The Good PWWace - GAME THREAD

[reddeadrobin]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

I feel that getting any deeper in the weeds would be a bad idea so I'm leaving this as this for now.

Demons that strictly work under Shawn or in general?

 

[reddeadrobin]

Hey you're not Janet!

Unfortunately, I am a knowitall to the point that's it's probably pathologic.

 

[_rae_]

Demons that strictly work under Shawn or in general?

I guess I’m trying to get a sense of how many scum I think there are (Shawn demons). CGs read list felt very scum heavy but doing the math I think we DO have quite a bit of scum left.

Migraine brain math is historically unreliable though.

 

[kitzsuna]

I still think to have an overall win villagers need to complete their wincons which is difficult to do without working together

 

[kitzsuna]

I guess I’m trying to get a sense of how many scum I think there are (Shawn demons). CGs read list felt very scum heavy but doing the math I think we DO have quite a bit of scum left.

Migraine brain math is historically unreliable though.

Lowkey wondering if there is actually just 4 humans if we are going that route, whoever is playing the characters you mentioned (assuming anyone is playing those characters i guess) and a higher proportion of baddies that could incidentally take each other out?

Are those the only humans in the entire show?

 

[_rae_]

I still think to have an overall win villagers need to complete their wincons which is difficult to do without working together

while fake role reveals are always a possibility, the inability to role reveal is actually a very difficult twist in the game. It forces us to rely on other things, which is fun but also requires us to be more creative.

 

[_rae_]

Lowkey wondering if there is actually just 4 humans if we are going that route, whoever is playing the characters you mentioned (assuming anyone is playing those characters i guess) and a higher proportion of baddies that could incidentally take each other out?

Are those the only humans in the entire show?

No. But those are the only humans we know about in the first seaso.

 

[_rae_]

Shorty is either cackling at me for trying to solve it this way or is mildly annoyed at me lol

 

[reddeadrobin]

I still think to have an overall win villagers need to complete their wincons which is difficult to do without working together

It's true
But some think that working together is wolf-coded or allows wolves to hide more easily.

 

[reddeadrobin]

By my observation, there are players who either don't have individual wincons or don't care about helping with wincons and would rather hunt wolves or Good place skinned wolves.

WHICH IS FINE, but makes it hard for everyone to win

Which feels like a trope from the show as well

 

[supershorty]

Shorty is either cackling at me for trying to solve it this way or is mildly annoyed at me lol

You don't know me

 

[supershorty]

I'm actually doing my job, as unbelievable as that may be.

 

[supershorty]

............does that mean we might have a Good Pwwace 2 and Good Pwwace 3?

lol we'll see how people feel after this one before committing to that

 

[_rae_]

By my observation, there are players who either don't have individual wincons or don't care about helping with wincons and would rather hunt wolves or Good place skinned wolves.

WHICH IS FINE, but makes it hard for everyone to win

Which feels like a trope from the show as well

Edit word: tHe spreadsheet shorty must have

 

[_rae_]

I'm actually doing my job, as unbelievable as that may be.

Then why are you responding


Jk jk it was right there I hade to I love you

 

[supershorty]

Then why are you responding


Jk jk it was right there I hade to I love you

I'm doing my job like Spurs is paying attention at his conference.

 

[reddeadrobin]

I just feel like we're very quickly coming to a point where we have to decide to try to win through Points or by hunting BBEG, and trying to convince people to change their stance is going to border on impossible.

 

[reddeadrobin]

I also can't help but think that working together is the only way to win but

 

[GoSpursGo]

@kitzsuna
How're you holding up?

I'm glad to hear you thought it was self-evident whether anyone regretted their vote last night 😛

 

[GoSpursGo]

lol we'll see how people feel after this one before committing to that

Everything is great!

 

[reddeadrobin]

I'm glad to hear you thought it was self-evident whether anyone regretted their vote last night 😛

Not to put a hat on a hat.

