe]

We have another hour, right?

 

[Abnerrs]

We have another hour, right?

Indeed

 

[Devastating]

Day 4 Officialish Lynch Tally

PBC (1) - MQ
Abney (2) - Dy, Deva
Mq (2) - Kcough, Promo
Kcough ()
Dy (2) - Ally, STL
Hayley (0) -
Promo (1) - DVMD
Finn (3) - Kam, Jilary, SOV
BBC (5) - Abney, WZ, Finn, Hayley, Ny

16/18 Voting. 10pm EST Deadline

I unlynched guis/abney a page or 2 back!

Also not liking the BBC lynch, and don't see anything there as far as Finn goes. Though I'm really just not doing well in the feels department at all

lynch MQ, I need to reread her reasoning behind the PBC accusation but wouldn't mind hearing more from her

 

[Abnerrs]

Hmm. You guys all have me rethinking BBC.

At the moment I'm going to stay with it because A. My other person I want to talk can't today and B. My other suspicions didn't hit me as hard today. BBC made me say wtf out loud more than once

 

[dyachei]

I don't think BBC is a wolf.

unlynch abs, lynch promo

 

[Abnerrs]

I don't think BBC is a wolf.

unlynch abs, lynch promo

Yeah honestly this makes me feel better at the moment


Unlynch bbc, Lynch promo

 

[Abnerrs]

Yeah honestly this makes me feel better at the moment


Unlynch bbc, Lynch promo

He ALWAYS gives me feels.

 

[Kam325]

Based on some stuff that's happened I don't think Promo is a wolf, and would rather keep him around and have someone look into him if people are worried. I get the feels, though. Just think it's his style.

Unlynch Finn.

 

[Abnerrs]

Though I'm keeping BBC in the back of my nugget. I do NOT understand the difficulty figuring out the theme on this game. The mechanics? Definitely. The roles? Sure. Not being able to research enough to have a basic knowledge of the 2 influences? No.

 

[Abnerrs]

Based on some stuff that's happened I don't think Promo is a wolf, and would rather keep him around and have someone look into him if people are worried. I get the feels, though. Just think it's his style.

Unlynch Finn.

Yeah that's the problem. He always gives me feels.

Unlynch promo, Lynch bbc

I'll weather whatever happens

 

[Kam325]

Lynch MQ

 

[Devastating]

Though I'm keeping BBC in the back of my nugget. I do NOT understand the difficulty figuring out the theme on this game. The mechanics? Definitely. The roles? Sure. Not being able to research enough to have a basic knowledge of the 2 influences? No.

I was confused t00, but I just can't see it as being some kind of wolf play. ETA: or chaos/neutral/lone-wolf/whatever else we may have

 

[morninqlory]

After reading Kam's claim of receiving a howl from PBC I am inclined to ***unlynch PBC*** for the time being and ***lynch BBC***

 

[allyphoe]

Liking posts is strategy, dead wolf.
@genny

 

[morninqlory]

Additionally, I had the information that PBC was the possible wolf yesterday before genny came out with what she said. I had inquired with the mods if players are lynchable while in The Nether and waited for an answer before deciding if I would say anything. When the mods answered on the thread I decided I was better off waiting until today. I did realize that genny saying that she also thought PBC was the lone wolf would likely raise suspicion upon me but decided I needed to come out with what I thought I knew for the good of the village.

 

[Promethean]

But what if she was a lone wolf?
Finn, are you claiming fill vanillager?

I'm pretty sure that Genny was not a lone wolf. It has been discussed more than a few times that lone wolves usually get another color in the write up. Also, I think that PBC was the "lone wolf" who was mentioned in the write ups.

 

[Kam325]

Oh, btw, I just had time to watch a video that I received with my last night's results.

It seems to be a video of a cockatoo and a blonde ( i think) woman in a cadillac saying "peekaboo" back and forth to each other for over a minute.

I am completely perplexed. If there was supposed to be some meaning behind that it escapes me.

Don't spend any time trying to read into that. It was just me using MJ's ability that got swapped to me last night.

 

[Promethean]

Day 4 Completely unofficial volunteered Lynch Tally

PBC (0) -
Abney (0) -
Mq (4) - Kcough, Promo, Deva, Kam
Kcough ()
Dy (2) - Ally, STL
Hayley (0) -
Promo (2) - DVMD, dy,
Finn (1) Jilary
BBC (6) - WZ, Finn, Hayley, Ny, Abney, MQ

15/18 Voting. 10pm EST Deadline

 

[Abnerrs]

Day 4 Completely unofficial volunteered Lynch Tally

PBC (0) -
Abney (0) -
Mq (4) - Kcough, Promo, Deva, Kam
Kcough ()
Dy (2) - Ally, STL
Hayley (0) -
Promo (3) - DVMD, dy, Abney
Finn (1) Jilary
BBC (6) - WZ, Finn, Hayley, Ny, Abney, MQ

16/18 Voting. 10pm EST Deadline

No I Unlynched you

 

[Promethean]

Ooops, I put Abs 2x

Editing that.

