The WWalking Dead-Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Lynch genny

I saw her post from yesterday, which I cant find now ...stupid sdn....where she said she was trapped cause if she changed her lynch vote she looks like she is just changing to join the crowd and if she doesn’t she looks bad for not lynching the wolf.

I mean, who is that paranoid/defensive for no reason.. everyone does that when the obvious bandwagon is obvious. Why would anyone care. A wolf might feel persecuted for doing so but no one else should.
Tbf, genny has been a wolf in like the last 5/6 games or some ridiculous stat like that, so I could see her being a little squiggly about getting accused of looking sketch.

I also have refrained from votes like that in the past, because meh - what's the point.

Although most of the time I'll toss out a vote for whoever is next on my wolf list.
 
I didn't notice the medic part on first read through. Couldn't this also implicate Weim as well though?

i don;'t know what to think about weim. did she check in again after saying oops i didnt know i was rezzed?
These are the only two posts.
Soooo I didn’t realize I had been rezzed until like 1 minute ago so I’m reading today now. If anyone wants to get me with a readers digesst version holla at me.

My brain hurts.

Lynch allieh
Her allie vote was the 8th lynch vote on her.
 
Tbf, genny has been a wolf in like the last 5/6 games or some ridiculous stat like that, so I could see her being a little squiggly about getting accused of looking sketch.

I also have refrained from votes like that in the past, because meh - what's the point.

Although most of the time I'll toss out a vote for whoever is next on my wolf list.
That is a reasonable response. If she feels like she is gonna be targeted for always be8ng a wolf....it sounded very defensive ....

Hmmm. I will come back later and see if youse come up with a better theory,
 
And I don’t get all this suspicion on Mel. The guy ID’ed a wolf day 2. Highly unlikely a wolf would do that so early in the game, in a small game where there aren’t gonna be a lot of wolves, that is just crazy,

Pippy’s play and comment seem waaaay out there, but I presume she is always like that, cause what wolf would act so gardarned suspicious? I gotta assume she is just a crazy playing villager.
Agreed on the Mel bit. As much as I dislike the fact he wants to put a bullet in my head I'm not convinced enough that he'd bus a wolf that early. THAT BEING SAID he did have a crazy on thread fight with dy once when they were both wolves and it bought him way too much cred for end game as I recall.

Still not sure about pippy but would like to hear from her or anyone who may have tried to shoot Mel last night. And if it was defensive... well then that's interesting and we should start looking at Mel a little more closely.
 
And I don’t get all this suspicion on Mel. The guy ID’ed a wolf day 2. Highly unlikely a wolf would do that so early in the game, in a small game where there aren’t gonna be a lot of wolves, that is just crazy,

Pippy’s play and comment seem waaaay out there, but I presume she is always like that, cause what wolf would act so gardarned suspicious? I gotta assume she is just a crazy playing villager.
I would disagree that I'm always a crazy player, but I do usually pull a lot of attention and I'm used to my theories & analysis getting ignored at this point, so join the club lol

FWIW, I probably have a better win record as a wolf these days but also typically am not that terrible of a villager.

I think you're also discounting what Mel would/would not try to pull as a wolf. He likes the fancy footwork & risky stunts. He might just be like, getting better at it 😛
 
Agreed on the Mel bit. As much as I dislike the fact he wants to put a bullet in my head I'm not convinced enough that he'd bus a wolf that early. THAT BEING SAID he did have a crazy on thread fight with dy once when they were both wolves and it bought him way too much cred for end game as I recall.
Pretty sure he was lynched the very next day. It was buying him cred... until Dy was assassinated.
 
Read writeup + his posts. Writeup indicates kill attempt stopped by a bible (apparently bibles stop bullets? who knew), he said he had a bible he needed thrown at him.
As an aside, there are stories of soldiers saved from injury due to carrying the little pocket new testament they hand out during basic training (also, pocket watches and other things) requires a bullet with low enough velocity at the time of the hit that the extra bulk stops it, but technically possible. Though this bible had a bullet hole not a bullet in it right? So that would imply it didn't actually stop the bullet so that wiuld mean the target got shot. Hmm. I might be overthinking or they weren't as precise as they could be. After all the initial phrasing on governor in black and wolf in red has been changed to all in red so my initial thought of convert now has no basis.
 
