StardeWW Valley - GAME THREAD

[BobLoblaw78]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

Blue

@BobLoblaw78 @SportPonies Why did you both sad react this? You're both in the yellow for me!

i just thought you had left me off the list. Now I see that you have me on there as BLL.

 

[BobLoblaw78]

I still don't think SP is wolfy. May it bite me in the butt if I'm wrong.

This feels like some hedging I do as a wolf when I know know that they are headed for a misyeet.

I don’t prefer biting butts, you’re safe.

Thanks for that clarification

Bob pls did you even read my posts?

I wasn't casting sus on cubs at all. I was mildly village leaning him at that point.
And as for the last sentence, I literally said in the post that everyone usually wolf reads him and I was wigged out by everyone suddenly village reading him last night. So yes. Exactly what you just explained.

I’ll have to go reread

 

[WildZoo]

This feels like some hedging I do as a wolf when I know know that they are headed for a misyeet.

Thanks for that clarification

I’ll have to go reread

Bobbles, who are you looking at rn besides sporty?

 

[WildZoo]

Who said the thing about Bob and AM disagreeing more when Bob is a wolf? @Animal Midwife is that accurate?

 

[SportPonies]

Lol, I was literally in the middle of typing up a post to ask you who you suspect.

If you get time, wouldn't mind hearing your reasons to suspect wolf-stoat.

Already stated my wolf list and my reasonings. Stoat is not providing original insight as much as I saw from her in the noob game. She feels opportunitistic and (to a lesser extent), “aggro”

 

[Zenge142]

Who said the thing about Bob and AM disagreeing more when Bob is a wolf? @Animal Midwife is that accurate?

It was me. Wolf!Bob loves to fight with AM. Idk why.

 

[Truenamer]

Already stated my wolf list and my reasonings. Stoat is not providing original insight as much as I saw from her in the noob game. She feels opportunitistic and (to a lesser extent), “aggro”

Ah, gotcha. Well, I can't speak to aggressiveness, but she hasn't been providing much original insight because she's been throwing up and bedridden for about 36 hours :/

 

[Animal Midwife]

Who said the thing about Bob and AM disagreeing more when Bob is a wolf? @Animal Midwife is that accurate?

I don't know that it is but I'm also not village reading Bob atm.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

This feels like some hedging I do as a wolf when I know know that they are headed for a misyeet.

This is the second time you've compared something I've done to something you did as a wolf. It's starting to feel like deflection.

 

[WildZoo]

I don't know that it is but I'm also not village reading Bob atm.

Ok
I was just looking through Owwlympics and Madagascar. He did come at you pretty strong in the latter, OWWlypmics it looks more like it was reactive once you started pushing him to post his reads and vote earlier and such. Notably read you village that time, maybe he didn't enjoy the experience of putting you as his top wolf read in Madagascar
But I'm about to compare to some village games too

 

[SportPonies]

Maybe I should run another owwlympics game because it’s the Winter Olympics now

 

[WildZoo]

Oh yeah, pretty solid village read on Midwife in Shots. I know prior to that there were more communication issues between them, but wolfing together in Criminal Minds seemed to help with that.

 

[kaydubs]

I’ve been mentioning Criminal Minds a bit recently @WildZoo @vetmedhead

 

[kaydubs]

CAST Your Votes - D2 Tally (#1864)

Sporty (3) - Bob, stoat, Zenge
genny (1) - dubz
kdswg (2) - AM, cubs
Bob (1) - Truey
cubs (1) - kdswg
Stout (1) - Sporty

@SportPonies, you are in the lead!
9/12 voting
Missing: PSV, genny, Barky

Vote closes at 9pm EST (8pm CST/6pm fantasyland) on Saturday, 2/5 (~9.5 hours/570 MINUTES)

 

[WildZoo]

What if I...reread...instead of working on my homework...

 

[WildZoo]

Gotcha @SportPonies

 

[cubsrule4e]

Who said the thing about Bob and AM disagreeing more when Bob is a wolf? @Animal Midwife is that accurate?

I said I feel like they tend to disagree more as v/v, like neither is holding back (normal for AM) and it frustrates village Bob to give it back to her. I dont remember who said they disagree more with Bob as a wolf.

