WWild WWedding Afterparty Game Thread - A Pipsy & Jbooze Production

[Crayola227]

---

Members do not see this ad.

When I wolfed with Jboo she assigned posting restrictions to people and they posted all day.

****. What game was this? I thought she was the one posting in Teen Wolf memes the noob game. What are you talking about?

 

[Crayola227]

This literally never happened😵

I'll dig up the quote because I know I called you out on it.

 

[SARdoghandler]

********
Someone spilled some salt
**********

***************
The shares in the salt mine I bought last game and doubled down on this game are paying dividends
***************

 

[Crayola227]

Also if I was a wolf, I would know if tarty or coops ate village and since chaos doesn’t count for village numbers and I’d want to lose as many villagers as possible, I’D VOTE THE VILLAGERS NOT THE CONFIRMED CHAOS.

maybe that is what you would do, it seems to me you are contradicting yourself, but this is hardly wolf strategy that goes without saying, plenty of wolves will try to eliminate 3rd party immediately because they can actually be more dangerous alive than the trade off of not reducing village number right away going with a different lynch/NK choice

um, so pointing out people's bad reasoning isn't game content to help village on my part, uh, OK

 

[Crayola227]

I wanted AM to move on

why cater to that, exactly? I see the point about eggs and cracking, but I just don't understand the way people have been voting lately

 

[tartesos]

why would voting Coffee mean you would be NK'd?

I broke a tie and became the lead lynch target when I moved my vote from coop to coffee..... 4 to 3.
Take it as you may.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

 

[MOOSEygoosey]

****. What game was this? I thought she was the one posting in Teen Wolf memes the noob game. What are you talking about?

WW colorado

 

[jaboo]

I remember because they made jboo, who was wolf, have to post as teen wolf, which was hilarious, I remember that distinctly.

~~~~~~~~
I had to post only in wolf memes/gifs. Teen wolf was a loophole I found and I’m very proud of it 🙂
~~~~~~~~

 

[DVMDream]

*********************************

********************************

 

[Animal Midwife]

Activity level especially from Mel means nothing in that it's NAI. Maybe for others being quiet is wolfy. But the fact that Mel is more active than another player means nothing. So yeah in every universe this reasoning of yours makes no sense.

Did I say anything about activity? I was referring to content.

 

[Melchizedek]

According to Mel,
REASONS
*eye roll*

no not REASONS

its


~REASONS~

Get it right 🙄

@allieh8607 def a IDGAF attitude

Not convinced AM was trying in earnest to vig kill a wolf, maybe that was staged somehow. Also, what was the timing of her doing that with regards the lynch that day?

Coffee as confirmed chaos. WTF are you getting this? I'm not saying it isn't possible or I don't see the concerns, but this smacks of Coop's comments on genny, I'm really surprised to see hypocrisy from Mel in the form of just lazy playing and pushing unsupported crap.

I did not ****ing side step you about explaining Lawper D1. I answered it and also referred to a lengthier post in the sign up thread. You guys seriously don't think I type enough? I reserve the right to say I already ****ing told you even though more than 1/2 the time I end up retyping shyte anyway. What about D1 revenge vote for the game he won as a noob wolf don't you understand? What about unlynching him when he was danger because I am partial to him from preallo and didn't want to lose him D1 when I don't get to play with him often is sidestepping? Because I know between this thread and the other one that is what I ****ing said.

****ing quit with your lies and bullshyte Mel. I've admitted where I was wrong at every point. You just continue to repeat the same BS that is unsupported even when you're called out.

The rest of your points are well taken but hardly excuses the other issues here with you.

Nevermind half your reads are even more vague than you accuse me of. I might not dig up all the quotes (which tend to be present in my PbPa replies with my thoughts on them) but I always offer at least 1 sentence on why I think what I think. Explain Kara, Coffee, and Paws.

