Magical WW Signups and Game Thread

[hazelmoo]

---

Members do not see this ad.

One hour remaining!!

 

[LadyOtheFarm]

Agree with you 100%.

Like I said, that post is definitely not enough for me to throw a lynch vote at her at all. She's either learning because we all think she's suspicious so often or she's adjusting her play because she's not a villager. Trying to figure out which at this stage in the game based on like two posts is realistically not gonna happen. It's more likely that I've just noticed her actively changing her play style and me calling her out for not being suspicious is an accidental way of complimenting her.

Also, are you enjoying the catch 22 @LadyOtheFarm ? You're seeming sketchy to me because you're not seeming sketchy to me 😛

I comment on it every game. I would prefer to talk more. It would be more fun. I get killed or lynched if I talk.😳

I have the start of a migraine and I tend to get verbose because I can't keep track of my thoughts as well. So I am talking elsewhere. You are all welcome.

 

[nyanko]

that's not true i was a little annoyed too by all those words

 

[Skimble]

Except yesterday?

I wasn't in the lead yesterday, I am today.

I didn't want to out this at all, but I guess I have to. I don't have a lynch avoidance, but I do have a one time ability that I could use to cancel this lynch. I didn't want to say it because I'd much rather use that ability in a different, more useful way, but I will use it today if I have to and I implore everyone to look into me tonight no matter what happens during this lynch.

 

[vetmedhead]

that's not true i was a little annoyed too by all those words

I thought you were kind of always annoyed though

 

[LetItSnow]

I comment on it every game. I would prefer to talk more. It would be more fun. I get killed or lynched if I talk.😳

I have the start of a migraine and I tend to get verbose because I can't keep track of my thoughts as well. So I am talking elsewhere. You are all welcome.

It isn't how much you say, it is the way it is said that has set off alarms previously. Volume has nothing to do with it. Volume (game-focused) is awesome.

 

[Mad Jack]

Lynch gwen

 

[nyanko]

I thought you were kind of always annoyed though

maybe you damn kids shouldn't be so annoying then!!??????

 

[LetItSnow]

I wasn't in the lead yesterday, I am today.

I didn't want to out this at all, but I guess I have to. I don't have a lynch avoidance, but I do have a one time ability that I could use to cancel this lynch. I didn't want to say it because I'd much rather use that ability in a different, more useful way, but I will use it today if I have to and I implore everyone to look into me tonight no matter what happens during this lynch.

In that case, we should lynch you to get the ability off the table in case you really are a wolf. Wouldn't be smart to risk letting a wolf carry that ability into later game.

 

[Gwenevre]

that's not true i was a little annoyed too by all those words

And we're not the only ones that get annoyed by a lot of words. I was just the first one to comment about it.

 

[finnickthedog]

Man, this is what I get for taking a nap. I think I'm mostly caught up here, probably missed a little bit due to skimming.

So... Jilary revealed to me. If a villager she could be useful. She does sound villagery to me and I don't mean that just in terms of role but her response to being lynched reminds me of a previous game where she was lynched as a villager. Then again, I don't actually remember how she acted when lynched as a wolf so it's possible she acts the same regardless.

Personally, I'm still not thrilled with AM but I'm not unhappy enough to lynch her about it. I certainly hope someone has looked into her at this point and for now I will assume that someone has.

As for gwen... what is the thinking behind voting for her and have we heard any response?

 

[Gwenevre]

Sidebar, is there an actual legit basis for my lynch? IIRC, this started when STL didn't like the front runners.

 

[allyphoe]

What's the case for Gwen? Will go back and read, too.

 

[hazelmoo]

Current Lynch Tally

Jil (7)- trilt, LIS, Kam, Caiter, Gwen, AM, VMH
AM (3)- Hayley, allyphoe, crayola
genny (2)- DVMD, Jil
Gwen (6)- STL, LoTF, FFM, MQ, raf, MJ
Trilt (2)- genny, dyachei
Raf(1)- nyanko

21/23

 

[Caiter92]

I wasn't in the lead yesterday, I am today.

I didn't want to out this at all, but I guess I have to. I don't have a lynch avoidance, but I do have a one time ability that I could use to cancel this lynch. I didn't want to say it because I'd much rather use that ability in a different, more useful way, but I will use it today if I have to and I implore everyone to look into me tonight no matter what happens during this lynch.

Your unwillingness to share anything about yourself and instead 1)lynch someone you said was probably a villager after voting for them and 2) waste an ability you think is important really isn't helping your case.


Jk, Finn posted while I was typing. forgot you had revealed some to people in your group

 

[allyphoe]

Having gone back to read, the case for gwen looks like two votes for "seemed annoyed" and 4 votes with no reason given.

 

[heyyimhayley]

Can I get a TLDR? sorry been on a wine tour since 10am. Just got on now , I'll read through but it would be helpful if people could tell me who the top contenders are and why?

 

[nyanko]

it's you. you are a top contender. because reasons.

