Supernatural: Villains WW Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
potentialsheltervet said:
You know what? I think there are no wolves in this game. I think the scum are all "lone wolves," or scummy 3p, i.e. cannibals, and I think they potentially absorb the power of whomever they chow down on, hence seeing people's roles after they've eaten them.
I think zenge is one and he was hunting for a PR reveal. I think stoat is potentially one. I know how much she's wanted to be scum of some sort and I think her overreaction to kdswg's post was wanting to not get yoten early because she's finally scum.
Click to expand...

potentialsheltervet said:
I don't know if they can absorb multiple PRs. Maybe just one.
Click to expand...

potentialsheltervet said:
I don't have much to expand on. I think it would be overpowered to have a wolf pack plus cannibals. So, I think there are no wolves, only cannibals working independently (maybe three or so?). I found it a little "hmm" for Dubz to post in the sign-ups that everyone was a vanillager unless told otherwise; it seemed odd. Then for her to mention this game would be interesting, as well as saying all the SPN games have been mechanically broken in one way or another... Clearly this game isn't basics. There's something very different about it. So my tinfoil is village is trying to sniff out the cannibals.
Hey @alleycat03 what did you mean when you said you had pointy ears but no fur? What were you referring to?
Click to expand...
I would like to revisit these posts. I can’t say I’m a fan of what pshelty is doing with this train of thought. I don’t think we should get caught up in 3P hunting until we have caught wolves. It gave me icky vibes
 
cubsrule4e said:
lol we just discussed it last night. RvB.
Click to expand...
Ohhhh

I mean Samac was a convert though. Not exactly the same scenario though I admit I read her incorrectly and you were correct. But it was mainly a matter of us knowing our own affiliations and I didn’t trust you at all and I trusted Samac completely.
 
alleycat03 said:
Let me look at her posts because I kinda forgot she was playing
Click to expand...
Well let me pare it down for you, cause im having issues with this:

alleycat03 said:
So I’m currently feeling okay about Samac, pleasy, and pshelty (in that order). Zenge seems to be a tiny bit more on his village side, but I also hate his opening post and how he’s going about that claim. Ace seemed a bit odd to me but idk if we played together before (like if he participated in bowwling?) and I wasn’t a huge fan of fluffy’s posts earlier. Stoat, AM, kdswg, and cubs are ??? right now.
Click to expand...

alleycat03 said:
Pleasy’s questioning of Zenge and actually daring to question his logic rather than just accepting he was village.

Because he came in, claimed seer, and then just expected none of us to question it in a giant essay post. And for the most part all we did was accept it and joke about it. I also REALLY don’t like that the mods legit said “don’t use role-revealing to solve the game, it won’t work” and Zenge immediately role-revealed. Just kinda rubbed me the wrong way and it wasn’t how I like to start games. I like working our way up to long posts and ISOs. I really only like role-revealing when someone is in danger of being yeeted.

Also it wasn’t what I wanted to see first-thing at 7am so I was a bit annoyed. Like “damn it, I have to actually think super early today and use my brain.” That part is a joke but I definitely wasn’t conscious for my first 2 read throughs of that post.
Click to expand...

alleycat03 said:
I like this
Click to expand...

Bottom one is in referring to kds also being a little skeptical of zenge. So youre agreeing with kds, and village reading Please specifically for her questioning of Zenges intentions; fluff was the first one to come out and stir up discussion about it, yet you werent a fan of those posts.
 
bluestoat said:
It's snowing today and I love this aspect of Minnesota so much.View attachment 351779
All the dried and withered blooms have a sort of forlorn grace with the dusting of snow. Even the crappy parking lot foliage looks pretty.
Click to expand...
Maybe its not AI, but this reminds me of the noob game, when you posted that picture of the snowy landscape after you'd gone for a walk and people were yeeting you. Somehow it makes me feel better about you.
 
cubsrule4e said:
yeet samac

to get on the board, while I read some of the earlier stuff again now that I can concentrate a little more.
Click to expand...
Hm. I actually wanted to post that I agree that she's slightly more reserved this game but I've liked her logic so far.
Although, she hasn't really pushed anyone except for Ace a little bit, and I don't know if it's really because Ace didn't engage or she just wanted to have a vote on the board cause she's wolfing.
 
cubsrule4e said:
Well let me pare it down for you, cause im having issues with this:







Bottom one is in referring to kds also being a little skeptical of zenge. So youre agreeing with kds, and village reading Please specifically for her questioning of Zenges intentions; fluff was the first one to come out and stir up discussion about it, yet you werent a fan of those posts.
Click to expand...
I figured out what was bothering me. It was the discussion about calling Zenge’s play lazy. I strongly disagree with that phrasing. Zenge has done a lot of things as a player but I wouldn’t call it lazy at all.

