Tortall WW Official Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Devyn, how can you be so sure that there was no wolf attack?
 
variegata said:
I don't have any hunches strong enough that I really trust them. I'm still wondering how Kakuru knew there was an attack in Scanra last night, but she's silenced and I don't really want to lynch without her reply. Not really sure what to do at this point...
Click to expand...

I'm not silenced and really don't want to disclose how much I do know about there being an attack protected until necessitated by a lynch vote because I don't want to make anyone a wolf target, but there is a (obviously villager) role that allows for protection of a country at a time. Am trying to be cautious about saying too much now and providing a good target for the wolves.

Also, unless anyone else knows anything to the contrary, I am strongly suspicious of a conversion last night (rather than a wolf kill on a protected player). Just have no idea know.
 
kakurubird said:
Also, unless anyone else knows anything to the contrary, I am strongly suspicious of a conversion last night (rather than a wolf kill on a protected player). Just have no idea know.
Click to expand...

Rather, that should be, just have no idea who. Whoops.
 
I feel like this is some kind of record. Almost 8 hours since results were posted and only 3 votes?
 
DVMDream said:
I know what that "other source of investigation" is. I know 100% that it is an honest, reliable source.

You have been on my suspicious list since Day 1. So this just made me...
:eyebrow:
Click to expand...

Well considering Sheeps seemed pretty convinced that dyachie was a villager, revealed his source, and in an attempt to save dyachie her character, I think his source is reliable.

Then we have this other source that comes back that dyachie was evil, we don't know the source, just that you say it's 100% reliable... okay.

Obviously dyachie was not evil, and well nor was she a villager, but there have been neutrals in previous games. Just saying that someone is lying, the source of the lie, might be a wolf, thats all, suspect who you may. Investigate me.

Anyways,

lynch Phil
 
Remember being sooo upset about a certain important person dying? Remember what she was? Remember who told you Dyachei's character? Is it that hard to figure out the source? Js..

Lynch TT. Not very active and she really might be just sitting on items while they could be useful to the villagers. And maybe she's a wolf. That'd be awesome!
 
Official vote tally:

twelvetigers - 2 (orca, Petpony)
Sheepdog - 1 (Jamrockin)
cuitlamiztli - 1 (variegata)
Philliab - 1 (bbeventer)
 
bbeventer said:
Obviously dyachie was not evil, and well nor was she a villager, but there have been neutrals in previous games. Just saying that someone is lying, the source of the lie, might be a wolf, thats all, suspect who you may. Investigate me.
Click to expand...

Wait, just curious, but why are we know saying dyachei was not evil? As I understood the lynch results, it simply wasn't revealed which side dyachei was on, not that she was on neither side.
Unless I missed something?
 
I'm going to go with lynch philliab due to krist's reasoningof process of elimination
 
bbeventer said:
Well considering Sheeps seemed pretty convinced that dyachie was a villager, revealed his source, and in an attempt to save dyachie her character, I think his source is reliable.

Then we have this other source that comes back that dyachie was evil, we don't know the source, just that you say it's 100% reliable... okay.

Obviously dyachie was not evil, and well nor was she a villager, but there have been neutrals in previous games. Just saying that someone is lying, the source of the lie, might be a wolf, thats all, suspect who you may. Investigate me.

Anyways,

lynch Phil
Click to expand...

Are you really that daft?????? 😕 Not to insult you, but seriously? 🙄

I am inclined to believe that dyachei was a wolf. The mod gods just didn't want us to have any advantage in that lynch in knowing the full truth and knowing she had 2 identities. It is possible there is another person out there will 2 identities and that is why. Just a thought that popped into my head now that I have a few drinks in me. :idea:

PetPony said:
Remember being sooo upset about a certain important person dying? Remember what she was? Remember who told you Dyachei's character? Is it that hard to figure out the source? Js..

Lynch TT. Not very active and she really might be just sitting on items while they could be useful to the villagers. And maybe she's a wolf. That'd be awesome!
Click to expand...

👍 ummmm yeah BBE read this......


And not sure about TT just yet... have to go read something else and think about my vote.
 
devyn said:
Yes Phil's Lab is on my short list and I did talk to Krist about it when I was over in Carthak on my short vacation.
Click to expand...

I'll go back to read it and then we'll see. 🙂
 
Ok so TT has not posted in this thread since the 9th, but has posted elsewhere.... I am not sure what to think of that... I am not convinced she is silenced as then I would see her lurking more

so for now....

lynch TT


it really is between her & Phil's Lab and I may waffle a bit here
 
Official vote tally:

twelvetigers - 3 (orca, Petpony, devyn)
Sheepdog - 1 (Jamrockin)
cuitlamiztli - 1 (variegata)
Philliab - 2 (bbeventer, Sheep)
 
devyn said:
I am inclined to believe that dyachei was a wolf. The mod gods just didn't want us to have any advantage in that lynch in knowing the full truth and knowing she had 2 identities. It is possible there is another person out there will 2 identities and that is why. Just a thought that popped into my head now that I have a few drinks in me.
Click to expand...

