A Lighthouse, A Man, A City...A BioShock WW Game

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Is there something about jaboo that has you thinking she's a wolf other than she's pretty much checked out from the thread?
Zenge seemed organic, but her play after is not great. Can someone link the VCA again? Knowing I seemingly messed up mayo, I may be wrong on jaboo, but I have a vague notion she has flipped a switch to voting villagers since.
 
Zenge seemed organic, but her play after is not great. Can someone link the VCA again? Knowing I seemingly messed up mayo, I may be wrong on jaboo, but I have a vague notion she has flipped a switch to voting villagers since.
She has. This is only FINAL votes for the day (other than D2 where I have the before/after Dina revealed) so any waffles are not captured.

Screenshot (226).png

Sorry it's not neatly cropped this time.
 
I am an Oracle or ask-a-mod. It's written in that my ability isn't infalliable, and I asked how many wolves there are and it failed entirely. I asked about converts and the answer was a lot of flavor that didn't really say one way or the other but it definitely didn't rule it out.

I asked about 3P, there's more than one and I think their wincon is exclusive. I was pretty sure it only pointed to one group, but with LIS' reveal I am questioning my interpretation of this. The only thing I am sure is that there is more than one hinted at.

I had more luck phrasing questions very generally than specific. I asked "what can you tell me about 3P" and that seemed to get me a better answer than my other questions did.

After being village read so much so early I feared NK, once I had the cigarettes and a feel for how the ask-a-mod was gonna work, I thought I should get more info ASAP. I also stupidly missed the part where I couldn't act after smoking. I thought I would get an extra question so this is why I thought being silenced and stuck with whatever I discovered might be worth the risk. I also thought maybe the wolves wouldn't off me right away because the sus on a silenced player, but with Mkg I thought I might survive village's wrath, so I thought in the final analysis I might get more info, avoid NK, avoid elim, and get this info ASAP and then to thread.
 
She has. This is only FINAL votes for the day (other than D2 where I have the before/after Dina revealed) so any waffles are not captured.

View attachment 332861
Sorry it's not neatly cropped this time.
Noting that you have an identical voting pattern, lol.
 
**** it I want this to be over.
mayo and I are a neutral pair. It is why I’ve defended neutral so hard because I know what it means.
shorty you’re right about the write up. It was a big daddy and 2 people who smoked yo for vote.
I’m pretty sure based on that cray is the last wolf and can we please end this please
 
I am an Oracle or ask-a-mod. It's written in that my ability isn't infalliable, and I asked how many wolves there are and it failed entirely. I asked about converts and the answer was a lot of flavor that didn't really say one way or the other but it definitely didn't rule it out.

I asked about 3P, there's more than one and I think their wincon is exclusive. I was pretty sure it only pointed to one group, but with LIS' reveal I am questioning my interpretation of this. The only thing I am sure is that there is more than one hinted at.

I had more luck phrasing questions very generally than specific. I asked "what can you tell me about 3P" and that seemed to get me a better answer than my other questions did.

After being village read so much so early I feared NK, once I had the cigarettes and a feel for how the ask-a-mod was gonna work, I thought I should get more info ASAP. I also stupidly missed the part where I couldn't act after smoking. I thought I would get an extra question so this is why I thought being silenced and stuck with whatever I discovered might be worth the risk. I also thought maybe the wolves wouldn't off me right away because the sus on a silenced player, but with Mkg I thought I might survive village's wrath, so I thought in the final analysis I might get more info, avoid NK, avoid elim, and get this info ASAP and then to thread.
See? role I wanted to be in the game.

Role that is unverifiable and useless so far.

Do you understand why I have been AGONIZING, guys? lol.
 
**** it I want this to be over.
mayo and I are a neutral pair. It is why I’ve defended neutral so hard because I know what it means.
shorty you’re right about the write up. It was a big daddy and 2 people who smoked yo for vote.
I’m pretty sure based on that cray is the last wolf and can we please end this please
Wait a minute, now we have 2 people claiming the 2/1 neutral thing between you and LIS
 
Me and mayo are true.
trilt, I know you’ve been talking with mayo regularly and the contents.
we’re basically masons but neutral.
it’s true and the write up is likely indicating 2 wolves talking and throwing them to me.
 
