SDN Reactions and Emojis WW Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members do not see this ad.

mostly just that they seem to be constantly changing their suspicions with every new piece of info, which I definitely did a ton in noob game. I think it's more of a noob thing than a sus thing.

Though i checked my spreadsheet and others have actually changed votes way more times

I'm always happy to see that level of evaluation and would actually associate it with better awareness of threadstate.

 

[Barkley13]

What?

Okay, I do agree it best to find stronger wolf leans over weak ones, but I guess I'm confused why going after her strongest one made you wolfread her.

It was the later post that felt like hedging

???

what

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial D1 Yeet Tally
kras () -
SAR (1) - kras
dubz () -
Doggo (1) - Enigma
prints (4) - AM, Cray, Zenge, please
genny () -
AM () -
shorty (4) - Dina, dubz, genny, Vis
Enigma (1) - mayo
mayo (2) - alley, shorty
April () -
sunshine () -
Barks (1) - Doggo
Zenge () -
Cray (1) - April
please (1) - Barks

16/21
yeet close in ~3 hours

 

[Animal Midwife]

It was the later post that felt like hedging

Which one was that?

 

[Doggo Labs]

If you're feeling okay about barks, why are you still voting there?

It's my joke vote, am rereading a few pages and will change it soon

 

[Viscernable]

It was the later post that felt like hedging

what

She said prints was her strongest wolf read, not village read

 

[TelemarketingEnigma]

Just on reading through I felt okay about her. Seems like her village self, going mostly off my gut right now

Fair! I don't have context for her village self. So for now I'm still neutral/wolf on genny, but would love to hear any additional supporting thoughts you have as you reread

 

[Barkley13]

Which one was that?

the one where she said it was a placeholder vote

 

[Barkley13]

She said prints was her strongest wolf read, not village read

oh oops I mistyped. Yes wolf read

 

[Animal Midwife]

@holdthemayo why did you okay react that post?

 

[supershorty]

My current reads from most villagey to most wolfy:

Village:
AM: playing pretty much exactly how it seems like village!AM plays in the past, I haven't seen anything that threw a red flag up.
April: I think April being nice to noobs is NAI, seems otherwise same play style as other previous games.

Barks, doggo, and kras are all giving me village vibes although I don't have strong reasoning behind any of them. I have SAR as weak village too. I think I have TEM as weak village for now, but the hedging makes me want to keep an eye on them. alley hasn't posted that much this game so far, posted more when wolfing.

Neutral: pawprints due to lack of posting, same with Lainey to a lesser extent. I've changed my view of Zenge for now to being neutral because he does seem to be playing typical noob. Bread hasn't really posted that much, compared to other games I've seen bread in, I'm leaving him as neutral for now. I've never played with Dina before or read games that she played, and I thought her logic about my suspecting mayo and zenge was odd, but that's been cleared up. Leaving her neutral for now.

Neutral/wolfy: Dubz because she's changed her vote a few times without giving much reasoning behind it beyond "a ping" that she never elaborated on. I also have genny in this category because I'm not sure why she's coming after me, but I'm freely willing to admit that my having her as wolfy is partially retaliatory.

Wolfy:

cray: I still feel like there's a posting style difference in this game versus other village!cray, even with the time difference and all of that, but again, not confident enough in this to make it a vote.

mayo: I don't have strong reasons that I haven't already stated, but nothing has convinced me that those reasons are wrong yet.

Vissy: Jumped on the wagon late, seems like an easy way to get rid of a villager and I think it's sus. I'm giving this extra weight because vissy and I have wolfed together before and they know how I approached posting that time, which is pretty different from this time.

sunshine: has posted a lot of hmm reactions to people, but hasn't actually provided that much content, and the whole concept of the creepy guy in the van being the non sketchy one, while I ultimately got what they were trying to say, was the strangest analogy ever.

(also, I kind of feel like it's a big stretch to call it wolfy that I said I think D1 is hardest - although I agree with TEM that D1 in the noob 12/12 was much different from how this feels)

 

[supershorty]

Unyeet mayo

based on what I just posted for now

 

[Doggo Labs]

I'm going to

Unyeet Barks
Yeet Kras

On reread something doesn't feel right about her, not 100% sure what it is yet, so going to put some pressure here

@kraskadva do you have any reads so far?

I'm still not following the shorty or prints wagons, if someone could point me in the right direction I would appreciate it.

 

[holdthemayo]

@holdthemayo why did you okay react that post?

It was particularly unhelpful.

 

[Animal Midwife]

It was particularly unhelpful.

As opposed to the helpfulness of sitting on a joke vote for almost 48 hours?

 

[Barkley13]

Unyeet mayo

based on what I just posted for now

But he’s a wolf read?

 

[Viscernable]

My current reads from most villagey to most wolfy:

Village:
AM: playing pretty much exactly how it seems like village!AM plays in the past, I haven't seen anything that threw a red flag up.
April: I think April being nice to noobs is NAI, seems otherwise same play style as other previous games.

