The Good PWWace - GAME THREAD

[fruitsalad]

---

Members do not see this ad.

5.) We're trying something new in The Good Place because it's paradise! There are no bad guys here! Village must work together to attain their individual wincons in order to win as a team! As some wincons can still be met post-mortem, individual villager wincons will not be revealed until the conclusion of the game.

this feels twisted like death mommy

if there are no bad guys, we’re still forced to vote someone out?

 

[WildZoo]

I think they’d just be the bad guy equivalent no?
What if aliens

No, I think any "bad guy equivalent" would go against the stated rules. Although I can't remember the alien wincon so there might be wiggle room.

 

[fruitsalad]

fixed grammar, darn meandering typos

 

[samac]

To put it to rest though after rechecking my role PM I do agree with Zenges, there are baddies. Of some flavor.

 

[samac]

Hehe now I’m gonna get N1’d watch it

 

[samac]

I do think this is V/V discussion tho

 

[WildZoo]

Hehe now I’m gonna get N1’d watch it

You brought this on yourself!!!

 

[samac]

You brought this on yourself!!!

Well I can’t let the circle continue and them just sitting over there going “hehehe watch the thread argue if we even exist!”
Nah fam
Next question
I accept deth

 

[GoSpursGo]

I would agree except that the mods literally said there are no bad guys and I reject your assumption that they would lie.

I've played games without wolves. It's not that big of a deal. Play to your wincon, play to help others meet their wincon. It's literally what the rules say to do. I assume there are elements of conflict written into some of the win conditions but that does not mean they have to be entirely exclusionary like classic scum.
!

If we were to entertain a game setup like this… does that actually help us figure out how to vote? At least on d1?

I guess we also need clarity on if sleep is an option.

 

[WildZoo]

If we were to entertain a game setup like this… does that actually help us figure out how to vote? At least on d1?

I guess we also need clarity on if sleep is an option.

No that's why in my mind sleep was the best option pending night info unless someone's wincon either 1) benefited from death or 2) wasn't harmed by death

 

[finnickthedog]

I would agree except that the mods literally said there are no bad guys and I reject your assumption that they would lie.

If this wasn't the Good Place, I would agree with you. But "hey, you're all village" is like the one mod lie that would be thematically appropriate so I don't know. I'm not sold either way, but I'm not outright dismissing the possibility of wolves (or something close enough)

 

[WildZoo]

But I will trust samac saying there is some kind of bad faction

 

[samac]

But I will trust samac saying there is some kind of bad faction

Now find em so I can sheep you pls

 

[WildZoo]

Now find em so I can sheep you pls

Oh, well I'm sheeping Zenge so you might be waiting a while

 

[GoSpursGo]

! As some wincons can still be met post-mortem, individual villager wincons will not be revealed until the conclusion of the game.​

No that's why in my mind sleep was the best option pending night info unless someone's wincon either 1) benefited from death or 2) wasn't harmed by death

This seems to imply there may be some players who benefit from (or at least are not hindered by) death.

 

[Zenge142]

I would agree except that the mods literally said there are no bad guys and I reject your assumption that they would lie.

Michael lied! It wasn't the good place! #ThisIsTheBadPlace

I bet in the real good place there are no wolves.

Do you think we're really in the good place?

 

[WildZoo]

If this wasn't the Good Place, I would agree with you. But "hey, you're all village" is like the one mod lie that would be thematically appropriate so I don't know. I'm not sold either way, but I'm not outright dismissing the possibility of wolves (or something close enough)

Sure and I get that (I have watched the show) and probably wouldn't have thought anything of it if they hadn't also said they wouldn't be intentionally tricksy

But I'll consider the matter settled

And then brag about it if it does turn out there were no real baddies in the end

 

[WildZoo]

Michael lied! It wasn't the good place! #ThisIsTheBadPlace

I bet in the real good place there are no wolves.

Do you think we're really in the good place?

I am simply doing the best I can with the information presented to me and trying not to make assumptions

 

[GoSpursGo]

Alright gotta start prepping for flight home, and enjoy last few hours with my parents. I’ll check in later

 

[samac]

Spurs
Zenges
Dubz
Village

 

[samac]

@WildZoo genny way?

 

[WildZoo]

@WildZoo genny way?

How many times do I have to say I've lost that card too soon to tell anyway I think

 

[finnickthedog]

I feel pretty good about Dubz for the record. Which traditionally would mean nothing because I think my success rate in reading her is zero. But maybe I've been retired long enough to consider my eyes fresh so I'm gonna roll with that feeling for now.

 

[WildZoo]

I feel pretty good about Dubz for the record. Which traditionally would mean nothing because I think my success rate in reading her is zero. But maybe I've been retired long enough to consider my eyes fresh so I'm gonna roll with that feeling for now.

Trying to remember my read rate on you and I have absolutely no idea

 

[Clem J]

Wow, no one has ever actually read it closely enough to notice that! You get a gold star.

I'd like to trade that gold star in for an oversized ballista with which to yeet someone into the sun, please and thank you

 

[Clem J]

I refuse.

Same there can't be no wolves if dubz is a wolf hmmyes

(For legal purposes this does not count towards my read history if wrong)

 

[Clem J]

Apop is roleplaying Jason from the show in at least some of their posts 🙂 but also, apop in general has been challenging for me (and many others) to read early in games, and consequently often winds up being on the board. Ironically, I haven’t seen them actually flip W before.

