SDN WW ReneWWed Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members do not see this ad.
smplyvanillasoy said:
Lynch MJ? Just being a lemming. Forgive the delay. I was seeing patients, and also have a sick baby at home.
01538bc9a63dd4e39832f2a205d821ba-gif-of-the-day-cascade-o-lemmings.gif
Click to expand...
Nope, don't lynch MJ. Pick anyone except him.

But I appreciate this lemming gif a whole lot, A for effort on the gif front 😉
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
don't like lynching people when they haven't posted yet. especially noobs. I don't like ceke's rng vote. we have caught too many wolves recently D1 to be rng-ing a vote

lynch ceke
Click to expand...
I like this reasoning. Also. Vanilla soy just checked in and I want the noob to be able to play.

Lynch ceke
 
Who did you seer n1?


what an annoying situation.

role and ability seering; honestly I'd say a more scummy leaning type of seer than village leaning. And KC is a very good wolf, so if that is taken into account at all in role distribution, it fits.

And/but it's an STL game. I frankly just discount affiliation seering in his games after watching people get absolutely screwed over by the amount of false seering that's usually inherent. So I don't really care if someone seers MJ as village. What will determine affiliation are his actions (previous, future) and whether the ****er dies soon enough. ha.
 
Trilt said:
Who did you seer n1?


what an annoying situation.

role and ability seering; honestly I'd say a more scummy leaning type of seer than village leaning. And KC is a very good wolf, so if that is taken into account at all in role distribution, it fits.

And/but it's an STL game. I frankly just discount affiliation seering in his games after watching people get absolutely screwed over by the amount of false seering that's usually inherent. So I don't really care if someone seers MJ as village. What will determine affiliation are his actions (previous, future) and whether the ****er dies soon enough. ha.
Click to expand...
Claimed to have seered me; the result matches up.
 
STL said at the beginning of the game that role names and abilities don't determine affiliation. So honestly my opinion is still neutral on MJ.
 
Trilt said:
Did he justify why you? Had you opened a PM with him prior?

Reasonably village behavior to seer PM partner, although I think the choice of you vs. SOV is a little odd.
Click to expand...
I had opened a PM pretty quickly after the game started, because there were important cat gifs that needed to get exchanged stat.

I'd agree the choice of me is a little weird, but I also don't know if he and SOV have a PM open.
 
Jilary said:
2) I was wolf killed N1 my first game (maybe even first 2 games? I forget), and I was just told "noobs get killed N1, it's just how it is." Someone has to be the first night kill, and someone has to be the first lynch, it's kind of a dick move to do to anyone really. If soybean hasn't at least followed a game before, then maybe lynching her early really isn't the biggest dick move because she can follow along and get a feel for the game that way.
Click to expand...
Ha. I won my first game ever :banana:
 
Also ###lynch nyanko### what even is that name?
 
Trilt said:
Who did you seer n1?


what an annoying situation.

role and ability seering; honestly I'd say a more scummy leaning type of seer than village leaning. And KC is a very good wolf, so if that is taken into account at all in role distribution, it fits.

And/but it's an STL game. I frankly just discount affiliation seering in his games after watching people get absolutely screwed over by the amount of false seering that's usually inherent. So I don't really care if someone seers MJ as village. What will determine affiliation are his actions (previous, future) and whether the ****er dies soon enough. ha.
Click to expand...
I seered pippy night one because they were the only person I was in contact with. I can seer ability OR role, not both. I hate that I feel this much responsibility for a stupid game right now. Mods, can you just close and let me leave in peace, there's no flipping this lynch and I don't want my WW problem to be interfering with my real life right now. I didn't expect this to happen, and I'm sorry to let you guys down.

I swear to god I'm a villager seer guys. That's all I've got.
 
