CHOOSE YOUR OWWN IV - Game Thread

[beans2020]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

I'm gonna do some iso in the morning (prob not tonight) and see if I can dig anything up about who spurs may have been paired with. (Is it possible that he was a lone wolf? Or do we go with he probably was paired for now??)

 

[supershorty]

That doesn't matter though. I mean she's not a werewolf clearly but she could still be any other scum.

I think I've decided you can tentatively be in my blocc.

 

[WildZoo]

I'm gonna do some iso in the morning (prob not tonight) and see if I can dig anything up about who spurs may have been paired with. (Is it possible that he was a lone wolf? Or do we go with he probably was paired for now??)

There is no way to know

 

[samac]

I'm gonna do some iso in the morning (prob not tonight) and see if I can dig anything up about who spurs may have been paired with. (Is it possible that he was a lone wolf? Or do we go with he probably was paired for now??)

I would like this info. He probably wasn’t alone

 

[supershorty]

Not based on that comment, there was a different one yesterday that gave me a microread I really believe in.

 

[Zenge142]

Yeet PSV

@Animal Midwife @Dr. ForgotToFlush

 

[WildZoo]

I think I've decided you can tentatively be in my blocc.

I AM BLOCC?!??

 

[samac]

Yeet PSV

@Animal Midwife @Dr. ForgotToFlush

WAT

 

[supershorty]

Yeet PSV

@Animal Midwife @Dr. ForgotToFlush

*record scratch*

Say what?

 

[Zenge142]

So I've gone back and thought about this a lot, I had inklings yesterday, and I kept digging and I have a really bad feeling about PSV.

Lets look at the facts:

1. She's one of the players who could in theory have not been given any town options at all.

2. She's one of the players who claimed Vanilla Townie for affiliation, which is where scum likes to hide.

3. For being fairly Town read, she's not dead.

4. I really didn't like the way she kind of tried pushing Samac yesterday. It felt a little like a manufactured "got ya" moment to try and get Samac out early.

5. I also really didn't like how she handled my slot at all. She was bandwagoning and hopping on the vote when it was convenient. Village!PSV wouldn't do that. She wanted a player she knows is a good scum hunter out early on a misyeet. Same way she tried to handle Samac's slot.

6. She's really been pretty lackluster in her posts and just sort of floating in the background. And it goes beyond not just being here as much. Her thoughts feel crowdsourced from ideas on the consensus rise.

7. Whatever arguments you have related to how you think she "sounds village" because you think she's scum hunting - THIS IS MULTIBALL - Scum hunts Scum. Of course she sounds like she's scum hunting, she is, kind of - scum is a threat to her just as much as it is to village. But not hard enough to get night killed. PSV is not village here - I feel it in my bones.

I've read village PSV, I have a nose for village PSV. This isn't it. She's scum hunting, sure, kind of... But she's not on our side. She's not town.

 

[samac]

I AM BLOCC?!??

I have the keys and you sit there in the block maamn

 

[WildZoo]

Not based on that comment, there was a different one yesterday that gave me a microread I really believe in.

What comment??

 

[fruitsalad]

i'm thinking if i'm wrong on alissa

 

[supershorty]

Also now that I've settled down some, I kind of regret that rage!shorty came on the thread screaming at genny because I had already softed my role so I'm sure other people had picked up that I wasn't vanilla, but whatever. She's an impulsive b, that rage!shorty

I edited this bc I didn't think Spurs would let me say that even though the forum would lol

 

[WildZoo]

I have the keys and you sit there in the block maamn

NUH UH SHORTY SAID IM BLOCC

AND NOW IM SCARED, I'VE NEVER BEEN HERE THIS EARLY BEFORE

 

[samac]

So I've gone back and thought about this a lot, I had inklings yesterday, and I kept digging and I have a really bad feeling about PSV.

Lets look at the facts:

1. She's one of the players who could in theory have not been given any town options at all.

2. She's one of the players who claimed Vanilla Townie for affiliation, which is where scum likes to hide.

3. For being fairly Town read, she's not dead.

4. I really didn't like the way she kind of tried pushing Samac yesterday. It felt a little like a manufactured "got ya" moment to try and get Samac out early.

5. I also really didn't like how she handled my slot at all. She was bandwagoning and hopping on the vote when it was convenient. Village!PSV wouldn't do that. She wanted a player she knows is a good scum hunter out early on a misyeet. Same way she tried to handle Samac's slot.

6. She's really been pretty lackluster in her posts and just sort of floating in the background. And it goes beyond not just being here as much. Her thoughts feel crowdsourced from ideas on the consensus rise.

