WW: Mysterious Planet Official Game Thread

[Trematode]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Varz is sitting on the other side of my bed watching me get flustered.
Thought y'all might need a laugh.
Hurry up with the PP/JMJ thing.
I was to go play Just Dance 3.

 

[Trematode]

wait, since when do Lissa & the leaders actually know whether PP is good or evil?

i guess it doesn't matter since we can't lynch her right now anyway, but i mean i guess it's useful for numbers..

Lissa just said that they have dirt on PP and "are discussing it now" whatever that means.

 

[Katie8]

Lissa just said that they have dirt on PP and "are discussing it now" whatever that means.

yeah but I thought we can't lynch/kill PP until we kill the fox...sooo....

 

[abbercadaver]

Are you sure about that? As far as I could tell in other games that hasn't been the case...

Neutral players do not count as wolf players in numbers, therefore they count as villagers in numbers.

there are no sucky roles, just sucky players who can't make any role own.

that is my sage advice for the day. i am wise.

Pft. There are definitely lame roles.

Mine is pretty lame (again, no offense DVM. I imagine it is really hard to come up with 40 roles plus items 😱). That's why I wanted to be a leader. It would give me something cool to do.

👍

Didn't we determine that Orca is the jackalope? And isn't the jackalope bad? Why aren't we lynching her?

Orca, do you HAVE to attack someone every time you get the chance, or do you get the option of saying "No attacking tonight."

 

[DVMDream]

Official Vote Tally:

JMJ 2 (krist, abber)

Trematode 5 (heylodeb, equine, SOV, dyachei, lissa)

Lissa 1 (trematode)

Waffle meter: 5

Deadline is 7 PM PST. You have 2 hours.

Please make sure this is correct, there were quite a few posts to go through and bolded words that weren't lynch votes. 🙂

 

[Trematode]

A few thoughts. So why are we apologizing for lynching pp? What came out that says she's not a wolf? I think I missed that. Someone explain it to me if I'm just not seeing it. If we're only going off the fact that we couldn't kill her... I'm not sure that's entirely wise. For all we know she could be the mother of all wolves that's hard to kill. For a veteran player I feel like her defenses were still funky at best. Or maybe I'm reading into that too much. But let's not forget the weirdness of last lynch. I think we can put her on the backburner for now until we get this "fox" and re-evaluate from there. She could be an evil creature that is protected by another evil creature, an evil creature that hides her soul in an innocent creature, or an innocent creature that got her soul stolen (or sold her soul to the devil or something), or an innocent creature that is being protected by another innocent creature. Who knows...

As for the new info that's come up. It looks like we're looking at peeps from the Keb Desert (Trem, SOV, PP, lissa) and wildcatj, orca, ftb or wtf. Outside of PP, I don't have too much to say about any of them, except maybe that SOV is always suspect because he's a wolf of some kind more of than not 🙄. LIS isn't sure that wildcatj is a good choice to lynch (then who's the better choice LIS?). FTB is apparently vouched for.

That leaves: Trem, SOV, Lissa, Orca, and WTF.

Orca and WTF being a tad bit higher on my suspect list just because if PP is a wolf then the other 3 very well could not be. One thing that stood out to me about WTF, was that she asked for protection for cuilt. I don't think this in itself makes WTF suspect, but it made me question something. Do the people in the "know" have information as to whether cuilt even came back as a seer when she revived? I remember in clue (another DVMD game), the wolves could resurrect someone dead as a wolf but without the skills they had previously before they died. We chose IPB because she was a seer who got lynched early for a noob error I think, and we would have her "pretend seer" other innocent players to clear them to make it convincing that she's worth protecting. Just a thought.

I'm hoping to get back on before the lynch after maybe some others weigh in, but I may not have the chance since it'll be another super long day for me. Unlike in vet school when you can just go "oh screw studying... pretty sure I can at least pass this test, so prioritize ww!" work is a whole nother beast 😛

I am still basing my votes off of this post.

 

[TigerWillow]

wait, since when do Lissa & the leaders actually know whether PP is good or evil?

i guess it doesn't matter since we can't lynch her right now anyway, but i mean i guess it's useful for numbers..

We don't know for sure.

There is something that doesn't match up. It involves what pp said about her role. But it wasn't like a "oh yes, little one, pp is most definitely a wolf!"

 

[Ivorypolarbear]

************
This is awesome to watch, just so you know. 🙂


************

 

[Trematode]

We don't know for sure.

