Star WWars III Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Does anyone else feel like LoTF is being kinda quiet? Maybe that's her play style, but it's something that I noticed...those of you who have played more games with her would know better maybe...
 
Does anyone else feel like LoTF is being kinda quiet? Maybe that's her play style, but it's something that I noticed...those of you who have played more games with her would know better maybe...
She is sometimes quiet until the evening when she can actually get on thread. She's been pretty talkative in PM but I can't chat with her anymore since I got moved.
 
I know we've only caught 2 wolves so not terribly much to go on when looking back at lynches but I find it interesting that both wolves we caught were not on the ceke lynch at the end.

Some of my thoughts

3m: I had a pm until she was moved and it pretty much echoed how she has posted. Seemed more like fishing for my thoughts than posing any thoughts of her own. More in my weak category

genny: has reminded me of how she played when we were trying to get her lynched in immuno but I don't know if that is just how she plays. And what VMH outlined


fb: yes, she might have not had internet access this weekend but that was also said in the immuno game. She's had some late votes and even though she thought she was breaking a tie towards BBC that could have been a great thing to do as a wolf - especially knowing BBC had a kill avoidance. Plus cyndia mentioned using a tracking item on Genny who visited FB but on thread when asked, FB said nothing weird happened that night

LOL Seriously, can you really blame me for not wanting to share things with you? You were a wolf in the only two other games I've played in!
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
So going back to VMH original points I agree Genny is super sketchy, but I would worry about a LIS conversion. He is the strongest villager aligned right now so it would make sense to convert him. I don't want to go after converts until after all original wolves have been caught, but I thought I'd throw that out there for consideration. Anyways,

Lynch Genny
 
The most obvious conversion target in the game is LIS since he's so strongly played town so far (and Jilary would be another good one). But we still have enough originals out there that we can sit on converts for awhile IMO. I just wouldn't take vouching from suspected converts quite as seriously at this point.
 
What were you blocked by on N3? On my spreadsheet I have all blocks accounted for already, so I'm double checking this.

I wasn't blocked by a wolf, I was detained by the imperial prison for a night. Both my own actions and actions that others took on me were blocked.

I'm going to laugh so hard if genny is a wolf :laugh: lynch genny
 
It wasn't fake. He legit posted a wolf pm on the thread. :laugh:
Lmaooo... I'm sad I missed that game. :laugh: Okay nevermind, scratch what I said, guess it is possible haha.

Does anyone else feel like LoTF is being kinda quiet? Maybe that's her play style, but it's something that I noticed...those of you who have played more games with her would know better maybe...

She's been pretty active in pms with me, and nothing she's said to me has set off any red flags.
 
So I'm definitely in agreement that a conversion could be likely since the wolves have lost some of their numbers so far but - can we also find out who was blocked last night?

****lynch genny**** for reasons I listed before. I did find out there is likely a silencing ability in the game, so I'm wondering if she was silenced yesterday, but regardless I know the intended target of today's silencing and it's not her, so she should be able to respond. I'd also like to echo caia's question of why the heck genny wasn't blocked last night...
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
hmoo what do you mean by this?

I thought she was a wolf and voted for her yesterday, but that was before we got the info for teep. I was worried that me not voting for teep before I voted for genny would make me look like a wolf, BUT if genny turns up wolf today I'm pretty damn sure people won't think I'm sketchy anymore. So I'm hoping she flips wolf :laugh:
 
I thought she was a wolf and voted for her yesterday, but that was before we got the info for teep. I was worried that me not voting for teep before I voted for genny would make me look like a wolf, BUT if genny turns up wolf today I'm pretty damn sure people won't think I'm sketchy anymore. So I'm hoping she flips wolf :laugh:
Oh! Okay! Yeah I remember that now. Yeah with genny, I'm suspicious, but so much of it is feels. I've gotta re read her posts and check my spreadsheet before solidifying my suspicions
 
Interesting that Jabba didn't pick Genny, given we were pretty clear yesterday as a group that that's where we were heading today. Assuming, of course, based on earlier bounties that it doesn't seem to just be random players.

Lynch Genny

Yeah I find this weird too.. Possibility Genny is Jabba? But if she is a wolf it's weird Jabba wouldn't put her up for bounty because yesterday we'd all said we were going to vote her today.

Based on all the conversation yesterday. And the feeling she is playing a lot like in the immuno game.

