Game Night WW - Game Thread

[dolphin106258]

---

Members don't see this ad.

😕 ftfy

Sorry it’s what felt most sketchy to me at the time. But have you even given out your own reads since you joined the game that weren’t pippy’s? Or did I just miss them?

 

[dolphin106258]

What is it about Pippy/MsP's play that's bothering you?

It was more the tone of Pippy’s posts in the early game it wasn’t even the more angry/frustrated posts either. But honestly I was hoping to have time to get back on tonight but I’ve finally gotten this freaking online class under somewhat of control where I can breathe. But I see all I missed was everyone being anti chaos, and I would’ve said guys that’s dumb, and no one would’ve listened to me. Because 9/10 I can’t get anyone on the thread to move one way or the other.

 

[Navilly]

Why?

Because she is not a wolf. And that’s one of the eat my hat statements and I have said that since day 2, on repeat.

 

[dolphin106258]

Because she is not a wolf. And that’s one of the eat my hat statements and I have said that since day 2, on repeat.

Okay? But just because I think you’re village doesn’t mean I have to listen to every inclination you have.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Sorry it’s what felt most sketchy to me at the time. But have you even given out your own reads since you joined the game that weren’t pippy’s? Or did I just miss them?

I gave my input on Barks/Cubs

 

[dolphin106258]

Btw chaos hunting is dumb. If you say you don’t believe AM and thinks she’s still a wolf well okay that’s a better argument. But just to lynch chaos because you don’t want chaos in the game IS DUMB.

 

[Navilly]

Btw chaos hunting is dumb. If you say you don’t believe AM and thinks she’s still a wolf well okay that’s a better argument. But just to lynch chaos because you don’t want chaos in the game IS DUMB.

Who says I believe they are chaos? They are flip flopping on what their role does. I am saying even if they are chaos, they are actively working against the village, so that was the best lynch for today, and I will 100% stand by that regardless of how she flips in the coming day(s)

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Sorry it’s what felt most sketchy to me at the time. But have you even given out your own reads since you joined the game that weren’t pippy’s? Or did I just miss them?

I have a few reads but I want to go over them more before I post them.

 

[dolphin106258]

I gave my input on Barks/Cubs

Yeah but when cubs was actually being lynched you voted Nav while simultaneously being like yeah lynch cubs it should be an interesting flip without actually having to vote there. But now Nav is still telling people you aren’t a wolf. So you decided to not vote him today and vote Barks in the last minutes despite being on the thread before that??? None of this adds up to sketchier behavior to anyone but me? Okay cool.

 

[dolphin106258]

Who says I believe they are chaos? They are flip flopping on what their role does. I am saying even if they are chaos, they are actively working against the village, so that was the best lynch for today, and I will 100% stand by that regardless of how she flips in the coming day(s)

Okay so I think I know what you want AM to do, completely broadcast the ins and outs of her chaos role on the thread so the wolves know exactly what’s going on. Sounds like a good plan to me.

I just think sometimes if you take a step back and realize whatever you were picking up in AM’s play could’ve been Bc she was chaos and knows majority of people are anti chaos and also realize just don’t drink things...but I mean if that’s too much for everyone just lynch her tmrw so we can have a day of no discussion.

 

[Navilly]

Yeah but when cubs was actually being lynched you voted Nav while simultaneously being like yeah lynch cubs it should be an interesting flip without actually having to vote there. But now Nav is still telling people you aren’t a wolf. So you decided to not vote him today and vote Barks in the last minutes despite being on the thread before that??? None of this adds up to sketchier behavior to anyone but me? Okay cool.

This is MsP and what she does. And every game I think about this and say I want to lynch her, and don’t, and normally actively defend against her wrongful lynches. Which I would do again. Pippy provided me with a way of knowing she is village before subbing and I am sticking with it. Could she be converted? Sure but I am not convert hunting right now.

 

[dolphin106258]

This is MsP and what she does. And every game I think about this and say I want to lynch her, and don’t, and normally actively defend against her wrongful lynches. Which I would do again. Pippy provided me with a way of knowing she is village before subbing and I am sticking with it. Could she be converted? Sure but I am not convert hunting right now.

I’d love for you to play one day where you have no extra information from anyone and have to play straight post/tone reads and VCA. That would be a beautiful day.