Kara - actually encouraging discussion on a day when people where hunkering down on a Coops vote
Coffee - ****ING CHAOS BECAUSE SHE *****ING TOLD ME SO
Paws - Look at her ISO. She's been pressuring people, questioning their reads, and refuting stupidity.

WHATCHU GOT?

*May be slightlyl hydrated.





Y'all can lynch me or

Spoiler

erryday I be trollin

 

[SkiOtter]

*May be slightlyl hydrated.

******
Slightlyl
******

 

[WildZoo]

*May be slightlyl hydrated.

*********
@Animal Midwife
**********

 

[Melchizedek]

I am literally so done with this village right now I actually asked the mods to pass a message to the wolves that I'm ready to be converted because running this game as a wolf would be INSTAWIN.

 

[MOOSEygoosey]

I am literally so done with this village right now I actually asked the mods to pass a message to the wolves that I'm ready to be converted because running this game as a wolf would be INSTAWIN.

Would you like us to lynch you?

 

[Melchizedek]

Would you like us to lynch you?

PLZ AND THNK YOU

 

[Crayola227]

I broke a tie and became the lead lynch target when I moved my vote from coop to coffee..... 4 to 3.
Take it as you may.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

still don't get why this would lead to you being NK'd, perhaps I'm just too tired

 

[MOOSEygoosey]

PLZ AND THNK YOU

 

[Crayola227]

no not REASONS

its


~REASONS~

Get it right 🙄

@allieh8607 def a IDGAF attitude

Kara - actually encouraging discussion on a day when people where hunkering down on a Coops vote
Coffee - ****ING CHAOS BECAUSE SHE *****ING TOLD ME SO
Paws - Look at her ISO. She's been pressuring people, questioning their reads, and refuting stupidity.

WHATCHU GOT?

*May be slightlyl hydrated.





Y'all can lynch me or

Spoiler

erryday I be trollin

Fair enough.

Can you tell us more about this reveal of Coffee to you?

 

[Melchizedek]

@bryndiana.jones now is a good night to use it.

 

[Melchizedek]

Fair enough.

Can you tell us more about this reveal of Coffee to you?

wolf

 

[Animal Midwife]

*********
@Animal Midwife
**********

 

[MOOSEygoosey]

View attachment 238242

Care to share your thoughts now?

 

[allieh8607]

PLZ AND THNK YOU

Ooooo you don't have to tell me twice.... but something something reverse psychology and all that jazz

 

[Melchizedek]

Ooooo you don't have to tell me twice.... but something something reverse psychology and all that jazz

I'm just here for the likes

 

[WildZoo]

I'm just here for the likes

**********
Oooo you're so close to 2:1
***********

 

[Melchizedek]

Oh p.s.

If I die tonight lynch AM and the Cray in that order.

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Anyway moving on with my thoughts from mel Bryn would be my next candidate. Besides the tie she has casted shade while being noncommittal to it in general with some of her suspects but also particularly when pushing mel she pursued interrogation but didn't seem to take any steak at all when he refused to answer and instead called him out for his play style instead.
After bryn less in depth reads off memory I could go paws, lawper or lotf. Paws a few of her reads have gone from wolf to village without many posts imo to sway a player from one end to the other and she's a good wolf so it wouldn't surprise me. Lotf I just don't have a great read overall and is more of a mystery to me than others. Lawper not liking his play mostly votes and not much substance.

 

[Lawpy]

Oh p.s.

