WW: Mysterious Planet Official Game Thread

[Katie8]

---

Members do not see this ad.

explain your thought for me cause my brain is fried. are you trying to say that the word "appeared" was there to mean that he is indeed a phoenix from the desert... but somehow this camouflage is supposed to help him not be detected as such?

Yes, appeared isn't definitive. As having been a mod it's a good use of a word to give players when the character cant be investigated/doesnt give real results but yet out can't outright tell the other players that. I could be completely off base. But the use of "appears" makes me think the investigation results emiloo received were not true to SOVs real identity which is why I cannot vote to lynch for him

With all the SOs out there, I'm going with one of them being a bad guy sooo lynch Varzs

I'm not compelled enough to vote for any of the front runners. Might look bad for me later if one of them is a wolf but what can you do

 

[Minnerbelle]

Where is SOV??? I'd like to hear a defense.

yeah and lissa, at this point it might be good to divulge that info you didn't want to give earlier.

question. where exactly was this investigation posted? i would think that SOV is smarter than to claim that he's a phoenix when it's already been posted that he was investigated as a forest critter.

 

[StartingoverVet]

ok.... so here it goes...

1) I am a forest creature. I have one other ability besides resurrection which I can only do when the planet is a forest. Lissarae and the leaders know what it is, it is not the most important role, but it adds value. Why did DVMD put me in the forest? I have no idea, and never thought about it.

2) I have no ability to camouflage stated in my role. Unless everyone is camouflaged when their region is the planet, then stating I was investigated and camouflaged is an out and out lie.

therefore
Unlynch trematode.
lynch emiloo4, because I think she is caught in a lie. She and her fellow wolves are trying to get rid of me the only way I can. I am sure they figure there is no way this false investigation would bite them in the butt, as I was just a camouflaging forest creature.

 

[TigerWillow]

unlynch SOv

Planetary conference revealed something vital.

 

[Lissarae06]

Well SOV can't be lynched anyways. Without revealing what his role is, it works on forest days. Thanks to TW, I just went back and found a message he sent me that said that.

 

[Minnerbelle]

So because I'm suspicious now, nobody listens to what I have to say? Ok.. Back to reading then.

well you just confirmed that her role is what she told you (which is helpful, thank you). i'm not especially interested in tisk tisking each other's behavior on PM's though... which is why i had nothing to say to that.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Well SOV can't be lynched anyways. Without revealing what his role is, it works on forest days. Thanks to TW, I just went back and found a message he sent me that said that.

Yes, this is true. I cannot be lynched. I was trying to hold that back, as at least one piece of information the wolves wouldn't understand...

I'm a Phoenix girls. I get reborn whenever I die. Get it?

 

[cuitlamiztli]

unlynch SOv

Planetary conference revealed something vital.

Times like this I really wish I could communicate with the desert group leader. Then I'd pass the info emiloo shared with me so you could see how it compares to your info.

Not sure if I should share the info here since emiloo's around?

 

[cuitlamiztli]

Unlynch SOV.

 

[Emiloo4]

Times like this I really wish I could communicate with the desert group leader. Then I'd pass the info emiloo shared with me so you could see how it compares to your info.

Not sure if I should share the info here since emiloo's around?

Writing... h/o

 

[Minnerbelle]

2) I have no ability to camouflage stated in my role. Unless everyone is camouflaged when their region is the planet, then stating I was investigated and camouflaged is an out and out lie.

therefore
Unlynch trematode.
lynch emiloo4, because I think she is caught in a lie. She and her fellow wolves are trying to get rid of me the only way I can. I am sure they figure there is no way this false investigation would bite them in the butt, as I was just a camouflaging forest creature.

oh wait... this investigation thing was something that emiloo JUST came out and said? Not something posted earlier by someone else that we all forgot about?

Unlynch SOV

 

[StartingoverVet]

I kind of feel like we have forced the wolves hands a little. More lies are out in the open.

I feel good about what has happened.

Do we have a recent tally?

 

[Katie8]

i would think that SOV is smarter than to claim that he's a phoenix when it's already been posted that he was investigated as a forest critter.

👍

Alright SOV, I'll bite. I do think it's weird emiloo is gunning for you like that after we've pretty much discovered lynching is the only way you'll die.

unlynch Varzs
Lynch Emiloo

 

[Lissarae06]

Yes, this is true. I cannot be lynched. I was trying to hold that back, as at least one piece of information the wolves wouldn't understand...

I'm a Phoenix girls. I get reborn whenever I die. Get it?

Sorry, I thought you had already said it 😳

 

[cuitlamiztli]

Writing... h/o

👍

 

[Katie8]

👍

Alright SOV, I'll bite. I do think it's weird emiloo is gunning for you like that after we've pretty much discovered lynching is the only way you'll die.

unlynch Varzs
Lynch Emiloo

Merp. Just saw your post about you can't be lynched either. Shoot why don't we just lynch you every time we aren't sure if we have a wolf or not and then we save all the villagers. Hello?! Best idea ever?!?!