Lynch Genny
 
Soooo...conversion?

possibly? They don't have the ability to kill and convert in the same night anymore

That's exactly why I think a wolf would visit someone. To convert them.

Why do you think so little of yourself and FB? 😉 But seriously, if they had the ability to kill and convert in the same night until yesterday, then why wouldn't they have been converting people all along? And choosing a conversion last night versus a kill would help boost their numbers after the past 2 days.
Sent from my Nexus 5X using SDN mobile

Agreed regarding Genny.

But if Genny flips wolf, Caia does move to the possible-wolf list. Now that the wolves lost their "convert+kill same night" player, it stands to reason they have to give up a night kill to convert. And since there was no kill last night with Genny visiting Caia, it's not a stretch to think conversion.

There's time to tease it out, though. Presumably we still have seering..... I don't like lynching people because they "might" be converted, unless they are acting sketchy. And so far Caia is strong village, I think.
I have heard that there HAS been a conversion last night, but that there hadn't been any before last night.
 
Please explain to me why you think a wolf would visit another wolf.

Unless she was doing the converting, she wouldn't be and I really doubt the wolves would have blown their conversion load so early on FB and I.
If genny is the converter, it totally makes sense that she would use it last night since so many of us voiced suspicion about her yesterday.

Lynch genny
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Everyone has brought up good points about genny that I agree with after reading back over the last day or so.

###lynch genny###
 
What were you blocked by on N3? On my spreadsheet I have all blocks accounted for already, so I'm double checking this.
All blocks? Blocking mechanisms I have heard of include a wookiee, the ale, and now supposedly an imperial prison. Not everyone I assume mentions that they were blocked when they were.

...care to elaborate on where you heard that info?
Could be construed as fishing for information or power roles. Could be construed as wolfy behavior. Bringing it to your attention.

How would anyone know this? How could anyone KNOW there hasn't been a conversion until this point?
See comment above re: PippyPony.

What to know someone was converted? They're the ones doing the conversion so they would already know, I'm clearly missing your point.
Pretty sure that was her point. As in, wolves would know about conversions automagically.
 
What to know someone was converted? They're the ones doing the conversion so they would already know, I'm clearly missing your point.
Yeah that was my point. Sure maybe someone has some special ability...or they could actually be a wolf...
 
Yeah, a wolf could definitely claim that as an ability in an attempt to "provide info" while not providing that useful of information - I think most of us assume that there was a conversion last night.

I was just saying according to my source, the first conversion of the game was last night. People last night were wondering if Teep had converted anyone while he was still alive and had the ability to allow conversions and kills on the same night.
 
I was just saying according to my source, the first conversion of the game was last night. People last night were wondering if Teep had converted anyone while he was still alive and had the ability to allow conversions and kills on the same night.

What made said source tell you this? I feel like revealing roles is risky...?
 
That's exactly why I think a wolf would visit someone. To convert them.



Why do you think so little of yourself and FB? 😉 But seriously, if they had the ability to kill and convert in the same night until yesterday, then why wouldn't they have been converting people all along? And choosing a conversion last night versus a kill would help boost their numbers after the past 2 days.

I'm sticking with my vote unless vmh, LIS, or anyone else who I think is very villagery has any compelling arguments otherwise.


Sent from my Nexus 5X using SDN mobile

I don't think little of us. They don't typically get to convert as many times as they want. It's limited in number and sometimes have time restrictions.

And she would be fishing as a seer too, less people you have to seer the better.

Anyway, not like I can't be seered if people are concerned.
 
Last edited:
any chance your source knows who or is that out of the scope of their ability?
This is usually way too much for a mod to want to give away. This is the same reason why "ask a mod" items usually don't allow you to ask for a list of wolves. Game balance has to be considered and mods generally want to give the wolves at least a snowball's chance in hell.
What made said source tell you this? I feel like revealing roles is risky...?
Role revealing can be risky or it can't be, depends on the role, the confidence in the person you reveal to, and the importance of information shared/reason for revealing. I've role revealed to a few people in my old group already. May reveal to a few people in the new group soon. Risky isn't always bad and sometimes you have to take a measured risk for the sake of the village. Not always, but sometimes.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I don't think little of us. They don't typically get to convert as many times as they want. It's limited in number and sometimes have time restrictions.

And she would be fishing as a seer too, less people you have to seer the better.

Anyway, not like I can't be seered if people are concerned.
why is the post you quoted attributed to LIS? It was a PippyPony post................. 😵