If I die tonight lynch AM and the Cray in that order.

why AM?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

why cater to that, exactly? I see the point about eggs and cracking, but I just don't understand the way people have been voting lately

If you look at my list of abilities I believe the wolf abilities were listed at the top.
Coop and tarter sauce did not reveal to be any of these abilities. Thus I theorized that in fact there was not a wolf up for lynch today. Between tarter and coop, though coop has a more beneficial ability, she also explicitly said she won't be around much from now on and it made sense to select the more active villager to save. As well as get AM off of that so she can move her focus elsewhere because itd be good to have her discussing something else

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Anyway moving on with my thoughts from mel Bryn would be my next candidate. Besides the tie she has casted shade while being noncommittal to it in general with some of her suspects but also particularly when pushing mel she pursued interrogation but didn't seem to take any steak at all when he refused to answer and instead called him out for his play style instead.
After bryn less in depth reads off memory I could go paws, lawper or lotf. Paws a few of her reads have gone from wolf to village without many posts imo to sway a player from one end to the other and she's a good wolf so it wouldn't surprise me. Lotf I just don't have a great read overall and is more of a mystery to me than others. Lawper not liking his play mostly votes and not much substance.

How many times do you want me to ask him the same question when he is clearly avoiding it? Then he posted reads afterwards so....that's what I wanted and why would I pester him with the "who if not coop?" after that? How have I casted shade and been noncommittal? I have been on tart and have mentioned others because y'all have been asking, but I can only vote for one.

 

[Crayola227]

Late to party, as usual.

### unlynch Lawper ###

Don't really want him to die D1 on a joke vote, I don't know if he's been shady for realz since I voted. I'm partial to him as well, and I haven't played with him in like forever. Isn't this his first time in a while?

I also don't want a last minute waffle to lead to a bunch of ties or his death, but we'll see. Not sure where to put my vote now.

I said in sign up. Revenge for the game where you won as the noob solo wolf cub. Plus I'm partial to you for being from the allo side.

my instinct said, always a good move, I read this as village, but then I thought that was probably what you wanted me to think, and this would be a sneaky way for wolf genny to get Mel out of the way early with little risk. He's easy to start joke bandwagons on

I'm awake, I'm just enjoying you ranting away
Unfortunately I can't argue with you because I have yet to see you take a coherent stance on anything worth arguing about haha

How do you feel about lawper?

very good question, I should reread his stuff, because he was saying stuff and it seemed like he did have more of an agenda than I expected for a relative noob this early on

kay just ISO'd Lawpy, and it all seems to hang OK

this looks scarily like a similar list from last game.... I think. You and someone else made these color code lists IIRC. I wonder how much this reflects intrinsic bias you have vs how much it's actually been influenced by player behavior this particular game.

this post is bringing up some serious feelz right here

the backtracking on CoffeeQ feels like a wolfy consolation move, the ask to be green feels a little suck up-y to (was it Paws she quoted there?). This feels like a defense of WZ and a threat to Dolph.

I hope you can see all the WIFOM in this statement

I really want to read this as just a villager who's wrong, but it just reads wolfy.

I get this Sparky, all the villagers want to lynch wolves, and I get it, Dubz was a wolf, but not in hindsight, why were we so willing to Dolph's word here? It's great when we get a wolf, but I think village needs to be careful the thinking habits it develops in the process

everything to this point made me think Allie is village.... but now I'm wondering if that's because she seems just oh so insightful this game..... note to self or others to ISO and see if it reads as villager on point or informed minority

wolfy feelz from this for LotF.... not really sure why she's giving Coffee a hard time here for dropping the word "be". Also she makes a point about Allie, but this also could be PR hunting.

the "defense by casting shade" move here feels wolfy, otherwise mostly a fluff post

for some reason repeating this verbatim, plus the serious WIFOM here that you're trying to sell us, comes off way wolfy

I will add something here. We get this idea that not voting is wolfy. I think it's NAI in so many cases. I am eyeing Moose for a lot of reasons related to her interactions with people. However, I don't see what she had to gain as a wolf by abstaining here.

I can see people voting/not voting as a result of IRL stuff, hardly wolfy strategy. It's so unbelievably easy to drop fake votes that make you look more village, that I don't know why a wolf would purposefully abstain here and look wolfy for it over dropping a vote.

This isn't WIFOM. This is common sense. There are so extremely few instances I can think of where a wolf benefits from not voting on purpose that I just cannot even.

