Smash Bros WW Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
allieh8607 said:
The voice in my head has some thoughts about Skim-

This is what I'm seeing on the almost pbc lynch. Doesn't make sense as moose had a soft vouch from genny. Yet skim was willing to trust jboo's role. And she doesn't even mention pbc. This is at the start of the swing to pbc
Click to expand...
Why should she have mentioned PBC? Was she specifically asked about her?
allieh8607 said:
and then there's this. Doesn't go back to her moose vote and still doesn't mention pbc
Click to expand...
People can waffle to whoever they want, and don't have to mention other people if they don't have thoughts about them (I guess unless specifically asked?).

allieh8607 said:
Then after bryndy's shot, she makes this comment but doesn't really try to swing it to am who she is on. Her only other comment after the shot was to stagg about needing to stop tunneling dvmd's hydra comment
Click to expand...
She made the comment, what more was she expected to do? I don't think I fought hard to get people to switch off bryn. Hell the evidence was right there on thread, what more should the rest of us have done?

allieh8607 said:
she has time to post this and another post but doesn't do much else. Why not try and get some questions answered and keep the conversation going? She was around later
Click to expand...
Why not play a different way and fuel more conversation yesterday? That statement could be said about literally everyone who posted yesterday.

Everything I read in this post sounds like "I don't like the way she is playing" not "I think she is sketchy." Maybe semantics, but all of the "complaints" feel like things a lot of people have been/are doing.

Didn't like this post or the analysis. Feels like fishing. May be biased for agreeing with a lot of Skimblejil's posts previously but I'm not seeing the smoke here.

Edited for formatting.
 
Unofficial 😴 D6 Lynch Tally

am (1) - kcough
ny (1) - pippy
skim (3) - am, dubz, paws
pippy (1) - dvmd
dubz? (1?) - dvmd?
Cray (2) - Mel, bryndy
bryndy (1) - genny

9/19

Deadline ~4 hours (9pm central/ 10pm eastern)
 
kcoughli said:
She made the comment, what more was she expected to do? I don't think I fought hard to get people to switch off bryn. Hell the evidence was right there on thread, what more should the rest of us have done?
Click to expand...
Eh that point in particular I really agree with, the timing of the post was 5 minutes before lynch close, and it felt oddly placed as more of a "wow you guys dun goofed" than an actual attempt to do anything about the lynch. I dunno. I'm used to skim being on the passionate side of things and really would have expected her to comment earlier if she felt that strongly about it.

The other stuff I could see (looking back PBC only had one vote and maybe two people had mentioned her at the time skim voted that day).

I still think she's been very, very narrow in her focus and following along with the crowd, at this point in the game I'd expect to see more substance from her
 
bryndiana.jones said:
From Pippy:

"- I am pissed that I am silenced because I was under the impression the silencer was probably village, and I don't know why they would silence me. Just don't use it. This is a heavy silence ability. It is for a full day and night cycle and I can't even touch the thread at all, not even to like posts. And one of my 2 PM partners has a posting restriction today.

- I want to lynch Jil since I brought up this damn line of inquiry in the first place and now other people are saying what I wanted to say, but I don't totally love that she already has 3 votes. It looks like people are going to go for a wagon on her if this keeps current momentum...I guess I'm not sure that wagon would be wrong. But I do think we should also talk about other people today since yesterday was pretty shot after the BBC info came out, rather than all piling on one person together."
Click to expand...

Can you have Pippy double check to make sure the silencing is, indeed, for the entire day and night cycle?
 
allieh8607 said:
The voice in my head has some thoughts about Skim-


This is what I'm seeing on the almost pbc lynch. Doesn't make sense as moose had a soft vouch from genny. Yet skim was willing to trust jboo's role. And she doesn't even mention pbc. This is at the start of the swing to pbc


and then there's this. Doesn't go back to her moose vote and still doesn't mention pbc


Then after bryndy's shot, she makes this comment but doesn't really try to swing it to am who she is on. Her only other comment after the shot was to stagg about needing to stop tunneling dvmd's hydra comment


she has time to post this and another post but doesn't do much else. Why not try and get some questions answered and keep the conversation going? She was around later
Click to expand...
I really didn’t care about the soft couch from genny and PBC wasn’t on my radar, so why would I mention her?

As far as the bj comment, I was honestly surprised I needed to say anything at all. I’m still baffled why you and so many others stayed on that lynch, speaking of, have you ever explained why you stayed on that very obviously bad lynch?
MixedAnimals77 said:
I do agree that some of skim's stuff has been sketchy and could go there particularly her as usual lynch BBC comment. However I would most like to hear more from @SARdoghandler they've been relatively quiet.
Glam now bryn was making alot of sense which kinda makes me wonder actual logic or wolf going well duh to village.
Did I miss it? Did we ever figure out why WZ was also with moose and BBC?
Click to expand...
What do you mean by “usual lynch bbc”? If you meant my lynch vote for her yesterday, sorry but everything came out prior to me checking in and well it was pretty obvious who to vote for at that point.