 

[justafluff]

Still reading this as casual purchase of hookers. Coveted, coveted hookers.

Me too honestly. No idea what a hoe does for farming 😆

 

[WildZoo]

I said I feel like they tend to disagree more as v/v, like neither is holding back (normal for AM) and it frustrates village Bob to give it back to her. I dont remember who said they disagree more with Bob as a wolf.

Oh. Well that's the opposit thing

 

[cubsrule4e]

Can you answer my earlier question re: Bob being wolfy to you

Post 1626:

TLDR the lack of Bob/AM interaction that I described there and again right before this post, as well as the tone/type of posts he's making (much shorter, not quite as rambling) but he did come out and say he wouldnt have as much time this game so not sure how much i can use that for AI assessment in this game if thats true.

 

[Zenge142]

Post 1626:

TLDR the lack of Bob/AM interaction that I described there and again right before this post, as well as the tone/type of posts he's making (much shorter, not quite as rambling) but he did come out and say he wouldnt have as much time this game so not sure how much i can use that for AI assessment in this game if thats true.

I think you have it backwards.

And Dubz’s posts looking at the past games seem to confirm that bit.

Wolf!Bob came at AM like a freight train in Madagascar.

 

[WildZoo]

I think you have it backwards.

And Dubz’s posts looking at the past games seem to confirm that bit.

Wolf!Bob came at AM like a freight train in Madagascar.

And lived to tell the tale, which is the most impressive part.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Oh. Well that's the opposit thing

I mean I AM 40 now. My memory could be fading or I could be mixing up games. The reason it stands out to me is because on several occasions I made the joke to bob that I understand what he's going through because I used to have many of the same arguments with her.

 

[cubsrule4e]

And lived to tell the tale, which is the most impressive part.

Well then I wasnt necessarily wrong, I was still on the same team with him, just not the village team lol.

 

[Zenge142]

I mean I AM 40 now. My memory could be fading or I could be mixing up games. The reason it stands out to me is because on several occasions I made the joke to bob that I understand what he's going through because I used to have many of the same arguments with her.

I remember it mostly because I had this Bob tell of Bob fighting with AM, and was looking for it when I was sus of wolf Bob D1 but let it go because he wasn’t fighting with AM, only to find out it was because they were w/w in criminal minds. Smh.

 

[WildZoo]

Spoiler: Don't open this sporty

I am actually rereading the last couple hours of d1. Homework is boring.

 

[cubsrule4e]

I remember it mostly because I had this Bob tell of Bob fighting with AM, and was looking for it when I was sus of wolf Bob D1 but let it go because he wasn’t fighting with AM, only to find out it was because they were w/w in criminal minds. Smh.

Well now ill never forget!

 

[WildZoo]

Stoat pls

 

[Zenge142]

Spoiler: Don't open this sporty

I am actually rereading the last couple hours of d1. Homework is boring.

Oooof an @bluestoat angry react. Wonder what that’s about.

 

[bluestoat]

Ok, I’m finally caught up. I’m feeling worse about sporty after last night, the vanilla reveal, moaning about making it to endgame, and the below post

Come across as very theatrical to me.

I’m feeling better about zenge, but I still haven’t seen anything that clears cubs for me so
Yeet cubs

This has a certain "Vissy definitely feels very wolfy, yeet YK" energy to it. Explain what's wolfy about Cubs to you? I had a d1 cubbie vote for a bit and migrated away from it. Curious what you see there.

 

[bluestoat]

Oooof an @bluestoat angry react. Wonder what that’s about.

Because I support the best successes from @WildZoo and maaaaybe relate to homework procrastination.