Barks, doggo, and kras are all giving me village vibes although I don't have strong reasoning behind any of them. I have SAR as weak village too. I think I have TEM as weak village for now, but the hedging makes me want to keep an eye on them. alley hasn't posted that much this game so far, posted more when wolfing.

Neutral: pawprints due to lack of posting, same with Lainey to a lesser extent. I've changed my view of Zenge for now to being neutral because he does seem to be playing typical noob. Bread hasn't really posted that much, compared to other games I've seen bread in, I'm leaving him as neutral for now. I've never played with Dina before or read games that she played, and I thought her logic about my suspecting mayo and zenge was odd, but that's been cleared up. Leaving her neutral for now.

Neutral/wolfy: Dubz because she's changed her vote a few times without giving much reasoning behind it beyond "a ping" that she never elaborated on. I also have genny in this category because I'm not sure why she's coming after me, but I'm freely willing to admit that my having her as wolfy is partially retaliatory.

Wolfy:

cray: I still feel like there's a posting style difference in this game versus other village!cray, even with the time difference and all of that, but again, not confident enough in this to make it a vote.

mayo: I don't have strong reasons that I haven't already stated, but nothing has convinced me that those reasons are wrong yet.

Vissy: Jumped on the wagon late, seems like an easy way to get rid of a villager and I think it's sus. I'm giving this extra weight because vissy and I have wolfed together before and they know how I approached posting that time, which is pretty different from this time.

sunshine: has posted a lot of hmm reactions to people, but hasn't actually provided that much content, and the whole concept of the creepy guy in the van being the non sketchy one, while I ultimately got what they were trying to say, was the strangest analogy ever.

(also, I kind of feel like it's a big stretch to call it wolfy that I said I think D1 is hardest - although I agree with TEM that D1 in the noob 12/12 was much different from how this feels)

Damn, this is some solid village analysis (ah, my distrust of being trusted and trust of being distrusted, I can always count on you to show up 😬).

unyeet shorty

 

[supershorty]

But he’s a wolf read?

He's one of my weaker ones, I'd rather put my vote on sunshine or vis for now, but I want to leave my options open in case I need to self-prez.

 

[holdthemayo]

*flashbacks to last game when I had my only correct wolf read due mainly to a similar comment*

So probably 3-4 wolves given total player number, maybe?

More like 4-5.

@Viscernable why did shorty's answer ping you as sus, but AM's didn't to the same question?

Shorty leaned very heavily on playing up an exagerrated noob persona in cartoons. She wouldn’t do the same thing again because mayo, genny, AM and I who saw her actual play in wolfchat would call her out.

Agreed. Shorty would have to wolf differently. I'm more curious if some of the other new players is going try shorty's noob wolf style. I'm not sus of them yet, but it's something I'll be thinking about.

 

[Viscernable]

This is awkward timing w yeet close but I have about an hour of packing/unpacking and an hour of driving to do. I’ll probably keep hopping on as I pack but I’m not sure I’ll have time to do any isos I want to do (sunny and Dubz at the top of the list) to decide on a good vote.

 

[holdthemayo]

As opposed to the helpfulness of sitting on a joke vote for almost 48 hours?

You asked. I answered.

I can't eyeroll my own posts.

 

[Viscernable]

@Viscernable why did shorty's answer ping you as sus, but AM's didn't to the same question?

Because shorty brought it up and AM was just responding. It isn’t a strong suspicion, the post just felt a bit wrong.

 

[Animal Midwife]

He's one of my weaker ones, I'd rather put my vote on sunshine or vis for now, but I want to leave my options open in case I need to self-prez.

Well, you can still pressure stronger wolf reads first before it comes to needed self-prez.

 

[kraskadva]

I'm going to

Unyeet Barks
Yeet Kras

On reread something doesn't feel right about her, not 100% sure what it is yet, so going to put some pressure here

@kraskadva do you have any reads so far?

I'm still not following the shorty or prints wagons, if someone could point me in the right direction I would appreciate it.

Just got home from getting an oil change, gotta reread a couple pages

 

[The_Breadmann]

So probably 3-4 wolves given total player number, maybe?

###yeet shorty###

for now since last game a wolf tried suggesting a lower number. still have to reread some stuff. Just stuck at work rerunning samples since I switched standard solutions.

 

[supershorty]

Yeet sunshine

 

[kraskadva]

I'm going to

Unyeet Barks
Yeet Kras

On reread something doesn't feel right about her, not 100% sure what it is yet, so going to put some pressure here

@kraskadva do you have any reads so far?

I'm still not following the shorty or prints wagons, if someone could point me in the right direction I would appreciate it.

I also do not understand these wagons. Which makes them smell wolfy.
While I firmly stand by D1 reads being mostly nonsense, I'm not getting wolf vibes from either shorty or prints, so by extension, the folks voting that way are more sus to me

 

[holdthemayo]

Unyeet Enigma
Yeet Vis

I remember Vis playing a pretty "pro-villager" meta when wolfing, that felt similar to this.

