WW: Mysterious Planet Official Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members do not see this ad.
TigerWillow said:
Honestly-

The JMJ vote was brought up by Krist.

IPB was suspicious about JMJ from her words during the WS lynch
I agreed with IPB. Since IPB turned out to be a villager, I knew that that hunch wasn't bogus.

But other than that I had nothing. I removed my vote and am still undecided.
Click to expand...

What happened to Krist btw? She and LIS has been guiding voices for me in the past lynches. Krist, why JMJ??? You don't need to give specifics if it's sensitive but give us something please. Degree of suspicion even would help us out a lot
 
orca2011 said:
I'm honestly considering putting my vote out there for JMJ. She's only posted a few times, and if I recall correctly, none if it has really been useful. I thinking voting to elect a leader just to add diversity is weird, and for some reason her telling Wildcat she should have had time to fix her "Lynch LIS" post just rubbed me the wrong way. It's nothing solid, but it's just a hunch.
Click to expand...

That helps. Thanks
 
nyanko said:
Hm well it's on fire so of these biomes I'd say desert would probably fit best..
Click to expand...

Lissarae06 said:
For serious though, wiki mentions Egypt so I would say desert.
Click to expand...

So for the most part, everything points to dessert.

He was investigated when the terrain was a forest... since he is a forest creature and the terrain was forest, he was camouflaged and escaped investigation. 😕
 
Okay, the more I re-read the thread the more confused I get. Not sure I got any new info or suspicions in the last hour or whatever it's been.
Minnerbelle said:
so HAS cuilt actually been investigated after the resurrection?
Click to expand...
Someone please do so if it hasn't already been done.
nyanko said:
Hm well it's on fire so of these biomes I'd say desert would probably fit best..
Click to expand...
👍
 
I am a sad panda....

I have to leave now.. 🙁

Ksmi, will close out the lynch.. Hey, Ksmi... text me with who they lynch once day is over... 😀

Happy Lynching everyone!! 🙂

When I get home, I will let you know how I liked Magic Mike... Gentlmen of pre-vet you may not care...
 
Minnerbelle said:
That helps. Thanks
Click to expand...

It's not much, but all I really have on her. Also, she didn't vote for WS and was towards the end of the voting for Kakuru. She also didn't vote for SQ, who we're all pretty sure was a wolf, right? Not that not voting means anything, I know I've missed quite a few cause of work and forgetting to put in contingency votes for the cycle during the earlier part of the day.
 
Seriously? I come out with that and everyone just disappears?! :laugh:
 
Lissarae06 said:
I have reasons to trust SOV. I know not everyone trusts me right now but I thought I would put that out there.
Click to expand...

I can't say I trust you lissa, so I can't take that and run with it. I would like to know a little bit about what those reasons are (in general terms), or hear it from someone else. Not that it matters too much since neither of you stick out enough to be on my lynch list right now. I really don't have any reasons to believe either of you is a wolf. But I don't have any reasons to believe you are villagers either.

(not that it's likely, but man, how much of a doozy would we be in if SOV and lissa were actually in kahoots with each other in that keb desert)
 
Minnerbelle said:
I can't say I trust you lissa, so I can't take that and run with it. I would like to know a little bit about what those reasons are (in general terms), or hear it from someone else. Not that it matters too much since neither of you stick out enough to be on my lynch list right now. I really don't have any reasons to believe either of you is a wolf. But I don't have any reasons to believe you are villagers either.

(not that it's likely, but man, how much of a doozy would we be in if SOV and lissa were actually in kahoots with each other in that keb desert)
Click to expand...

I don't feel comfortable revealing more info. If SOV wants to come out with it, he can.
 
A Phoenix has to be good though. Or at least Harry potter has me blindly convinced of that!!

I just can't get on board with lynching trem. And I have no clue why we we're even suspicious of JMJ other than Krist's hunch.

Also, anyone else notice how just equineconstant and I have posted??? Or am I just missing SnS, wildcatj, and nohikas posts amongst this mess? Where's the rest of zora tundra?!
 
That's my point, he claims to be a phoenix, but upon investigation came back as a forest creature... it doesn't add up.
 
Lissarae06 said:
I don't feel comfortable revealing more info. If SOV wants to come out with it, he can.
Click to expand...

