A Lighthouse, A Man, A City...A BioShock WW Game

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
It's true. She could be a convert. I accept that, but it still felt like an out of left field lynch.

And you're so adamant about LIS not being a wolf, but at the same time are questioning why I'm lumping you two together and questioning the neutral claim. You can't have your cake and eat it too, lol.
Sure I can. Look at jdh's game when I had a crew and I protected them all to the near end without having a seering ability. I lost that stupid game because in the end I voted my group member over the convert wolf and I still to this day regret it.
 
Yeet LIS

because if nothing else, it'll give us information on the neutral claim, I don't think I want to yeet Cray tonight, the Lupin/Trilt argument is making my brain hurt, and if LIS flips anything other than neutral, then we'll have more of an idea of where to look tomorrow. And if I'm going to vote for a neutral, it's going to be the one claiming it without any seering info.
 
Sure I can. Look at jdh's game when I had a crew and I protected them all to the near end without having a seering ability. I lost that stupid game because in the end I voted my group member over the convert wolf and I still to this day regret it.
Meaning I have been protecting samac and chaos just as much as LIS this game.
 
Sure I can. Look at jdh's game when I had a crew and I protected them all to the near end without having a seering ability. I lost that stupid game because in the end I voted my group member over the convert wolf and I still to this day regret it.
This still leaves LIS claiming 3+ neutrals in the game while hard defending you as "not a wolf."
 
I'm willing to vote elsewhere but not if it puts me into the lead.

Also will need guidance on when best to role reveal.
Role reveal whenever, it's a useless ability in the context of what you've told me and unverifiable so I don't think it's gonna get you far in sympathy.
 
So in the end, you are third person player hunting instead of wolf hunting? Is that what I need to take away from this?
Sure, if that's what you want to take away from it. The player who absolutely loves and defends neutrals is just randomly 3p hunting for fun.
 
Role reveal whenever, it's a useless ability in the context of what you've told me and unverifiable so I don't think it's gonna get you far in sympathy.
Wait, I thought you said earlier that it was something you thought the game should have?

I'll add her role claim is unverifiable, but is something that I really feel *should* be in this game. Like I thought "damn we need one of these" a couple days ago. So that also might be influencing my decision in part.
 
Sure, if that's what you want to take away from it. The player who absolutely loves and defends neutrals is just randomly 3p hunting for fun.
Well, that seems to be what you are doing if you are lynching LIS and you believe his neutral claim. Then also saying I'm on that bloc too as his possible third neutral. I don't see wolf hunting in that.
 
I guess, let's go from this angle:

Do you agree that it would be weird for MJ to NOT have chaos characters in a game he designed?

Also, do you not agree that it's a bit weird our two night kills suddenly died off?
 
Day 9: Were Not Finished! Not Finished! Vote Tally

samac (1) - Chaostrodon
Chaostrodon (3) - LIS, jaboo, Cray
Cray (3) - samac, mayo, Barks
Lupin ()
LIS (2) - Trilt, supershorty
jaboo (1) - Lupin

10/10

Leading: @Crayola227

Missing: —

Deadline: 10pm EST on 3/18/21 (~65 minutes)

tumblr_lrl00u8xm71qffgibo1_500.gif
 
Well, that seems to be what you are doing if you are lynching LIS and you believe his neutral claim. Then also saying I'm on that bloc too as his possible third neutral. I don't see wolf hunting in that.
...I don't necessarily believe his neutral claim? I think I've been pretty straightforward about that between hypothesizing about a second pack, a chaos subset, etc...
 
I guess, let's go from this angle:

Do you agree that it would be weird for MJ to NOT have chaos characters in a game he designed?

Also, do you not agree that it's a bit weird our two night kills suddenly died off?
Considering we've killed three wolves? And don't know if cigs allowed for double kills and whatever else mechanically could be there such as a one time double kill ability or something of the sort? This is where AM would probably be sassy about relying on mechanics instead of analyzing people and their posts/VCA and current play.
 