OTOH, could a wolf accidentally not vote, and then in their attempt to defend, look wolfy? Sure. I mentioned that something about Miranda's defense looked off when she repeated herself and some word choice.

Not saying BJ is trying to crucify Moose for this, but I have to point out that getting hung up on someone not dropping a vote... I see that as more village because I can't see a wolf doing it intentionally. Given that instinct to call it villagey, that makes it villagey or WIFOM, so it's more that I can't assume it's wolf or village, really.

lynch Moose

the way you've gone from me to Mel.... I find that Mel is *actually* being helpful... which makes your weird vibe from it... weird. Plus all the other stuff from you I've commented on so far.

um.... PR hunting?

It's sorta like that one game I played with AM. How close does your encounter with a wolfy player have to be to scar you forever? I was driving to Yellowstone at night and saw the biggest blackest horse dog I ever saw in my life running right alongside the car. You don't have to come that close to a wolf for it to stay with you.

I had a feeling like that with WZ when I was drunkenly trying to chat up WW. Like, "where did my friend go???" Then of course I was passed out so that went nowhere. I wasn't too surprised at her flip. This isn't me trying to take any sort of credit for that, btw.

Anyway, take this from the person who apparently so easily scars that the wolf meta I invent for people as a wolf becomes real in my mind.

Besides worrying about AM's affiliation as per usual, if I think she's village I take anything she says about the tone of other players very seriously. I'm going to try not to put her on a pedestal, but if she says she can read Coop, she probably can.

OTOH, I was getting wolfy vibes from Coop last game. I'm not feeling the wolfiness this game in tone. I can't follow the talk about results enough to make anything of the bouncer talk in that assessment, though.

this strikes me as the oddest villager defense I've ever seen....

that comment by genny didn't really read village to me, not to slam on her, but more than that your reading of it right now is really what doesn't strike me as village

that's like the appetizer of wolf WIFOM, fake wolf matyrdom for village

um, sketchy timing BJ, gotta say

sounds wolfy, but sure, it could just as easily be wolfy

hard to say if the role or the reluctance to reveal such a role, is NAI or not

unless it wasn't Moose's only chance

is Moose the alpha? did she have a lynch avoidance she didn't want to waste? possibly it's nothing nefarious, but you know what they say about what doesn't die.... she's gonna have to go on the short list to be lynched before lylo

I can't tell if this is the wannabe noob wolf brag from a noob too afraid not to actually be dead to actually brag, but couldn't quite deny being a wolf upon lynch anyway

this doesn't explain why you handled your reveal and who you used it on, the way you did

I always hesitate with the villagers seeming to make the most sense.

I am suspicious of Allie. Her tone is different. I can't tell if that's good or bad. She is less angry and defensive. I would say that's good, but this is WW.

the wording of this rings wolfy to me every time I read it

this is so painfully nooby, it reads as village lynch mob. If Tarty ends up being a wolf, I'm going to have to applaud him for maintaining what appears to be his takeover from myself the role of VI.

everything about this reads wolfy
- producing a list "on demand" because you "forgot"
- playing dumb about Coop (since when are you so noob you don't even know Coop's gender?). Maybe you don't but it just reads as claiming ignorance, as in, claiming.
- the fact that you edited this post several hours later....

Each one alone isn't a nail on coffin, still. Sketchz

I can't tell which questions you answer with such authority are due to mysterious sources, or just your own opinion. It would be nice to know. Since the wolves are the informed minority and holding back on us.... it's just good to know where people are getting their ideas.

I don't understand why we're coming back around to this.

The only time I see this much focus this early in game to catch a 3rd party is usually by wolves or 3rd party that needs to catch the 3rd party for their win condition.

Let me be a bit clearer, you used your identity on a dead player.... the only reason to hold onto that info AFTER role revealing... ????

It sounds like you needed a pause to come up with a good cover story.