There is something that doesn't match up. It involves what pp said about her role. But it wasn't like a "oh yes, little one, pp is most definitely a wolf!"

So, again, why am I a target if something fishy is going on between them two over there?

 

[TigerWillow]

So, again, why am I a target if something fishy is going on between them two over there?

Who is "them two"

We tried lynching pp once. Didn't work. Are we really going to do it again?

 

[DVMDream]

I have about another hour to watch this... 😎

 

[nyanko]

Neutral players do not count as wolf players in numbers, therefore they count as villagers in numbers.

But that's not necessarily true.

 

[Trematode]

Who is "them two"

We tried lynching pp once. Didn't work. Are we really going to do it again?

I don't understand why I am still a target if it is more obvious that something wolfy is going on over there.

That =/= everyone lynch PP.

Geeze.

 

[nyanko]

I don't understand why I am still a target if it is more obvious that something wolfy is going on over there.

over where?

 

[Varz]

Trem is correct, I am sitting across from her munching on chips enjoying the show.

After reading past posts and looking at the info I narrowed my choices down to Orca or JMJ. Orca because after reading their previous posts, I wonder why the jackalope thing didn't get resolved quickly instead of being drawn out or just identified right away.

JMJ because the information provided is mostly showing a trend to be malevolent. JMJ, you can resolve this by a simple PM, I will check back, but for now...Lynch JMJ

 

[abbercadaver]

But that's not necessarily true.

When has it not been true? Even in the Lounge game I played, there was a Minion player. I specifically asked, and the Minion (even though he helped the wolves) was still counted as a villager in numbers because he was NOT a WOLF.

Have you played a game where a neutral player has not counted as a villager and has counted as a wolf?

 

[Trematode]

With PP and Lissarae.
Duh.

Unlynch lissa.
Lynch JMJ

Nobody is lynching. I am bored. I might as well push for a tie and go do something fun with my life.

 

[Lissarae06]

I don't understand why I am still a target if it is more obvious that something wolfy is going on over there.

That =/= everyone lynch PP.

Geeze.

You didn't answer the question. Who is "them two"?

 

[nyanko]

Have you played a game where a neutral player has not counted as a villager and has counted as a wolf?

No, the neutral players are not counted as villager or wolf in the games I've played with neutral players. They are just supposed to survive, and win with whatever side wins if they survive.

 

[Trematode]

 

[TigerWillow]

Trem is correct, I am sitting across from her munching on chips enjoying the show.

After reading past posts and looking at the info I narrowed my choices down to Orca or JMJ. Orca because after reading their previous posts, I wonder why the jackalope thing didn't get resolved quickly instead of being drawn out or just identified right away.

JMJ because the information provided is mostly showing a trend to be malevolent. JMJ, you can resolve this by a simple PM, I will check back, but for now...Lynch JMJ

I'm seeing a bias here

Trem I have yet to vote for you, but if you keep flinging horse poop over to the leaders saying we are shady then I really have no choice outta anger.

You keep on bringing up pp. what can we do about it?

 

[Trematode]

You didn't answer the question. Who is "them two"?

YOU (Lissa) and PP.

 

[DVMDream]

Official Vote Tally:

JMJ 4 (krist, abber, Varz, Trematode)

Trematode 5 (heylodeb, equine, SOV, dyachei, lissa)


Waffle meter: 6

Deadline is 7 PM PST. You have 2 hours.

 

[Lissarae06]

YOU (Lissa) and PP.

How is something fishy going on between me and PP? Are you talking about the fact that I shared info about PP to the leaders?

 

[Varz]

I'm seeing a bias here

Trem I have yet to vote for you, but if you keep flinging horse poop over to the leaders saying we are shady then I really have no choice outta anger.

You keep on bringing up pp. what can we do about it?

If I thought she was a wolf, I would totally do it just to see the reaction I would get when she read about me lynching her.

 

[nyanko]

Have you played a game where a neutral player has not counted as a villager and has counted as a wolf?

I mean like, what's the point of calling somebody "neutral" if they are counted as one side or the other for numbers (the entire point of the game) purposes? 😕

 

[DVMDream]

I am MOD: Hear me ROAR!! 😀😀

 

[abbercadaver]

Reason I asked Orca whether she could opt out of her attack is this: If she can opt out, then there is no reason for us to lynch her for being a jackalope. If she cannot opt out, then by not lynching her we run a serious risk of her silencing a villager and not a wolf. That is no good for the villagers as people are definitely still willing to jump on the "Well, (s)he's not here to defend his/herself, but it's the best option we've got." And someone who is an innocent villager and silenced ends up lynched due to her action.