I disagree, I see no reason why the mods wouldn't have told us if dyachei was a wolf, which is why I believe she was neutral. In the last game TW was voldemort but disguised as a patil twin, but when she was lynched her true wolf identity was revealed even though you were still hiding behind the identity of the other patil sister. We aren't really killing a lot of wolves yet so there is no reason the mods should hide a successful lynch from us. This really isn't helpful to future lynches but just wanted to get my opinion out there.
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
I disagree, I see no reason why the mods wouldn't have told us if dyachei was a wolf, which is why I believe she was neutral. In the last game TW was voldemort but disguised as a patil twin, but when she was lynched her true wolf identity was revealed even though you were still hiding behind the identity of the other patil sister. We aren't really killing a lot of wolves yet so there is no reason the mods should hide a successful lynch from us. This really isn't helpful to future lynches but just wanted to get my opinion out there.
Click to expand...

Well then we will have to agree to disagree on this one.... cause I think differently. I think that the holy god dude Kyprioth is a trickster and is playing tricks on us by not telling us the truth on this one.
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
I disagree, I see no reason why the mods wouldn't have told us if dyachei was a wolf, which is why I believe she was neutral. In the last game TW was voldemort but disguised as a patil twin, but when she was lynched her true wolf identity was revealed even though you were still hiding behind the identity of the other patil sister. We aren't really killing a lot of wolves yet so there is no reason the mods should hide a successful lynch from us. This really isn't helpful to future lynches but just wanted to get my opinion out there.
Click to expand...

I really do think someone else got involved with how the results were presented to us. I mean, it was pretty clear that the god got involved. Cause you're exactly right. The mods have no reason to hide that info from us. I really think a wolf out there prayed for the confusion. Any other time, a neutral player has been revealed. I truly believe Dyachei was anything but neutral and not on the good side.

And in all honestly, anyone who is questioning whether Dyachei was a wolf or not, should be looked into if you ask me. Just my $.02.
 
orca2011 said:
I really do think someone else got involved with how the results were presented to us. I mean, it was pretty clear that the god got involved. Cause you're exactly right. The mods have no reason to hide that info from us. I really think a wolf out there prayed for the confusion. Any other time, a neutral player has been revealed. I truly believe Dyachei was anything but neutral and not on the good side.

And in all honestly, anyone who is questioning whether Dyachei was a wolf or not, should be looked into if you ask me. Just my $.02.
Click to expand...

👍 This is my feeling as well. I really do wonder about people who do not think Dyachei was a wolf.
 
Ivorypolarbear said:
As everyone gathered around dyachei threateningly, suddenly there was a great boom. A bolt of lightning came streaking out of the clear, cloudless sky, and incinerated dyachei. Kyprioth, feeling that the confusion surrounding dyachei's identity was a worthy amusement, had decided to keep the mystery unsolved. Dyachei, a person of uncertain identity and allegiance, has been killed.
)
Click to expand...

It says that Kyprioth decided to keep the mystery unsolved. He is a trickster according to the mods. He saw us arguing and decided to keep it a secret. He's messing with us.

If there are two different investigations, I will believe the one that says she's a wolf. I doubt they would lie about that.

Sheepdogpsu said:
I disagree, I see no reason why the mods wouldn't have told us if dyachei was a wolf, which is why I believe she was neutral. In the last game TW was voldemort but disguised as a patil twin, but when she was lynched her true wolf identity was revealed even though you were still hiding behind the identity of the other patil sister. We aren't really killing a lot of wolves yet so there is no reason the mods should hide a successful lynch from us. This really isn't helpful to future lynches but just wanted to get my opinion out there.
Click to expand...

Nowhere in the write up does it say she is neutral - it says uncertain.

There's no use going back to other games for every single detail. This is a different game with different characters, items and actions. It's not all the same.

The mods don't necessarily care about us not killing a lot of wolves. They want to have fun. Or maybe even someone prayed to Kyprioth to keep it a secret in order to make us unsure. That person is most likely a wolf. I have prayed to Kyprioth before and my wish was fulfilled.
 
Alright. I'm heading to bed in a few. Gut says lynch BBeventer. I'll check back after my shower in case some new info came forward or anyone has a better idea.
 
kakurubird said:
I'm not silenced and really don't want to disclose how much I do know about there being an attack protected until necessitated by a lynch vote because I don't want to make anyone a wolf target, but there is a (obviously villager) role that allows for protection of a country at a time. Am trying to be cautious about saying too much now and providing a good target for the wolves.