No, I'm not into role reveals even unto my villager death. That's my meta. OTOH, I can't see why in this case it was hard to get you to discuss anything. You seemed less worried that you would hurt village with the intel, and more worried you would come off wolfy. Which 2 min before your lynch death, should not be a worry. Unless....

To be fair, I've come through a lynch tie as village, and didn't spill all the beans unto my death. I've even seen a rez coming and didn't want to spoil it by bringing down the wolves and village with too much intel spilled, even though I knew being closed mouth would put me on the radar.

So your situation and my gameplay are 2 different stories. This is what we mean by use better reasoning. Your sketchy behavior doesn't look better in light of me.

Hey, I've been saying for a long time that villager role reveals and intel sharing is not my strong suit. But talking about dead players...?

But did she really? Or is that a very convenient lie for a wolf?

I'll add to, that all the times I've quoted or spoken about Moose since night close, is how I feel about Moose "knowing" that about her.

Fair enough, except can you see why it's problematic to say that no one else coming forward means you're telling the truth?

Wolves have to fake using their abilities on each other or not at all or on dead people oh but wait on this person first all the time.

I'm not saying your usage to date is proof of wolfiness, which is why I've mostly focused on other things about play. OTOH, it doesn't clear you either.

I could get on a YK lynch.

I will say that Coffee is the other player I would consider going back to a vote on. Maybe it's just the heavy-handedness of how intel has been dished out from her side of things these last few days.

were you also told this would lead to a no kill night? or would cancel lynch? or save a villager?

sorry, it's just starting to feel like there's nothing this one time bonus can't do....

Side eye for what could be subtle PR hunting. I'm not sure that saying whose results are whose is going to help village find wolves better than it helps wolves find PRs. Maybe you weren't thinking of that.

That might be your interpretation of wolf genny's behavior, not quite on point. Wolf pushing a vote is different than just sorta putting the same one out there for consistency's sake. Wolf genny doesn't lead or jump on wagons as a rule. Well, or I should say that so far genny's voting the same person twice is completely null tell for her as far as I'm concerned.

Also, why is the most important homework to do, to go look at who the *wolf* incriminated and cleared? I'm all for studying w vs ? interactions once narrowed down that way, still.

I find this suspicious

I agree with 99% of this post. MA has in her village pile a number of my suspects, but that's hardly unusual for players. I agree that Mel and BJ are worrisome for reasons stated by MA and myself. BJ was going on a bit about people's sketchy last min change votes for SAR but I didn't find her defense all that convincing when I pointed out hers.

As far as chaos, we really don't have to speculate if someone is or not. There might be mechanics where that might be important (see Age of the Gods) but otherwise, like I keep saying, it's enough to just decided you don't think they are village or are not working for village. That's it. That said, I don't find her role claims to be particularly concerning, more just how she's been interacting with us about it. She seems cagey and I don't totally get why at this point

Weak defense on a number of fronts. Pointing out that others are wrong to explain your own play, not good village defense if you are village, and the "me too!" thing is a common one you see wolves claim as they try to blend in with the lynch mob.

Also asking why should you sit on a nowhere vote... we've all been over this. We all change from nowhere votes to players up for contention, but it's overall a truism to vote who you really are convinced is a wolf. Sure, you're going to intervene to save people, but that should be made clear at the time before flip. Maybe there wasn't time or you did make that clear. Dunno. Not using this to roast you, but had to point out this isn't great defense and taken all around not liking the whole sitch.

was PBC in the last game? I thought she was village
sooo I think this is wrong
but who am I to judge that sort of mistake in remembering prior games, or even stuff from this one?

except it just feels like you're throwing things out there to see if they'll stick

Pretty decent post, but there are other issues with play.

I didn't catch that MA was suggesting chaos was low priority - I'm championing that we don't get too sidetracked hunting chaos per se, not that same thing as suggesting they should be tolerated because they are usually benign. Not so at all. I was a neutral redirector once that chose to play village, and caused a good amount of havoc. However as we saw in the last game with SAR, she chose to work with the wolves. So that is just the most ridiculous point and I missed it. Raises an eyebrow.

