Ladies and Gentlemen... a Noob WW Game Thread!

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Alright I'm on board with this logic for now, I would like to hear from killerleaf today

Lynch killerleaf
 
Doctor-S said:
At this moment:

I am inclined to believe the following people are villagers (and I am also using a process of elimination):

1. wallydo (because wally was, in fact, the first person who stated that she was, in fact, visited by a fortune teller at night).

2. Lyra (because Lyra was the second person who stated that she was visited by a fortune teller at night).

3. mmm (because mmm was the third person who stated that she was visited by a fortune teller at night).

4. SAR (although SAR did not disclose that SAR was visited by a fortune teller at night, SAR was the fourth person who reported the same "fortune-telling night visit" and her story matches the "fortune-telling-at-night" stories already reported by wally, Lyra, and mmm).

5. serher (because serher was defended by Lyra yesterday ans if I believe Lyra, then I am inclined to believe that serher is a villager because Lyra repeatedly defended serher from being lynched on D6).

6. TrashPanda [because mmm has defended TP. (See Post #2958). At this time, I am trying to believe mmm.]

7. Kittenmittens (KM also reported the same paralyzing liquid incident that I reported. So, since KM's story matches my own story; and since KM adamently defended SAR on D6, I am inclined to believe KM at this moment, absent any evidence to the contrary).

However ...

1. I am unsure about @killerleaf at this moment. Although kl outed BOB (Wolf 1), is it possible that kl changed into a wolf or something else (another chaos thing)?

2. I am also unsure about @sheltermed (although we all know that sheltermed is going through a very distressful time right now due to her missing dog. I think it's safe to say that everyone here is feeling badly for sheltermed at this time).
Click to expand...

I feel very much on the same page as you Dr. S
 
Trilt said:
Lynch Tally (D7):
KB (2) - Lyra, Mmmm
TPan (1) - S&M
KL (4) - Serher, Wally, Dr-S, KM

7/11 accounted for
Deadline 9pm EST (~4hrs away)
Click to expand...
...

TnkQTtC.gif
 
I'm stuck somewhere between karab and killer...so i guess one or the other needs to defend themselves before i can really decide...
 
Karabiner13 said:
Ok, I can’t PM with anyone and no one has PM’d with me which may be why no one has a strong opinion about me. I try to post my thoughts but even in real life I am quiet, succinct, and observant which translates into fewer posts and sometimes sitting back. Because I can’t PM with anyone, I get what information I have from the write-ups and discussion so I look over them carefully. Although I might be guilty of over analyzing and reaching for something that isn’t there.
Click to expand...

Karabiner13 said:
From the beginning I tried to imply my understanding of roles if I knew them so that I would not be outing anyone and making them a target to the wolves (#293). This has probably led me to hold my own role information pretty tight. I believed DrS early on based on what I understood of her role although not always her thinking (#296). When I thought we were thinking wrong about redirection, I mentioned it (#964) and checked with my mentor (#1206). I also relayed information about chaos based on my interpretation of the write-up and what my mentor told me (#1348). I tried to post my interpretation of write-ups in case there were clues which were sometimes missed by others (#1206). I pointed out that villagers despite being confusing are worth keeping around for numbers (#1791).
Click to expand...

I have used my ability for the good of the village especially on N3 and not for killing. I'd prefer to not to have to say more.

What questions may I answer?
 
TrashPanda said:
Why do you believe sheltermed? It's not that I don't, it's just that she's said so little I have no way of knowing.
Click to expand...
Mostly gut instinct, and her posts yesterday sounded more like she's a useful villager to me.
Doctor-S said:
serher (because serher was defended by Lyra yesterday ans if I believe Lyra, then I am inclined to believe that serher is a villager because Lyra repeatedly defended serher from being lynched on D6).
Click to expand...
You must be thinking of somebody else, I wasn't around when serher almost got lynched yesterday. I believed her defense, but I have no real reason to defend her myself.
 
:coldfeet::bucktooth::cyclops::angelic::dead::bucktooth::grumpy::bucktooth::cow::happy::bucktooth::cow:👽:eggface::cigar::couchpotato::asshat:😱:happy::cold:😀🙄:coldfeet::bear:

Tip for future games: It's much easier to follow arguements if you guys just click the +quote (for multiple posts) or reply (for one post) on the bottom right of a post and quote all the messages you're referring to rather than using post numbers. Saves a lot of trouble of having to go back and hunt down a post after someone brings it up. 🙂

ETA: especially for those last minute lynches you guys seem so fond of. 😉

:lurking::smug::stop::sour::smuggrin::zombie::heckyeah::smuggrin::wacky::yawn:🤐:stinkyfeet::snaphappy::smug::singing::snaphappy::spitoutpacifier::pompous::sorry::smug::wacky:
 
LyraGardenia said:
Mostly gut instinct, and her posts yesterday sounded more like she's a useful villager to me.

