WWhere There's a WWhisk, There's a WWay! - Game Thread

[PippyPony]

---

Members don't see this ad.

awww this was my first real game. 😍

I agree I’m not a fan of Mel’s fast start. But I’m also not a fan of the increasing almost bandwagon going against him. So they’re just two things going in my spreadsheet. Good ‘ol day 1 lynches make me feel a certain way.

A bandwagon now = one vote?

 

[SkiOtter]

I agree I’m not a fan of Mel’s fast start. But I’m also not a fan of the increasing almost bandwagon going against him. So they’re just two things going in my spreadsheet. Good ‘ol day 1 lynches make me feel a certain way.

Him as in Cheezit? Or? Because cheez has 1 vote...?

 

[cdo96]

A bandwagon now = one vote?

Was it one? I thought it was a couple. My bad.

Him as in Cheezit? Or? Because cheez has 1 vote...?

Wow okay, I need to not drink and WW.

Paws made the first real strategy lynch, (Finn posts early when wolf) which I’m not a fan of. Mel backed up/ supported the idea. Which I’m also not a fan of. But I’m not ready to hop on either side to say which one is wrong.

 

[SkiOtter]

Wow okay, I need to not drink and WW.

Well you ARE a hydration specialist 😉

 

[WildZoo]

Alright I have arrived, this thread can really start cooking now 😏

 

[PippyPony]

Was it one? I thought it was a couple. My bad.

Wow okay, I need to not drink and WW.

Paws made the first real strategy lynch, (Finn posts early when wolf) which I’m not a fan of. Mel backed up/ supported the idea. Which I’m also not a fan of. But I’m not ready to hop on either side to say which one is wrong.

Cdo, I really did not want to lynch you on D1 of your first game back in a while, but you're already making that tough to stick to.

You don't like people lynching strategically? Lol wat?

 

[WildZoo]

Strategy is bad for the village. Tut tut. Better to sit back and wait for the wolves to reveal themselves.

 

[PippyPony]

Alright I have arrived, this thread can really start cooking now 😏

This is awful

 

[WildZoo]

This is awful

Hey, this is my kitchen, you're all just baking in it
Or, getting baked

Something like that.

 

[nohika]

I will fully admit to not lynching CheezyD for any sort of strategic reason, just the fact that I know they're going to get on my nerves at some point and pre-empting that move. So.

Yes, I am quite the petty human.

 

[cdo96]

Cdo, I really did not want to lynch you on D1 of your first game back in a while, but you're already making that tough to stick to.

You don't like people lynching strategically? Lol wat?

What? No! Of course I like lynching strategically. I just think it’s crap/ poor playing to go “FINNICK IS POSTING EARLY. OBVIOUSLY A WOLF!”

 

[kaydubs]

I just got ninja'd so many times.

Ninja-ception?

 

[kaydubs]

after the day I've had:

That is all.

Edit: Fixed the gif

Omg, me too. I was gonna pack to go home but said nope nope nope

 

[vetmedhead]

Strategy is bad for the village. Tut tut. Better to sit back and wait for the wolves to reveal themselves.

If I've learned anything from James Bond movies it's that the villain will always confess who they are and what their evil plot is before they try to kill anyone, so really I'm expecting some confessions before the end of the first night cycle

 

[Trilt]

What? No! Of course I like lynching strategically. I just think it’s crap/ poor playing to go “FINNICK IS POSTING EARLY. OBVIOUSLY A WOLF!”

Don't mischaracterize.

First of all; Staypos posted about Finn lynching first.
Second; Mel even pointed out that the idea gave her village cred in speed game and bit him. There's justification and consistency there. It doesnt' mean he isn't a wolf (wolves can be consistent fo sho) but your statement of his post is absurd.

Plus. It is day one. You jump on something and push and watch the response. Otherwise it's a bunch of BS random votes and that's no fun. Don't discourage good play.

 

[Trilt]

If I've learned anything from James Bond movies it's that the villain will always confess who they are and what their evil plot is before they try to kill anyone, so really I'm expecting some confessions before the end of the first night cycle

Always in a very dramatic monologue style too. of course.