 

[Emiloo4]

ok.... so here it goes...

1) I am a forest creature. I have one other ability besides resurrection which I can only do when the planet is a forest. Lissarae and the leaders know what it is, it is not the most important role, but it adds value. Why did DVMD put me in the forest? I have no idea, and never thought about it.

2) I have no ability to camouflage stated in my role. Unless everyone is camouflaged when their region is the planet, then stating I was investigated and camouflaged is an out and out lie.

therefore
Unlynch trematode.
lynch emiloo4, because I think she is caught in a lie. She and her fellow wolves are trying to get rid of me the only way I can. I am sure they figure there is no way this false investigation would bite them in the butt, as I was just a camouflaging forest creature.

Please show me ONE shred of evidence where I have acted like a wolf.
Second, what's the lie you caught me in? It didn't say your ROLE was that you can camouflage, it was the mods way of saying you evaded investigation I guess? I assume its her being clever with wording. No idea.
This is a rather brash defense of telling me that I'm lying about something when I clearly stated information I received.

 

[StartingoverVet]

i would think that SOV is smarter than to claim that he's a phoenix when it's already been posted that he was investigated as a forest critter.

This just came out in the effort to discredit me.
And don't forget, I invited people to investigate me... I am not worried about what they find... Even if you guys were right that I had a 1/4 chance of evading, would you risk your life on those odds? Not me. I have bigger fish (i.e. wolves) to fry.

 

[heylodeb]

I'm just staying with my vote. who the hell knows if it is right or not.

oh sheesh. waffles sound good.

 

[Emiloo4]

oh wait... this investigation thing was something that emiloo JUST came out and said? Not something posted earlier by someone else that we all forgot about?

Unlynch SOV

He was just investigated last night (I believe) because the seer that investigated him can only investigate when the terrain is forest. Obviously I have a direct link to this person.... soo......not sure what else I can say without outing a seer, which I'm not gonna do. I would rather die, then out a seer since they can help us way more than I can.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Please show me ONE shred of evidence where I have acted like a wolf.
Second, what's the lie you caught me in? It didn't say your ROLE was that you can camouflage, it was the mods way of saying you evaded investigation I guess? I assume its her being clever with wording. No idea.
This is a rather brash defense of telling me that I'm lying about something when I clearly stated information I received.

It's all about spin. Before you made it sound like I am guilty because i evade investigation. now you blame the mods for the way they presented it.

Perhaps you are innocent, or perhaps you are trying to get rid of a thorn in the wolves side. Too bad it can't work.

 

[Emiloo4]

Merp. Just saw your post about you can't be lynched either. Shoot why don't we just lynch you every time we aren't sure if we have a wolf or not and then we save all the villagers. Hello?! Best idea ever?!?!

SOV can't be lynched?

 

[TigerWillow]

lynch Emiloo

You have been involved in two explanations. I think that's kinda suspicious in itself.


If you turn out to be a wolf I know who to lynch next.

 

[heylodeb]

Merp. Just saw your post about you can't be lynched either. Shoot why don't we just lynch you every time we aren't sure if we have a wolf or not and then we save all the villagers. Hello?! Best idea ever?!?!

she has a point here! we might want to just lynch SOV, anyway??

 

[Minnerbelle]

This just came out in the effort to discredit me.
And don't forget, I invited people to investigate me... I am not worried about what they find... Even if you guys were right that I had a 1/4 chance of evading, would you risk your life on those odds? Not me. I have bigger fish (i.e. wolves) to fry.

From what she said, i was under the impression that emiloo had remembered a post from before, not that she just came up with it.

But inviting investigation and actually having been investigated are two different things ya know? You can "invite" and investigation and then give reasons why others are higher priority to evade investigation. That's why I kept asking if someone actually had investigated you. I just wanted to know for sure

 

[Katie8]

Yes, this is true. I cannot be lynched. I was trying to hold that back, as at least one piece of information the wolves wouldn't understand...

I'm a Phoenix girls. I get reborn whenever I die. Get it?

Yeah!!! Right here he says it. Sooo why aren't we saving an innocent and lynching the man who will be resurrected anyway?!

 

[Lissarae06]

unlynch trematode
lynch emiloo

 

[StartingoverVet]

SOV can't be lynched?

That is not true. I can be lynched. I just don't stay dead.

 

[Emiloo4]

It's all about spin. Before you made it sound like I am guilty because i evade investigation. now you blame the mods for the way they presented it.

Perhaps you are innocent, or perhaps you are trying to get rid of a thorn in the wolves side. Too bad it can't work.

All I was trying to do is be helpful and come out with what I know. I didn't make you sound guilty because you could evade, the whole reason I thought you were guilty is because you were a FOREST creature which just didnt add up. Villagers can evade investigation too I'm sure, but you avoiding investigation was not my reason. Your role not adding up to a seer's info was!