 

[Navilly]

I’d love for you to play one day where you have no extra information from anyone and have to play straight post/tone reads and VCA. That would be a beautiful day.

Even when we are on the same side and are not going for one another, the salt is real.

 

[WildZoo]

I’d love for you to play one day where you have no extra information from anyone and have to play straight post/tone reads and VCA. That would be a beautiful day.

Is such a thing even possible

 

[dolphin106258]

Is such a thing even possible

I mean that’s how I played when I was vanilla

 

[dolphin106258]

Even when we are on the same side and are not going for one another, the salt is real.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Yeah but when cubs was actually being lynched you voted Nav while simultaneously being like yeah lynch cubs it should be an interesting flip without actually having to vote there. But now Nav is still telling people you aren’t a wolf. So you decided to not vote him today and vote Barks in the last minutes despite being on the thread before that??? None of this adds up to sketchier behavior to anyone but me? Okay cool.

I was very interested in cubs' flip but did not vote for him because he wasn't there to defend himself and it was getting very close to lynch end. He was absent for most of the day when votes were piling up on him and I didn't feel comfortable voting for someone who wasn't there when they had a whole wagon on their lynch. I think people should have a chance to defend themselves if they choose to. I mentioned this when people were lynching stagg when he was absent in Navs game. Sometimes this can lead to bad lynches (allie). If it came down to someone who I didn't think deserved to get lynched and Cubs I definitely would have voted him though regardless. Cubs was going to get lynched whether or not I was on his lynch so I voted for the next person I found sketchy at the time.

Nav telling people I'm village was not why I no longer found him sketchy. Heck! an outed wolf voting to lynch him everyday was not the reason I found him village. I'm liking his posts so far and I've found other people sketchy.

As for the Barks vote, I was always going to vote her. I did wait to lynch her at the last minute. A lot of people change their votes around the last minute so I really didn't see the need to vote early. All the action takes place around the last 30 minutes or so anyway. Also I wasn't the only one who voted late. Genny literally waited until the last minute (after I made my vote) to lynch Dina and she was on the thread before that.

 

[dolphin106258]

I was very interested in cubs' flip but did not vote for him because he wasn't there to defend himself and it was getting very close to lynch end. He was absent for most of the day when votes were piling up on him and I didn't feel comfortable voting for someone who wasn't there when they had a whole wagon on their lynch. I think people should have a chance to defend themselves if they choose to. I mentioned this when people were lynching stagg when he was absent in Navs game. Sometimes this can lead to bad lynches (allie). If it came down to someone who I didn't think deserved to get lynched and Cubs I definitely would have voted him though regardless. Cubs was going to get lynched whether or not I was on his lynch so I voted for the next person I found sketchy at the time.

Nav telling people I'm village was not why I no longer found him sketchy. Heck! an outed wolf voting to lynch him everyday was not the reason I found him village. I'm liking his posts so far and I've found other people sketchy.

As for the Barks vote, I was always going to vote her. I did wait to lynch her at the last minute. A lot of people change their votes around the last minute so I really didn't see the need to vote early. All the action takes place around the last 30 minutes or so anyway. Also I wasn't the only one who voted late. Genny literally waited until the last minute (after I made my vote) to lynch Dina and she was on the thread before that.

Definitely not saying that voting early has to happen but just because other people on the thread wait until the last minute does not mean it is in any way helpful for everybody else to wait too. If you’re legitimately busy or away from the thread fine, but the waiting thing is honestly annoying and makes it harder to analyze after the fact in my opinion.

And Genny is only more village because of her obvious flip before but I’m not ruling out that she could be converted or didn’t come back village. And yeah Dina does that a lot too and I’m not a fan and it’s annoying. And it makes her harder to analyze, I don’t know everyone’s reasons for lynching Dina but it also doesn’t help her look any less sketchy usually (at least from my memory of past games).

 

[Navilly]

Definitely not saying that voting early has to happen but just because other people on the thread wait until the last minute does not mean it is in any way helpful for everybody else to wait too. If you’re legitimately busy or away from the thread fine, but the waiting thing is honestly annoying and makes it harder to analyze after the fact in my opinion.

