The Good PWWace - GAME THREAD

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
_rae_ said:
Everyone needs to come say words so we can get down to serious business
Click to expand...
In addition to my default of Clem and apop that I mentioned last night, I would agree PSV has made a few eyebrow-raising comments. But it's a weird setup and I don't want to ding PSV too hard for being confused about "no baddies." I also don't love the idea of voting out apop when they're clearly making an effort to roleplay, which is fun. And yet going "*shrug* maybe Clem" is also unsatisfying.

That said I just don't know what else we are supposed to go on here. Vibes could be meaningful, or they could just be folks being excited or confused. But unless something else comes up, I suppose those three are my POE.

I am generally biased against a sleep vote, for the reasons I think others are. I'm willing to consider if others really think it's worth it, but it feels like a potential trap. Assuming there are wolves, I just don't see a positive to willingly give up a chance to find one.
 
Genny's out here defending me as if I wasn't just like "YES SAMAC IS INTERACTING WITH ME GIVE ME SOMETHING TO PLAY WITH"

But I appreciate you genny.
 
GoSpursGo said:
In addition to my default of Clem and apop that I mentioned last night, I would agree PSV has made a few eyebrow-raising comments. But it's a weird setup and I don't want to ding PSV too hard for being confused about "no baddies." I also don't love the idea of voting out apop when they're clearly making an effort to roleplay, which is fun. And yet going "*shrug* maybe Clem" is also unsatisfying.

That said I just don't know what else we are supposed to go on here. Vibes could be meaningful, or they could just be folks being excited or confused. But unless something else comes up, I suppose those three are my POE.

I am generally biased against a sleep vote, for the reasons I think others are. I'm willing to consider if others really think it's worth it, but it feels like a potential trap. Assuming there are wolves, I just don't see a positive to willingly give up a chance to find one.
Click to expand...
Oh, if I'm getting "hmmms" based on just ignoring @_rae_ 's posts, I see all of it and it's squint-worthy, but I still read it as more "excited to be here." And obviously, we can't kill Janet until at least midway through the season/game 😉
 
GoSpursGo said:
In addition to my default of Clem and apop that I mentioned last night, I would agree PSV has made a few eyebrow-raising comments. But it's a weird setup and I don't want to ding PSV too hard for being confused about "no baddies." I also don't love the idea of voting out apop when they're clearly making an effort to roleplay, which is fun. And yet going "*shrug* maybe Clem" is also unsatisfying.
Click to expand...
I disagree so far. I think PSV has been very PSV. I think taking the no baddies thing at face value is tough and worthy of being talked out.

I also do not want to auto-yeet apop for being apop because I like her and she brings some chaos that I think is needed at times.

I feel as if I have learned that a vote for clem is never wrong, but I also haven't seen anything that's pinging me.
 
_rae_ said:
I disagree so far. I think PSV has been very PSV. I think taking the no baddies thing at face value is tough and worthy of being talked out.

I also do not want to auto-yeet apop for being apop because I like her and she brings some chaos that I think is needed at times.

I feel as if I have learned that a vote for clem is never wrong, but I also haven't seen anything that's pinging me.
Click to expand...
Who would you consider then?
 
_rae_ said:
I've spent the last five minutes trying to come up with a good RP as either Eleanor (because I love shrimp) or Tahani (because secretly I would like to always be dressed up and on my way to a dinner party), but alas I have such a personality of my own that I can't convincingly over come it. I'm cursed, I guess.

I am inclined, as dubz is, to vote sleep day one. The only other game I've played where D1 was a yeet was death mommy, and we got insanely lucky that Stagg was absolutely swamped and also a vote that we yeeted him on inactivity alone. Without triple checking the roster - and I'm too lazy to click back to page one - I feel most people that I expect to check in have already done so in a manner that makes me not want to vote for them.

I am currently inclined to believe that we're in a "everyone has a wincon and can win together" situation as much as a "there's wolves in them there hills". So consider me sheeped.

That was a whole lot of fluff out of me to say "idk, nothing?" but that's also my MO. Have a gif of Tahani being distracted by a gem stone because that's how I'm feeling.
season 2 jameela jamil GIF by The Good Place
Click to expand...

There's a lot about this post that rubs me the wrong way and subsequent posts haven't resolved that feeling.

Not particularly strong reasons for a vote, but better than "my baby may or may not have told me too"

##uncover clem##
##vote rae##

@supershorty

I'll tag the other mods momentarily. My phone is making it really difficult to tag people at the moment. Also "uncover" was autocorrect and I'm choosing to leave it because it amuses me.
 
