GlobetWWotting: Food Edition - GAME THREAD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I don’t have much of an opinion on him yet, I need till after yeet close to form one
I don’t wanna hold inactivity against anyone until it’s been a full cycle
Yeah, it's hard getting a feel for someone when they have four posts and one of them is just "third!"
 
Not going to try to talk you out of this, but I feel much better about Stoat after sleeping on it and looking back over the thread. She's definitely a little weirdly sure about genny (and I also don't see how she could be), but it's normal for her to be weirdly confident about her takes.
Notes that confidence in takes is normal
But for now it’s what I got
If a stronger lean come sup later I’ll move my vote
 
Can’t exclude that possibility. Stoat’s jumping on different people was weird. But on the other hand Genny’s vote was weird too. I had flimsy reasoning for my Zenge vote so I wonder why she didn’t pick on me instead.
I will phrase this better by pulling on some genny meta in our other two games. Tl;dr surprise she voted for me (I think she circled me when she was scum in stardew as well?) turned into an angry "oh I recognize this behavior, this is a wolf, no thank u"

She is a lowposter so I have zero qualms about sticking to my guns @vetschoolsletmeinplease

This is about as active as she has been in my other two games with her
 
So was it her initial vote you disagreed with or the later village read?
I disagreed with the vote (which, left unchanged would have bothered me less) but I disagreed more with the transition of going from voting for him to village leaning him without interacting w him in between
Or him being here for any interaction beyond a couple of joke posts
 
I disagreed with the vote (which, left unchanged would have bothered me less) but I disagreed more with the transition of going from voting for him to village leaning him without interacting w him in between
Or him being here for any interaction beyond a couple of joke posts
If Zenge is a wolf he's established a brilliant meta; no one can confidently wolf-read you on Day 1 if you're just not around.
 
If Zenge is a wolf he's established a brilliant meta; no one can confidently wolf-read you on Day 1 if you're just not around.
I mean I don’t think that’s fair
Stuff happens to not be around for like a day
Now if he continues to not be here past today then absolutely Ill find that sus
But I don’t find much value in speculating on people that aren’t here on d1
Could that lead me astray? Absolutely
But is how I prefer to play
 
I mean I don’t think that’s fair
Stuff happens to not be around for like a day
Now if he continues to not be here past today then absolutely Ill find that sus
But I don’t find much value in speculating on people that aren’t here on d1
Could that lead me astray? Absolutely
But is how I prefer to play
Not that this probably changes much in the grand scheme of things, but I wouldn't say Zenge isn't here. That's reserved for zeroposters or people that otherwise miss the minimum. I have yet to see Zenge do either in a game.
 
yeah i have to agree- i know zenge tends to be lurky early on, so i don’t think i feel comfortable placing a yeet there right now, but i want to see more from him.
also bluestoat, i want to hear your reasoning for thinking he’s village. i really apologize if i missed it, i’ve just been on my phone the past 2 days. but i remember reading that you voted for him to see how he would react as a test, but how did the test go to make you think he’s village?
 
Not that this probably changes much in the grand scheme of things, but I wouldn't say Zenge isn't here. That's reserved for zeroposters or people that otherwise miss the minimum. I have yet to see Zenge do either in a game.
I will refrain from Zengebullying until at least tomorrow 😇
 
I mean I don’t think that’s fair
Stuff happens to not be around for like a day
Now if he continues to not be here past today then absolutely Ill find that sus
But I don’t find much value in speculating on people that aren’t here on d1
Could that lead me astray? Absolutely
But is how I prefer to play
Yeah Zenge is a tough read. In BoWWling, my first game ever with him, he was a wolf and he was around but he was echoing other people’s reads a lot. People gave him a hard time on not pushing people again on MarWWel but he was a villager. He was widely village-read in that game after voting for wolves. So it’s hard to read him until a wolf flips.
 
Yeah Zenge is a tough read. In BoWWling, my first game ever with him, he was a wolf and he was around but he was echoing other people’s reads a lot. People gave him a hard time on not pushing people again on MarWWel but he was a villager. He was widely village-read in that game after voting for wolves. So it’s hard to read him until a wolf flips.
Easy solution: we flip a wolf tonight 😀
 
Who's villagey to you?
Dubz, but she was also villagey in StardeWW (but I want to belieeeeve)

AM feels exactly the same as always, though I acknowledge that I haven't played with her while she's woofin', but still

You feel normal to me <3

Fluff seems like village-Fluff, though perhaps her experience last game was enough to level her up and now she's Super Powerful Boss-Wolf Fluff (unlikely)
 
yeah i have to agree- i know zenge tends to be lurky early on, so i don’t think i feel comfortable placing a yeet there right now, but i want to see more from him.
also bluestoat, i want to hear your reasoning for thinking he’s village. i really apologize if i missed it, i’ve just been on my phone the past 2 days. but i remember reading that you voted for him to see how he would react as a test, but how did the test go to make you think he’s village?
Note to myself to get back to this.

I want to respond properly because I spent this morning trying to remember why I thought True was wolfy last night (I left commentary in my role PM that reminded me, and I'm chewing on some other notes I left for myself there). I would like to properly lay out why I feel what I feel, since it is based on words and approach. It needs to be phrased properly for me to be understood and for the pattern that made it reasoning instead of randomness to be clear.
 
Lol I wish!
You and Zenge feel the most village to me. Zenge seems... I don't know how to phrase it. He's relaxed and jokey when he's not a wolf, but it's not like he doesn't joke when he's a wolf. He just doesn't seem relaxed. I could be wrong but I feel very comfortable with how he's posted so far. I will change this feeling if something sets me off but he reads like a villager who isn't concerned about being wolf coded or needing to mantain an image. He's the only player that kind of thought process actually applies to for me, because I have gotten correct village reads of him from it before.