I can tell you what I think.

I'm seeing a few players starting to use a lot of interrogation questions rapid fire, which is great, good strategy, but I sometimes wonder if it's just another way for a wolf to look like they are wolf hunting without actually contributing to hunting wolves.

I've seen a wolfy AM use this technique in various ways. Not saying she's doing that this game, just saying pointing out that it is one wolf strat for realz is all.

Tarty's village play looks like what he's been doing, but since his play habits are, well, what they are, he could so easily be wolf. Basically it's all null tell with him. If he's village it's a shame to lose the numbers, keep him from continuing to get experience and improve, and he is active at least. But, there's no way to tell what he is at this point and village has to play it safe.

What I just said was my reasoning, I'm sorry if that isn't specific enough for people or committal or what the **** ever.

@Melchizedek now that you've lombasted my play, can you explain again why you keep saying Coffee is confirmed chaos? Because yeah, you haven't been totally vague about that.

Not convinced AM was trying in earnest to vig kill a wolf, maybe that was staged somehow. Also, what was the timing of her doing that with regards the lynch that day?

Coffee as confirmed chaos. WTF are you getting this? I'm not saying it isn't possible or I don't see the concerns, but this smacks of Coop's comments on genny, I'm really surprised to see hypocrisy from Mel in the form of just lazy playing and pushing unsupported crap.

I did not ****ing side step you about explaining Lawper D1. I answered it and also referred to a lengthier post in the sign up thread. You guys seriously don't think I type enough? I reserve the right to say I already ****ing told you even though more than 1/2 the time I end up retyping shyte anyway. What about D1 revenge vote for the game he won as a noob wolf don't you understand? What about unlynching him when he was danger because I am partial to him from preallo and didn't want to lose him D1 when I don't get to play with him often is sidestepping? Because I know between this thread and the other one that is what I ****ing said.

****ing quit with your lies and bullshyte Mel. I've admitted where I was wrong at every point. You just continue to repeat the same BS that is unsupported even when you're called out.

The rest of your points are well taken but hardly excuses the other issues here with you.

Nevermind half your reads are even more vague than you accuse me of. I might not dig up all the quotes (which tend to be present in my PbPa replies with my thoughts on them) but I always offer at least 1 sentence on why I think what I think. Explain Kara, Coffee, and Paws.

Kay I don't mind your reads here, but the whole thing about me not contributing game content and not just theory, is going to lead to a very long and painful requoting of myself.

I think you and Mel are just going to use me as distraction and freebie mislynch. I do it to you and Mel and all the time so I'm not surprised you're doing this to me. I was trying not to go for you and Mel this game because, well, that's a wolf move for me and without reason I'm not going after you two as village. But your bullshyte wolfing ganging up on me I can't ignore, plus all the other issues I've already pointed out with your guys' play.

Poor reasoning. Or is this not contributing game content on my part to say so? JFC smh rn for everything.

Noob game had someone who could do post restrictions that was not wolf. I remember because they made jboo, who was wolf, have to post as teen wolf, which was hilarious, I remember that distinctly. It makes no sense for a fellow wolf to have done that to her that game and I know it wasn't.

So is it not content to point out that you're just wrong here? That even if I'm not going to take you to task for faulty memory, that this sort of ability based wolf hunting is just bad bad reasoning, I find it wolfy.

I'm not surprised. That's why you need to just go. You are no longer contributing and you're now making it clear you don't intend to.

um so anyone should be trying to take out chaos, so I don't see how this is affiliation indicative

I'll dig up the quote because I know I called you out on it.

maybe that is what you would do, it seems to me you are contradicting yourself, but this is hardly wolf strategy that goes without saying, plenty of wolves will try to eliminate 3rd party immediately because they can actually be more dangerous alive than the trade off of not reducing village number right away going with a different lynch/NK choice

um, so pointing out people's bad reasoning isn't game content to help village on my part, uh, OK

Oh p.s.