 

[kraskadva]

Unyeet Enigma
Yeet Vis

I remember Vis playing a pretty "pro-villager" meta when wolfing, that felt similar to this.

I can get behind that.

Unyeet SAR
Yeet Vis

 

[Animal Midwife]

I can get behind that.

Unyeet SAR
Yeet Vis

So you're not touching anyone voting either shorty or prints despite your prior post?

 

[SARdoghandler]

###yeet shorty###

for now since last game a wolf tried suggesting a lower number. still have to reread some stuff. Just stuck at work rerunning samples since I switched standard solutions.

See, I actually have shorty village points for that post

Also sorry guys, re-read is going very slowly because my fiance talked me into watching a movie I haven't seen before

 

[kraskadva]

So you're not touching anyone voting either shorty or prints despite your prior post?

Vis is voting for shorty

 

[Animal Midwife]

Vis is voting for shorty

She unyeeted her a half hour ago.

 

[kraskadva]

So you're not touching anyone voting either shorty or prints despite your prior post?

nvm, missed this

Damn, this is some solid village analysis (ah, my distrust of being trusted and trust of being distrusted, I can always count on you to show up 😬).

unyeet shorty

recalibrating....

 

[holdthemayo]

Other way-too-early thoughts:

Equally sus of Shorty. Her read list feels good, but it's really easy to make a good looking read list when you already know who is village and who is wolf.

Dina - need to hear a lot more. Seems a bit to eager to hunt the fresh meat.

AM feels different - less aggro, 20 questions etc. It's day 1 so I'm inclined to sit on it and see.

Cray - No instant wolf vibes like last game. Or strong village vibes like game prior to that game.

April - Normal village self.

Alleycat - just fluff

Bread - his usual self. Leaning village.

Quite a few people have not posted enough for me to tell. Curious about the ones not on shorty's list if she were to go tonight and flip wolf.

 

[holdthemayo]

See, I actually have shorty village points for that post

Also sorry guys, re-read is going very slowly because my fiance talked me into watching a movie I haven't seen before

What movie?

 

[genny]

what this mean?

That’s the sound I make when someone pokes me in the eyeball.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Other way-too-early thoughts:

Equally sus of Shorty. Her read list feels good, but it's really easy to make a good looking read list when you already know who is village and who is wolf.

Dina - need to hear a lot more. Seems a bit to eager to hunt the fresh meat.

AM feels different - less aggro, 20 questions etc. It's day 1 so I'm inclined to sit on it and see.

Cray - No instant wolf vibes like last game. Or strong village vibes like game prior to that game.

April - Normal village self.

Alleycat - just fluff

Bread - his usual self. Leaning village.

Quite a few people have not posted enough for me to tell. Curious about the ones not on shorty's list if she were to go tonight and flip wolf.

Can you give a concrete lean on shorty, Dina, Cray, and alley? What does the bolded mean?

 

[genny]

Think I'm looking in prints/kras/genny/dubz/sunshine for now. Don't think this is the full team at all, but am wondering if a wolf or two is in this group.

You always put me in your wolf reads when I’m busy.

 

[holdthemayo]

Spoiler: squick

 

[Animal Midwife]

You always put me in your wolf reads when I’m busy.

Then village harder when your on.

 

[holdthemayo]

Can you give a concrete lean on shorty, Dina, Cray, and alley? What does the bolded mean?

Shorty clearly says sus = wolf
Dina Lean wolf, need more
Alley fluff - That's her meta, so who knows

If shorty were to flip wolf, it would be interesting to think about who she avoided reading and why she might do that. If she flips village, it's far less interesting.

 

[SARdoghandler]

What movie?

...it may or may not be White Chicks

 

[genny]

Then village harder when your on.

I’m trying but I lack food.

 

[supershorty]

If shorty were to flip wolf, it would be interesting to think about who she avoided reading and why she might do that. If she flips village, it's far less interesting.

Who did I miss?

EDIT: it does look like I omitted pleasy but not intentionally. Pleasy neutral for now, no strong vibes.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Shorty clearly says I'm sus = wolf
Dina Lean wolf, need more
Alley fluff - That's her meta, so who knows

If shorty were to flip wolf, it would be interesting to think about who she avoided reading and why she might do that. If she flips village, it's far less interesting.

So if you're leaning shorty and Dina as wolf, why did decide to start a new wagon on Vis?

 

[The_Breadmann]

See, I actually have shorty village points for that post

Also sorry guys, re-read is going very slowly because my fiance talked me into watching a movie I haven't seen before

###unyeet shorty###

Not doing a good job reading at the moment

 

[genny]

Who did I miss?

Why are you answering the “if you flip wolf” part? This question is weird.

 

[holdthemayo]

...it may or may not be White Chicks

I don't know what I was expecting, but this made me lol

 

[holdthemayo]

So if you're leaning shorty and Dina as wolf, why did decide to start a new wagon on Vis?

For the reasons I stated in my Vis vote.

Do you read my posts before you ask questions?