Serial/Criminal Minds WW - Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I mean I also worry about the tinfoil possibility of like a "copy cat" or something. Someone who wants to get caught but didn't actually commit the crime.

I mean, unless this would be an exclusive jester, it's not a major concern outside of burning a yeet.

 

[WildZoo]

I voted for the MacAttack. Looks like your tally shows it. But I did get the tag.

Did you ever get BBQ at Dead End while you were here? Because that's the name of a great sandwich there

 

[samac]

My thoughts are similar to most, its becoming like an NAI thing to a degree for alley to give off super pings D1. Im not recommending ignoring them because at some point she will be a wolf, but Im personally going to continue to abstain from voting there at the moment.

I know I was a tot, but in HZD I was in tot chat saying she wasn’t a wolf correctly when everyone else was wolf reading her.

 

[WildZoo]

Has yet to vote: @Melchizedek @BobLoblaw78 @cubsrule4e @genny @Zenge142 @vetschoolsletmeinplease @mkg323

Players pls, vote pls

 

[alleycat03]

I mean I also worry about the tinfoil possibility of like a "copy cat" or something. Someone who wants to get caught but didn't actually commit the crime.

explain gently

 

[alleycat03]

What are you thinking on Zenge now?

Feeling a bit better today but the jury's still out

 

[Zenge142]

explain gently

Jester

 

[alleycat03]

I mean, unless this would be an exclusive jester, it's not a major concern outside of burning a yeet.

Ohhhh Zenge thought I might be jester? I'm not 3P (or a wolf for that matter).

 

[alleycat03]

Jester

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

I’m wondering if she would lean into it and act more wolfy once someone called her out or if she would try to back pedal.

I feel like that woud be a really dangerous game, I'm not sure she would take that risk?

See this is the kind of posts I was looking for. Like actual thoughtful posts with some sustenance. I agree, I am not a wolf. Not sure why everyone is getting pinged by my posts, but whatever. I think this is kind of like Madagascar where I tried to generate discussion early on and then got a ton of sus for it.

But I do not understand her going this hard for zenge based off of not being active when theres only like 24 hrs in the game so far. I understand grasping at straws bc its day 1 but a) she started too early for straw grasping b) this feels like more than straw grasping

 

[samac]

I feel like that woud be a really dangerous game, I'm not sure she would take that risk?

But I do not understand her going this hard for zenge based off of not being active when theres only like 24 hrs in the game so far. I understand grasping at straws bc its day 1 but a) she started too early for straw grasping b) this feels like more than straw grasping

Sure. It’s a WIFOM situation. If you’re called out would you lean into it or back off? What would get the better results? I dunno. I also am self aware enough to know if I get an idea in my head it gets hard for me to shake it without some significant evidence to the contrary cause I’m stubborn.

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

********
I will likely be driving during yeet tonight bc I have a field trip that ends at like 6:30 pm and then I have my gig right after so I'll catch up pretty late!
*********

 

[TelemarketingEnigma]

I mean I also worry about the tinfoil possibility of like a "copy cat" or something. Someone who wants to get caught but didn't actually commit the crime.

yesss join the foil club

I know I was a tot, but in HZD I was in tot chat saying she wasn’t a wolf correctly when everyone else was wolf reading her.

I can't remember if it was HZD or another one but I remember thinking alley was coming out swinging too early in another game and thinking it was wolfy and being wrong. so that's making me hesitant here. I can also see where she's coming from on zenge - i think D1 reads tend to suck, but oddly quiet/not bold early game zenge is one of the things that tipped me off when I caught him wolfing before, and everyone was trying to tell me that was normal for him. His response has felt more villagey than his response last time though.

 

[TelemarketingEnigma]

the lack of content from cray so far is a bit concerning

 

[TelemarketingEnigma]

also does anyone with strong memory for past games have a good example of village!genny? I'd like to compare something

 

[vetschoolsletmeinplease]

also does anyone with strong memory for past games have a good example of village!genny? I'd like to compare something

I don't but I just combed through what shes posted so far and I think what we have so far is completely NAI
Even if you compared it to a village or a wolf genny, it wouldn't tell you much of anything imo

 

[TelemarketingEnigma]

I don't but I just combed through what shes posted so far and I think what we have so far is completely NAI
Even if you compared it to a village or a wolf genny, it wouldn't tell you much of anything imo

I have a specific thing I'm interested in comparing
it is likely the thing is NAI
but I still wanna compare it

 

[alleycat03]

I feel like that woud be a really dangerous game, I'm not sure she would take that risk?