If I die tonight lynch AM and the Cray in that order.

Kay, so these were all the posts that I consider to be specific content on my part that shows I am trying to wolf hunt. That's in addition to what I have contributed in terms of asking clarifying questions and contributions about strategy and what I think village is doing wrong, which while you might not like for wolf hunting, is hardly fluff imho. Just because you might not like the noise:signal ratio doesn't mean a fair amount of content is being put forth.

I dug up where I called BJ out on the timing of her switch with the SAR lynch, so I've addressed the fact that I asked about it, and what her response was that I find lacking.

I posted where I said what I had to say about Lawper. Mel can be not satisfied with my answer all he wants, but that's hardly the same thing as sidestepping.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

I'm getting annoyed with this, and it's contributing to the sense that I'm not trying, because my PbPa gives my thoughts and reactions to people's play, which is meant to then support the list I keep repeating.

BJ, Coffee, Moose, Mel, AM, Allie, and I'm sure that doesn't match up with everything I've said so far for who I suspect, but frankly I keep better track of feelz which I fake when I am wolf. Since by my count we can easily have up to 4 or 5 non-village, and the best wolf list in my strat book is 2x that, yeah, out of almost 20 players I am looking closely at around 1/2.

There are enough players that I go through the roster daily to consider people. I'll have more to say consolidating all this later.

I never said you weren't trying, I asked the same or similar to multiple people today

 

[bryndiana.jones]

I dug up where I called BJ out on the timing of her switch with the SAR lynch, so I've addressed the fact that I asked about it, and what her response was that I find lacking.

BJ was going on a bit about people's sketchy last min change votes for SAR but I didn't find her defense all that convincing when I pointed out hers.

I dug up where I called BJ out on the timing of her switch with the SAR lynch, so I've addressed the fact that I asked about it, and what her response was that I find lacking.

But these aren't the same thing, you calling me out for switching, and saying that I was trying to shade those who were switching is two completely different things.

 

[Melchizedek]

Contingency lnych Cray again

Because I can and

 

[MixedAnimals77]

How many times do you want me to ask him the same question when he is clearly avoiding it? Then he posted reads afterwards so....that's what I wanted and why would I pester him with the "who if not coop?" after that? How have I casted shade and been noncommittal? I have been on tart and have mentioned others because y'all have been asking, but I can only vote for one.

Not saying pester him. How did that exchange make you feel and his response is a better question I suppose. What do you think of his and crays interactions? Just not very expansive when mentioning other candidates I suppose. The whole tie thing is what bugs me most and I can't get past. Sporty made some decent points but for the sake of original thought.

Anyway won't be around much tomorrow or following days through Thursday if this game lasts that long cause moving but I'll try my best to keep up and be present.

 

[Crayola227]

um, sketchy timing BJ, gotta say

You can think of it this way, SAR was next on the chopping block after Moose and genny, and if I didn't want to vote for either of them then what makes the most sense?

I can't recall if the way this unfolded that your vote for SAR was in a good direction or not... namely away from tie or Moose or Genny....

We keep blaming genny and moose for where the bandwagon went yesterday, what about BJ and other late voters/switchers??

Although at this point that could be academic. The runaway train mislynch of yet another villager in a village like ours (I don't just mean this game) is hardly unusual for this bunch.

I'm a fan of bandwagon voting as both villager and wolf, and even I've been just plain shocked at the trains lately. It's frankly more disgusting than most porn I watch and that's really saying something.

This was what I found for the exchange I had with BJ about her late SAR vote switch, and her response. I'm not loving her explanation, but not sure why today she said it didn't come up

 

[Crayola227]

But these aren't the same thing, you calling me out for switching, and saying that I was trying to shade those who were switching is two completely different things.