I want to note I had no need to do this. I could have kept skating by. But the theory shorty laid down yesterday with the write up I hoped it would take off without me throwing down a reveal.
 
If LiS is telling the truth, and he has the details right, then he is the wrong vote.

I didn't know there was another set, so I can't confirm he is telling the truth.
 
Look.

There is game consistency in there being big daddy/little sister pairs, and I've theorized maintaining little sisters might be a decision that needs to be made.

But there's also a note that the villagers in this game are majority splicers, someone who are literally the little sisters' ENEMIES.

And are we near parity with four potential "neutrals"? Because this could easily be a last second trap.
 
I want to note I had no need to do this. I could have kept skating by. But the theory shorty laid down yesterday with the write up I hoped it would take off without me throwing down a reveal.

This. Samac and I have no reason to blow up our neutral mason game. Neither one of us is on the chopping block tonight.

We are genuinely trying to win with the village. I think LiS and whoever his big daddy is are too.
 
In the game, you play as a character who is rewarded for saving little sisters. Like, better ending, more stuff, a cool character isn't a dick to you, etc.

You don't play as a splicer. That's this game's twist.

I hate this. Why couldn't this conversation have been had LAST NIGHT so we could actually talk it out instead of being fifteen minutes from lynch close and having to hash out complicated game theories.
 
I can't believe for a hot minute MJ put in 4 non-villagers and none of them have an exclusive wincon.

If this is so we should be that much more concerned voting out a villager over a 3P right now.

We get more time to solve this puzzle with people putting their cards on the table tomorrow by not voting out a villager.
 
In the game, you play as a character who is rewarded for saving little sisters. Like, better ending, more stuff, a cool character isn't a dick to you, etc.

You don't play as a splicer. That's this game's twist.

I hate this. Why couldn't this conversation have been had LAST NIGHT so we could actually talk it out instead of being fifteen minutes from lynch close and having to hash out complicated game theories.
Because if it was wrong we were selfish and wanted to live and people were on cray anyway so if it was wrong we’d keep living.
 
In the game, you play as a character who is rewarded for saving little sisters. Like, better ending, more stuff, a cool character isn't a dick to you, etc.

You don't play as a splicer. That's this game's twist.

I hate this. Why couldn't this conversation have been had LAST NIGHT so we could actually talk it out instead of being fifteen minutes from lynch close and having to hash out complicated game theories.
Cuz that is WWar the way it is meant to be. Also, come on. A bunch of medical students and doctors? The only way to do things is last minute.
 
Cray was not a majority lynch until mid day today when I pushed people to commit.
You were on it, shorty was headed that way and had me and mayo. We thought it was going to happen without a reveal.
 
I can't believe for a hot minute MJ put in 4 non-villagers and none of them have an exclusive wincon.

If this is so we should be that much more concerned voting out a villager over a 3P right now.

We get more time to solve this puzzle with people putting their cards on the table tomorrow by not voting out a villager.

You can't win without getting wolves...

I don't get it, you can see every crazy MJ iteration of this game and my role, except for the one that actually happened.
 
I hope this "neutral" Big Daddy powers up and kills each and every one of you painfully for being like this.
I’m neutral. Mayo and I are literally a neutral Mason pair. He’s been seered. Don’t play semantics. The neutral game.
 
Not everyone is a splicer though, my role pm specified that I've never spliced.
I know.

I'm a splicer seer. Vanillagers and (apparently) neutrals both seered the same to me.

The problem here is that if this is a mislynch and this game is splicers vs. neutrals (and they can kill) we've lost at this point if we don't knock out one of them.
 
In the game, you play as a character who is rewarded for saving little sisters. Like, better ending, more stuff, a cool character isn't a dick to you, etc.

You don't play as a splicer. That's this game's twist.

I hate this. Why couldn't this conversation have been had LAST NIGHT so we could actually talk it out instead of being fifteen minutes from lynch close and having to hash out complicated game theories.
Which Bioshock is this game based on?
 
I'm inclined to believe the pairs thing because the write ups support that with big daddy/little sister mentions.
It's straight up waffle and pancake panic time at my house right now because I feel like I have no idea where to vote.
Sorry.
 
Top