THAT is where I draw the line. If she HAS to silence someone, then she is more of a liability than a benefit to the villagers at this point.

I'm still not convinced she isn't a wholly a wolf, though.

 

[Trematode]

How is something fishy going on between me and PP? Are you talking about the fact that I shared info about PP to the leaders?

And you said that you were going to decide what to do about it among the leaders before anything gets said in the thread.

Lissa:

To be quite frank with you, I am still pretty upset that everyone is lynching me because of a series of PMs that took place in a matter of hours pn the first day over the fact that I have no idea what the word "neutral" ment in the world of WW.

I am also pretty upset that PP knows my role and knows I protected Cuitz and has not tried to help me out at all. Why? I want to know that myself.

There is more dirt floating around out there about other players. I am trying to uncover it so that the lynch vote is based on something more substantial than "Trema worded something funny".

 

[abbercadaver]

No, the neutral players are not counted as villager or wolf in the games I've played with neutral players. They are just supposed to survive, and win with whatever side wins if they survive.

Hm. So if there are only villagers left, neutrals win, too; but if there are only neutrals left in the game, the wolves can win? I've just not had much encounters with neutral players. That's super weird to me.

I mean like, what's the point of calling somebody "neutral" if they are counted as one side or the other for numbers (the entire point of the game) purposes? 😕

To cause this kind of confusion.

 

[Minnerbelle]

I am still basing my votes off of this post.

Just because you highlighted the ever so insightful post that everyone seemed to have ignored (and if anyone paid attention wtf's response to that made her look super wolfy) that I might not lynch you for now because I'm flattered.

There are a couple things you've said that bring you down from being suspicious in my book, but there are a couple of things that make you suuuuper suspicious. I don't know what to do.

Why is JMJ suspicious again?

 

[Lissarae06]

And you said that you were going to decide what to do about it among the leaders before anything gets said in the thread.

Lissa:

To be quite frank with you, I am still pretty upset that everyone is lynching me because of a series of PMs that took place in a matter of hours pn the first day over the fact that I have no idea what the word "neutral" ment in the world of WW.

I am also pretty upset that PP knows my role and knows I protected Cuitz and has not tried to help me out at all. Why? I want to know that myself.

There is more dirt floating around out there about other players. I am trying to uncover it so that the lynch vote is based on something more substantial than "Trema worded something funny".

Be upset with me all you want. It's nothing personal. It's a game. It is all I have to base my vote on at this moment. The info on PP isn't conclusive and even if it was we are trying to figure out what we could even do about it.

 

[nyanko]

I haven't heard real evidence that says Trematode is a wolf. I also haven't really heard any hard evidence for JMJ being a wolf. So based on my own gut feelings, Trematode is acting more suspicious than JMJ. That may be wrong, my gut's been wrong before (in fact, went against it when it was telling me to lynch Lissa in the last game haha), but as of right now Trem's probably going to be my vote, though I am not doing much today so I can wait until closer to the deadline in case SOMETHING more definitive comes out.

 

[Lissarae06]

Just because you highlighted the ever so insightful post that everyone seemed to have ignored (and if anyone paid attention wtf's response to that made her look super wolfy) that I might not lynch you for now because I'm flattered.

There are a couple things you've said that bring you down from being suspicious in my book, but there are a couple of things that make you suuuuper suspicious. I don't know what to do.

Why is JMJ suspicious again?

It wasn't ignored!

 

[Minnerbelle]

I am also pretty upset that PP knows my role and knows I protected Cuitz and has not tried to help me out at all. Why? I want to know that myself.

ohhhh trust me PP is on the top of the list of people I want to lynch, but I think it's worthless until the fox or whatever turns up dead.

i just don't have enough info on the others to go for a lynch just yet.

 

[Trematode]

I haven't heard real evidence that says Trematode is a wolf. I also haven't really heard any hard evidence for JMJ being a wolf. So based on my own gut feelings, Trematode is acting more suspicious than JMJ. That may be wrong, my gut's been wrong before (in fact, went against it when it was telling me to lynch Lissa in the last game haha), but as of right now Trem's probably going to be my vote, though I am not doing much today so I can wait until closer to the deadline in case SOMETHING more definitive comes out.