Considering we've killed three wolves? And don't know if cigs allowed for double kills and whatever else mechanically could be there such as a one time double kill ability or something of the sort? This is where AM would probably be sassy about relying on mechanics instead of analyzing people and their posts/VCA and current play.
I hit d5 with zero wolf suspects by analyzing posts/VCA. I've mentioned this more than once, lol.
 
If we flip LiS and he is what he claims can we please vote cray tomorrow?
I will immediately put in a contingency yeet for Cray and not move it, fingers crossed lol.

She smoked to use a useless ability twice in one night?
Let her reveal, it makes sense.
 
I hit d5 with zero wolf suspects by analyzing posts/VCA. I've mentioned this more than once, lol.
Also I'm noting you avoided my question about chaos and MJ.

And we didn't have items in play for n1 to potentially be cig-doubled. I went down that rabbit hole already. They were distributed in the morning.
 
Also I'm noting you avoided my question about chaos and MJ.

And we didn't have items in play for n1 to potentially be cig-doubled. I went down that rabbit hole already. They were distributed in the morning.
I didn't avoid chaos. My version of chaos is having MJ put Mayo in as seering neutral when he is in fact something else. If you mean like a chaos 3rd party, then sure, maybe, but I highly doubt it is LIS.
 
Hey cray, so with Trilt analyzing you, what do you think of her? Obviously you haven't voted to lynch her, but do you have any inkling she is being tricksy wolf?

Same q for mayo.

She seems to be doing a lot of behind the scenes with you guys.
 
Hey cray, so with Trilt analyzing you, what do you think of her? Obviously you haven't voted to lynch her, but do you have any inkling she is being tricksy wolf?

Same q for mayo.

She seems to be doing a lot of behind the scenes with you guys.

Her VCA is a big point against her, but she has seemed genuine on PM and seems to wolfhunt on the thread.

I haven't asked her to role reveal, but I have shared mine with her. She's been pretty forthcoming with information and theories, which fit with what she's said on the thread.

I had her as neutral yesterday, and probably still do. I would much rather see Chaos or Cray.
 
Do you agree that it would be weird for MJ to NOT have chaos characters in a game he designed?
I didn't avoid chaos. My version of chaos is having MJ put Mayo in as seering neutral when he is in fact something else. If you mean like a chaos 3rd party, then sure, maybe, but I highly doubt it is LIS.
I don't know how you could possibly misinterpret this question as being about Chaos the player.

And really, your version of chaos is a false seering role. From MJ. Who attracts the chaos roles and has been a mentor for chaos players in more than one noob game. Really?
 
I don't know how you could possibly misinterpret this question as being about Chaos the player.

And really, your version of chaos is a false seering role. From MJ. Who attracts the chaos roles and has been a mentor for chaos players in more than one noob game. Really?
He would want a chaotic player to stick around, so why not make them seer as neutral. Here's what I'm getting at. You all are barking up the wrong tree with LIS. I will stand by that to the end.
 
Hey cray, so with Trilt analyzing you, what do you think of her? Obviously you haven't voted to lynch her, but do you have any inkling she is being tricksy wolf?

Same q for mayo.

She seems to be doing a lot of behind the scenes with you guys.
I'm not sure. I don't understand why she would be working against my mislynch. My main tinfoil on her is that she's also a neutral but not sure that works with what else she's doing lately. That was an earlier thought.
 
From what I've read, there's more than one faction in Bioshock. Like Fontaine is working against Ryan, and the protagonist is fighting them and the Big Daddies.
Big daddies aren’t necessarily bad or good from my understanding.
 
I mean, there is a wacky MJ twist. I think I know what it is.

If I'm correct then it's weirder than anyone has guessed.

I'm worried if I blow it up, this village will call me a liar and misyeet itself into a loss.
Honestly at this point, I don't know how village is going to pull this off if we are all concentrating on third parties and not getting at least one more wolf.
 
Honestly at this point, I don't know how village is going to pull this off if we are all concentrating on third parties and not getting at least one more wolf.
Is there something about jaboo that has you thinking she's a wolf other than she's pretty much checked out from the thread?
 
Top