 

[Gwenevre]

If someone cares to look into me tonight, feel free. My ability is passive so my nights are uneventful.

 

[Ceke2002]

*********
I'm just picturing some of you guys playing a table top style game, and having blazened across your character sheets - "Does not like talking, mute but points at things, can't always make self understood"
*********

 

[allyphoe]

Can I get a TLDR? sorry been on a wine tour since 10am. Just got on now , I'll read through but it would be helpful if people could tell me who the top contenders are and why?

Jil for reasons, Gwen for no reasons, AM for having been in the lead before.

 

[vetmedhead]

Current Lynch Tally

Jil (7)- trilt, LIS, Kam, Caiter, Gwen, AM, VMH
AM (3)- Hayley, allyphoe, crayola
genny (2)- DVMD, Jil
Gwen (6)- STL, LoTF, FFM, MQ, raf, MJ
Trilt (2)- genny, dyachei
Raf(1)- nyanko

21/23

Can I get a TLDR? sorry been on a wine tour since 10am. Just got on now , I'll read through but it would be helpful if people could tell me who the top contenders are and why?

As for why, jil because of her PBC vote and general sketching, plus a lynch cancel ability
AM for inconsistent/bad defenses and some confusion about why she hasn't been killed yet if her role is important
Genny because Feely feels and also some posts that seem weirdly worded/sharing info in a not super timely manner
Gwen because ??????
Trilt for playing aggressively and leading the PBC lynch, plus apparently a sketchy role name
Raf because nyanko hates us ****ed annoying kids

 

[Skimble]

Your unwillingness to share anything about yourself and instead 1)lynch someone you said was probably a villager after voting for them and 2) waste an ability you think is important really isn't helping your case.


Jk, Finn posted while I was typing. forgot you had revealed some to people in your group

Yeah, I don't feel that doing a full reveal on thread really helps the village. And it's not wasting the ability because 1) I'm a villager so it will literally be saving a villager and 2) if you lynch me and I don't use it, then the ability is gone, so either way it will get wasted.

I also mentioned at least twice that I revealed to other people via pm. If you aren't paying enough attention to pick up on something that has been stated multiple times then how can you pick up on things that I'm doing differently?

 

[raf2769]

I already said my feels for gwen were really minor, basically I just didn't have more feels for anyone else on the grid for tonight. I don't have super strong thoughts on anyone else right now to throw out a new lynch contender, or else I would. I think it's strange that all of the super quiet people on the thread are popping in just to lynch gwen and offer no reasoning....

 

[Skimble]

As for why, jil because of her PBC vote and general sketching, plus a lynch cancel ability
AM for inconsistent/bad defenses and some confusion about why she hasn't been killed yet if her role is important
Genny because Feely feels and also some posts that seem weirdly worded/sharing info in a not super timely manner
Gwen because ??????
Trilt for playing aggressively and leading the PBC lynch, plus apparently a sketchy role name
Raf because nyanko hates us ****ed annoying kids

Again... PBC is dead

Edit- whoops, on my phone it looks like PBC lynch is the start of a new line

 

[raf2769]

to clarify, the quiet people popping in and lynching gwen is giving me some feels on the quiet people, not on gwen.

 

[allyphoe]

to clarify, the quiet people popping in and lynching gwen is giving me some feels on the quiet people, not on gwen.

Lynches gwen, has feels about people who lynch gwen. 😉

(I know, your vote for her really isn't equivalent, in context, but this just struck me as funny.)

 

[kaydubs]

LOLZ all the way down. Y'all are crazy

 

[raf2769]

Lynches gwen, has feels about people who lynch gwen. 😉

(I know, your vote for her really isn't equivalent, in context, but this just struck me as funny.)

lol now that I'm reading it as you did, it is pretty funny.. it made sense in my head, I promise!

 

[LetItSnow]

I'm off to a movie with my son. I'm pretty ok with my lynch vote, but I'm also ok with most of the leading candidates. I think it's just time to roll the dice and break some eggs.

 

[vetmedhead]

Again... PBC is dead

Edit- whoops, on my phone it looks like PBC lynch is the start of a new line

I never implied she was alive in this post. People thought your vote on PBC yesterday was sketchy. People also thought Trilt leading the charge on PBC was sketchy. Both things not altered by PBC being dead today

 

[Ceke2002]

*********
Grabs popcorn. This is getting good, lynch by annoyance, lynch because words, lynch because 'last game....' Geez, I was a newbie, what's all your excuses?
*********

 

[LadyOtheFarm]

My Gwen lynch was because I wanted to add a candidate to the field of discussion and STL had one vote on a new person. I hoped 2 was enough to start conversation. That was my reason. To move discussion forward since I had no feels on the leaders at that point. I even said so at the time.

 

[Skimble]

I'm off to a movie with my son. I'm pretty ok with my lynch vote, but I'm also ok with most of the leading candidates. I think it's just time to roll the dice and break some eggs.