 

[orca2011]

Not quite sure who to believe, but I guess Lynch Emiloo

 

[cuitlamiztli]

she has a point here! we might want to just lynch SOV, anyway??

That's one way to find out the truth I guess.

 

[Minnerbelle]

she has a point here! we might want to just lynch SOV, anyway??

i kind of like that idea, but i kind of wonder if the mods will get mad and give the wolves extra resurrection/conversion powers to speed things up...

 

[Lissarae06]

Yeah!!! Right here he says it. Sooo why aren't we saving an innocent and lynching the man who will be resurrected anyway?!

If we just keep lynching SOV, we will never get a wolf while the wolves will just keep killing villagers.

 

[Emiloo4]

Alright, you guys are dumb, whatever. Really really have no idea how anything I just said makes me suspicious. So much for sticking my neck out and trying to help. Peace out.

 

[heylodeb]

i kind of like that idea, but i kind of wonder if the mods will get mad and give the wolves extra resurrection/conversion powers to speed things up...

well, for now, it is a good test to see if he is telling the truth or not? I dunno.....does seem to be a consequence perhaps the mod didn't think of.

 

[cuitlamiztli]

All I was trying to do is be helpful and come out with what I know. I didn't make you sound guilty because you could evade, the whole reason I thought you were guilty is because you were a FOREST creature which just didnt add up. Villagers can evade investigation too I'm sure, but you avoiding investigation was not my reason. Your role not adding up to a seer's info was!

In her defense (don't care if this makes me look guilty, but someone here is getting played by a wolf somewhere along the line) this is basically what she told me via PM.

Now, do I waffle back to my original vote? Ugh.

 

[zanydogz]

OMG I'm so confused right now...will someone please update me on what's going on? I tried reading through everything and 😕

For now, since deadline is coming up, lynch emiloo I feel we have more evidence against her than trem or jmj for now...

 

[Jamr0ckin]

Do NOT lynch emiloo. She is being a messenger for me. I am the one providing the information. She is innocent, I promise!

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

 

[PetPony]

Yea I said that she told me that's her role. But her threatening makes me think she's lying. That's what I meant. She could be lying in both pm and the thread, so I don't know how that proves she's innocent.

 

[Minnerbelle]

well, for now, it is a good test to see if he is telling the truth or not? I dunno.....does seem to be a consequence perhaps the mod didn't think of.

i like it. lynch sov

if he's telling the truth, we'll know who isn't. I can't get myself to lynch emiloo when she was trying to be helpful. No one can prove right now if she lied either. it's her words against sov

 

[Emiloo4]

I can't wait to say I told you so, and have you all look back and realize not one thing I said makes me look guilty. You all just lost your **** when SOV came on.

 

[StartingoverVet]

i kind of like that idea, but i kind of wonder if the mods will get mad and give the wolves extra resurrection/conversion powers to speed things up...

Not accusing you, but we lynch suspicious people. If we wait until 100% sure every time, wolves will more likely win the game in my opinion.

To me 1/3 odds of getting a wolf every time = villager victory.
0/3 odd of getting a wolf = villager defeat.

Obviously it won't hurt me personally to lynch me, but it is not a smart strategy mathematically unless we are no good at taking good odds guesses.

IMHO.

 

[orca2011]

unlynch Emiloo and I guess I'll go back to lynch JMJ because I have no idea what is going on and am exhausted.

 

[Emiloo4]

OMG I'm so confused right now...will someone please update me on what's going on? I tried reading through everything and 😕

For now, since deadline is coming up, lynch emiloo I feel we have more evidence against her than trem or jmj for now...

WHAT evidence?!?!?!

 

[cuitlamiztli]

Lynch SOV. Let's see how this turns out.

 

[wildcatj]

Stabbing my eyeballs out from attempting computer programming and now this big mess. I have no freaking clue who to lynch. I don't think I'm comfortable with SOV or emiloo so I guess I'll Lynch JMJ?

 

[Emiloo4]

I wish I knew the vote count so I could at least self preserve 😡

 

[Minnerbelle]

Not accusing you, but we lynch suspicious people. If we wait until 100% sure every time, wolves will more likely win the game in my opinion.

To me 1/3 odds of getting a wolf every time = villager victory.
0/3 odd of getting a wolf = villager defeat.

Obviously it won't hurt me personally to lynch me, but it is not a smart strategy mathematically unless we are no good at taking good odds guesses.

IMHO.

yeah but imho you're still just as suspicious as emiloo. but if we choose emiloo and she was telling the truth, we're out a villager. if we choose you and you were telling the truth, we get you back

 

[StartingoverVet]

good luck trying to tally this vote.

 

[LetItSnow]

I'm guessing you don't want to RNG her role?

*****************************
Put it this way. If DVMD signs up, we're adding a 25th player and I'm creating a special role. 😉
*****************************