Also, unless anyone else knows anything to the contrary, I am strongly suspicious of a conversion last night (rather than a wolf kill on a protected player). Just have no idea know.
Click to expand...

Ah, fair enough. That's definitely a role that needs to be protected.
 
Official vote tally:

twelvetigers - 3 (orca, Petpony, devyn)
Sheepdog - 1 (Jamrockin)
cuitlamiztli - 1 (variegata)
Philliab - 2 (bbeventer, Sheep)
bbeventer - 1 (wildcat)
 
I don't have much time to read this right now. I just almost died IRL so please don't kill me on here too 👎... that is all for now. Skiiing accidents are bad news 🙁 I'll try and catch up when I can.
 
Emiloo4 said:
I don't have much time to read this right now. I just almost died IRL so please don't kill me on here too 👎... that is all for now. Skiiing accidents are bad news 🙁 I'll try and catch up when I can.
Click to expand...
I hope you're okay!
 
Whatever, I really doesn't matter whether dyachei was good or bad since she is dead now, people were already arguing about it so I gave my opinion. To be honest I haven't really been paying extremely close attention since I have been really busy and I don't know anything about the books.
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
Whatever, I really doesn't matter whether dyachei was good or bad since she is dead now, people were already arguing about it so I gave my opinion. To be honest I haven't really been paying extremely close attention since I have been really busy and I don't know anything about the books.
Click to expand...

👍
 
Sheepdogpsu said:
Whatever, I really doesn't matter whether dyachei was good or bad since she is dead now, people were already arguing about it so I gave my opinion. To be honest I haven't really been paying extremely close attention since I have been really busy and I don't know anything about the books.
Click to expand...

But I feel like in these games it does matter since everyone uses voting patterns and pays attention to who defends who to figure things out. I can understand being busy though.
 
Hearing that others are suspicious of philliab makes me feel better about my hunch/suspicion. lynch philliab
 
Ok I have to go to bed... I have an early vet appt with the dog, so can't stay on as late as I usually would and wait to see what happens. 🙁 I wish we had more to go on with this lynch, but hoping one of our hunches plays out right. It is between either Phil's Lab or TT for me right now - so I just chose one. Hope we are right!

Emiloo - hope you are ok!
 
Official vote tally:

twelvetigers - 3 (orca, Petpony, devyn)
Sheepdog - 1 (Jamrockin)
cuitlamiztli - 1 (variegata)
Philliab - 4 (bbeventer, Sheep, abber, HOH)
bbeventer - 1 (wildcat)
 
Since others seem to be more suspicious of Philliab, I'll follow their lead,

unlynch sheep

lynch philliab
 
Ok, this is complete bandwagon bc I need to go rest.
Lynch Philliab

Night y'all.
 
(Sorry this is short - I don't feel well and am hurrying to bed).

Tentatively the villagers gather around Philliab. "Are we sure he's bad?" asks one. "Well..." says another. Finally, the deed is done.

You have lynched Philliab, Nawat the Crow, a villager. Too bad he never got the chance to see who held items...

19 people left, I think.

Night deadline is 12pm CST.
 
Yay silence over!!! I was part of the group that was on a secret mission. Whatever that means, I think there may be ghosts do some thing. If there are, hello ghosts. 🙂

Sorry you were lynched philliab. 🙁

I am now really suspicious of bbeventer and sheeps. Seriously, dyachei wasn't neutral. It just wasn't revealed as to what she was on the thread. My being 100% convinced that someone is honest is very difficult to accomplish. Ever think that maybe I have a really good reason to believe dyachei was a wolf is because I was given information by someone that knows a lot about this particular game. 😉
 
DVMDream said:
Yay silence over!!! I was part of the group that was on a secret mission. Whatever that means, I think there may be ghosts do some thing. If there are, hello ghosts. 🙂

Sorry you were lynched philliab. 🙁

I am now really suspicious of bbeventer and sheeps. Seriously, dyachei wasn't neutral. It just wasn't revealed as to what she was on the thread. My being 100% convinced that someone is honest is very difficult to accomplish. Ever think that maybe I have a really good reason to believe dyachei was a wolf is because I was given information by someone that knows a lot about this particular game. 😉
Click to expand...

First off if I was a wolf it would not be very good tatic to be the first to vote for a villager. Secondly, yes DVM, that is my point, that maybe your information was wrong, that maybe you aren't trustworthy. People come back from the dead as wolfs all the time. Since I know I am not a wolf and you keep pointing your finger at me, it sure makes me suspicious of you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
481
Views
4K
nicoledoesvetstuff
nicoledoesvetstuff
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
52K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
176
Views
11K
supershorty
supershorty
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
31K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top