7. Whatever arguments you have related to how you think she "sounds village" because you think she's scum hunting - THIS IS MULTIBALL - Scum hunts Scum. Of course she sounds like she's scum hunting, she is, kind of - scum is a threat to her just as much as it is to village. But not hard enough to get night killed. PSV is not village here - I feel it in my bones.

I've read village PSV, I have a nose for village PSV. This isn't it. She's scum hunting, sure, kind of... But she's not on our side. She's not town.

This is spicy

 

[supershorty]

What comment??

I'm not telling you

 

[WildZoo]

So I've gone back and thought about this a lot, I had inklings yesterday, and I kept digging and I have a really bad feeling about PSV.

Lets look at the facts:

1. She's one of the players who could in theory have not been given any town options at all.

2. She's one of the players who claimed Vanilla Townie for affiliation, which is where scum likes to hide.

3. For being fairly Town read, she's not dead.

4. I really didn't like the way she kind of tried pushing Samac yesterday. It felt a little like a manufactured "got ya" moment to try and get Samac out early.

5. I also really didn't like how she handled my slot at all. She was bandwagoning and hopping on the vote when it was convenient. Village!PSV wouldn't do that. She wanted a player she knows is a good scum hunter out early on a misyeet. Same way she tried to handle Samac's slot.

6. She's really been pretty lackluster in her posts and just sort of floating in the background. And it goes beyond not just being here as much. Her thoughts feel crowdsourced from ideas on the consensus rise.

7. Whatever arguments you have related to how you think she "sounds village" because you think she's scum hunting - THIS IS MULTIBALL - Scum hunts Scum. Of course she sounds like she's scum hunting, she is, kind of - scum is a threat to her just as much as it is to village. But not hard enough to get night killed. PSV is not village here - I feel it in my bones.

I've read village PSV, I have a nose for village PSV. This isn't it. She's scum hunting, sure, kind of... But she's not on our side. She's not town.

Oh man how long have you been cooking this one up

 

[fruitsalad]

5. I also really didn't like how she handled my slot at all. She was bandwagoning and hopping on the vote when it was convenient. Village!PSV wouldn't do that. She wanted a player she knows is a good scum hunter out early on a misyeet. Same way she tried to handle Samac's slot.

i'm thinking about this actually

she accelerated your wagon in direct response to my voting CG

 

[beans2020]

There is no way to know

I'm starting to see the joys of multiball

 

[apoptosis09]

Omg though poor Spurs isn't this like the third time he's been vigged (though in this case he could have been shot by other scum technically)

If we suspect 2 scum factions wouldn't a vig mean 3 kills probably?

 

[Zenge142]

This is spicy

It's a good vote. She's scum.

 

[supershorty]

So I've gone back and thought about this a lot, I had inklings yesterday, and I kept digging and I have a really bad feeling about PSV.

Lets look at the facts:

1. She's one of the players who could in theory have not been given any town options at all.

2. She's one of the players who claimed Vanilla Townie for affiliation, which is where scum likes to hide.

3. For being fairly Town read, she's not dead.

4. I really didn't like the way she kind of tried pushing Samac yesterday. It felt a little like a manufactured "got ya" moment to try and get Samac out early.

5. I also really didn't like how she handled my slot at all. She was bandwagoning and hopping on the vote when it was convenient. Village!PSV wouldn't do that. She wanted a player she knows is a good scum hunter out early on a misyeet. Same way she tried to handle Samac's slot.

6. She's really been pretty lackluster in her posts and just sort of floating in the background. And it goes beyond not just being here as much. Her thoughts feel crowdsourced from ideas on the consensus rise.

7. Whatever arguments you have related to how you think she "sounds village" because you think she's scum hunting - THIS IS MULTIBALL - Scum hunts Scum. Of course she sounds like she's scum hunting, she is, kind of - scum is a threat to her just as much as it is to village. But not hard enough to get night killed. PSV is not village here - I feel it in my bones.

I've read village PSV, I have a nose for village PSV. This isn't it. She's scum hunting, sure, kind of... But she's not on our side. She's not town.

Hmmm

I will ponder this.

 

[samac]

I'm not telling you

I need you to tell me after the game cause I play with her more often than you 😛

 

[samac]

It's a good vote. She's scum.

Interacting with her and her gotcha on me felt so genuine tho

 

[WildZoo]

If we suspect 2 scum factions wouldn't a vig mean 3 kills probably?

Not if someone was protected or scum targeted the same person or someone was blocked or all the other options that might mess with kills happening as planned

 

[WildZoo]

I need you to tell me after the game cause I play with her more often than you 😛

Y'all are meanies 😔

 

[Zenge142]

Oh man how long have you been cooking this one up

It's been bubbling

 

[supershorty]

6. She's really been pretty lackluster in her posts and just sort of floating in the background. And it goes beyond not just being here as much. Her thoughts feel crowdsourced from ideas on the consensus rise.