But I do not understand her going this hard for zenge based off of not being active when theres only like 24 hrs in the game so far. I understand grasping at straws bc its day 1 but a) she started too early for straw grasping b) this feels like more than straw grasping

It's not grasping at straws and not based off of him not being active. He is here and he is actively reading the thread, but he was not generating a lot of content himself. It's almost as if he has taken a step back and he is watching the rest of us talk and not actually contributing much himself. I know I have done that in the past as a wolf, so I try to look out for it in other people as the game progresses. Usually Zenge is actively contributing and has unique thoughts. Now I will give him some credit because I have started to see a bit of that in his most recent posts talking about me being TWTBT and his jester theory. Also it is D1 and there is not a lot of stuff to tallk about, but TME and I have both pointed out things that we noticed and what we think are actions that are a bit off, and we have both gotten sus for doing that.

 

[samac]

I have a specific thing I'm interested in comparing
it is likely the thing is NAI
but I still wanna compare it

@Animal Midwife may have a good example.

 

[Animal Midwife]

also does anyone with strong memory for past games have a good example of village!genny? I'd like to compare something

Last game is a good one.

 

[TelemarketingEnigma]

okay, thing reviewed from a few prior genny games. I think it's only very loosely AI but there is a trend that I've noticed in the way she posts. I actually feel a little bit better about her now based on what I looked at BUT I def need to see more before drawing any firm conclusions

 

[mkg323]

Hi until 10 minutes ago I thought the thread wasn’t open

Yeet mkg

feels like it’s been forever since we played together! Welcome back

thanks for the warm welcome! 🤣

 

[samac]

thanks for the warm welcome! 🤣

Oh hello there. Forgot you were here.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Did you ever get BBQ at Dead End while you were here? Because that's the name of a great sandwich there

dont think Ive ever heard of that.

 

[cubsrule4e]

okay, thing reviewed from a few prior genny games. I think it's only very loosely AI but there is a trend that I've noticed in the way she posts. I actually feel a little bit better about her now based on what I looked at BUT I def need to see more before drawing any firm conclusions

This is third full on hedge so far today by you: samac, alley, now genny. It doesnt bother me, because I think a little hedging is required for proper analysis, but pointing out for others who might want to look into it further.

 

[TelemarketingEnigma]

This is third full on hedge so far today by you: samac, alley, now genny. It doesnt bother me, because I think a little hedging is required for proper analysis, but pointing out for others who might want to look into it further.

it's not WW if no one is calling me hedgey

 

[cubsrule4e]

it's not WW if no one is calling me hedgey

I just call it out now when I see it so people cant use it against me when I do it ☺️

 

[genny]

I have a specific thing I'm interested in comparing
it is likely the thing is NAI
but I still wanna compare it

What’s the thing?

 

[cubsrule4e]

What’s the thing?

Its THE thing, genny. Come on now.

 

[genny]

I only pulled three teeth today. I feel like I’m slacking off.

 

[genny]

Its THE thing, genny. Come on now.

Well, now I can’t do it because everyone is watching

 

[mkg323]

Oh hello there. Forgot you were here.

im still catching up, but RUUUUDEEEE

 

[mkg323]

Not offended, Sammy just strikes a cord
Macdaddy, bigmac, sam. Samacasourous-Rex, OUSNAR

FTFY

 

[cubsrule4e]

Well, now I can’t do it because everyone is watching

Dont worry, poor Barks still doesnt know what she didnt do last game.

 

[samac]

FTFY

Fair point
OUSNAR FOREVERRRRRRRRR

 

[mkg323]

also does anyone with strong memory for past games have a good example of village!genny? I'd like to compare something

Bioshock is a good one

 

[mkg323]

feeling ok about Alley and Vissy rn, shocking I know. That being said, the whole 'Zenge is lurking so he must be a wolf' train left the station a couple of games ago. Pleasy hasn't pinged me, not actually sure how to feel about TME and Samac.

 

[Animal Midwife]

feeling ok about Alley and Vissy rn, shocking I know. That being said, the whole 'Zenge is lurking so he must be a wolf' train left the station a couple of games ago. Pleasy hasn't pinged me, not actually sure how to feel about TME and Samac.

What do you mean by the bolded?

 

[BobLoblaw78]

It doesn’t make it a less confusing term though.
I had to read it like 3 times.
Just say suspects, or the perpetrator, or something that makes sense dammit.
Weird ass show.

It's a field term. I know what it means but my brain always wants to make it mean unsubstantiated and kicks out the real definition that I routinely look up.