THAT BEING SAID he did have a crazy on thread fight with dy once when they were both wolves and it bought him way too much cred for end game as I recall.
He also got his wolfy self elected for mayor recently, and used the "why would a wolf put themselves up for a mayor role since it is assumed mayors will get investigated" as a defense. And it worked.

I'm not pulling this **** completely out of nowhere.

Still not sure about pippy but would like to hear from her or anyone who may have tried to shoot Mel last night.
I'm not sure, otherwise I would be voting for that person. I was going to say greenie because her posts about him were hella weird...but I don't know if she would call out Mel and then try to shoot him. idk. May vote there.
And if it was defensive... well then that's interesting and we should start looking at Mel a little more closely.
It wasn't, at least from my end. See previous post: mods clarified I did not shoot.
 
Oh god please stahp - dubz is already fueling his ego on that front enough this game.

Quick Mel -- try a wolfy plan and fail spectacularly, for the memories.
I'm operating from the hope that he's village. You know I hate his wolf play 😛
 
As an aside, there are stories of soldiers saved from injury due to carrying the little pocket new testament they hand out during basic training (also, pocket watches and other things) requires a bullet with low enough velocity at the time of the hit that the extra bulk stops it, but technically possible. Though this bible had a bullet hole not a bullet in it right? So that would imply it didn't actually stop the bullet so that wiuld mean the target got shot. Hmm. I might be overthinking or they weren't as precise as they could be. After all the initial phrasing on governor in black and wolf in red has been changed to all in red so my initial thought of convert now has no basis.
Setting aside show lore for a second...who do you think is wolfy?

In my opinion, you typically have very strong post analysis when you're village, and I'm not seeing a ton of that from you this game. Some logic rebuttals about mechanics, sure. But not a lot of strategy beyond that.
 
Still not sure about pippy but would like to hear from her or anyone who may have tried to shoot Mel last night. And if it was defensive... well then that's interesting and we should start looking at Mel a little more closely.
I was shot AT trying to sneak over the wall and the bible defended me. The write up doesn't say anything about the shooting being defensive.

As for who else could have shot me....honestly it may have been Cray, she was pretty peeved at me last night, but I have no idea where she'd get the bullet from. I currently like Pippy's theory that the bullet was shared from Allie to another wolf.
 
1) If it was a villager that shot at Cheezit last night, please please step forward. Not going to immediately lynch you. I need the info.

2) No death or shots n1, only the infection of kc, so there may be something to wolves being involved in that.
 
Speaking of, when do I get to switch to being suspicious of you for hanging out and acting all buddy-buddy & nonchalant? Is it now?
You can be suspicious of me whenever you want. I've been waiting :yawn:
 
How do people currently feel about Skimble?
I still am borderline on her. She lynched Allie D1, but then had all those claims about it being a joke vote...and then pointed out that she voted for Allie and was annoyed she didn't get village cred for that.

Doesn't seem particularly town-ish to get annoyed you didn't get village cred for a joke vote the day before.

But I also understand that it's frustrating to think you are voting well and then get no credit for a wolf lynch. Because I have been there. 🙄 lol
 
1) If it was a villager that shot at Cheezit last night, please please step forward. Not going to immediately lynch you. I need the info.
Oh, you specifically need it? I'm pretty sure most people would like that info.

2) No death or shots n1, only the infection of kc, so there may be something to wolves being involved in that.
There was no ammo in circulation N1 except the arrow that KC says she had, so it would make sense that there were no shots.
 
That's my theory, at least. If people have to ask for items or otherwise do something on the thread that gets mods/whoever to give them rewards, and KC was the only person who asked for an item during that cycle --> no one else had items. And she says was attacked, so it presumably got used. = no other shots to account for.

As an aside, there is a possibility she is lying about not having the arrow at this point in time. And I could see both wolfy and village reasons for doing that, but would probably lean wolfy on it.
 
That's my theory, at least. If people have to ask for items or otherwise do something on the thread that gets mods/whoever to give them rewards, and KC was the only person who asked for an item during that cycle --> no one else had items. And she says was attacked, so it presumably got used. = no other shots to account for.

As an aside, there is a possibility she is lying about not having the arrow at this point in time. And I could see both wolfy and village reasons for doing that, but would probably lean wolfy on it.
Oh I have an arrow again. Ask and ye shall receive is apparently the rule now.
 