 

[Trilt]

Lynch closed, results pending!

See Promo's tally for final numbers.

 

[genny]

Liking posts is strategy, dead wolf.
@genny

****************
Nothing strategic about it. I liked your post that mentioned things may have turned out different with my lynch if I had been around to defend. I whole-heartedly agree! LIKE!


****************

 

[dyachei]

****************
Nothing strategic about it. I liked your post that mentioned things may have turned out different with my lynch if I had been around to defend. I whole-heartedly agree! LIKE!


****************

If it can affect the decisions of living players, don't do it

 

[WildZoo]

Welp, no way could I have two good luck days in a row, so this lynch was probably bad

 

[Promethean]

Welp, no way could I have two good luck days in a row, so this lynch was probably bad

That is what I'm expecting.

 

[Trilt]

I don't do drugs. I am drugs.​

Sometimes things are not as they seem.

(Take heed of that. There are many hints that have not been noticed).

Take, for example, the humble Silverfish - @BeautifulBritishColumbia. She had done nothing of particular note recently, simply content to stay curled up in her rocky block home and await the end of night each evening. The young man - our protagonist, they said? - was thoroughly perplexed when he found her body while mining. He ran his hands through his close-cropped hair, and looked closely at the tightly coiled body, somewhat surprised. These creatures were fairly rare, and usually lived near one another, but he had found no others around. Hmm.

She had been safe from many of the terrifying (and more benign) actions of the night, but the day managed to do her in.

It is now Night 4. Night will close at 7AM EST, as per normal please try to get actions in during the night.

- - - - ----------------------

---------------------- - - - -

​

OVERWORLD
1. @allyphoe
3. @dyachei
25. @StartingoverVet
5. @SummerTheLynx
6. @Jilary
7. @heyyimhayley
9. @kcoughli
10. @PrincessButterCup
11. @guisantes
12. @morninqlory
13. @DVMDream
14. @nyanko
16. @Kam325
17. @WildZoo
19. @Crayola227
22. @finnickthedog
23. @Promethean
24. @Devastating

NPC: @Ceke2002

THE NETHER

THE END
20. @hazelmoo - Enderman
2. @Zensing - Mooshroom
18. @Mad Jack - Dream Caused by the Flight of a Bee Around a Pomegranate a Second Before Wakening
21. @LadyOtheFarm - Pig
15. @genny - Hunger (The Basket of Bread)
4. @LetItSnow - The Ender Dragon
8. @BeautifulBritishColumbia - Silverfish

 

[Trilt]

(help I'm being eaten by mosquitos and my laptop swarmed by bugs. I hope you appreciate me doing this from a campsite!)

 

[WildZoo]

Well if a Silverfish isn't evil I don't know what is!

 

[Abnerrs]

Fack. That was my fault.

 

[Abnerrs]

Well if a Silverfish isn't evil I don't know what is!

Yeah that's kind of what I was thinking too but it doesn't state otherwise so villager

 

[allyphoe]

Well if a Silverfish isn't evil I don't know what is!

Hunger and lightning?

Silverfish will only swarm you if you mine their houses.

 

[WildZoo]

Hunger and lightning?

Silverfish will only swarm you if you mine their houses.

It was a joke
Also, lightning?

 

[Abnerrs]

IF this wasn't some cracked out game on shrooms I'd say that she was a convert or chaos waiting to happen. But this is Wonderland on extra LSD.

 

[WildZoo]

(I mean the Ender Dragon was a villager so I'm not even seriously considering roles as evidence of anything at this point)

 

[Abnerrs]

(I mean the Ender Dragon was a villager so I'm not even seriously considering roles as evidence of anything at this point)

Fo sho

 

[allyphoe]

It was a joke
Also, lightning?

I read LIS' death as possible lightning. The accompanying crash of thunder scares the life out of me every time, and you can hear it no matter how far down in the mines you are.

 

[WildZoo]

I read LIS' death as possible lightning. The accompanying crash of thunder scares the life out of me every time, and you can hear it no matter how far down in the mines you are.

I don't really read that as lightning. Why would the dude go running out into the woods for that? Sounds like there was a crash in the woods, like the dragon falling and breaking several dozen trees.

 

[Abnerrs]

I don't really read that as lightning. Why would the dude go running out into the woods for that? Sounds like there was a crash in the woods, like the dragon falling and breaking several dozen trees.

This is how I read it as well