And Genny is only more village because of her obvious flip before but I’m not ruling out that she could be converted or didn’t come back village. And yeah Dina does that a lot too and I’m not a fan and it’s annoying. And it makes her harder to analyze, I don’t know everyone’s reasons for lynching Dina but it also doesn’t help her look any less sketchy usually (at least from my memory of past games).

The way you are analyzing that lynch makes me think that you think AM is wolf? Or am I misunderstanding? (If I am misunderstanding could you elaborate a bit, I am curious on the logic)

Tomorrow is going to be insane for me in terms of my time commitments. Will try and check in when I can, but t may be far and few between if at all. Will be on for the majority of the day after.

In case I don’t get a chance to get on:

************contingency lynch AM**********

 

[Karabiner13]

Night closed, results pending

 

[Barkley13]

A lot of people change their votes around the last minute so I really didn't see the need to vote early. All the action takes place around the last 30 minutes or so anyway.

Okay but there’s no reason for all the action to happen at the end. If you’re here and know who you’re going to vote for why not just do it?

 

[Karabiner13]

N5

The group was getting more and more paranoid as time went on. Someone was killing people but they couldn't figure out who. They had made most of their suspects leave. Guess it was time to sleep on it. As everyone was napping someone snuck up behind DVMD and strangled her.

DVMD had just wanted to play good, old fashioned werewolf. She had even taken to applying the same principles to every other game they played. She had stayed up late pondering some deep questions as she evaluated everyone. 'Are they a villager defending their home with every fiber of their being and trying to rid it of those pesky werewolves? Or are they a werewolf trying to frame their friends and accuse them of trying to destroy the village when that's what they are really doing?' Oh well, guess you never know what will come out of the brain of the mod creating the whole experience.

Dead is @DVMDream, Werewolf, who could rez one person during the game or would auto rez if died before using ability

It is now Day 6. Lynch will close at 10pm EST

Players:
2. @StartingoverVet
3. @mizchiefmanaged
7. @WildZoo
10. @Animal Midwife
11. @Barkley13
12. @SportPonies
14. @dolphin106258
15. @Navilly
16. @Ms Procrastinator (formerly pippy)
17. @katashark
19. @genny

Battleships Sunk
18. snowy, village neighbor
5. jboo, village ability absorber thief
8. allieh, vanillager
6. skim, village designated survivors
13. cubs, wolf even night blocker
9. finn, village 2x gambler vig
1. dina, village night cancel
4. dvmd, village 1x rez

 

[Barkley13]

Lynch MsP

 

[genny]

Lynch AM

 

[StartingoverVet]

I have no reason to believe AM, and I don’t see any sign she is looking for wolves, so she has to go. Best case scenario we Lynch a wolf. Worst case scenario we Lynch a player not actively helping village.

Lynch AM

 

[WildZoo]

My POE is all messed up right now. Need to reread and do lynch trackers to get my head on straight, but just in case I don't have time (likely) for now...

lynch sobsob

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lynch kata

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lynch AM

Why?

I have no reason to believe AM, and I don’t see any sign she is looking for wolves, so she has to go. Best case scenario we Lynch a wolf. Worst case scenario we Lynch a player not actively helping village.

Lynch AM

None of my pushed lynches have flipped. How do you "know" I'm not lynching wolves?

 

[StartingoverVet]

Why?

None of my pushed lynches have flipped. How do you "know" I'm not lynching wolves?

Pretty much the only person you have pushed is me, and I know that is wrong, you are not playing the same this game. That is apparent,

 

[Animal Midwife]

Pretty much the only person you have pushed is me, and I know that is wrong, you are not playing the same this game. That is apparent,

Is kata no longer a part of this game?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Dead is @DVMDream, Werewolf, who could rez one person during the game or would auto rez if died before using ability

Also, this is very meta.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Dungeon Master Tally
Nav (5) - Nav, miz, pippy, allie, snowy, kata
Barks (2) - AM, dolph
dolph (3) - Dina, cubs, skim
dubz () -
SOV () -
DVMD (2) - DVMD, SOV, jboo
cubs (5) - barks, dubz, sporty, finn, genny
jboo () -