You must be thinking of somebody else, I wasn't around when serher almost got lynched yesterday. I believed her defense, but I have no real reason to defend her myself.
Click to expand...

She's prob thinking of me?
 
Okay I went and read back through killer's posts...

nothing outright wolf-y, but then her lack of defense has me suspicious...and her whole death and then un-death leaves me wondering...

unlynch kar

lynch killerleaf
 
mmmdreamerz said:
Okay I went and read back through killer's posts...

nothing outright wolf-y, but then her lack of defense has me suspicious...and her whole death and then un-death leaves me wondering...

unlynch kar

lynch killerleaf
Click to expand...

I agree with you on that. I'm just not confident enough with how resurrections work in this game to be confident that she's not a wolf, or even another chaos, since a chaos player wouldn't care if she gave up a wolf
 
I understand yall's concerns. I have been very quiet, probably too quiet. I am just a villager now, without the ability to seer. however, we are getting down towards critical numbers...we need all the villagers we can get. SAR said something to the effect of at least we won't lose one with abilities....uh, guys we don't need to lose any villagers.
 
###Lynch SAR####

because of attitude that we can afford to lose villagers
 
killerleaf said:
I understand yall's concerns. I have been very quiet, probably too quiet. I am just a villager now, without the ability to seer. however, we are getting down towards critical numbers...we need all the villagers we can get. SAR said something to the effect of at least we won't lose one with abilities....uh, guys we don't need to lose any villagers.
Click to expand...

Did anything happen to you overnight?

I agree I thought that post by SAR was a little strange, though I understand what she meant.
 
not last night, but night before I had someone watching over me.
 
killerleaf said:
###Lynch SAR####

because of attitude that we can afford to lose villagers
Click to expand...

I do not think we can afford to lose villagers - however our track record for finding wolves is not the greatest. So if we have to choose someone who may be wolf or chaos, we can at least hedge our bets in knowing you aren't a seer anymore
 
Interesting. I will be back, but not until pretty close till lynch close. I think I will regret leaving lol. Sorry if I miss critical discussion, but I will catch up.
 
[My Update at 7:35 PM/4:35 PST]

At this moment:

I am inclined to believe the following people are villagers (and I am using a process of elimination):

1. wallydo - because wally was, in fact, the first person who stated that she was, in fact, visited by a fortune teller at nighttime. Since I do not have any information to disbelieve wally at this moment, I am inclined to believe wally is a villager.

2. Lyra - because Lyra was the second person who stated that she was visited by a fortune teller at nighttime. Since I do not have any information to disbelieve Lyra at this moment, I am inclined to believe Lyra is a villager.

3. mmm - because mmm was the third person who stated that she was visited by a fortune teller at nighttime. Since I do not have any information to disbelieve mmm at this moment, I am inclined to believe mmm is a villager.

It would be useful to determine if the nighttime fortune-teller person is a "villager," or if they are a wolf. Is it possible that a wolf has obtained an "item" that would allow the wolf to come to a villager, at nighttime, and tell (or not tell) the villager's fortune? I don't know.

4. SAR.

Today, we learned that SAR is the fourth person who reported the same "fortune-telling nighttime visitor" story. If this is true, it means that SAR's story matches a similar (but not necessarily identical) "fortune-telling-at-nighttime" story that was already reported by wally, Lyra and mmm.

It might be useful to remember that karabiner has also defended SAR in the past; and it is useful to note that Karabiner also told us:

Karabiner: “Despite my original vote last night for SAR, I now believe she [SAR] is a villager and quite possibly did a lot for us.”

Therefore, it is possible that Kara knows something important about SAR that is beneficial to the villagers. If karabiner's statement is true (and at this time, I do not have any reason to disbelieve karabiner), I do not want to lynch SAR. However, I would like to know "why" karabiner said that SAR "quite possibly did a lot for us."

5. serher - because serher was defended by mmm yesterday; and mmm did not want serher to be lynched.

If I believe mmm, then I am inclined to believe that serher is a villager because mmm strongly defended serher from being lynched on D6. Plus, serher also told us that she [seher] was protected on one night. So, is it possible that serher may have been protected by an "item" made by KM (because KM has told us that she [KM] had the ability to make "items." I don't know. KM has also told us that she is a "magician."