But does anyone regret how they voted tonight?

No I did
I think i'm just getting ignored at this point

 

[GoSpursGo]

I'm doing my job like Spurs is paying attention at his conference.

I was actually driving most of the morning, then I had lunch with my division chief, and now I'm skipping the meet and greet to prep my slides and be here.

I'm gonna fall off the face of the earth again in a second. Legacy will still get done at some point today, it just may be abbreviated compared to the tomes I wrote previously. I will not have time to do a detailed interaction check on Clem but hopefully someone can do that eventually

 

[GoSpursGo]

Not to put a hat on a hat.

But does anyone regret how they voted tonight?

Oh sorry! Thanks for pointing this out. It came right after I posted last night, and i missed it. And obviously I'm catching up relatively quickly

I regret my vote terribly.

(This is a joke)

 

[GoSpursGo]

Bless you all for having a reasonable number of post to review today. TTYL

 

[samac]

But our dead are bad place demons. And they’re all village (minus Clem).

So I think there is a distinction here in the baddies on the show vs the good place demons just being demons

 

[WildZoo]

Bless you all for having a reasonable number of post to review today. TTYL

Okay guys, Spurs is gone, time to really get the chatter going!

 

[WildZoo]

Oh no he saw that

 

[CeeGee14]

Okay guys, Spurs is gone, time to really get the chatter going!

Give it a few minutes for Spurs to get wrapped up in real life duties. THEN we can get the chatter going.

 

[samac]

My current tinfoil is that there are 3-4 factions
Bad place demons who followed Michael and wanted to ensure a fair afterlife where those being tortured were the ones who deserved it
Bad place demons like Shawn who didn't give a shirt about the rules and just wanted to fork up the afterlife
The humans
+/- The good place folks who can never get anything done

I think the Shawn follower bad place demons' win con is to kill the humans
I think the Michael follower bad place demons' have a separate win con that has nothing to do with the humans
I think the humans need to stay alive
I have no idea what the good place folks win con would be. Accomplish a single thought before the end of the game?

I think there’s 4 factions in the game. I think it breaks down to
Good place demons faction village
Bad place demons faction 1
Humans faction 2
And medium place. This one I think matters the least to the overall game. We’ll ignore that one.

I think the good place demons way to win is to have enough people reach their wincon. I think that’s it. I think some may have win cons related to keeping humans alive and some may have some related to helping the bad place demons.
And they’re caught in the crossfire between humans and bad place demons.
Bad place demons need to eliminate humans.
Humans have to stay hidden and not be eliminated or stop the bad place demons.

This is my tinfoil.

 

[samac]

Demons that strictly work under Shawn or in general?

Trevor and Vickie I bet ya

 

[samac]

Lowkey wondering if there is actually just 4 humans if we are going that route, whoever is playing the characters you mentioned (assuming anyone is playing those characters i guess) and a higher proportion of baddies that could incidentally take each other out?

Are those the only humans in the entire show?

No. Others show up as new test subjects but I think that’s likely more than we have here

 

[samac]

while fake role reveals are always a possibility, the inability to role reveal is actually a very difficult twist in the game. It forces us to rely on other things, which is fun but also requires us to be more creative.

You’re allowed to ability reveal at least if needed

 

[Animal Midwife]

votes to end tinfoil

comes back to even more tinfoil

 

[GoSpursGo]

Oh no people from my center are sitting next to me and they will judge me for being here.

Hmmm

 

[Animal Midwife]

Well I suggest you at least stop going along with forming the whole conception of the game around interactions with Clem!

Unpairing interaction = that player is not paired with Clem? Great
Unpairing interaction = that player is village? No. Stop that.

And like if people want to try to sus out whether Clem has teammates we need to be worried about that's fine, I'm not sure his behavior supports that but it's a reasonable avenue to hunt down.

But no village bloccs should be formed based on who pushed Clem. It's simply not going to be that easy.

