Like BloodyHell said, Einstein isn't really a school about numbers. I truly believe that my classmates are phenomenal people. Ask any MS1 and MS2 at Einstein and they will all say that the students at Einstein are special in many unique ways. You won't understand that until you get here.
I personally believe that Einstein is a good fit for many of my classmates. We are all quirky, slightly weird, and HILARIOUS people. My classmates are some of the funniest people I have ever met! At the same time, we work hard, party hard, and most seems to have some global health/international health interest.
If Einstein was truly about numbers, they would waitlist you, wait for you to write a LOI and then accept you. Some of my friends got rejected from Einstein straight off the bat and didn't get waitlisted. They all went to other medical schools. They were simply not good fit for Einstein. Furthermore, there are students that got accepted today who are in your range of MCAT scores. There are students in my class with MCAT scores over 36 (even over 40). So numbers can only get you so far. There are people in my class who turned down better ranked schools because Einstein was a better fit for them.
I truly believe that if you didn't get accepted to Einstein, it means that you were not a good fit for the school. The Admissions Office pick students that they know will fit well here. My friends and I all feel that way.
Best of luck!