 

[Karabiner13]

D1 Keep Calm and Bake On Lynch Tally

VA (1) - finn
Paws (1) - capri
Mixy (2) - lawp, KL
finn (2) - paws, VA
Kski (1) - pippy
nohika (1) - am
KL (1) - trilt
vmh (1) - boo
mel (1) - nohika

😏 A tie! 😏

11/24

Deadline Midnight EST Tomorrow (~24.5 hours)

 

[vetmedhead]

Not a mod obviously but I gotchu guys.



Mods in this case can correct me if I'm wrong but generally with activity requirements an extended cycle will still count as one "day".



They are operating as one player. I believe only one of them will actually be posting on the thread in this game.

I believe they are "hydra-ing", which is when two players play as one. Generally happens when people don't have time to commit to the game individually but still want to play.

I'm trying to decide if the above are more "I'm answering this question because these noobs are still green and I want to help them" or "I'm answering this question because look everyone, I'm helping village"

 

[vetmedhead]

Crap, Pos has a point here. Sketch points to Finn

Having wolfed with you in the last game I know you like to spend some time finding other players who are suspicious enough for you to draw up lynches on later in the game when you or another wolf are under fire. This post feels a little bit too much like suspicion farming and I'm keeping my eye on you

awww this was my first real game. 😍

I agree I’m not a fan of Mel’s fast start. But I’m also not a fan of the increasing almost bandwagon going against him. So they’re just two things going in my spreadsheet. Good ‘ol day 1 lynches make me feel a certain way.

But, I recognize cdo's point here (I think her point here?) that Mel is always an easy lynch (&cow) target and while this isn't anything near a bandwagon right now (with a whopping what, one vote?) there has been enough discussion about Mel suspicion for me to see where she's coming from. Mel is also usually all over accusations against him, but he's like that when he's village or wolf so it's hardly diagnostic behavior whether he does it or not

 

[finnickthedog]

I'm trying to decide if the above are more "I'm answering this question because these noobs are still green and I want to help them" or "I'm answering this question because look everyone, I'm helping village"

C. I answered because capri was my manatee and I wanted to feel useful after I spent most of that game letting the other wolfators do most the work

And it would have been super rude to not answer the other question.

 

[PippyPony]

I'm trying to decide if the above are more "I'm answering this question because these noobs are still green and I want to help them" or "I'm answering this question because look everyone, I'm helping village"

Look at the distribution of players on this roster and I think the answer to this question should be pretty apparent.

 

[vetmedhead]

Was it one? I thought it was a couple. My bad.

Wow okay, I need to not drink and WW.

Paws made the first real strategy lynch, (Finn posts early when wolf) which I’m not a fan of. Mel backed up/ supported the idea. Which I’m also not a fan of. But I’m not ready to hop on either side to say which one is wrong.

And see, talking about having bad reading comprehension because of XYZ in order to explain away weak or spotty lynch votes also reads like a total wolf thing to me (I mean, I even did it in my last game lol). AM's thing about disliking people mentioning hydration on thread is probably on some level related to this tendency of some wolves.

 

[vetmedhead]

Anyway was that enough accusations for the evening? I'm going to let these cook and see if I've developed enough salt on thread tomorrow morning

 

[cdo96]

And see, talking about having bad reading comprehension because of XYZ in order to explain away weak or spotty lynch votes also reads like a total wolf thing to me (I mean, I even did it in my last game lol). AM's thing about disliking people mentioning hydration on thread is probably on some level related to this tendency of some wolves.

I’ve never heard of this tendency/ theory before. I haven’t read a game since WWildZoo/ played since SPN, so I mean, it makes sense, as a play. I’ve just never actually seen it done (except for Finn in the one speed game).

 

[Animal Midwife]

I’ve never heard of this tendency/ theory before. I haven’t read a game since WWildZoo/ played since SPN, so I mean, it makes sense, as a play. I’ve just never actually seen it done (except for Finn in the one speed game).

I could write a whole novel about hydrated wolves in rage font and sprinkle it with salt.