Breaking eggs by lynching the one person who won't actually be able to be lynched? Yeah makes sense.

I never implied she was alive in this post. People thought your vote on PBC yesterday was sketchy. People also thought Trilt leading the charge on PBC was sketchy. Both things not altered by PBC being dead today

Did you see my edit?

Also, I knew that it was best for the village if I revealed my lynch cancelation ability. That is in the best interest of the village. It would be stupid for me to even try this as a wolf because at most it would buy me one day as I'm sure to get investigated thoroughly tonight.

 

[Abnerrs]

*********
Grabs popcorn. This is getting good, lynch by annoyance, lynch because words, lynch because 'last game....' Geez, I was a newbie, what's all your excuses?
*********

***********************************
Be a little careful talking about the game. Talking **** can be construed as strategy
***********************************

 

[hazelmoo]

5 MINUTES REMAINING!

 

[finnickthedog]

I don't like ties so I don't want to vote for gwen, but I'm not totally feeling Jil and I don't want to vote for her just because she's in the lead. Not voting for either of those two seems relatively meaningless at this point given their lead. So here I am with a lynch vote, 5 minutes to place it, and no idea who to stick it on. Yay.

 

[vetmedhead]

***********************************
Be a little careful talking about the game. Talking **** can be construed as strategy
***********************************

****************************
Talking **** is my primary life strategy actually
****************************

 

[LadyOtheFarm]

I have had a lynch cancellation twice. Both times I was a villager.

I guess I buy it as a villager ability.😀 I haven't noticed it as a wolf role... but I suppose it could be.

 

[Abnerrs]

****************************
Talking **** is my primary life strategy actually
****************************

******************************
Aha! Proves my point!
*************************

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

•••lynch trilt•••


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

 

[finnickthedog]

lynch genny

I don't know. I do think it's weird that she didn't share Ceke was a seer until really late in the day as I think that could have been valuable information. Not sure that withholding that information actually makes her a wolf but as I said, I'm not feeling like vote for either of the two leads. I don't want to slap down a vote on someone complete random so that leaves the few people who are on the board and I'm just picking one.

 

[Ceke2002]

***********************************
Be a little careful talking about the game. Talking **** can be construed as strategy
***********************************

*****
Oh, shoot, oops, that wasn't meant as strategy, I was joking around.
*****

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

I don't know what I think of Jil....she seems like her typical defensive villager self but I wouldn't call her guard teed village by her ability by any means


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

 

[Abnerrs]

*****
Oh, shoot, oops, that wasn't meant as strategy, I was joking around.
*****

*************************************
I know! But because you were a player any comment has to be careful. Likes too. I just wanted to warn you 🙂
****************************************

 

[hazelmoo]

lynch closed.

FINAL Lynch Tally - check votes

Jil (7)- trilt, LIS, Kam, Caiter, Gwen, AM, VMH
AM (3)- Hayley, allyphoe, crayola
genny (3)- DVMD, Jil, fin
Gwen (6)- STL, LoTF, FFM, MQ, raf, MJ
Trilt (3)- genny, dyachei, BBC
Raf(1)- nyanko

21/23

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

My reasons for Trilt: I know I said earlier that I was content with her defense but her style of defence seems so strange compared to how else I have seen her defend... I get that no one will come out and admit they seered but something is still rubbing me the wrong way


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

 

[hazelmoo]

The residents of magical world once again decided that one of them had to go. Accusations flew, names were called out, and they finally decided on Jilary. Before they could string her up to the big oak tree, sparkling dust sprinkled down from the heavens. What were they about to do again? Who knows, who cares! They felt so carefree and sleepy, so they all slugged back to their dwellings and curled up for a full night of sleep.

LYNCH HAS BEEN CANCELED. Get night actions in please! Dead line is 8 AM.

Current roster:

Magical Forest
2. @Flim Flam Man
3. @Mad Jack
4. @Kam325
5. @Trilt

Shimmering Lake
1. @Jilary
6. @allyphoe
7. @finnickthedog
8. @BeautifulBritishColumbia
10. @LadyOtheFarm

Top of the Beanstalk
11. @SummerTheLynx
12. @heyyimhayley
13. @Gwenevre
14. @Caiter92 / @WildZoo
15. @morninqlory

Fairytale Fields
16. @DVMDream
17. @LetItSnow
18. @dyachei
20. @nyanko

Valley of Death
19. @Crayola227
21. @vetmedhead
23. @genny
24. @Animal Midwife
25. @raf2769

The Great Beyond (dead):
22. @Ceke2002 - Dragon
9. @PrincessButterCup - Hobgoblin

 

[Trilt]

My reasons for Trilt: I know I said earlier that I was content with her defense but her style of defence seems so strange compared to how else I have seen her defend... I get that no one will come out and admit they seered but something is still rubbing me the wrong way


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

I'm pretty sure I've only been a wolf (or mod) since you started playing...

 

[Abnerrs]

********************************
Make it good guys. I wanna see some action!
***********************************