That's fine. Like I said, doesn't really matter right now. I just wanted to bring it up so that people don't count him out entirely just because of his possible antics. He's a tricky one, is all I was trying to say. If anyone can clear him then that would be helpful.
 
I know I'm sticking my neck out here and if SOV is a wolf, will most likely be dead soon, but
Lynch SOV

That is by far the most evidence I have for someone to be lynched.
 
Katie8 said:
I just can't get on board with lynching trem. And I have no clue why we we're even suspicious of JMJ other than Krist's hunch.
Click to expand...

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Katie8 said:
Also, anyone else notice how just equineconstant and I have posted??? Or am I just missing SnS, wildcatj, and nohikas posts amongst this mess? Where's the rest of zora tundra?!
Click to expand...

are you just talking about your group? Cause there are a ton of people missing in this discussion. it's friday night before 4th of july... i can't blame them
 
Minnerbelle said:
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍



are you just talking about your group? Cause there are a ton of people missing in this discussion. it's friday night before 4th of july... i can't blame them
Click to expand...


Speaking of, after this lynch, I may not be around for a few cycles. I have 60-70 people showing up at my house for our annual 4th of July tomorrow, and will most likely be preparing and cooking in the morning. I will try to check in but won't be able to read the thread very well. 👍
 
I am trying really hard to follow this, but I am really sleep deprived (up for 22.5 hours straight). Trematode seems to have more evidence against her atm than JMJ. In group PMs, people mentioned that JMJ stood up for WS in the beginning of the game, I *think* that is where the votes for JMJ are based.

So right now, for me it is between lynching typos and confusing famous (sorry, thought that was funny!) SDNers or a WS defender. Neither is a really strong case right now. Sorry Trem, I know you sound desperate in your defense, but that almost makes it worse...

lynch Trematode

Off to sleep now.
 
Emiloo4 said:
That's my point, he claims to be a phoenix, but upon investigation came back as a forest creature... it doesn't add up.
Click to expand...

Just got back from the movies, Ted was hilarious, way better than some movie about male strippers😎.

Anyway that is a pretty interesting finding, I don't think of a phoenix being considered a forest creature. Did the investigation say his creature name or just that he was a forest creature?
 
Minnerbelle said:
Wait, so he WAS INVESTIGATED? And it was a forest creature? Did the investigation just only say what terrain that person is from?
Click to expand...

HE WAS investigated... the investigation came back saying that it appeared (yes, their word, not mine) SOV is a forest creature and bc the terrain was forest that night, he was well camouflaged and therefore it couldn't be determined who he was.

So according to investigation... he is a FOREST creature. Now, maybe DVM made him a forest creature this game...no clue, but there ya go!
 
Yeah... He was investigated???

And glad to know one of you is still out there
 
Emiloo4 said:
I know I'm sticking my neck out here and if SOV is a wolf, will most likely be dead soon, but
Lynch SOV

That is by far the most evidence I have for someone to be lynched.
Click to expand...

hmm, missed this whole discussion in writing up my trem/jmj debate

might have to waffle, will try and stay awake a little longer
 
Emiloo4 said:
Speaking of, after this lynch, I may not be around for a few cycles. I have 60-70 people showing up at my house for our annual 4th of July tomorrow, and will most likely be preparing and cooking in the morning. I will try to check in but won't be able to read the thread very well. 👍
Click to expand...

Same here. I'm not sure how much I'm going to be around after tonight so I'm trying to get as much useful discussion flowing as I can (kind of hoping I'll get attacked by wolves tonight so I can be on my merry way and still feel accomplished)
 
Edit: Maybe DVM made a phoenix a forest creature*
 
Emiloo4 said:
HE WAS investigated... the investigation came back saying that it appeared (yes, their word, not mine) SOV is a forest creature and bc the terrain was forest that night, he was well camouflaged and therefore it couldn't be determined who he was.

So according to investigation... he is a FOREST creature. Now, maybe DVM made him a forest creature this game...no clue, but there ya go!
Click to expand...

A Phoenix does not seem like a forest creature ....

And how convenient to tell the thread a role that can't be investigated 1/4 of the time.
 
TigerWillow said:
It's obvious. Lynch the ostrich
Click to expand...

tumblr_m5f7zhFRm01r6xrn3o1_400.gif
 
Emiloo4 said:
HE WAS investigated... the investigation came back saying that it appeared (yes, their word, not mine) SOV is a forest creature and bc the terrain was forest that night, he was well camouflaged and therefore it couldn't be determined who he was.