Sorry guys, I haven’t been playing well. I’m honestly a lot busier than I thought I’d be. I don’t even know when night and day closing is. I would have asked for a sub, but after the comment from the mods the other day, I figured I was at least good for village numbers. I understand why some of your are lynching me as I’ve really not partipated as much as I normally do. You will just be lynching a villager though.
 
LadyOtheFarm said:
This quote was in reference to PMing? And Skimble was Jil? I think I mentioned my experience with Jil and PMing...
The thing above has been driving me crazy since the first hour I took over. I have little things reminding me of wolf Jil... but nothing that makes me sure.
Click to expand...
So the reason I ask was you two were the first ones to discuss silencer being a village ability. If you had specifics regarding who was silencer and why you thought they were village, that'd be helpful for me but if you aren't automatically figuring why it would be then I'm probably wrong 😛

LadyOtheFarm said:
Did you die?

Seriously tho. What happened? Spill.
Click to expand...

Definitely dead right now :depressed:

Remember what my role is?
 
Skimble said:
I really didn’t care about the soft couch from genny and PBC wasn’t on my radar, so why would I mention her?

As far as the bj comment, I was honestly surprised I needed to say anything at all. I’m still baffled why you and so many others stayed on that lynch, speaking of, have you ever explained why you stayed on that very obviously bad lynch?

What do you mean by “usual lynch bbc”? If you meant my lynch vote for her yesterday, sorry but everything came out prior to me checking in and well it was pretty obvious who to vote for at that point.

Sorry guys, I haven’t been playing well. I’m honestly a lot busier than I thought I’d be. I don’t even know when night and day closing is. I would have asked for a sub, but after the comment from the mods the other day, I figured I was at least good for village numbers. I understand why some of your are lynching me as I’ve really not partipated as much as I normally do. You will just be lynching a villager though.
Click to expand...

Who should we be looking at instead?
 
LadyOtheFarm said:
Amuse me.
I actually fell asleep.

Wanna play a game?
Click to expand...
tenor.gif
 
Animal Midwife said:
Can you have Pippy double check to make sure the silencing is, indeed, for the entire day and night cycle?
Click to expand...
Pippy said:

"That is what my pm from the mods said. I am "very sleepy" --> no activity on the thread at all -- posting or likes -- for one day and night cycle. I am obviously allowed to PM.

You can also tell AM that if she lynches me when I can't defend myself then she is dead to me. Just in case that crossed her mind."
 
Skimble said:
As far as the bj comment, I was honestly surprised I needed to say anything at all. I’m still baffled why you and so many others stayed on that lynch, speaking of, have you ever explained why you stayed on that very obviously bad lynch?
Click to expand...

Which obviously very bad lynch? The bryndi lynch? Because we (KB and I, but I guess at that time is was still RL & KB) were on Moose at that time, not bryndi.
 
Okay, so Pippy is, literally, the only silenced player is this game. Is there evidence for the post restrictor/silencer not being the same person?
 
Animal Midwife said:
Okay, so Pippy is, literally, the only silenced player is this game. Is there evidence for the post restrictor/silencer not being the same person?
Click to expand...
Yes

Edit: also, BBC was silenced and I'm pretty sure (not 100%) that it was real
 
WildZoo said:
For sure like "AM thinks so but is gonna state it like it's a fact" or for sure like "There is actual game evidence of such"
Click to expand...

I'm just running by BBC's silencing versus Pippy's silencing. There's inconsistencies.
 
Animal Midwife said:
I'm just running by BBC's silencing versus Pippy's silencing. There's inconsistencies.
Click to expand...
I can't explain that inconsistency (BBC's silencing was more consistent with what I expected actually, if I'm remembering correctly that it was lifted at the end of the day), but if you're chasing down the silencer you're barking up the wrong tree. Like I said, pretty sure BBC's silencing was real, and guarantee the silencer is village.
 
WildZoo said:
I can't explain that inconsistency (BBC's silencing was more consistent with what I expected actually, if I'm remembering correctly that it was lifted at the end of the day), but if you're chasing down the silencer you're barking up the wrong tree. Like I said, pretty sure BBC's silencing was real, and guarantee the silencer is village.
Click to expand...