6. TrashPanda - because mmm has defended TP in the past. At this time, I am trying to believe mmm; and therefore, I am inclined to believe that TP is a villager.

7. Kittenmittens - because KM also reported the same "paralyzing-liquid-attack" incident that I [DrS] reported. So, if KM's story is true (i.e., if her story also matches my own paralyzing-liquid-attack story); and since KM adamantly defended SAR on D6, I am inclined to believe KM at this moment (absent any evidence to the contrary).

8. Karabiner voted to lynch BOB (Wolf 1). Kara also voted to lynch HH (Wolf 2). Kara has also defended SAR (as noted above) by insinuating that SAR is a villager and that SAR "quite possibly did a lot for the villagers."

However ...

1. Killerleaf: I am still unsure about @killerleaf at this moment. Although killerleaf "outed" BOB (Wolf 1), is it possible that kl changed into a wolf or something else (another chaos-type thingy)? I don't know. When asked by serher if anything happened to killerleaf last night (N6), killerleaf responded:

Killerleaf: "not last night, but night before I had someone watching over me." What does that mean?

2. I am unsure about @sheltermed (although we all know that sheltermed is going through a very distressful time right now due to her missing dog. I think it's safe to say that everyone here is feeling badly for sheltermed at this time). I don't know. [Despite the mods admonitions about real-life stuff and WW, I do not want to cause sheltermed any further emotional distress.]
 
Doctor-S said:
[My Update at 7:35 PM/4:35 PST]

Karabiner: “Despite my original vote last night for SAR, I now believe she [SAR] is a villager and quite possibly did a lot for us.”

Therefore, it is possible that Kara knows something important about SAR that is beneficial to the villagers. If karabiner's statement is true (and at this time, I do not have any reason to disbelieve karabiner), I do not want to lynch SAR. However, I would like to know "why" karabiner said that SAR "quite possibly did a lot for us."
Click to expand...

I don't know how to say it without revealing the ability that I suspect. If I didn't over interpret, I arrived at my suspicion by looking at SAR's defense on D4 and events that happened N3
 
Doctor-S said:
[My Update at 7:35 PM/4:35 PST]

At this moment:

I am inclined to believe the following people are villagers (and I am using a process of elimination):

1. wallydo - because wally was, in fact, the first person who stated that she was, in fact, visited by a fortune teller at nighttime. Since I do not have any information to disbelieve wally at this moment, I am inclined to believe wally is a villager.

2. Lyra - because Lyra was the second person who stated that she was visited by a fortune teller at nighttime. Since I do not have any information to disbelieve Lyra at this moment, I am inclined to believe Lyra is a villager.

3. mmm - because mmm was the third person who stated that she was visited by a fortune teller at nighttime. Since I do not have any information to disbelieve mmm at this moment, I am inclined to believe mmm is a villager.

It would be useful to determine if the nighttime fortune-teller person is a "villager," or if they are a wolf. Is it possible that a wolf has obtained an "item" that would allow the wolf to come to a villager, at nighttime, and tell (or not tell) the villager's fortune? I don't know.

4. SAR.

Today, we learned that SAR is the fourth person who reported the same "fortune-telling nighttime visitor" story. If this is true, it means that SAR's story matches a similar (but not necessarily identical) "fortune-telling-at-nighttime" story that was already reported by wally, Lyra and mmm.

It might be useful to remember that karabiner has also defended SAR in the past; and it is useful to note that Karabiner also told us:

Karabiner: “Despite my original vote last night for SAR, I now believe she [SAR] is a villager and quite possibly did a lot for us.”

Therefore, it is possible that Kara knows something important about SAR that is beneficial to the villagers. If karabiner's statement is true (and at this time, I do not have any reason to disbelieve karabiner), I do not want to lynch SAR. However, I would like to know "why" karabiner said that SAR "quite possibly did a lot for us."

5. serher - because serher was defended by mmm yesterday; and mmm did not want serher to be lynched.

If I believe mmm, then I am inclined to believe that serher is a villager because mmm strongly defended serher from being lynched on D6. Plus, serher also told us that she [seher] was protected on one night. So, is it possible that serher may have been protected by an "item" made by KM (because KM has told us that she [KM] had the ability to make "items." I don't know. KM has also told us that she is a "magician."

6. TrashPanda - because mmm has defended TP in the past. At this time, I am trying to believe mmm; and therefore, I am inclined to believe that TP is a villager.

