Its a tough exam indeed. Have you signed up to take the exam again? I've seen different sources convert my score between a 17 and 19, so I guess I can safely say my score is more like an 18. I'd say content makes up 50% of the exam while critical thinking takes the other 50%.
As for my GPA I got a 3.0 overall and 2.98 science gpa. I'm really not sure what I should do. I don't know if doing more passages is going to improve my score.
I am going to sign up for the one at the end of September. If I don't feel ready in 2 months, I'll change the date to a later one (if they post any other test dates). It really depends on how you studied. For me, I kind of focused too much about learning concepts and the materials and didn't really focus on the passages and practice test (did most of the passages near the end). So that's why I feel like focusing on passages will help with my scores. Figure out how you studied and see what you are really lacking and go from there. You can study for 10 hours a day, but it doesn't mean you are getting anywhere (I learned that the hard way). Have you taken the MCAT before?
Unfortunately, since I am trying to figure my chances as well, I'm not sure where you stand. Your GPA is on the lower end, compared to the average. with your 491, it might not be enough. I feel that the best way to know if you have a chance is to call the schools directly and get their feedback. I called NYCPM and Temple and this is what they told me (My info: 3.314 cgpa, 3.08 sgpa, 489 mcat)
NYCPM: my GPA is on the lower end, but not in the red zone. However, with my mcat, my score is low and was told to aim for a score near the 500 mark. (felt like he was just basing my stats on the avg, didn't get too much info here)
Temple: my cgpa is fine, but my sgpa is a little low, but overall, GPA is fine. My MCAT score is on the low end. She advised me to retake and try to aim around 495. She told me it's fine even if I apply after January (as long as my MCAT score is better). I asked if I applied with what I have now, she said that I don't have a good chance. (btw, she said my score fell in the 18-19 mark, so your score might be in the 20s)
I'm going to try to contact more schools for a better understanding.
There are obviously exceptions. There are people getting in with less than 3.0 gpa, or low mcat score. You don't have to obtain the average marks for every category, but it's nice to get some perspective from actual universities. Perhaps if you apply early, you could get an interview. You would just have to nail it.
It sucks that we didn't get the scores we wanted (I am super pissed, since I actually did fine on the practice tests), but it doesn't mean it's the end. It seems like there's plenty of time for the application process, so if you have time to improve anything, you can do it. one stat isn't everything, but if you are lacking in something, it would be better to balance it with something else.