So you think he is 3p?

 

[GoSpursGo]

Oh no people from my center are sitting next to me and they will judge me for being here.

Hmmm

Judge me for playing on SDN during a conference I’m presenting at. Not for being at this conference, obviously.

Yet despite it being obvious I guess I felt the need to clarify

 

[_rae_]

votes to end tinfoil

comes back to even more tinfoil

I mean, Samac and I tinfoiled Clem being Shawn and it was right, so may I offer you some………

 

[kitzsuna]

I mean, Samac and I tinfoiled Clem being Shawn and it was right, so may I offer you some………

So who is your next vote now that shawn is knocked out of the way?

 

[_rae_]

So who is your next vote now that shawn is knocked out of the way?

I told you, if you die, I have a strong theory but I don’t want to say right now. I will explain if I think I’m right.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I mean, Samac and I tinfoiled Clem being Shawn and it was right, so may I offer you some………

You also tinfoiled that Clem couldn't die unless all counterwagons were decimated.

 

[_rae_]

You also tinfoiled that Clem couldn't die unless all counterwagons were decimated.

You win some you lose some

 

[Animal Midwife]

You win some you lose some

Heavy on lose some. (Not a jab at you specifically, just my own experience.)

 

[samac]

votes to end tinfoil

comes back to even more tinfoil

The vote fueled my tinfoil AM. Fueeeeeeeeellllled

 

[samac]

I mean, Samac and I tinfoiled Clem being Shawn and it was right, so may I offer you some………

I had already all caps it at her in out day pm lol

 

[WildZoo]

So you think he is 3p?

I am in agreeance with rae and samac's interpretations of the game's structure. I am not sure if "3p" is the correct terminology in context, but sort of?

 

[Animal Midwife]

I am in agreeance with rae and samac's interpretations of the game's structure. I am not sure if "3p" is the correct terminology in context, but sort of?

Can you explain more?

 

[kitzsuna]

I told you, if you die, I have a strong theory but I don’t want to say right now. I will explain if I think I’m right.

I forgot, that’s fair!

 

[WildZoo]

Can you explain more?

I think samac and rae covered it pretty well! My thoughts are probably closer to samac's, and I think it's likely that humans have some specific anti-bad place demon wincon rather than it just being survival, but either is possible.

My current tinfoil is that there are 3-4 factions
Bad place demons who followed Michael and wanted to ensure a fair afterlife where those being tortured were the ones who deserved it
Bad place demons like Shawn who didn't give a shirt about the rules and just wanted to fork up the afterlife
The humans
+/- The good place folks who can never get anything done

I think the Shawn follower bad place demons' win con is to kill the humans
I think the Michael follower bad place demons' have a separate win con that has nothing to do with the humans
I think the humans need to stay alive
I have no idea what the good place folks win con would be. Accomplish a single thought before the end of the game?

I think there’s 4 factions in the game. I think it breaks down to
Good place demons faction village
Bad place demons faction 1
Humans faction 2
And medium place. This one I think matters the least to the overall game. We’ll ignore that one.

I think the good place demons way to win is to have enough people reach their wincon. I think that’s it. I think some may have win cons related to keeping humans alive and some may have some related to helping the bad place demons.
And they’re caught in the crossfire between humans and bad place demons.
Bad place demons need to eliminate humans.
Humans have to stay hidden and not be eliminated or stop the bad place demons.

This is my tinfoil.

 

[CeeGee14]

Potential faction wincons:
Bad Place demons-Kill humans
Humans-Survive? Seems kinda boring and not something Shorty would do. This just makes it a normal village game for them
Good Place demons-Kill Bad Place demons?

 

[reddeadrobin]

Potential faction wincons:
Bad Place demons-Kill humans
Humans-Survive? Seems kinda boring and not something Shorty would do. This just makes it a normal village game for them
Good Place demons-Kill Bad Place demons?

I can't say more than this, but none of these are my wincon