I like this idea, but given that Elmer was beaten to death (albeit with his own shotgun), I think it’s more likely that he was a wolf kill.
To follow up on this, really the only person where I feel like the timeline of events is such that I don't see a good argument NOT to yeet them is Random. There were apparent 3p kills every night EXCEPT the night that Random was blocked by the anvils.
So I'm wondering if on N2, Elmer was the one to kill Haunter before he himself was killed? On that night, Cyclops heard gunfire/commotion, and we know that Elmer used a shotgun to kill (since he was the one to likely kill Inspector Gadget). Also, before Elmer was killed, he was desperately trying to get away from a location: "Elmer Fudd fled the third floor of the hotel, paying little attention to how conspicuous he was being, he needed to get away now. He made it to his room, out of breath, and collapsed against the door. He only felt safe for half a moment though..." and we don't technically know the exact times when each were killed either. Though we also don't know the COD of Haunter, because Elmer was probably a wolf kill (he was beaten), Haunter could have been shot, perhaps by Elmer...?
Oh actually, now that I'm re-reading the post for the millionth time, maybe Elmer was trying to kill Cyclops (which is why Cyclops heard the gunfire/commotion in the first place), but someone/something was able to protect Cyclops from the kill, which could also be why Elmer was trying to run away from that location. In this case, there is someone who is able to kill, but it looks like only on even nights (N2 & N4), which is why we didn't see a 3rd kill on N1, and also a 2nd kill on N2.
Kills could be vigilante, as I outlined earlier. Vigilante is very valuable, since it’s basically an extra wolf-vote-free yeet. It would be especially valuable if it had the kill restrictions mammalade points out are possible given the kill pattern we’ve seen. Plus, intentionally yeeting any villager, even if they’re killing other villagers (which, again, we’ve done by vote as well. By the logic you give, we should all give up, stop yeeting, and just wait for wolves to kill us. I’d rather go down fighting than just hand the game to scum
What? That would be so out of character for this group! 🤣
I've been thinking about this comment a lot throughout the day. You're saying you know someone on that list is village but don't want to out them as village, can I ask the reason? By not giving is the information, my noob brain can only see how it harms the village because the villagers are the players at a disadvantage of knowledge. The wolves get to know each other from the start, and presumably the cult knows each other or at the very least the cult leader may know who've they converted. But the villagers don't get to know for certain who is a villager unless information is revealed. So if you claim "X person" is village then you haven't told the wolves or cult anything they don't know, so I assume it shouldn't put a target on them.
WildZoo, did you have to change the font color of each letter individually to get that gradient?? How long did that take you? (or is that and SDN function and I'm dumb)
Haha nah I use a bb code colorizer
Weird theory, but do you think cults can convert the dead? Hear me out...
Oh good, I didn't want to imagine you sitting there for three hours individually selecting the font colors
Shhhhhhhhh
Just because she knows where to find the bb code generator doesn't mean she didn't also waste 3 hours using the gradient slider to pick the prettiest colors
The flower is a weird action. We haven’t seen any actions similar to that before and it doesn’t clearly map to a staple action like blocking, getting info, or protecting. I could see getting a flower marking conversion...
Well there goes my hairbrained ideaWait I’m dumb, the writeup says m935 was converted slightly before death
Does anyone know if cultists are able to know who else is a cultist? Are they able to discuss amongst themselves like I assume wolves are? Does it change from game to game?
No, I haven't gotten any more messages.
That's fair, I can see how confirming someone as village puts a target on them from the cult's perspective. Because I imagine the wolves know each other and don't know anyone else, and the cult might know each other or at least the converter knows who is cult, but the wolves likely don't know who is village vs. cult and the cult probably doesn't know who is village vs. wolf.
I don’t think it matters for them though. The cult wins if they get parity, the wolves win if they get parity. Wolves want to kill cultists just as much as they want to kill villagers and cultists want to convert wolves just as much as they want to convert villagers.
If this mess was created by a seer, M935 was obviously village first so that's where I'm confused. This has to be a chaos character then.
Can cults convert village, 3P, and wolves to cultists? That would make sense, but just wanted to confirm.
Probably not visc because they have been soft confirmed as villager with samac
My mentor says yes
Are you confusing me with kras? I am confused
The last thing is someone visited the then dead body and laid down a white orchid. It's not clear what their intentions for visiting were.
