- Joined
- Jan 23, 2016
- Messages
- 35,493
- Reaction score
- 43,389
No, I usually vote once on D1 and never vote again.i missed this happen, interesting
i don't recall if i've seen an AM waffle like this
No, I usually vote once on D1 and never vote again.i missed this happen, interesting
i don't recall if i've seen an AM waffle like this
ok back to thisi have a comment on this but its not pertinent
placeholder/reminder
Yeah? Why is it interesting?
ok back to this
there's this killer in the series who like TORMENTS the bau, he's kinda one of the only main characters/bad guys (he name Mr.Scratch)
I'm not sure that anyone on the BAU would be a wolf, but i would be a bit surprised if Mr.Scratch wasn't in the game as a wolf
And you'll note neither time I voted for you. This is something easily verifiable.I'm surprised you moved a deciding vote that easily, especially knowing what has happened to me in the last 2 games I made verifiable claims...
I agree with stagg.ok back to this
there's this killer in the series who like TORMENTS the bau, he's kinda one of the only main characters/bad guys (he name Mr.Scratch)
I'm not sure that anyone on the BAU would be a wolf, but i would be a bit surprised if Mr.Scratch wasn't in the game as a wolf
I don't think that's how role names are working in this game, but could be totally wrong...
I'd be surprised if it's just entirely reversed though. There's enough flips and hints on thread that I'm guessing many of us have picked up a pattern and if we ALL fit that pattern, it's just normal villager code but backwards. there is a pattern though.I agree with stagg.
I think this game is designed to **** up preconceived notions.
cover roles. i think it would be game breaking to have village fit a pattern and wolves have named roles with no clue about how to role reveal convincingly.if we ALL fit that pattern
normal villager code
it happens when necessary. like when the rest of the village is sitting on their hands, watching a seer claim like it's no big deal.i missed this happen, interesting
i don't recall if i've seen an AM waffle like this
aw. but i rebutted it.... doesn't that count for something?The phrase villager code has been uttered, causing a mod brain meltdown. Reboot will take approximately long enough for everyone to get twitchy about the lack of writeup, plus 5 more minutes. What a shame.
What if we all said we're twitchy now?The phrase villager code has been uttered, causing a mod brain meltdown. Reboot will take approximately long enough for everyone to get twitchy about the lack of writeup, plus 5 more minutes. What a shame.
i've been twitchy for hours, but i think that's a whole separate issue.What if we all said we're twitchy now?
that was my whole point! 🙁aw. but i rebutted it.... doesn't that count for something?
it happens when necessary. like when the rest of the village is sitting on their hands, watching a seer claim like it's no big deal.
Just kidding, my brain was already melting down, I was just making a point.aw. but i rebutted it.... doesn't that count for something?
There’s a difference between hypocritical reads and possible slip ups, though. I don’t have a problem with any and all hypocritical reads because you can realize that something you’re doing is something wolves are more likely to do (e.g. ghosting and giving little to no reasoning), but have your own reasons for doing it (e.g. cleaning up toddler vomit), and obviously know that you’re a villager so not be suspicious of yourself but be suspicious of others who are doing itIt essentially boils down to "villagers don't care about looking sketchy and will call out other people for seemingly hypocritical reasons"
But chasing down hypocritical reads and possible slip ups is what villagers do and its weird that cray is saying VSLMIP is pinging for doing the village thing.
STOP LEAVING THEM AT WORKJust kidding, my brain was already melting down, I was just making a point.
Placeholder writeup incoming because it turns out I'm out of spoons
no thank you. i'm happily botulism free!i can give everyone botox to stop the twitching incidents. Not sure how to get the write up back though.
Omg this works on so many levelsSTOP LEAVING THEM AT WORK
i didn't say he was a genius, i said he claimed to be a seer.A seer who somehow didnt think to self-prez? Seems a little...irresponsible? 🤔
perhaps a nice dose of gabapentin then?no thank you. i'm happily botulism free!
oh i actually have that. for my hellcat.perhaps a nice dose of gabapentin then?
Just double or quadruple or something the dose and youre good to go!oh i actually have that. for my hellcat.
He objectively did, as I quoted.He didn’t move last second onto a villager wagon.
and?I did.
Started as low post. Bad D1. Has a carefree tone that doesn’t align as villageWhat made you choose Stagg?
uh.... no. hellcat gets 300mg. my brother takes way less than that for his neuropathic pain.Just double or quadruple or something the dose and youre good to go!
Posts today did seem better. I said your posts seemed to be carefree up to a point you started posting more that made me feel you werent village aligned.I don't believe in this, wolves can do anything and good ones will.
You serious? Have you read any of my posts today?
And since when is asking for more of a justification of your vote reaching for low-hanging fruit? You previously posted a giant hedgey list of everyone that gave minimal explanation and when I asked why I was your top pick your response was "Feels". You really going to try and argue that's manufactured shade and that I'm not trying to hunt wolves?
Going all the way up to TID with that isnt uncommon.uh.... no. hellcat gets 300mg. my brother takes way less than that for his neuropathic pain.