 

[LetItSnow]

I dunno guys, I feel like I might have trouble meeting this posting requirement. Three posts a day...yeesh

I'm pretty sure @Mad Jack could meet a 3 post/minute requirement.

 

[LetItSnow]

hey everybody!

Sketchy.

 

[LetItSnow]

Oh boy, the deep end.

Lynch Paws

Because 6 is my unlucky number and I wanted to get a lynch vote in early. 😛 Also I didn’t get a chance to submit a lynch vote with BS Day 1 reasoning last game.

So question for the mods, does the 3 posts per day requirement include today as a separate day from tomorrow even though they’re both technically Day 1? In other words, is it 3 posts today and 3 tomorrow, or just 3 posts between now and lynch deadline?

Is there a reason that you can't submit a lynch vote with non-BS reasoning once the day drags on a bit more?

 

[LetItSnow]

Lynch Finn

cuz wolfy Finn posts early

Just to make sure - I'm reading that as a serious comment. Is it?

(If so, I like it.)

 

[LetItSnow]

Bull. I post early when I have a pre planned vote and you should also know that I've been planning to vote for him since before sign ups were ever even posted because you were there. I'm watching you for this move.

Sketchy. Pretty defensive for a weak-reasoning D1 vote.

 

[LetItSnow]

Iunno if I actually give sketch points to Finn, but I like the thought from Pos. Mel jumping on the justification gets him sketch points. Me jumping into the justification might get me sketch points . . . ?

No. I was feeling exactly the same way.

 

[LetItSnow]

Gonna go with lynch CheezyD because getting it out of the way early.

Boo I actually have to post this game? So rude. I like my lurker strategy. 😛

That's a crappy reason.

... I'm still probably about to vote for him, though, for above-stated reasons.

 

[LetItSnow]

awww this was my first real game. 😍

I agree I’m not a fan of Mel’s fast start. But I’m also not a fan of the increasing almost bandwagon going against him. So they’re just two things going in my spreadsheet. Good ‘ol day 1 lynches make me feel a certain way.

At the time you posted this there was exactly one vote for him.

 

[LetItSnow]

A bandwagon now = one vote?

Serves me right for posting without doing the entire read-through.

 

[LetItSnow]

Better to sit back and wait for the wolves to reveal themselves.

When do you plan to do that?

 

[LetItSnow]

I will fully admit to not lynching CheezyD for any sort of strategic reason, just the fact that I know they're going to get on my nerves at some point and pre-empting that move. So.

Yes, I am quite the petty human.

lynch Nohika for now. I don't like the voting for no reason and then doubling down on voting for no reason.

 

[LetItSnow]

I'm trying to decide if the above are more "I'm answering this question because these noobs are still green and I want to help them" or "I'm answering this question because look everyone, I'm helping village"

FWIW, I read them as the latter.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

A bandwagon now = one vote?

If you played in the last noob game it was
however I'll get an early lynch vote in
###lynch lawper###
Not retaliatory but just because they thought I was wolf way before I was wolf in the noob game and apparently this is what I do ( lynch people with misconceptions from the previous game I played )
Will pry waffle tomorrow when I'm not up super late and have a semi functioning brain.

 

[Mad Jack]

I'm pretty sure @Mad Jack could meet a 3 post/minute requirement.

These days I'm not so post-y. I've nearly been modkilled for inactivity several times, actually...

 

[kaydubs]

D1 Keep Calm and Bake On Lynch Tally

VA (1) - finn
Paws (1) - capri
Mixy (2) - lawp, KL
finn (2) - paws, VA
Kski (1) - pippy
nohika (2) - am, lis
KL (1) - trilt
vmh (1) - boo
mel (1) - nohika
lawp (1) - Mixy

😏 More of a tie! 😏

13/24

Deadline Midnight EST Today/tonight (~18.75 hours)

 

[nohika]

Hey look, justified reasons for lynching CheezyD have appeared since I posted. Am I less suspicious if I claim those?

Also I'm about 99% sure last time I did a petty lynch vote I was a villager. I don't do that stuff as a wolf for exactly this reason.