So according to investigation... he is a FOREST creature. Now, maybe DVM made him a forest creature this game...no clue, but there ya go!
Click to expand...

Totally didn't know he was investigated. I read each page rather quickly (more than skimming though) in case I needed to respond to something to defend myself, so it's possible I missed any earlier reference. Was partially focuses on myself. 😳

But this is definitely an interesting bit of information. I would think of a Phoenix as being a forest creature either.
 
Emiloo4 said:
HE WAS investigated... the investigation came back saying that it appeared (yes, their word, not mine) SOV is a forest creature and bc the terrain was forest that night, he was well camouflaged and therefore it couldn't be determined who he was.

So according to investigation... he is a FOREST creature. Now, maybe DVM made him a forest creature this game...no clue, but there ya go!
Click to expand...

"appeared" key word there. If the mods used that i would be suspicious if the creature could actually be investigated. I'm confused now on what to believe about SOV. Since he just came out and said he can't be killed at night, that makes him a prime lynch target for the wolves. Sooo emiloo is now gunning for him....

I don't know what to believe
 
I am currently moving into my new house which is why I haven't really been on in the last few hours.

I was gonna defend Trematode due to her telling me her role. And it matches with what she said it was on here.

But.

Then she threatened to make me look really suspicious on the thread if I don't defend her. Which I really don't like. Threaten me to defend her? Really? That's not how you get a person to trust you. Which I don't know!

And I really don't trust SOV now with the news I just read about him being a Phoenix and forest creature at the same time. Yea, no.
 
Katie8 said:
"appeared" key word there. If the mods used that i would be suspicious if the creature could actually be investigated. I'm confused now on what to believe about SOV. Since he just came out and said he can't be killed at night, that makes him a prime lynch target for the wolves. Sooo emiloo is now gunning for him....

I don't know what to believe
Click to expand...

That's a good point as well. I know in the Clue game, I was a wolf who "appeared to be Brad Pitt."
 
Katie8 said:
"appeared" key word there. If the mods used that i would be suspicious if the creature could actually be investigated. I'm confused now on what to believe about SOV. Since he just came out and said he can't be killed at night, that makes him a prime lynch target for the wolves. Sooo emiloo is now gunning for him....

I don't know what to believe
Click to expand...

I am only voting for him because it is really really weird to me and as far as I have seen, the only concrete anything I have on anyone. So I'm sticking with it. I could be completely wrong, so y'all do what you want, but that's who I'm sticking with.
 
Katie8 said:
"appeared" key word there. If the mods used that i would be suspicious if the creature could actually be investigated. I'm confused now on what to believe about SOV. Since he just came out and said he can't be killed at night, that makes him a prime lynch target for the wolves. Sooo emiloo is now gunning for him....

I don't know what to believe
Click to expand...


and this is also why I made sure to include "appear" bc I know exactly what you mean 👍
 
Katie8 said:
"appeared" key word there. If the mods used that i would be suspicious if the creature could actually be investigated. I'm confused now on what to believe about SOV. Since he just came out and said he can't be killed at night, that makes him a prime lynch target for the wolves. Sooo emiloo is now gunning for him....

I don't know what to believe
Click to expand...

explain your thought for me cause my brain is fried. are you trying to say that the word "appeared" was there to mean that he is indeed a phoenix from the desert... but somehow this camouflage is supposed to help him not be detected as such?
 
Until my planet leadership conference commences ,

lynch SOV

Will change vote if someone tells me something important.
 
Where is SOV??? I'd like to hear a defense.
 
Katie8 said:
Sooo emiloo is now gunning for him....
Click to expand...
To be fair, I PM'ed emiloo and my question led us to talking about SOV. Obviously I can't be sure if our discussion led her to post or not.

In any event, I'm also going to vote to lynch SOV for now.

If he's benevolent then I think we need to go after Emiloo's source next.
 
So because I'm suspicious now, nobody listens to what I have to say? Ok.. Back to reading then.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
54K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
86 87 88 89 90
Replies
4K
Views
47K
WildZoo
WildZoo
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
39K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
250
Views
16K
supershorty
supershorty
Top