Not me I'm a champ at reading apop*

 

[Clem J]

None of the people I get reliable early reads on are in this game and that's not great for a very busy clem

I miss you Katie and vampy 🙁

 

[Zenge142]

Now find em so I can sheep you pls

Oh, well I'm sheeping Zenge so you might be waiting a while

I was planning to sheep Samac so...

 

[Clem J]

Players:
1.) @GoSpursGo
2.) @Animal Midwife
3.) @_rae_
4.) @screamqueenbee
5.) @potentialsheltervet
6.) @Clem J
7.) @WildZoo
8.) @genny
9.) @fruitsalad
10.) @finnickthedog
11.) @CeeGee14
12.) @kitzsuna
13.) @Barkley13
14.) @samac
15.) @apoptosis09
19.) @Zenge142

Subs:
*crickets*

Tots:
1.) @JaggedJimmyJay
2.) @Therapist4Chnge​

Oh my god has there always been a welcome video ????

Saving for later

 

[samac]

None of the people I get reliable early reads on are in this game and that's not great for a very busy clem

I miss you Katie and vampy 🙁

I feel like you usually read me pretty well pretty early
Or I just take your kill her comments to heart as a read
Heh

 

[samac]

I was planning to sheep Samac so...

HOLY FORKING SHIRTBALLS THIS IS BAD

 

[Clem J]

I feel like you usually read me pretty well pretty early
Or I just take your kill her comments to heart as a read
Heh

Oh really? I feel like I never feel good about you either way for awhile lol

 

[Clem J]

I think sometimes I defend you early actually but not in a like

"I townread you!" kinda way, more because you get unfairly maligned early sometimes imo

 

[samac]

Oh really? I feel like I never feel good about you either way for awhile lol

I always took your better yeet her comments as you village reading me for some reason
Maybe the one time you set up to try and keep me alive and I just kept it in my soul.

Whoops

 

[Clem J]

I always took your better yeet her comments as you village reading me for some reason
Maybe the one time you set up to try and keep me alive and I just kept it in my soul.

Whoops

I guess I do talk about yeeting you a lot too lol

Idk I'm i n c o n s i s t e n t

 

[Clem J]

I'm gonna be honest I don't really remember many details of what I've said in mafia games, my memory is largely vibes based

 

[Clem J]

I'm gonna be honest I don't really remember many details of what I've said in mafia games, my memory is largely vibes based

With the exception that I'm always right about dubz

 

[samac]

Oh no
My husband just came and asked me to see wicked tonight
It would be during close

 

[Clem J]

Oh no
My husband just came and asked me to see wicked tonight
It would be during close

I mean go see wicked obviously and we'll just yeet you while you're gone

Cause no good deed goes unpunished

 

[Clem J]

Alright bye, I'll be back later to make reads on spurs and maybe apop and maybe other players TBD but don't get your hopes up

Also to be super clear I do not have a read on dubz and my trolling her vote does not in any way count towards my reading credibility (unless it's correct, in which case I knew it all along)

 

[Clem J]

I mean go see wicked obviously and we'll just yeet you while you're gone

Cause no good deed goes unpunished

Don't angry react this smh that was a good pun!

 

[GoSpursGo]

Oh no
My husband just came and asked me to see wicked tonight
It would be during close

Seems simple to me!

We need to see that soon.

 

[_rae_]

I've spent the last five minutes trying to come up with a good RP as either Eleanor (because I love shrimp) or Tahani (because secretly I would like to always be dressed up and on my way to a dinner party), but alas I have such a personality of my own that I can't convincingly over come it. I'm cursed, I guess.

I am inclined, as dubz is, to vote sleep day one. The only other game I've played where D1 was a yeet was death mommy, and we got insanely lucky that Stagg was absolutely swamped and also a vote that we yeeted him on inactivity alone. Without triple checking the roster - and I'm too lazy to click back to page one - I feel most people that I expect to check in have already done so in a manner that makes me not want to vote for them.

I am currently inclined to believe that we're in a "everyone has a wincon and can win together" situation as much as a "there's wolves in them there hills". So consider me sheeped.

That was a whole lot of fluff out of me to say "idk, nothing?" but that's also my MO. Have a gif of Tahani being distracted by a gem stone because that's how I'm feeling.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

holy moly, it's going to be one of THOSE games, huh.
Meanwhile, I just spent a long time shoveling. For reference, I saw the very beginning of the first Spongebob movie (to the end of the dream sequence) and came back in at ALEXANDER CLAM BELL!

 

[potentialsheltervet]

I refuse.

That's literally just a line from the show itself.

I haven't watched in quite a while. But even if I had watched yesterday, I wouldn't have recognized this as a quote because it does, in fact, just sound like something you'd say

 

[_rae_]

holy moly, it's going to be one of THOSE games, huh.

I mean it's Samac, dubz, zenge, and clem in a room (and I humbly offer myself and spurs as massive **** posters and over posters). I'm shocked we're not up to 10 pages tbh.

 

[_rae_]

Oooh maybe I'll throw the good place on in the background for Inspo. I have some knitting I could work on today.

 

[GoSpursGo]

holy moly, it's going to be one of THOSE games, huh.
Meanwhile, I just spent a long time shoveling. For reference, I saw the very beginning of the first Spongebob movie (to the end of the dream sequence) and came back in at ALEXANDER CLAM BELL!

Aren’t they ALL those kinds of games?

 

[apoptosis09]

Not me I'm a champ at reading apop*

Are we sure that's not just that you always read me village and I also happen to always be village? 🤔
....
Go jags!