17/19

Day 2 Lynch Tally
jboo (2) - AM, dina
Miz (1) - snowy
kata (2) - SOV, finn
DVMD () -
Skim (1) - jboo
Nav (3) - barks, cubs, genny
Pippy (1) - miz
dubz (1) - dvmd
snowy (5) - dubz, dolph, Nav, skim, allie
sporty () -
Finn (1) - sporty

17/19
Missing: pip, kata

Day 3 Lynch Tally
finn (1) - MsP
SOV (1) - AM
allie (5) - dubz, SOV, dolph, dina, Nav
Nav (4) - sporty, barks, cubs, kata
barks (1) - miz
sporty (2) - genny, finn

14/17
Missing: DVMD, Skim, allie

Day 4 Lynch Tally
SOV () -
cubs (5) - dubz, Nav, finn, kata, miz
kata (3) - AM, barks, dina
Dina (1) - SOV
DVMD (1) - genny
Nav (3) - sporty, MsP, cubs
Sporty (1) - dolph
dubz (1) - DVMD

15/15

Day 5 Lynch Tally
MsP (2) - dolph, barks
kata () -
dina (5) - dubz, Miz, sporty, AM, genny
AM (5) - Nav, kata, DVMD, SOV, dina
SOV () -
Barks (1) - MsP

13/13

 

[dolphin106258]

Lynch AM

I have no reason to believe AM, and I don’t see any sign she is looking for wolves, so she has to go. Best case scenario we Lynch a wolf. Worst case scenario we Lynch a player not actively helping village.

Lynch AM

Will you all be planning to actively discuss other options or are we all gonna lynch AM and halt discussion today?

 

[dolphin106258]

Day 1 Dungeon Master Tally
Nav (5) - Nav, miz, pippy, allie, snowy, kata
Barks (2) - AM, dolph
dolph (3) - Dina, cubs, skim
dubz () -
SOV () -
DVMD (2) - DVMD, SOV, jboo
cubs (5) - barks, dubz, sporty, finn, genny
jboo () -

17/19

Day 2 Lynch Tally
jboo (2) - AM, dina
Miz (1) - snowy
kata (2) - SOV, finn
DVMD () -
Skim (1) - jboo
Nav (3) - barks, cubs, genny
Pippy (1) - miz
dubz (1) - dvmd
snowy (5) - dubz, dolph, Nav, skim, allie
sporty () -
Finn (1) - sporty

17/19
Missing: pip, kata

Day 3 Lynch Tally
finn (1) - MsP
SOV (1) - AM
allie (5) - dubz, SOV, dolph, dina, Nav
Nav (4) - sporty, barks, cubs, kata
barks (1) - miz
sporty (2) - genny, finn

14/17
Missing: DVMD, Skim, allie

Day 4 Lynch Tally
SOV () -
cubs (5) - dubz, Nav, finn, kata, miz
kata (3) - AM, barks, dina
Dina (1) - SOV
DVMD (1) - genny
Nav (3) - sporty, MsP, cubs
Sporty (1) - dolph
dubz (1) - DVMD

15/15

Day 5 Lynch Tally
MsP (2) - dolph, barks
kata () -
dina (5) - dubz, Miz, sporty, AM, genny
AM (5) - Nav, kata, DVMD, SOV, dina
SOV () -
Barks (1) - MsP

13/13

Also ew please don’t tell me that whole snowy lynch was villagers....unless dubz is a wolf 😱

 

[dolphin106258]

Pretty much the only person you have pushed is me, and I know that is wrong, you are not playing the same this game. That is apparent,

Who’re you pushing that doesn’t just seem to be the flavor of the day? You havent lynched a wolf either so idk why that’s suddenly the standard that has to be met.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

I could go for Barks or AM today. Lynch AM
I'll admit I let the ball drop on the AM lynch yesterday. I was stupid enough to fall for the chaos thing yesterday but it's just not adding up. That whole win condition just seems like BS.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

D6 Official tally
AM (4)- Nav, genny, SOV, MsP
MsP (1) - Barks
SOV (1) - dubs
kata (1) - AM

voting: 7/11
AM is in the lead
deadline: 8 hrs

 

[dolphin106258]

I could go for Barks or AM today. Lynch AM
I'll admit I let the ball drop on the AM lynch yesterday. I was stupid enough to fall for the chaos thing yesterday but it's just not adding up. That whole win condition just seems like BS.