As I get to know players more, I individualize their assessments more. For example, I refuse to village read AM until she votes a wolf because I'm sure I can't read her otherwise.
 
I'm feeling a bit spooked because @vetschoolsletmeinplease is posting a good amount but I am not seeing anything from their posts that makes me feel like they're villaging.
That's why schoolspls is a X? in my reads list

They haven't played for a while so I want to watch before deciding how to lean them. So easy to be spooked by an unknown variable.
 
You and Zenge feel the most village to me. Zenge seems... I don't know how to phrase it. He's relaxed and jokey when he's not a wolf, but it's not like he doesn't joke when he's a wolf. He just doesn't seem relaxed. I could be wrong but I feel very comfortable with how he's posted so far. I will change this feeling if something sets me off but he reads like a villager who isn't concerned about being wolf coded or needing to mantain an image. He's the only player that kind of thought process actually applies to for me, because I have gotten correct village reads of him from it before.

As I get to know players more, I individualize their assessments more. For example, I refuse to village read AM until she votes a wolf because I'm sure I can't read her otherwise.
Your strong takes on super-low-posters is making me furrow my brows, pls desist
 
Your earlier mention that you don't put 100% of what you're thinking on thread is making me wonder how you ACTUALLY feel about stoaty
Lol I never should have said that, now everything I say will get picked apart for double meanings

If anything, I spew too much of my thoughts on the thread, the fact that I keep any for myself is the real marvel
 
I stop bullying True now. He should listen to me though. I'm sure of what I'm sure of and will explain in length later.
 
You know what pings me? That he's so invested in my Zenge and Genny reads. That's new.
I don't feel very invested? Just trying to pay more attention and be more active this game after getting demolished in StardeWW and then completely carried by other people in MarWWel.
 
"Stoat is a normal villager to me but also I don't think her reads are reliable, just so you all know. I'm going to village read her but gently encourage that you all look away from her thoughts". That's never happened before.
I feel like this is a pretty harsh way to interpret me being surprised at your strong reads on two people who barely meet the post minimum put together.
 
I feel like this is a pretty harsh way to interpret me being surprised at your strong reads on two people who barely meet the post minimum put together.
Truey pls you live with me

When am I not harsh

My opinions are like anvils
 
I feel like this is a pretty harsh way to interpret me being surprised at your strong reads on two people who barely meet the post minimum put together.
Also you just told schools that being confident in my reads is NAI for me
 
Being NAI doesn't mean I can't push you to back up your opinions in a way the rest of us can grok
This is true! I like this. But please note that I want to take some time to iso and build on what set me off to explain that it's not just vibes. It won't be the most convincing post ever but my goal is for it to be clarifying.
 
Good morning everyone! Unyeet true.

I'm short on time rn but I should have an hour or more in the afternoon to look at the thread better.

(And, yeah, the true vote was just a placeholder, I'll cast a real yeet later.)

Sorry that I'm not great on time right now, I'll have more time to analyze everyone's posts later. Vague thoughts right now though are that stoaty seems to be going out of her to way to point fingers at genny and Zenge,, which makes me want to village/neutral-read her, even if idk if I agree. Everyone else has felt relatively normal so far, but I haven't had my tea yet so that might change.
 
Good morning everyone! Unyeet true.

I'm short on time rn but I should have an hour or more in the afternoon to look at the thread better.

(And, yeah, the true vote was just a placeholder, I'll cast a real yeet later.)

Sorry that I'm not great on time right now, I'll have more time to analyze everyone's posts later. Vague thoughts right now though are that stoaty seems to be going out of her to way to point fingers at genny and Zenge,, which makes me want to village/neutral-read her, even if idk if I agree. Everyone else has felt relatively normal so far, but I haven't had my tea yet so that might change.
Unyeeting me? Instant village read, Violet is good and noble
 
If Zenge is a wolf he's established a brilliant meta; no one can confidently wolf-read you on Day 1 if you're just not around.
I'm around plenty! What would you like to discuss?
 
I would not read too much into what she's saying right now, she weighs about as much as two ducks and had three strong drinks
Looking back, I wolf-ish read you for this because I was partly like "how DARE you silence me" but now I'm looking at my posts and it's like... Hm yeah you may have had a point. I need to re-read the thread.
 
I’m feeling a bit better about true today even though I don’t agree w most of their logic, esp regarding z
And speaking of z
I feel worst about stoat
I didn’t and don’t really understand either vote
And then I REALLY can’t wrap my head around being *so* sure of genny when genny had such a low post count
It would be bold for a woof but stranger things have happened



For now,
Yeet stoat
Meh. I don't like this vote.
 
Good morning everyone! Unyeet true.

I'm short on time rn but I should have an hour or more in the afternoon to look at the thread better.

(And, yeah, the true vote was just a placeholder, I'll cast a real yeet later.)

Sorry that I'm not great on time right now, I'll have more time to analyze everyone's posts later. Vague thoughts right now though are that stoaty seems to be going out of her to way to point fingers at genny and Zenge,, which makes me want to village/neutral-read her, even if idk if I agree. Everyone else has felt relatively normal so far, but I haven't had my tea yet so that might change.
I didn't have a strong wolf read on Zenge, since you're skimming you may have missed that. I was waiting for Zenge to respond or post more (and tbh was going to vote midwife for the same reason, but Dubz voted her just before me). I don't think AM or Zenge feel wolfy, but I don't want to village read AM without vote proof. The Genny vote is a 100% real vote because I find her thread efforts very typical of the kind of wolf circling I ignored in earlier games.
 
Top