If the silencer didn't actually target Pippy they'd speak up, right?
 
bryndiana.jones said:
You can also tell AM that if she lynches me when I can't defend myself then she is dead to me. Just in case that crossed her mind."
Click to expand...
Something in here sounds fishy to me. Anybody see a message being passed? I isolated the 2nd half since that is what set off my spider senses, but I suppose I shouldn't rule out the first half.
 
LadyOtheFarm said:
Something in here sounds fishy to me. Anybody see a message being passed? I isolated the 2nd half since that is what set off my spider senses, but I suppose I shouldn't rule out the first half.
Click to expand...
I didn't see anything that looked like code lol
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
Lynch Skimble

Cause my theory it would seem doesn't pan out
Click to expand...
What theory?
allieh8607 said:
Which obviously very bad lynch? The bryndi lynch? Because we (KB and I, but I guess at that time is was still RL & KB) were on Moose at that time, not bryndi.
Click to expand...
I was referring to Am, not you being on the bad bj lynch.
Animal Midwife said:
I'm just running by BBC's silencing versus Pippy's silencing. There's inconsistencies.
Click to expand...
What are the inconsistencies?
Animal Midwife said:
Who else?
Click to expand...
I honestly don’t know. Clearly not coffee or pip. The rez’d players are currently lower on my list too (Mixy and cray?) I’m curious why you didn’t answer my question that I directed towards you.
 
Skimble said:
What are the inconsistencies?
Click to expand...

Take a look back at the day I was asking BBC for her reads.

Skimble said:
I honestly don’t know. Clearly not coffee or pip. The rez’d players are currently lower on my list too (Mixy and cray?) I’m curious why you didn’t answer my question that I directed towards you.
Click to expand...

Why not Coffee? or Pippy? Why are the rezzed players lower? And it's interesting that you haven't reevaluated me and straight up ignored my question yesterday. What question did I miss?
 
I can't talk myself out of it and she is sitting closer to wuff than village. Even the busy claim to avoid defending.

Lynch Skimble
 
I agree Cray is too quiet.

AM still weirds me out.

Zen didn't seem right while playing before but I blamed that on me having not played for a bit. I feel like Bryn has a slightly calmer tone now, but the thread has been quiet too.

I wanna lynch anybody that has been pretty much silent through this point.

And if DVMD is not amusing, we should kill anything that isn't village and WZ turning away from that seems weird.

There. That is my thoughts. I go put kids to bed now.
 
LadyOtheFarm said:
I agree Cray is too quiet.

AM still weirds me out.

Zen didn't seem right while playing before but I blamed that on me having not played for a bit. I feel like Bryn has a slightly calmer tone now, but the thread has been quiet too.

I wanna lynch anybody that has been pretty much silent through this point.

And if DVMD is not amusing, we should kill anything that isn't village and WZ turning away from that seems weird.

There. That is my thoughts. I go put kids to bed now.
Click to expand...
How do you feel about Ny?
 
I saw people looking for thoughts from me today, so I'll attempt to provide some. I play a very loose game so honestly most of my play is based on feels. I've been getting on so scattered through the day that when I catch up, all the questions I've wanted to ask as I read are already asked. So apologies that I've not been playing well this time around - I do much better when I can low level lurk through the day.

I've tried to arrange people I feel are village vs people I feel are wolf, with some reasons for wolfs. No consideration given to converts at this time, though I can appreciate the arguments made to keep an eye on Cray. I agree that lately they've seemed somewhat more absent.

AM, Pippy, Coffee, Mel, Dubz are my more-village feels right now. This is why I keep saying I'm not feeling an AM lynch

Slight village lean on lotf, genny, and stagg.

I keep forgetting dolphin is playing (sorry dolphin) and I feel like that is a bit out of character for them? Makes me eh a bit but the same could be said for me.

Nyanko could just be normal villager busy self. But also good at this as a wolf from what I have seen and heard.

DVMD is an egg that needs cracking. I would rather not keep her around for the lulz like it seems a lot want to. I think this is more just that she is liked, but not overly helpful for village.

Arguments have been made against paws and skimble. I don't really have them either way on my sheet, which surprises me because I think I pegged paws as village lean like d1 and every day thereafter lastgame (though I could be thinking of someone else). So thinking back how she's another player I've almost forgotten... Could get behind that. Can see the arguments for Skimble too, but don't really have anything to add.

Anyone else I didnt mention I don't have good reads on. I'd be willing to go for anyone outside of my village reads at this point.

Eta: sorry for all the tags in the original post. I quoted the roster to help me organize my thoughts and forgot it at the bottom. Oops 😳

Eta2: forgot genny, added in at slight village lean
​
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
19 20 21 22 23
Replies
1K
Views
10K
_rae_
_rae_
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
52K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
197
Views
12K
katiemcat
katiemcat
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
31K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top