StardeWW 2: Ginger Island - GAME THREAD

[potentialsheltervet]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

@alleycat03 Who'd you guard last night?

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Okay then later we discussed order of operations for protection and bodyguarding. That was still before alley revealed.

The alley revealed and samac was like "yup there's the bodyguard".

Samac thought the lightning rods in that writeup were referring to the protection. I'm not so sure about that, idk.

I think it just reads as flavor.

 

[WildZoo]

@alleycat03 Who'd you guard last night?

No pls

 

[WildZoo]

On the off chance alley is village and survives the day I don't much care for wolves to know whomst is unable to be guarded tonight (if things work as usual and it can't be used consecutively...this is also not something alley should confirm).

I don't think knowing her target will help us evaluate her either.

 

[Jagged Jimmy Jay]

Something to ponder. If Clem was killed at least in part to avoid protection, that’d suggest town has protection (not mafia). That alone may work in alley’s favor.

I acknowledge that there’s wifom in that. But we must make a judgment.

 

[genny]

Something to ponder. If Clem was killed at least in part to avoid protection, that’d suggest town has protection (not mafia). That alone may work in alley’s favor.

I acknowledge that there’s wifom in that. But we must make a judgment.

Why would wolves try to avoid killing alley? i think it looks better for Barks.

 

[Stagg737]

I'm going to hang from the ceiling, so get all your waffles out of your system now or something

As a psychiatrist reading this I get super worried for about 0.5 seconds until I remember you do aereal stuff, lol.

The sword was an item available in the shop. It did not kill me but it did injure me and impact me. Whoever used it knows what it did to me. Regardless, it did not kill me and I was not stabbed while bodyguarding. The way my night results are written, they are completely separate events.

You're sure it was the sword from the shop? If so, I'm curious what its effects would be an who used it, as that could potentially carry significant village cred. I'm not asking you or whoever used it to reveal at this point, but definitely something to consider.

 

[WildZoo]

Something to ponder. If Clem was killed at least in part to avoid protection, that’d suggest town has protection (not mafia). That alone may work in alley’s favor.

I acknowledge that there’s wifom in that. But we must make a judgment.

Yes though I think it only indicates town has at least one form of protection, not necessarily two. And they might have thought Barks was lying about not being a protector, or at least could use it again.

 

[WildZoo]

It is a lot of WIFOM though

Which truly might have been the entire point

 

[potentialsheltervet]

No pls

Oh. I didn't realize we'd established that rule applied in this game. Fine.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

It is a lot of WIFOM though

Which truly might have been the entire point

Which points away from Stagg, I guess, given the earlier discussion lol

 

[WildZoo]

Oh. I didn't realize we'd established that rule applied in this game. Fine.

We haven't but it might and it's not VoLo so I'd rather be cautious

 

[potentialsheltervet]

We haven't but it might and it's not VoLo so I'd rather be cautious

Alright

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I'm not understanding the purpose of the stabbing nor announcing it on thread if it functionally did nothing.
I'm also still wondering about the diary reading.

 

[WildZoo]

This will have been a funny conversation if I end up moving back to alley anyway

 

[Stagg737]

Unyeet Miranda yeet PSV

Why?

 

[WildZoo]

Y'all should keep a close eye on me tonight, I've already told the mods I'm jonesing to make a tie and get myself killed since the wolves refuse to do it

 

[WildZoo]

Why?

Because

 

[Lawpy]

Y'all should keep a close eye on me tonight, I've already told the mods I'm jonesing to make a tie and get myself killed since the wolves refuse to do it

WZ pls

 

[alleycat03]

Agree. What's tripping me up is we've been assuming samac was targeted N1 for an NK and therefore a wolf bodyguard protecting her would be stupid because the bodyguard would be killed instead, but samac outright said I believe she never got any notification of being attacked so... It almost seems there wasn't ANY NK attempt N1.

I don't think Samac said that, I thought she alluded to the fact that a kill was attempted but she didn't want to reveal the commuting or that she was protected too

 

[alleycat03]

Who has a read on genny

lol

 

[genny]

I'm not understanding the purpose of the stabbing nor announcing it on thread if it functionally did nothing.

well, if this sword was like the sword in the previous game, it was a blocking item.

 

[alleycat03]

Just kind of funny that you said the only time you've village read Barks was when you were wolfing together
As we are currently in a game state where you have village read Barks

because she revealed as a JOAT

 

[Stagg737]

because she revealed as a JOAT

Why does that give her village points?

 

[WildZoo]

I don't think Samac said that, I thought she alluded to the fact that a kill was attempted but she didn't want to reveal the commuting or that she was protected too

No, she didn't get a kill attempt notification.

We should be very clear on that. The only reason she thought she was the target was because she knew she was protected and there was no village death that night.

 

[WildZoo]

We talked a bit about the possibility that something else had happened, and that's why she said on thread that if anyone knew of another reason why there wasn't a kill, they should speak up.

 

[genny]

No, she didn't get a kill attempt notification.