JMJ hasn't really posted anything in a while except to question me.
People wanted a defense from me. Well, I gave it.
Where is JMJ's? And what is the deal with people lynching JMJ?

 

[abbercadaver]

ohhhh trust me PP is on the top of the list of people I want to lynch, but I think it's worthless until the fox or whatever turns up dead.

i just don't have enough info on the others to go for a lynch just yet.

This!! 👍👍👍

JMJ hasn't really posted anything in a while except to question me.
People wanted a defense from me. Well, I gave it.
Where is JMJ's? And what is the deal with people lynching JMJ?

And THIS. 👍👍

 

[Minnerbelle]

Peeps please please come out with more information, even if it's "this person's index of suspicion has gone up but we can't say why" from our ring of communicative people in the "know"

Those of us with 0 line of communication and no seer ability have nothing but the thread to go off of.

 

[nyanko]

Hm. So if there are only villagers left, neutrals win, too; but if there are only neutrals left in the game, the wolves can win? I've just not had much encounters with neutral players. That's super weird to me.

you would never have a case where only neutrals are left in a game, because once the last non-neutral player is the only non-neutral player remaining, the game ends and that player's side wins...

To cause this kind of confusion.

that's sort of stupid - things like that just make the game less fun to play.

 

[Minnerbelle]

It wasn't ignored!

😍 well that makes me feel a lil better about getting up at 5am just to make that post

 

[nyanko]

Peeps please please come out with more information, even if it's "this person's index of suspicion has gone up but we can't say why" from our ring of communicative people in the "know"

Those of us with 0 line of communication and no seer ability have nothing but the thread to go off of.

👍 seriously. not in a group with a leader and can't investigate anything.

 

[Katie8]

I feel like jmj might be silenced since she has posted in other threads.

 

[Varz]

The reason I am going with JMJ at the moment is that I sent them a PM asking for any kind of defence that they may not want to have public so I could stand up for them. Since sending that PM, I have not seen a response and seen two posts in the main form by JMJ.

That's what the final straw was for me. If you can't even defend yourself at all via PM, especially in a group that has such limited communication ability, you're my target. As I said in my initial lynch post, they can change that completely by sending me a PM and not just posting on the forum.

 

[Minnerbelle]

👍 seriously. not in a group with a leader and can't investigate anything.

omg right? if anyone has the ability to move me or communicate with me please do. my group is a huge dud (and i don't blame them for not PM'ing because it really sucks for our group).

 

[Emiloo4]

I feel like jmj might be silenced since she has posted in other threads.

No she's been on randomly. I think she is at a Jazzfest though so she may be peaking in randomly on her phone.

 

[Minnerbelle]

The reason I am going with JMJ at the moment is that I sent them a PM asking for any kind of defence that they may not want to have public so I could stand up for them. Since sending that PM, I have not seen a response and seen two posts in the main form by JMJ.

That's what the final straw was for me. If you can't even defend yourself at all via PM, especially in a group that has such limited communication ability, you're my target. As I said in my initial lynch post, they can change that completely by sending me a PM and not just posting on the forum.

that just might mean she's silenced and can't pm you...

 

[Lissarae06]

The reason I am going with JMJ at the moment is that I sent them a PM asking for any kind of defence that they may not want to have public so I could stand up for them. Since sending that PM, I have not seen a response and seen two posts in the main form by JMJ.

That's what the final straw was for me. If you can't even defend yourself at all via PM, especially in a group that has such limited communication ability, you're my target. As I said in my initial lynch post, they can change that completely by sending me a PM and not just posting on the forum.

She is probably silenced. I don't remember the last time she posted in this thread. Let me check.

 

[Emiloo4]

The reason I am going with JMJ at the moment is that I sent them a PM asking for any kind of defence that they may not want to have public so I could stand up for them. Since sending that PM, I have not seen a response and seen two posts in the main form by JMJ.

That's what the final straw was for me. If you can't even defend yourself at all via PM, especially in a group that has such limited communication ability, you're my target. As I said in my initial lynch post, they can change that completely by sending me a PM and not just posting on the forum.

eh... I don't always reply to those kinds of PMs. For all she knows, you could be a wolf trying to get her role.

 

[Emiloo4]

40 minutes ago she posted.

 

[nyanko]

eh... I don't always reply to those kinds of PMs. For all she knows, you could be a wolf trying to get her role.

Yeah, I am super wary of those too to be honest.