I don’t remember much of mkg but their play seemed fairly good to me.Not super feeling Stagg and even if I was, it would be tough for me to vote with Bob and mkg rn lol
I’ll be honest, this reads to me like “here’s somewhere that he didn’t explain his logic. Wolfy” and “here’s somewhere he did explain his logic in more detail, I’ll give a village point to make it clear I’m being Fair and Balanced”. The fact that the villagest thing found (his reasoning on voting Cray over “considering him and Bob in a pack” (did not happen. Twisting her words) and “inconsistent reasoning” (like I said in another post, I don’t see it as logically inconsistent at all, so could also be twisting)) is, to me, the main point against him being village makes it hard for me to see this ISO as sincere. I’m keeping in mind that confirmation bias might be colouring how I’m reading it, though.yay mel iso
the search function is being weird so I need to do it the old fashioned, ctrl+f way
about TME:
So these were the like actual game posts he had made until this point (below) and other posts were just joking
So this initially jumped out to me as weird, bc mel had mentioned several other people, not cray among them, who he found sus
(the above was in response to visc asking why I had sketch points, hedginess is my most common critique lol)
So in reference to a couple of posts above, he was giving alley a D1 pass which I appreciate. But had still had yet to explain the cray vote
and then i felt weird about the logic of this one. cites tin foil and kinda leaves it at that, but I feel like that's a weird thing to do?
Then this was the thing that really put a bad taste in my mouth. There was other stuff going on on the thread, mel felt weird about other people who had been here, then votes and stick to a vote for someone who came on and said hey i know im not here but this is why
but at this point she had literally said she wouldn't be back until after yeet so like...... whyyy continue to vote her when you felt sus for people who were actually on the thread at the time and could interact with you? it feels like a staying out of the wagon and tie fray strategy to me
and then nothing i found that mel said out loud that floated cray from a vote the day before to in the neutral part of the reads list?
in response to why bob is wolfy
then there's a series of posts tagging people and asking them their various opinions on things, which can be an easy way to look busy
to be fair with this list, there isn't any like crazy amount of movement which gives mel a village point
and then cray slipped back down as the lists went on. I don't love that there's no like explanations behind these lists (which I know isn't everyone's style just bc its mine) or more listed out loud logic
logic behind today's cray vote
and this logic is actually decent to me, so another village point (not that I agree, but I can see this coming from a villager)
again, could be staying out of the wagon and tie fray
further explaining the cray post, which i appreciate
but that's not really what I'm doing? I'm sus'in you over your vote of a different player
but then votes me, which is different from what was said with the cray vote, and then says two other people who he didn't mention as possible other votes in the cray vote?
so my vote on mel boils down to
-really not liking the vote on cray yesterday
-not being able to follow how people move on the reads list very well, and then voting posts that contradict eachother
You seem to press me more when I’m not voting early. When I’m absent you seem to be pushing more quickly. I have been away for longer periods this game and I expect AM posts pushing me when I get on. I haven’t seen it as much as it seems you normally do. My replies have had less replies from you and less getting the last wordWhat exactly are you wolf reading me off of? I see you citing mkg but even she's not voting me today.
You seem to press me more when I’m not voting early. When I’m absent you seem to be pushing more quickly. I have been away for longer periods this game and I expect AM posts pushing me when I get on. I haven’t seen it as much as it seems you normally do. My replies have had less replies from you and less getting the last word
What?You seem to press me more when I’m not voting early. When I’m absent you seem to be pushing more quickly. I have been away for longer periods this game and I expect AM posts pushing me when I get on. I haven’t seen it as much as it seems you normally do. My replies have had less replies from you and less getting the last word
Certain players don’t stick out to me. When I made my list, I had TME in the middle. Or neutral. When I went back and looked at D1, TME looked way worse. I should’ve had TME lower on my listI
I’m having trouble understanding this paragraph, sorry, can you rephrase?
Full quote please and please include the full quote plus surrounding sentences. If you can’t do it then I’m going to assume you are creating a false narrative. If you don’t find that in the quote, will you kindly explain why you are creating a false narrative? I hope you can bc otherwise I would have to add another to your false statementsYou just told me you never vote early.
Huh?What?
What has happened???I'm surprised you moved a deciding vote that easily, especially knowing what has happened to me in the last 2 games I made verifiable claims...
I was literally trying to get you to vote earlier this cycle.Huh?
Cubs has bad look for 4 way tie comment. For saying it was joke when clearly not. And a third reason I would have to look back to remember. Then him saying I always vote early when I’ve been notorious for voting late seems like blatant lie/misinformation.
So if Mel has Cubs as number one villager, he must know something. I’d leave it at that. Or he is packmate.
I said this a day (or two) ago with my “tinfoil”. I have actually been trying to work through this game from write up standpoint and “mechanics” standpoint. Bc I assume there is some clues and crime solving to be done with this theme. I think a lot has been laughed off but I’m looking for what I can. And thank goodness bc people seem erratic this game and harder to read. I also feel like I’ve been finding good points on posts but they seem to not cause a blip on others radar.I'd be surprised if it's just entirely reversed though. There's enough flips and hints on thread that I'm guessing many of us have picked up a pattern and if we ALL fit that pattern, it's just normal villager code but backwards. there is a pattern though.
As much as what you normally do. You did some. Then less. Then some more. I held off saying bc I wanted to assess it.I was literally trying to get you to vote earlier this cycle.
*********************Where's @supershorty when you need some language-grammar interpretation assistance!
It's still the same cycle bro.As much as what you normally do. You did some. Then less. Then some more. I held off saying bc I wanted to assess it.
You just told me you never vote early.
You just told AM "you seem to press me more when im not voting early." Thereby implying that fact that you do vote early, after saying above that you notoriously vote late.
uh.... no. hellcat gets 300mg. my brother takes way less than that for his neuropathic pain.