This is actually something I had started thinking about toward the end of the day - like I felt like the whole thinking she was catching samac thing in a lie energy had dissipated, but I'm going to have to go back and look at her posts to confirm it.

 

[Zenge142]

Interacting with her and her gotcha on me felt so genuine tho

 

[apoptosis09]

Zenge I'm blocking that gif from your computer

 

[WildZoo]

I mean it is true that my PSV read was one of the ones that was based on something scum hunting other scum could also reasonably do

 

[WildZoo]

I think

 

[supershorty]

I mean it is true that my PSV read was one of the ones that was based on something scum hunting other scum could also reasonably do

ok well if you're going to say things like this, I'm going to say that your post on thinking about things that village would do that scum hunting other scum wouldn't was where I got my microread.

 

[Barkley13]

unyeet beans
yeet barky

barky feels weird to me

bad, i tried to push her

i’m just mulling over barky’s response to PSV… idk feels like a defense of CG?

also the followup comments on alissa feel weird

unyeet beans
yeet barky

@Animal Midwife @kaydubs @Dr. ForgotToFlush

shorty feels discomfort and barky tries to ease her by showing she’s trying to be different and not village reading alissa

something feels really off with that

accelerated catching up now

anyone interested in barky or beans?

i'll hold off on voting the leading wagons for a while, i'm interested in seeing alternatives

like

barky

i went after her but i acknowledged a blindspot and backed off... before going to barky and genny

i'm probably wrong about barky too if spurs is scum here

i'm tempted to swap to spurs but not sure how to feel about barky and raes parked over there

 

[apoptosis09]

3. For being fairly Town read, she's not dead.

I can understand where the rest of this is although she still leans village for me, but this one in particular doesn't make sense to be bc she was n1'd last game (so in theory d1/n1 immunity this time), and also neither dead player was strongly village read, so idk that means much here.

 

[supershorty]

I can't reply to Barky's post but I guess that is MORE comments and over a longer period than I thought.

However, I still don't agree with the characterization that that's all fruit focused on.

 

[Zenge142]

Zenge I'm blocking that gif from your computer

I mean fair but 😢

Also though I feel like it is regularly important to remember that it is Multiball and things that seem one way in a regular game, you can't put the same stock in, in a setup like this

 

[supershorty]

neither dead player was strongly village read

I'd say genny was.

 

[apoptosis09]

I mean fair but 😢

Also though I feel like it is regularly important to remember that it is Multiball and things that seem one way in a regular game, you can't put the same stock in, in a setup like this

I was just teasing! I think the gif is funny 😅

 

[Zenge142]

I can understand where the rest of this is although she still leans village for me, but this one in particular doesn't make sense to be bc she was n1'd last game (so in theory d1/n1 immunity this time), and also neither dead player was strongly village read, so idk that means much here.

Look not every point is going to be a smoking gun, but it's an accumulation of things that indicates that PSV is a hit (She's also a hoot!)

 

[WildZoo]

I can understand where the rest of this is although she still leans village for me, but this one in particular doesn't make sense to be bc she was n1'd last game (so in theory d1/n1 immunity this time), and also neither dead player was strongly village read, so idk that means much here.

Neither player was strongly village read?? genny was straight from the blocc!

You know who wasn't village reading her?

Spurs!!!

 

[apoptosis09]

I'd say genny was.

Am I misremembering a push on her someone in the firehose of D1?

 

[supershorty]

Anyway I'm mulling over whether I should just claim at this point since everyone who knows how to read knows that genny acted on me

 

[fruitsalad]

i went after her but i acknowledged a blindspot and backed off... before going to barky and genny

this quote was referencing the last game, so idk why barky included this

 

[supershorty]

Am I misremembering a push on her someone in the firehose of D1?

... what?

 

[samac]

I mean fair but 😢

Also though I feel like it is regularly important to remember that it is Multiball and things that seem one way in a regular game, you can't put the same stock in, in a setup like this

I mean fair but 😢

Also though I feel like it is regularly important to remember that it is Multiball and things that seem one way in a regular game, you can't put the same stock in, in a setup like this

I got you another option

 

[WildZoo]

I can't reply to Barky's post but I guess that is MORE comments and over a longer period than I thought.

However, I still don't agree with the characterization that that's all fruit focused on.

I think he was more focused on beans but I do agree he brought barks up enough to be notable and I can see why to her it would feel like a lot especially given how little she had posted at the time

I don't know if that says anything about her affiliation though.

 

[samac]

I got you another option

****

 

[samac]

Anyway I'm mulling over whether I should just claim at this point since everyone who knows how to read knows that genny acted on me

… I didn’t know dis