7. Kittenmittens - because KM also reported the same "paralyzing-liquid-attack" incident that I [DrS] reported. So, if KM's story is true (i.e., if her story also matches my own paralyzing-liquid-attack story); and since KM adamantly defended SAR on D6, I am inclined to believe KM at this moment (absent any evidence to the contrary).

8. Karabiner voted to lynch BOB (Wolf 1). Kara also voted to lynch HH (Wolf 2). Kara has also defended SAR (as noted above) by insinuating that SAR is a villager and that SAR "quite possibly did a lot for the villagers."

However ...

1. Killerleaf: I am still unsure about @killerleaf at this moment. Although killerleaf "outed" BOB (Wolf 1), is it possible that kl changed into a wolf or something else (another chaos-type thingy)? I don't know. When asked by serher if anything happened to killerleaf last night (N6), killerleaf responded:

Killerleaf: "not last night, but night before I had someone watching over me." What does that mean?

2. I am unsure about @sheltermed (although we all know that sheltermed is going through a very distressful time right now due to her missing dog. I think it's safe to say that everyone here is feeling badly for sheltermed at this time). I don't know. [Despite the mods admonitions about real-life stuff and WW, I do not want to cause sheltermed any further emotional distress.]
Click to expand...

WW isn't causing me emotional distress -- no worries 🙂
 
Karabiner13 said:
I don't know how to say it without revealing the ability that I suspect. If I didn't over interpret, I arrived at my suspicion by looking at SAR's defense on D4 and events that happened N3
Click to expand...
I would say, based on that (I think I know exactly to what you are referring to), that you definitely did not over-interpret. 😉
 
[In case it's useful, here is the final lynch tally from *yesterday (Thursday/D6)* in case anyone wants to see it and compare notes]

Officialish Final Lynch Tally for D6 (Thursday):

Mmmm () -
Lyra (1) - Snowy
S&M ()
KB (1) - Lyra
SAR (2) - Dr-S, T-Pain
Serher () -
Snowy (4) - KL, Karabou, SAR, Wally
TP () -
Wally (3) - Serher, mmdreamz, KM
 
Ljmp9od.jpg

The elephant never forgot, and during these past days she had been simply... sad.

She had been brutally wounded by someone she had worked with for years; hurt to the point that most had thought her dead. It was only through heroic measures that she had weakly found her spirit again, and had been slowly healing and finding her place back in this motley show that she called home. But it hurt. Everything still hurt.

So when the crowd began to gather around her, she barely bothered to raise her head. What use was it? She had done her best, and if they didn't believe her after her years of good-spirited service, working daily with people whom she could crush with the slightest blow, what could convince them?

If they didn't trust her despite her bringing the very woman who had betrayed her to justice, what was she going to do? It had been such a long run, and maybe it was time to be done.

As their cruel blows rained down, she retreated into her mind and remembered happier, warmer days.

Dead is @killerleaf, Circus Elephant, a villager who no longer had any abilities.
​
It is now Night 7, and there are 10 performers remaining. Please submit all night actions by ***10AM EST*** tomorrow morning.

- - - - ----------------------
ODNnSSm.png
---------------------- - - - -​

ROSTER:
1. @mmmdreamerz
3. @Karabiner13
9. @Doctor-S
10. @sheltermed
11. @serher
12. @TrashPanda
15. @SARdoghandler
20. @kittenmittens524
22. @LyraGardenia
23. @wallydo

DEAD:
4. @LetItSnow - FORMERLY The Oldest Man Alive
5. @Coopah - Diving Horse
8. @cdoconn - Mime
19. @hygebeorht - Juggler
16. @awesomenessity - Snake Charmer
13. @Animal Midwife - Fortune Teller
14. @raf2769 - Daredevil Motorcyclist
21. @Bottle of Bear - Lion Tamer
17. @Coopah - Contortionist
18. @hurtem&healem - Human Skeleton
7. @SkiOtter - Bicycle Bear
2. @SnowshoeDog143 - Tightrope Walker
6. @killerleaf - Circus Elephant (still)
 
Last edited:
Wow, that was a depressing writeup. I'll admit I did worry as today went on that KL may have been converted, but I guess not. Maybe tomorrow y'all should listen to me?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
157
Views
9K
samac
samac
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
37K
Clem J
Clem J
SportPonies
Noob WW Game 2023 Sign Ups OPEN!
Replies
40
Views
2K
SportPonies
SportPonies
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
30K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top