Mad Jack said:
I seered pippy night one because they were the only person I was in contact with. I can seer ability OR role, not both. I hate that I feel this much responsibility for a stupid game right now. Mods, can you just close and let me leave in peace, there's no flipping this lynch and I don't want my WW problem to be interfering with my real life right now. I didn't expect this to happen, and I'm sorry to let you guys down.

I swear to god I'm a villager seer guys. That's all I've got.
Click to expand...


There's a tie right now.
 
Jilary said:
1) I don't know the noob's schedule, so no way for me (or most of us) to know she couldn't check in before now.
2) I was wolf killed N1 my first game (maybe even first 2 games? I forget), and I was just told "noobs get killed N1, it's just how it is." Someone has to be the first night kill, and someone has to be the first lynch, it's kind of a dick move to do to anyone really. If soybean hasn't at least followed a game before, then maybe lynching her early really isn't the biggest dick move because she can follow along and get a feel for the game that way.

I'm not trying to be a jerk, I just have reasons to not want MJ or Kam to get lynched and so I'd rather soybean went of our 3 front runners right now.


You really don't like people posting "PS" do you? Wasn't it you that thought it was super weird/sketchy that I made a PS comment in a post in a recent game?
Click to expand...

This is harsh Jil. I'm giving you major side eye rn.

Trilt said:
There are a whoooole lotta people who I see liking things and not posting.
Click to expand...

Do you mean me? I was just liking all your posts as I caught up, apparently.
 
Unlynch MJ

His role reveal doesn't make him not a wolf, but I'd rather we didn't lynch a claimed village power role day one.
 
Im so excited everyone wants to continue with a terrible idea just to make the wolves have one less decision to make!

That's so sweet of you all!

(side note: are you ****ING KIDDING ME??!!)
 
Im actually really chipper and excited about this! It makes it really easy to know who to lynch next round if they really think this is a good idea!

Simplicity is so wonderful. The world is such a wonderful place and I'm glad I have you all here to teach me about it!
 
I would really appreciate it if people -- yes, this includes you MJ -- would back off my PM partner who is claiming a power role that can be at least partially verified.

But I'm sure he'll get lynched anyways, because all the damn noobs up in here can't see a bad lynch target even when it's hitting them in the face.
 
PippyPony said:
I would really appreciate it if people -- yes, this includes you MJ -- would back off my PM partner who is claiming a power role that can be at least partially verified.

But I'm sure he'll get lynched anyways, because all the damn noobs up in here can't see a bad lynch target even when it's hitting them in the face.
Click to expand...
unlynch mj, lynch ceke because you spoke to my soul
 
unlynch MJ

Lynch Kam

Been absent all day with votes on her and no defense. Kinda sketchy in pms thus far and didn't really give any good reason for being absentee.
 
Day 2 UnOfficial Learning How to Count Lynch Tally

snowy (1) - SOV
AM (1) - Kam
Kam (3) - ny, coop, FB
MJ (4) - kcough, dds, Trilt, PBC
teep () -
dpmd (1) - Haxx
vanilla (2) - trh, Jilary
Haxx (1) - AM
kcough (1) - DocE
trh (1) - teep
BoB () -
PBC (1) - Ceke
Ceke (4) - Pippy, Snowy, cdo, MJ
Pippy (1) - LOTF
ny (1) - Fireman

22/29 vote
 
Last edited:
DocEspana said:
Im actually really chipper and excited about this! It makes it really easy to know who to lynch next round if they really think this is a good idea!

Simplicity is so wonderful. The world is such a wonderful place and I'm glad I have you all here to teach me about it!
Click to expand...
Ugh I need bitter, cynical, and sarcastic DocE back.
 
I was following SOV's (or LIS'? Some dude's) lynch-the-player-who-lynches-themselves rule. But I'll gladly

Unlynch MJ (again)

That's true, if he really wants out of the game he'd be a better wolf kill than lynch. And assuming our protector is paying attention, we don't necessarily have to lose him this early.
 