 

[WildZoo]

Because I support the best successes from @WildZoo and maaaaybe relate to homework procrastination

The universe keeps forgetting to punish me for procrastinating so I just keep pushing my luck more and more

 

[bluestoat]

The universe keeps forgetting to punish me for procrastinating so I just keep pushing my luck more and more

Oh Samac you're Truenamer

 

[bluestoat]

Oh Samac you're Truenamer

Lemme tell you about that dingleberry's prelim some time

 

[WildZoo]

Lemme tell you about that dingleberry's prelim some time

Maybe after I'm done with mine so I don't get any ideas

 

[WildZoo]

I don't like ties so

I'm sure someone else has brought this up before and I've just forgotten but

 

[bluestoat]

I'm sure someone else has brought this up before and I've just forgotten but

Felt Sporty was pretty village at the time and immediately was like "oh, wrong decision" in the aftermath 🙃

 

[WildZoo]

My jimmies got rustled again as I was rereading

Spoiler

7:35pm referring to her vote for me

It wasn't and isn't real, though she doesn't sound quite like she did in the last couple games.
I'm not yet ready to yell about anal sticks though, given my history.

The tally at the time of this post:

Looks Like We Better Get To Work - D1 Tally

samac ()
DubZ (2) - Sporty, Bob
genny (1) - PSV
Zenge (1) - genny
AM ()
cubs (3) - True, kdswg, stoaty
stoaty ()
Sporty (1) - DubZ
kdswg (2) - Dana, AM
Barky ()
Dana (1) - Barks
True (1) - samac

@cubsrule4e, you are in the lead!
12/14 voting
Missing: @Zenge142 @cubsrule4e

Vote closes at 9pm EST (8pm CST/6pm fantasyland) on Thursday, 2/3 (~90 MINUTES)

And then people move around a bit, she makes a comment about the cubs defenses, and Zenge votes for her at 8:03pm

Looks Like We Better Get To Work - D1 Tally

samac ()
DubZ (2) - Sporty, Bob
genny (1) - PSV
Zenge (1) - genny
AM ()
cubs (1) - kdswg
stoaty ()
Sporty (2) - DubZ, Zenge
kdswg (2) - Dana, AM
Barky (1) - stoaty
Dana (1) - Barks
True (1) - samac

@WildZoo @SportPonies @kdswg, you are in the lead!
A 3-way

How ... delightful.

12/14 voting
Missing: @Truenamer @cubsrule4e

Vote closes at 9pm EST (8pm CST/6pm fantasyland) on Thursday, 2/3 (~55 MINUTES)

So now it's a 3-way tie including the two of us, and suddenly Sporty's vote for me is real (based on tone, as she says later)

8:11pm

As of page 10, I do not think Dana is a wolf.


It's now no longer a joke vote.

So I went to try to figure out what she might have been reading in between those posts and if I could believe she actually thought she was getting a tone read on me.

Zenge pulled my posts from page 10

Spoiler

This is in reference to Sporty’s vote on Dubz. This comes about 10 minutes after another post of Sporty’s saying she’s on page 10.

Here are all of Dubz’s Pg. 10 quotes:

Jesus Christ, I was not commenting specifically on her page 10 quotes with that. I was commenting on her real-time play as well.

So the real-time posts from me from the "not real" to "real" vote:

I think he's village


I actually had this problem last game too and it wasn't even this small

One time she was wolf-reading me she said it seemed like I had a stick up my butt. She might have also called me a scarecrow?

I guess I don't so much see it as a pass as requiring a higher bar for yeeting. Like I want the wolf ping to be pretty strong before I go there. If that makes sense.

Though she may actually have been referring to these posts from around 7pm that she reacted to in that timeframe, I'm actually not sure which set she was referring to as real-time.

I guess I'll go back to

vote sporty

but I don't feel good about anything

Pls do not

I'm open to explanations about what it is from these posts that suddenly made her vote real, but it feels conveniently timed to me given that it only became real when the votes shifted.



Edited because one of the tally quotes got chopped

 

[supershorty]

CAST Your Votes - D2 Tally (#1864)

Sporty (3) - Bob, stoat, Zenge
genny (1) - dubz
kdswg (2) - AM, cubs
Bob (1) - Truey
cubs (1) - kdswg
Stout (1) - Sporty

@SportPonies, you are in the lead!
9/12 voting
Missing: @potentialsheltervet @genny @Barkley13

Vote closes at 9pm EST (8pm CST/6pm fantasyland) on Saturday, 2/5 (~7.5 hours)

 

[supershorty]

(votes hadn't changed since kd's tally, I just wanted to start harassing people who haven't voted yet)

 

[WildZoo]

Felt Sporty was pretty village at the time and immediately was like "oh, wrong decision" in the aftermath 🙃

Ok. I just didn't remember you having Dana all that wolfy until you moved because of her move to sporty, which was a tie-breaking self prez.