OK, guess I'll have to go back and dig that up again too....

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Not saying pester him. How did that exchange make you feel and his response is a better question I suppose. What do you think of his and crays interactions? Just not very expansive when mentioning other candidates I suppose. The whole tie thing is what bugs me most and I can't get past. Sporty made some decent points but for the sake of original thought.

Anyway won't be around much tomorrow or following days through Thursday if this game lasts that long cause moving but I'll try my best to keep up and be present.

I think he was being a pain in the a**, and he was doing the same to you. I have been reading him as village, even though his sass today was frustrating, it didn't make me put him in my wolf pile. I will have to get back to you on their interactions, because I am currently trying to just catch up from lynch close, and should reread after that.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

OK, guess I'll have to go back and dig that up again too....

I went through my own posts looking for me calling out those involved in SAR's lynch, and I didn't find squat. Let me know if you do

 

[Animal Midwife]

Contingency Lynch Cray

for tearing up my village bloc, quoting posts out of order, and doing the exact thing you do as a wolf, but saying you're not a wolf this time.

 

[Crayola227]

this is total bullshyte lynching on your guys' parts

 

[Crayola227]

I say that because the lynching has been lazy and you guys keep going for the "obvious" lynches even though they're just wrong

Genny and Coop and SAR were not good lynches. And not because they flipped village, that's gonna happen. It was the reasoning and the way you guys went about it. Tarty was not the best choice either.

Go along with Mel's psychological mind games when he's been inconsistent af, and just begged to be converted, and admittedly is so frustrated he's not even trying to be helpful.

 

[Lawpy]

Uncontingency lynch Tarty
Contingency lynch Mel

 

[Crayola227]

Contingency Lynch Cray

for tearing up my village bloc, quoting posts out of order, and doing the exact thing you do as a wolf, but saying you're not a wolf this time.

how about village is doing that itself by just voting off the island actively participating players that are so "obviously wolfy" as to just not even be obvious anymore? Out of myself, Coop, genny, Tarty, I just don't see that those were the best choices.

You keep saying that Coop was playing different, and I don't think she was.

I think quite a few of you are just being opportunistic.

 

[Animal Midwife]

how about village is doing that itself by just voting off the island actively participating players that are so "obviously wolfy" as to just not even be obvious anymore? Out of myself, Coop, genny, Tarty, I just don't see that those were the best choices.

You keep saying that Coop was playing different, and I don't think she was.

I think quite a few of you are just being opportunistic.

You never answered my question from before. Who if not Mel?

 

[Coopah]

†************
Told you so 😛
*************

 

[Melchizedek]

Go along with Mel's psychological mind games when he's been inconsistent af, and just begged to be converted, and admittedly is so frustrated he's not even trying to be helpful.

Yupp pretty much, leggo

 

[Crayola227]

You never answered my question from before. Who if not Mel?

I said that I was seriously considering Coffee, BJ, and Moose already. I also said that I am considering you, Tarty, Allie, YK, among others. I think seriously considering placing a vote for 3 people, watching another 4, and allowing for the next night/day to help narrow further is reasonable.

Although to be fair, I need to go through the roster again and reconsider everyone. But I feel really good that of Mel, Coffee, BJ, and Moose, one is a wolf. That would be statistically true, and I've increased my pre-test probability since I believe all of them have exhibited wolfy or even sabotaging (Mel) behavior, so that is why I feel comfortable voting there now as it stands. Obviously of the 7 people I named re-read and future events will be helpful as well.

I'm defending why my list is long and seemingly vague, although I have quoted a lot of my content, and regarding my top 4 I will be quoting the exchanges to support why they will be my future lynch votes until otherwise indicated.

 

[Crayola227]

we need to stop repeating that I'm not answering people's questions, I am. If you say you're not satisfied and want more info, that's fine, you feel the way you feel. That's not the same thing as saying I'm not trying to address concerns.