We should be very clear on that. The only reason she thought she was the target was because she knew she was protected and there was no village death that night.

so the reason for no death could have been because AM vigged the lightning that was going to do the kill?

 

[alleycat03]

Get your spouse involved, and you'll be playing Mafia for your honeymoon. What a time!

What a terrible, terrible time.

Ah cam has actually played a game here but he didn't enjoy it. So Lawpy subbed in for him

@BanquetCam

 

[WildZoo]

so the reason for no death could have been because AM vigged the lightning that was going to do the kill?

It's a possibility, depends on order of ops.

 

[supershorty]

Be Glad You’re A Farmer… Day 4 Tally

Stagg ()
alley (5) - Stagg, SAR, Barky, PSV, Lawpy
PSV (4) - miranda, genny, Dubz, alley
miranda ()

@alleycat03, you are in the lead!

9/10 voting
Missing: @JaggedJimmyJay

Vote closes TODAY, 3/23, at 10 PM CDT (~3 hours).

 

[WildZoo]

Damn. Can't make a tie under these conditions.

 

[alleycat03]

Could you please summarize just briefly the motivation for your vote please and thanks

More of a process of elimination at this point. Everyone else has more village points. I could maybe see wolf!miranda but she voted for mighty. PSV's actions in this game are imo in range of her wolfing ability. I don't think Lawpy is wolfing. I believe Barks' claim. Stagg's recent defense posts make sense and I follow his thought process. I know he can be a deep wolf but I am just not really seeing that here. I don't think you, dubz, or SAR are wolfing. Genny is being genny. I can't really read her but I don't think she's a wolf.

 

[WildZoo]

so the reason for no death could have been because AM vigged the lightning that was going to do the kill?

I've also thought maybe Zenge redirected Vis to herself lol

 

[HRH Queeb SAR]

Y'all should keep a close eye on me tonight, I've already told the mods I'm jonesing to make a tie and get myself killed since the wolves refuse to do it

No pls. You keep complaining when I die that we didn't get to play together so you're not allowed to do it in reverse!

 

[alleycat03]

Unsafe

How this would work from a wolf perspective, and also how you could NOT be a wolf.

I know I'm not a wolf. I protected our mayor who asked for protection on thread. Then I protected consensus village bloc members. I have been forthcoming with everything this game and I'm really disappointed nobody believes me.

 

[alleycat03]

@alleycat03 Who'd you guard last night?

Someone

 

[potentialsheltervet]

More of a process of elimination at this point. Everyone else has more village points. I could maybe see wolf!miranda but she voted for mighty. PSV's actions in this game are imo in range of her wolfing ability. I don't think Lawpy is wolfing. I believe Barks' claim. Stagg's recent defense posts make sense and I follow his thought process. I know he can be a deep wolf but I am just not really seeing that here. I don't think you, dubz, or SAR are wolfing. Genny is being genny. I can't really read her but I don't think she's a wolf.

Okay but even if you think I'm a wolf there are likely two left.

 

[WildZoo]

No pls. You keep complaining when I die that we didn't get to play together so you're not allowed to do it in reverse!

This is solidly mid to late game, I am ready to be deceased

 

[alleycat03]

Why would wolves try to avoid killing alley? i think it looks better for Barks.

Because if they go for a village blocc member, I might be bodyguarding that person and then they kill a potential misyeet instead of someone who would never be misyeeted

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I know I'm not a wolf. I protected our mayor who asked for protection on thread. Then I protected consensus village bloc members. I have been forthcoming with everything this game and I'm really disappointed nobody believes me.

I get that but also we're at a point in the game where I can't just believe someone because they said so

 

[HRH Queeb SAR]

This is solidly mid to late game, I am ready to be deceased

Me before you pls

 

[genny]

Because if they go for a village blocc member, I might be bodyguarding that person and then they kill a potential misyeet instead of someone who would never be misyeeted

eh... if you're village, still a dead villager. and the added bonus of not having you get in the way of any kills anymore.

 

[WildZoo]

Me before you pls

NO!

 

[Lawpy]

I know I'm not a wolf. I protected our mayor who asked for protection on thread. Then I protected consensus village bloc members. I have been forthcoming with everything this game and I'm really disappointed nobody believes me.

So it’s just mechanics?

 

[HRH Queeb SAR]

NO!

 

[alleycat03]

Okay but even if you think I'm a wolf there are likely two left.

Yes but I think you should be a priority first, then I will address who your partner could be after your flip

 

[Jagged Jimmy Jay]

Welp, guess I'll just be blind then.

 

[genny]

Me before you pls

we just need to make today's vote between you and a wolf, then let dubz cast the tying vote. lots of death, everyone's happy!

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Yes but I think you should be a priority first, then I will address who your partner could be after your flip

Except I am also not a wolf so... Hm

 

[supershorty]

we just need to make today's vote between you and a wolf, then let dubz cast the tying vote. lots of death, everyone's happy!

hehe deth funny