MJ would be mod-killed for inactivity if it came down to it anyway. I don't understand why people feel like we have to lynch him today or else the game be ruined.
 
All those damn noobs. All of them.

It is absolutely classic for MJ to pitch a fit - often drawing in irl ****, (sorry dude) - like this when he's scum. Like, I could probably go back and find at least five examples. Every time he throws a ridiculously melodramatic temper tantrum, demands early closes, etc yada etc yada. He is claiming a role that is very much not slam bang village, and he's going to be a thorn in the side to interpret the whole game just like he always is.

But because she has ghosted when tied and I'm really not fond of that even after calling her out, let's do an unlynch MJ, lynch Kam.
 
Filly Bay said:
unlynch MJ

Lynch Kam

Been absent all day with votes on her and no defense. Kinda sketchy in pms thus far and didn't really give any good reason for being absentee.
Click to expand...
Can you elaborate on sketchiness in pms? Did she initiate the conversation or did you?
 
Trilt said:
seriously? And didn't it ****ing suck to get killed so quickly?

You never get better if you constantly die early. Don't perpetuate it. And @PippyPony get your friend on here stat.
Click to expand...
Getting killed early your first game isn't the worst thing ever. I followed that game closely and learned a lot, which helped me in the next game where I actually lived to end game. Did it suck in the moment, sure, did I get over it, yup.

PrincessButterCup said:
This is harsh Jil. I'm giving you major side eye rn.
Click to expand...
Why is that harsh? It's what happened to me, and I'm fine. Soybean would likely learn a lot about the game by following it closely and could join in the next game. Personally I find that preferable to losing MJ of Kam at this point.
 
Jilary said:
Why is that harsh? It's what happened to me, and I'm fine. Soybean would likely learn a lot about the game by following it closely and could join in the next game. Personally I find that preferable to losing MJ of Kam at this point.
Click to expand...
Particularly the comment about killing the noob so she can watch instead. Do you know for a fact she's never read a game before? I think it's easier to learn by trying and stumbling along than just sitting back and watching.
 
Coopah said:
Who would you recommend instead of shooting everybody's ideas down?
Click to expand...
Well considering I've justified every lynch I've made... try one of those. 😉

meanwhile we have precisely one legitimate justification among every Ceke vote:
PippyPony said:
******unlynch Teepster******
******Lynch Ceke*******
Click to expand...

SnowshoeDog143 said:
don't like lynching people when they haven't posted yet. especially noobs. I don't like ceke's rng vote. we have caught too many wolves recently D1 to be rng-ing a vote

lynch ceke
Click to expand...

cdoconn said:
I like this reasoning. Also. Vanilla soy just checked in and I want the noob to be able to play.

Lynch ceke
Click to expand...

Mad Jack said:
unlynch mj, lynch ceke because you spoke to my soul
Click to expand...

genny said:
lynch ceke
Click to expand...

smplyvanillasoy said:
okay unlynch MJ and lynch CeKe
Click to expand...

dpmd said:
Hmm, lots of craziness going on right now. Lynch ceke.
Click to expand...

I mean, hey, maybe she'll flip scum and I'll look like a *******. But this is lazy play and I'll grump at people for what I perceive as such.
 
Trilt said:
Ceke picking up on someone being aggressive and accidentally voting for an NPC reaaalllly feels wolfy to people?
Click to expand...

Coopah said:
Who would you recommend instead of shooting everybody's ideas down?
Click to expand...

Agreed with Coop on this. You were also trying to push MJ for what felt like easy go-to reasons, Trilt.

Slight side eye from me for posting things that seem like things you would do, for reasons you would do them, but just jamming the point home a little harder than usual.

Kam or MJ flip wolf, then different story, of course.

EDIT: post now complete with quotes, thanks phone
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
85 86 87 88 89
Replies
4K
Views
45K
supershorty
supershorty
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
54K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
39K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
250
Views
16K
supershorty
supershorty
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
31K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top