....the win condition is what doesn’t add up?? Okay.

 

[genny]

Will you all be planning to actively discuss other options or are we all gonna lynch AM and halt discussion today?

We can discuss other people. Who do you like for AM’s packmates?

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

We can discuss other people. Who do you like for AM’s packmates?

I like Barks.

 

[genny]

I like Barks.

Pretty sure there’s more than one other. Who else?

 

[Animal Midwife]

omg you guys. Why don't you want to hunt wolves? I'm just chaos.

 

[genny]

omg you guys. Why don't you want to hunt wolves? I'm just chaos.

What happened to your purple letters?? I am no longer convinced!!! 😡

 

[Animal Midwife]

What happened to your purple letters?? I am no longer convinced!!! 😡

The purple was just for my announcement, silly. 😛 It's one of my fave colors!

For real though, I'm confused as to why you're voting me.

 

[Navilly]

Dolphin I get the sentiment you are going with, if you feel like too many votes on AM is stifling discussion, then yes, I will go off AM. But I will likely be there by end of day.

******unlynch AM*******

Other originals could be Barkley, sporty, and SoV.

Dubz is not an original. MsP wasn’t. Miz wasn’t. Genny wasn’t. Dolphin wasn’t. Kata highly likely wasn’t.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

....the win condition is what doesn’t add up?? Okay.

She said her win condition is to get 3 people to drink her milkshakes. One person died from drinking the milkshake but she insists that they aren't poisonous (at least not all of them).

I dunno? It seemed funny at the time? Don't know if you would would actually get poisoned or not though. More of a roulette of flavors.

I have n=1, so not sure.

In this post she's saying that there are different flavors but I'm the only one that got a flavor so far. Why would the mods not include flavors if she had chosen different flavors to give to people. I'm more willing to believe that she's a PR wolf than a chaos killer who has no idea what the drinks she's handing out to people do. Poison drinks (even one confirmed) lean more towards serial killer than chaos to me. It's safer for AM to claim Chaos than serial killer of course.

I'm all for Barks as another wolf in the pack. This interaction just makes me even more sure of it.

Have there been different flavors? Because I’m kinda willing to believe different flavors do different things

Yes. Only one has been tried.

Also, it's been confirmed that there aren't different flavors and I'm pretty sure the mods wouldn't let you choose a flavor drink and then not give the person you chose that flavor.

Dubz has been saying that AM can't force anyone to drink the drinks and she's right. That still doesn't mean that she can't be a wolf making poisonous drinks. Sometimes there can be catches to wolf PR. For example in Navs game doggo had an extra wolf kill but they could only kill people if they were animal. Maybe AM can only kill people if they drink the drinks.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Also Genny why did you vote Dina yesterday?

 

[Animal Midwife]

She said her win condition is to get 3 people to drink her milkshakes. One person died from drinking the milkshake but she insists that they aren't poisonous (at least not all of them).


In this post she's saying that there are different flavors but I'm the only one that got a flavor so far. Why would the mods not include flavors if she had chosen different flavors to give to people. I'm more willing to believe that she's a PR wolf than a chaos killer who has no idea what the drinks she's handing out to people do. Poison drinks (even one confirmed) lean more towards serial killer than chaos to me. It's safer for AM to claim Chaos than serial killer of course.

I'm all for Barks as another wolf in the pack. This interaction just makes me even more sure of it.




Also, it's been confirmed that there aren't different flavors and I'm pretty sure the mods wouldn't let you choose a flavor drink and then not give the person you chose that flavor.

Dubz has been saying that AM can't force anyone to drink the drinks and she's right. That still doesn't mean that she can't be a wolf making poisonous drinks. Sometimes there can be catches to wolf PR. For example in Navs game doggo had an extra wolf kill but they could only kill people if they were animal. Maybe AM can only kill people if they drink the drinks.

MsP... What are you going on about? Do you know genny somehow didn't get a flavor?

 

[Barkley13]

it's been confirmed that there aren't different flavors

Who confirmed this?

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

MsP... What are you going on about? Do you know genny somehow didn't get a flavor?

So far I know there was a drink, a smoothie and my chocolate milkshake. Even if genny did get a flavor, not everybody did so obviously flavor doesn't have anything to do with it.