That's my theory, at least. If people have to ask for items or otherwise do something on the thread that gets mods/whoever to give them rewards, and KC was the only person who asked for an item during that cycle --> no one else had items. And she says was attacked, so it presumably got used.

As an aside, there is a possibility she is lying about not having the arrow at this point in time. And I could see both wolfy and village reasons for doing that, but would probably lean wolfy on it.
Ah. I am not currently operating under the assumption that it's a reward based system, but it could be. I could see wolves not having ammo n1 in any case though.
 
Just as likely that players who happen to receive items are sending them onward to people who are asking for them
So, normally I would agree...but idk. The way I received my item seemed like it was because I did something worth rewarding. And timing + flavor made it seem like it was from mods, not a player.
 
So, normally I would agree...but idk. The way I received my item seemed like it was because I did something worth rewarding. And timing + flavor made it seem like it was from mods, not a player.
I just wanted to believe the mods don't hate me 😢
 
I have major question marks next to snowy, greeny, and sporty.

Also kind of had a running theory that someone who knows the show well was involved in kc being infected (attacked?) n1. That points me towards paws but it's not really solid and I'd rather hear more from the lurkers today.
 
Also kind of had a running theory that someone who knows the show well was involved in kc being infected (attacked?) n1. That points me towards paws but it's not really solid and I'd rather hear more from the lurkers today.
At some point I'd like to hear that theory because I also have Paws in a vague "eehhhhh" category right now.

She's been a little vocal for her wolf game, maybe. Buuuuut...she is a smaaht cookie, my manatee. And at the risk of giving away one of my own wolf tells here, coming out of the gate with comments like "you're a scary wolf, pippy" sounds like something I might say when wolfing (about you, for example 😛)
 
for whatever reason I'm not as concerned with the lurkers as I usually am. Greenie maybe, because her catch up posts put me on edge. But I honestly don't even remember enough of Snowy or Sporty's posts other than I thought they were consistent with busy/lurker posts & otherwise unremarkable.

(Sorry Snowy/SportySpice, you are both remarkable 😉 )
 
Little bit o rereading. Forgot cray is also on the list of people who know the show well. Currently leaning village on her though.

Super tinfoil hat theory, the zombies are the good guys, the humans are the last vestige of a bygone world that should fall away into the past as a new world order takes over and zombies become the dominant form of life on Earth. 😛

This was sorta the idea in "I am legend," not so much the Will Smith movie but more the book it was based on. That might have been vampires instead.

So are you saying you are village but a zombie? Or are you a human that is wolf and not sure if the villagers are zombies? Cuz your own role should eliminate this theory.
I don't know that cray really answered this to my satisfaction.

OMG! You guys, there was totally a group that the good guys ran into on the show called Wolves, and they were bad humans that would use zombies as weapons or in traps, and they were always in need of guns and bullets. They had to use other implements to kill.
I like this though. But have to not think about it because of the whole "roles are RNG" thing.

There was also a group of bad guys that used zombies to kill their foes... The Governor.
This is interesting to me. The day allie gets lynched, paws happens to mention the governor? Even though we've been told roles don't matter? Feels like wolf being "helpful" by giving out a little bit of true info. One of my favorite tactics.
 
At some point I'd like to hear that theory because I also have Paws in a vague "eehhhhh" category right now.

She's been a little vocal for her wolf game, maybe. Buuuuut...she is a smaaht cookie, my manatee. And at the risk of giving away one of my own wolf tells here, coming out of the gate with comments like "you're a scary wolf, pippy" sounds like something I might say when wolfing (about you, for example 😛)
The theory is pretty much what I said. I know I personally didn't pick up on arrows = Daryl, people who are more into the show seemed to. That is actually why I asked who was super familiar with it yesterday 😛
 
Unofficial Day 3 Lynch Tally
Cray (1) - Mel
greeney (1) - AM
Sporty () -
Mel () -
kc (2) - Paws, Skim
genny (1) - SOV

5/15
lynch close in 9 hours
 
Ehhh I was feeling okay on Paws until the infection thing, while she's been helping out with providing game theory, I think she's also asked a lot of good questions in the way of wolf hunting.
 
Ehhh I was feeling okay on Paws until the infection thing, while she's been helping out with providing game theory, I think she's also asked a lot of good questions in the way of wolf hunting.
I didn't ask for your opinion :rage:
 
Top