Supernatural: Villains WW Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Are you feeling bad about Zenge in general?
I’m inclined to believe him. But it’s hard for me to clear him out on one post, just cause he said so, because wolf!Zenge wouldn’t do that etc etc.
Above all, I dislike that he role revealed this early; it feels like a lazy way to game-solve, and claiming seer essentially puts him in a position to determine who’s on his village bloc and who’s out. So I’m taking it with a grain of salt.
 
I’m inclined to believe him. But it’s hard for me to clear him out on one post, just cause he said so, because wolf!Zenge wouldn’t do that etc etc.
Above all, I dislike that he role revealed this early; it feels like a lazy way to game-solve, and claiming seer essentially puts him in a position to determine who’s on his village bloc and who’s out. So I’m taking it with a grain of salt.
Can you elaborate on the bolded?
 
Can you elaborate on the bolded?
Essentially he’s saying “I’m the seer, so you don’t need to worry about me, wolf-hunt elsewhere”. If that’s the case why don’t we all role reveal and decide who’s claim feels fake enough to be a wolf. It would make the game easier to solve, but this is not why we play WW is it?
 
Essentially he’s saying “I’m the seer, so you don’t need to worry about me, wolf-hunt elsewhere”. If that’s the case why don’t we all role reveal and decide who’s claim feels fake enough to be a wolf. It would make the game easier to solve, but this is not why we play WW is it?
Do you feel this game can be broken by claiming?
 
Essentially he’s saying “I’m the seer, so you don’t need to worry about me, wolf-hunt elsewhere”. If that’s the case why don’t we all role reveal and decide who’s claim feels fake enough to be a wolf. It would make the game easier to solve, but this is not why we play WW is it?
Probably not cause they are repercussions to claiming. I’m mostly interested to see what those are.
I'm confused by the progression here.
 
Why? I thought that was the general feeling about WW, game solving by mechanics is bad.
Solving heavily influenced by or solely based on unproven mechanics (aka tinfoil) is bad. That claim doesn't fall under this category. It's no different than someone saying they're a villager. I don't know if Zenge posted that for a reason so I won't go into depth regarding my feelings on it right now.
 
Solving heavily influenced by or solely based on unproven mechanics (aka tinfoil) is bad. That claim doesn't fall under this category. It's no different than someone saying they're a villager. I don't know if Zenge posted that for a reason so I won't go into depth regarding my feelings on it right now.
That’s fair. I don’t think that’s tinfoil territory at all. But it could still be WIFOM.
You mean you don’t know if he posted it for a mechanics reason?
 
anyone have thoughts on what conditions might need to be met to rez someone? i'm remembering the strikes/spares etc of boWWling concept, what else is there?
 
Day 1: Trouble at the Bunker Vote Tally (#112)

alley (1) - AM
Zenge (1) - kdswg
cubs (1) - alley

3/12

missing: :shrug:

200.gif


vote closes at 10pm Eastern/9pm Central/7pm Fantasyland, Monday 3/14/22 (~25.75 hours)
 
anyone have thoughts on what conditions might need to be met to rez someone? i'm remembering the strikes/spares etc of boWWling concept, what else is there?
This is a mechanical black box of a game. Speculation and tinfoiling is unwise without more information.

If this was more of a basics game it would just be a player has the ability to Rez someone or a Pack has the ability to Rez them into the pack.

This game is likely not basics and a mechanical marvel behind the scenes. Could be literally anything.

I’m not going to dwell on it until we have more concrete information.
 
I’ll feel better about Zenge once he catches a wolf. It is a hell lot of effort for a wolf to claim seer, but his post is essentially WIFOM, and the goal might have been to get us confused and leave him alone.

Doubt it. From what I saw in BoWWling, wolf!Zenge is too stressed and worried about everything to pull that off. At worst I think he's 3P but I'm willing to assume village for now.
I agree. It does not feel like a wolf!zenge move, but I’m not willing to throw it into the village pile yet.
Big PR Zenge seems to try and fly under the radar, maybe even be a little bit sketchy to avoid the death (zenges in Marvel). It doesn’t feel like a wolf or village zenge and I just don’t know what to make of it. I won’t vote there today at all though and I’m going to watch to see if he continues to extrude chaos.
 
Solving heavily influenced by or solely based on unproven mechanics (aka tinfoil) is bad. That claim doesn't fall under this category. It's no different than someone saying they're a villager. I don't know if Zenge posted that for a reason so I won't go into depth regarding my feelings on it right now.
I’m gonna have to change my award to best tinfoil aren’t I?
Tinfoil ain’t bad if there’s a little bit of magic to back it up. Just sayin.
 
Also MsP liked exactly one of my posts
And I have seen no sign of her again.
@Ms Procrastinator pls come back and play with us. No only vote deadline voting pop-ins pls.
Oh wow. She actually popped in. Huh. I was expecting just a 10 minutes to vote close chaos appearance.
 
Is this normal for MsP?

Edit: oh, it's even in her name, dur it's normal
Ily lol.

But yeah, it’s very normal, kind of chaotic, makes it hard to get any read on her. I don’t think I’ve ever seen her wolf to make a comparison.
 
Ily lol.

But yeah, it’s very normal, kind of chaotic, makes it hard to get any read on her. I don’t think I’ve ever seen her wolf to make a comparison.
like genny level?
 
Is this normal for MsP?

Edit: oh, it's even in her name, dur it's normal
Yes, I have seen more than once she waits until 10 minutes to vote close, makes her post minimums, and causes a bunch of last minute chaos.

It’s not what she does exclusively, but it’s definitely happened more than once.
 
I think the only game I’ve seen cubs play in that was Pm heavy he got deeply pocketed and even tried to give a wolf an extra kill.
That was a wild ride.
 
I think the only game I’ve seen cubs play in that was Pm heavy he got deeply pocketed and even tried to give a wolf an extra kill.

No dear. I tried to give a VILLAGER an extra kill, who just turned out to be a wolf in the end. And we STILL almost won, if it werent for you baiting alley to lock in her vote. But yeah, not my finest moment!
 
No dear. I tried to give a VILLAGER an extra kill, who just turned out to be a wolf in the end. And we STILL almost won, if it werent for you baiting alley to lock in her vote. But yeah, not my finest moment!
Oh man most of this crew doesn't even know about the perils of Canada and the wolf protector though
 
I'm of the opinion this is a game where Dean and Crowley (maybe Cas also?) are the "wolves" and the rest of us are the bad guys. So if you've got fur and pointy ears, you're actually likely to be village.
Who is Crowley
 
Who is Crowley
Crowley is a demon/sometimes the King of Hell depending on how the writers are feeling. It's all very confusing. He goes from being a major antagonist to an ally of the Winchesters and then back. He's basically a self-serving chaos agent that happens to really like the Winchesters most of the time, especially Dean.
 
I agree. It does not feel like a wolf!zenge move, but I’m not willing to throw it into the village pile yet.
Big PR Zenge seems to try and fly under the radar, maybe even be a little bit sketchy to avoid the death (zenges in Marvel). It doesn’t feel like a wolf or village zenge and I just don’t know what to make of it. I won’t vote there today at all though and I’m going to watch to see if he continues to extrude chaos.
I agree with this analysis. Trying to remember the last game I played with Z where he had a “strong” PR. I know there was his cool codebreaker role in England and I think that he had a pretty important role in RvB as well.
 
Top