There's a very thin line separating profiler from killer

Spoiler

Or does profiling and getting in that mindframe make them psychotic???

I like the vslimshady nickname too for pleasy
But wtf is VSLIMBIZKIT

It is VFATBIZKIT after a diet

I’m going to make you like the show by the end of this game 😛

I think I may try to get through some episodes this weekend. If you haven't seen Mindhunter on netflix, it is pretty good and along these lines.

 

[TelemarketingEnigma]

What’s the thing?

wouldn't you like to know!

it has to do with the way you start games but that's all I'll say for now. if I'm right, it's a useful piece of info for me. If I'm wrong then oops. for now it's working in your favor

 

[BobLoblaw78]

Macdaddy for the win. Actually MacAttack is my new preference.

I prefer Samus if I get a vote

sammich

nm. This is better!

What are your thoughts on "Too wolfy to be wolf"?

Because I agree Alley is pinging me. Her initial shading of me for not participating enough less than 50 posts into the game is super off, and subsequent voting for me is... lacking.

I worry though that it's too obvious, and too wolfy, and wonder if Wolf!Alley would be more careful.

Agree. Each game it seems like the pings are increased. Then she gets voted off and flips village. I don't learn lessons well, so I keep thinking that one day I will be right. But honestly don't have the heart to vote here on D1.

I know I was a tot, but in HZD I was in tot chat saying she wasn’t a wolf correctly when everyone else was wolf reading her.

Players pls, vote pls

Sorry. Today has been busy with someone shadowing. I care too much about appearances to jump on and play WW with a shadow.

Jester

the lack of content from cray so far is a bit concerning

I didn't realize she was playing!

also does anyone with strong memory for past games have a good example of village!genny? I'd like to compare something

I feel like she lurks and is less jokey as wolf. But, I used this for last game and I'm still not convinced she wasn't wolfing. lol

 

[BobLoblaw78]

Yeet cray

unsubs have been disproportionately lurking and I'm going here until the trend reverses. Too many village getting sacrificed without added content from wolves to catch them

 

[Viscernable]

I blew all y’all’s minds when I said “Samac” on discord lol

I always pronounced it right!

 

[BobLoblaw78]

Since we are tinfoiling, it would be cool to restrict the wolves to follow a pattern that could be solved by profiling in some manner.

 

[Viscernable]

What are your thoughts on "Too wolfy to be wolf"?

Because I agree Alley is pinging me. Her initial shading of me for not participating enough less than 50 posts into the game is super off, and subsequent voting for me is... lacking.

I worry though that it's too obvious, and too wolfy, and wonder if Wolf!Alley would be more careful.

I feel like it’s the heightened sensitivity we have (or at least I have) to when someone votes or suspects us for reasons that are lacking vs when they do the same to other people. Much like I don’t expect you to be out here solving the game because it’s D1, I don’t expect alley’s suspicions to be well-reasoned and her vote to be based on tons of evidence. She comes out of the gate strong to get discussion started rather than wait for evidence to come before accusing anyone, which I appreciate because it does get the content started. This is what I expect of village alley. I don’t remember wolf alley well, but I associate it more with village alley than wolf alley

 

[Viscernable]

the lack of content from cray so far is a bit concerning

Can you point to when amount of content has been AI for cray?

 

[samac]

Since we are tinfoiling, it would be cool to restrict the wolves to follow a pattern that could be solved by profiling in some manner.

Highly highly doubtful.

 

[Viscernable]

okay, thing reviewed from a few prior genny games. I think it's only very loosely AI but there is a trend that I've noticed in the way she posts. I actually feel a little bit better about her now based on what I looked at BUT I def need to see more before drawing any firm conclusions

I’m interested to see how this works out if you’re sincere about it… would be nice to have someone else who can read genny instead of hoping Dubz does it

 

[Animal Midwife]

I’m interested to see how this works out if you’re sincere about it… would be nice to have someone else who can read genny instead of hoping Dubz does it

okay then

 

[TelemarketingEnigma]

Can you point to when amount of content has been AI for cray?

Not really, I feel like I've been incorrectly concerned about a change in her content (either more, or less, or different style) in the past several games lol. I get the sense some of it may just be related to irl life things, so it's not a smoking gun by any means but I'm still concerned by it. Based on liked posts, she's definitely been lurking more than commenting

I’m interested to see how this works out if you’re sincere about it… would be nice to have someone else who can read genny instead of hoping Dubz does it

I am sincere but I already know that it's by no means 100% definitive, just a general trend that held up decently well for most of the games I reviewed earlier