WildZoo said:
Who would you consider then?
Click to expand...
I hate D1 voting. I genuinely prefer a mayor vote because even though voting a wolf into power is very bad, it feels less impactful than misyeeting a villager from the get go (is it still a misyeet if we're oops all village?)

Finnick voting me feels village coded, so I'm not inclined to retaliate vote. Spurs being all over the place is a role-play, sure, but definitely something I would consider look-at-able. I'm terrible at reading you, dubz, so if someone had a strong feeling I wouldn't be opposed. I genuinely feel most people are an option right now. I find fruit voting for CG three separate times notable.

Ugh I know this is a non-answer but I don't like giving solid votes until I have a strong feeling and I currently have no strong feelings.
 
_rae_ said:
I hate D1 voting. I genuinely prefer a mayor vote because even though voting a wolf into power is very bad, it feels less impactful than misyeeting a villager from the get go (is it still a misyeet if we're oops all village?)

Finnick voting me feels village coded, so I'm not inclined to retaliate vote. Spurs being all over the place is a role-play, sure, but definitely something I would consider look-at-able. I'm terrible at reading you, dubz, so if someone had a strong feeling I wouldn't be opposed. I genuinely feel most people are an option right now. I find fruit voting for CG three separate times notable.

Ugh I know this is a non-answer but I don't like giving solid votes until I have a strong feeling and I currently have no strong feelings.
Click to expand...
Roleplaying Chidi was my bit 😡
 
I guess let's try and get this going. Having played with them a few times, I genuinely think this feels like @_rae_ being over-excited, but also I feel better about potentially reading them later in the game. But that's a personal thing, so I can understand if others feel like they have earned votable vibes.

I guess :shrug: Clem is fine for now. FWIW, they did feel a little more talkative than in other recent games. Could just be cuz they're around more players that they're familiar with/have trouble reading. But here we are,.

Vote @Clem J
@kaydubs @supershorty @SARdoghandler

(For realsies this time, though I reserve the right to change my mind)
 
WildZoo said:
Can you be a bit more specific about what has you reading PSV village?
Click to expand...
Seems to be going through thread pretty thoroughly. Pointing out fruit waffling like usual but ending up on CG multiple times.
Being willing to question no wolves but also willing to work within that if the mods are in fact telling the truth.
Previous games I've played with her.

samac said:
And genny pls
Click to expand...
Genuinely mostly vibes and previous gameplay, however, looking back at her iso there's really not much to go off of, hence the +/- feelings right now. I think unconvinced but gut feeling?

ETA: fixed word; I am full of typos always
 
potentialsheltervet said:
I've only made a few comments, period. Are they all eyebrow-raisers?
Click to expand...
Really just the part about no wolves. But it was right after open of game, so as I said I’m not especially moved by that. There just isn’t a lot else to read either way
potentialsheltervet said:
I have question for @GoSpursGo and @_rae_
did either of you spectate last game?
Click to expand...
Yes. I was a potential sub, and then added to tots near the end. @WildZoo and @kaydubs can verify, based on my frequency of screaming into my personal void, I was watching very closely
 
_rae_ said:
It's so snowy and cozy and we decorated my living room on Friday so I'm enjoying my last day off all cozied up with the cats.
Click to expand...
I fell on ice yesterday and bonked the absolute heck out of my right hip. It's going to be an absolute nuisance sitting in class all day for the next two weeks.
 
potentialsheltervet said:
I see. I'm a little baffled by how you're reading me village here when that means you would've seen me be widely village-read last game while I was actually an anti-village 3p. And so early in the game, too. It surprises me.
Click to expand...
I've also seen you village and something feels villagey. You have a wide range and you can be hard to read, but the little that I have I stand by. It's D1. I could be wildly incorrect.
 
samac said:
I feel funny that I had some eye brow raises at Rae and then I felt like a lot of people had eyebrow raises
Click to expand...
Do you mean it’s funny that others piled on to thinking rae deserved an eyebrow raise? Or funny that others then made OTHER comments that made you raise your eyebrow at them?

(I hope you can understand what that word salad was intending. I’m trying to nap before heading to the airport)
 
GoSpursGo said:
Do you mean it’s funny that others piled on to thinking rae deserved an eyebrow raise? Or funny that others then made OTHER comments that made you raise your eyebrow at them?

(I hope you can understand what that word salad was intending. I’m trying to nap before heading to the airport)
Click to expand...
Funny in other piling on. Felt like people saw an opportunity and snatched it. But I know it’s not everyone
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

supershorty
The Good PWWace - Sign Ups [CLOSED, game start 11/29]
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
323
Views
5K
WildZoo
WildZoo
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
76K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
55K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
92K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
82K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Top