Got sidetracked by my rustled jimmies so I'm tracking the vote movements right near the end of the day now. What had you reading sporty village at the time? I didn't remember you mentioning her before vote close.

 

[WildZoo]

I still don't like the timing of the tie creation - stoat was around and commenting after sporty took the lead, and yet waited until two minutes before close to vote for Dana - but the thought occurred to me that she had to have known about the possibility of the tiemaker being included in the death RNG, so outside of very specific scenarios I think that move makes less sense for a wolf.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I still don't like the timing of the tie creation - stoat was around and commenting after sporty took the lead, and yet waited until two minutes before close to vote for Dana - but the thought occurred to me that she had to have known about the possibility of the tiemaker being included in the death RNG, so outside of very specific scenarios I think that move makes less sense for a wolf.

I think the self-sacrifice didn't really make sense in a wolf context either.

 

[SportPonies]

My jimmies got rustled again as I was rereading

Spoiler

7:35pm referring to her vote for me

The tally at the time of this post:


And then people move around a bit, she makes a comment about the cubs defenses, and Zenge votes for her at 8:03pm




So now it's a 3-way tie including the two of us, and suddenly Sporty's vote for me is real (based on tone, as she says later)

8:11pm

So I went to try to figure out what she might have been reading in between those posts and if I could believe she actually thought she was getting a tone read on me.

Zenge pulled my posts from page 10

Spoiler

So the real-time posts from me from the "not real" to "real" vote:








Though she may actually have been referring to these posts from around 7pm that she reacted to in that timeframe, I'm actually not sure which set she was referring to as real-time.

I'm open to explanations about what it is from these posts that suddenly made her vote real, but it feels conveniently timed to me given that it only became real when the votes shifted.

Please tell me what’s “convenient” about it when it doesn’t do me any favors. And you already know it’s a tone thing so idk what to tell you.

There was no “convenience” for me to suddenly say my read was real so I don’t understand why you suddenly decide that makes me wolfy.

 

[WildZoo]

I think the self-sacrifice didn't really make sense in a wolf context either.

Yeah, I had that thought too. Can't remember if any votes actually went there other than her own (lol LIS rule) but I feel better after thinking through that and the tie thing again.

 

[SportPonies]

I said I wasn’t going to engage today but I guess work is slower than most saturdays and rage!sporty is activated again. I really don’t want to spend my whole weekend sitting on my laptop and defending. 😑

 

[Animal Midwife]

Yeah, I had that thought too. Can't remember if any votes actually went there other than her own (lol LIS rule) but I feel better after thinking through that and the tie thing again.

I don't recall her ever actually self-voting. I think she just encouraged multiple of those on kdsw to switch.

 

[WildZoo]

I don't recall her ever actually self-voting. I think she just encouraged multiple of those on kdsw to switch.

Oh I thought she had actually voted for herself since people were yelling but that must have been preemptive.

 

[Truenamer]

Yeah, I had that thought too. Can't remember if any votes actually went there other than her own (lol LIS rule) but I feel better after thinking through that and the tie thing again.

I'll eat my hat if Stoaty is a wolf. I know that I have an unfair advantage into knowing how her brain works, but her flailing around vote close (and playing it so fast and loose with the danger of ties) is not what we'd see from a Stoat who has all the information she needs (if she was a wolf).

It just doesn't make sense to risk herself like that.

 

[WildZoo]

Please tell me what’s “convenient” about it when it doesn’t do me any favors. And you already know it’s a tone thing so idk what to tell you.

There was no “convenience” for me to suddenly say my read was real so I don’t understand why you suddenly decide that makes me wolfy.

I'm asking which posts you were referring to.

And yes it looks like convenient/odd timing to me that before we were tied for the lead the vote still wasn't real and then once we were, suddenly it was. So I'm trying to track the progression.