 

[Melchizedek]

awww this was my first real game. 😍

I agree I’m not a fan of Mel’s fast start. But I’m also not a fan of the increasing almost bandwagon going against him. So they’re just two things going in my spreadsheet. Good ‘ol day 1 lynches make me feel a certain way.

I've said it multiple times, but I hate the random voting stage of D1 and will push the game through it by backing logic and watching reactions.

Hey look, justified reasons for lynching CheezyD have appeared since I posted. Am I less suspicious if I claim those?

Also I'm about 99% sure last time I did a petty lynch vote I was a villager. I don't do that stuff as a wolf for exactly this reason.

Hmm except for the fact that what everyone is pointing out as me being sketchy happened BEFORE you voted for me.

ETA: What I'm getting at is that this smells like a wolf seeing people getting suspicious of me for a flimsy reason and trying to galvanize suspicion into a lynch.

This then leads to a tin-foil-hat theory that Egg is aware of Nohika's plan through wolfchat (thats why she was expecting a bandwagon) and playing against Nohika to get village cred for pseudo defending a villager. (Kind of accusing Egg of doing what I did to Dy in Michigan WW)

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Cdo, I really did not want to lynch you on D1 of your first game back in a while, but you're already making that tough to stick to.

You don't like people lynching strategically? Lol wat?

I feel like mistaking one vote for a bandwagon is more villagey then wolf atm. But if she's hydrated then I guess could be either.

I'm trying to decide if the above are more "I'm answering this question because these noobs are still green and I want to help them" or "I'm answering this question because look everyone, I'm helping village"

That's what I was trying to decide with Finn. Her comment made me think wolfy. Though I haven't played with her much to know I that's normal. I don't think pips is more or less helpful as a wolf vs village.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Eh for now

Lynch Allie

To get her talking because she's normally quieter. Might switch to a Finn vote though.

 

[Skyerien]

Yesterday I drove to Tennessee for an interview and now I'm on my way to Missouri for an interview. Crazy!!!

####lynch lawp#### for saying hello, haha.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Hi lawper! 🙂

Also

###Lynch Fynn!!!!

Cuz really, what did I do? Stupid meanie head. Hang for your crimes!

I don't like this. Seems way too comfortable and familiar with the other player.

I look forward to your tenacity this game!

Don't like this for the same reason I don't like Asparagus (except I hate Asparagus IRL)

Hey look, justified reasons for lynching CheezyD have appeared since I posted. Am I less suspicious if I claim those?

Also I'm about 99% sure last time I did a petty lynch vote I was a villager. I don't do that stuff as a wolf for exactly this reason.

Poor reasoning and trying to use the I don't do this as wolf strategy... will keep this in mind but I don't like it.

I've said it multiple times, but I hate the random voting stage of D1 and will push the game through it by backing logic and watching reactions.

Hmm except for the fact that what everyone is pointing out as me being sketchy happened BEFORE you voted for me.

ETA: What I'm getting at is that this smells like a wolf seeing people getting suspicious of me for a flimsy reason and trying to galvanize suspicion into a lynch.

This then leads to a tin-foil-hat theory that Egg is aware of Nohika's plan through wolfchat (thats why she was expecting a bandwagon) and playing against Nohika to get village cred for pseudo defending a villager. (Kind of accusing Egg of doing what I did to Dy in Michigan WW)

Personally, I don't like Mel's tin-foil-hat theories in general...especially this early in the game.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I don't like this. Seems way too comfortable and familiar with the other player.

Too familiar with Lawper or finn?

 

[LetItSnow]

Hey look, justified reasons for lynching CheezyD have appeared since I posted. Am I less suspicious if I claim those?

Also I'm about 99% sure last time I did a petty lynch vote I was a villager. I don't do that stuff as a wolf for exactly this reason.

So you only vote meaningfully when you're a wolf?

That's ... super helpful for the village.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Too familiar with Lawper or finn?

Too familiar with Lawper.

 

[Trilt]

So you only vote meaningfully when you're a wolf?

That's ... super helpful for the village.

Theres a reason I lynch her a lot...