Hold on a second because I ISO’d and quoted the exact posts but my phone isn’t cooperating.
 
justafluff said:
Almost caught up! I still don't know who to vote for 🙁
Also I have a dance lesson in an hour, and I won't be around for vote close today. So apologies if some waffles are missing from the table!
Click to expand...
Dance lesson? Like…Ballroom? Jazz? Tap? Horse? Ice? Salsa?
 
justafluff said:
Almost caught up! I still don't know who to vote for 🙁
Also I have a dance lesson in an hour, and I won't be around for vote close today. So apologies if some waffles are missing from the table!
Click to expand...
Is there anyone you're suspecting?
 
justafluff said:
I’m inclined to believe him. But it’s hard for me to clear him out on one post, just cause he said so, because wolf!Zenge wouldn’t do that etc etc.
Above all, I dislike that he role revealed this early; it feels like a lazy way to game-solve, and claiming seer essentially puts him in a position to determine who’s on his village bloc and who’s out. So I’m taking it with a grain of salt.
Click to expand...
This is the post I had issues with.
justafluff said:
Probably not cause they are repercussions to claiming. I’m mostly interested to see what those are.
Click to expand...
Seemed like she was trying to hint at something bad would happen to Zenge for role revealing. Unsure if she meant a game mechanic or something else.
justafluff said:
Why? I thought that was the general feeling about WW, game solving by mechanics is bad.
Click to expand...
Also this is not really accurate and I think fluff should know the distinction by now of relying solely on mechanics vs using it as one piece of the puzzle to catching wolves.
 
justafluff said:
Almost caught up! I still don't know who to vote for 🙁
Also I have a dance lesson in an hour, and I won't be around for vote close today. So apologies if some waffles are missing from the table!
Click to expand...
I'm changing my vote.

Story time: in my role PM, I mused that Samac's vote on Ace was interesting and I wrote a little tinfoil that when she's a wolf, she's likelier to vote on a noob. Samac tends to play with a little bit of psychology mixed into her game strategy, and she definitely must be considering the cognitive bias people have against the "other"; it makes her votes innocuous at the beginning, and noobs aren't very good at self-defense. They also don't have a meta or established group of peers to draw on for support. If she's village, she is likelier to circle around and possibly vote on established/veteran players. Also... I think Samac is smart enough to recognize that Ace was joking? And she is also smart enough to seize the opportunity a joke provides?

Then Zenge said he found that Ace's play pings him too and I was like "well nevermind, I don't think he's a wolf at all and I'm just being dumb/pro-noob again, better keep mum and ask about the Ace sus"

THEN Cub showed up on thread. He has a simpatico with Samac that far exceeds most players. If he comes in D1, reads the thread, and think "eesh this is weird, vote Samac" then tbh I'll sheep that.

Unvote kdswg
Vote Samac
 
Hi this is Tim on pleaseys phone she went to the eye doctor and got her pupils dismayed and she can’t read anything she’ll be back when she can see

Yeet ace

this is a weak lean but it’s the best she can do without rereading
 
Of course I immediately feel like a traitor because Samac has been really having my back so far, and it seems treacherous to then admit "oh, yeah, I am actually willing to vote on you though..."
 
D1 probably crappy reads

Village lean
Pleasy
Samac

Slight village lean
AM
Stoat

Neutral
Fluffy (forgot to delete her name after I did the iso)
Ace
Zenge
Cubs

Slightly wolf lean
Kds

Wolfy
Fluff
Pshelty

Literally hasn’t made a post
@Ms Procrastinator
 
Last edited:
vetschoolsletmeinplease said:
Hi this is Tim on pleaseys phone she went to the eye doctor and got her pupils dismayed and she can’t read anything she’ll be back when she can see

Yeet ace

this is a weak lean but it’s the best she can do without rereading
Click to expand...
Hi Tim

Hi Pleasey

Can you get some details from Pleasey because I literally just waffled about the Ace thing and if Zenge, Samac, AND Please are awkward about Ace then I'ma wanna listen.
 
Yeet alley
There's some inconsistencies between posts that I'm not liking.
Also, just so we're clear, I'm not necessarily trying to 3p hunt. I don't think it's the wildest conclusion to come to given what Dubz has hinted at about the setup of this game. It doesn't matter that much to me anyway because I'm going to yeet whoever seems scummiest. Doesn't really matter to me what sort of scum they are.
 
bluestoat said:
Hi Tim

Hi Pleasey

Can you get some details from Pleasey because I literally just waffled about the Ace thing and if Zenge, Samac, AND Please are awkward about Ace then I'ma wanna listen.
Click to expand...
I mean, the thing about Ace is that it’s his 2nd game. Noobs say weird things that ping me. But I’m not really feeling the Ace vote overall. I’m more, watching to see how Ace develops. Yeeting the game 2 noob day 1 seems…not good.
 
alleycat03 said:
D1 probably crappy reads

Village lean
Pleasy
Samac

Slight village lean
AM
Stoat

Neutral
Fluffy
Ace
Zenge
Cubs

Slightly wolf lean
Kds

Wolfy
Fluff
Pshelty

Literally hasn’t made a post
@Ms Procrastinator
Click to expand...
I do not like this list, even disregarding my placement. Fluff is literally in both neutral and wolf. That makes me feel like this was submitted in wolfchat for feedback and alley forgot to make changes.
 
potentialsheltervet said:
You know what? I think there are no wolves in this game. I think the scum are all "lone wolves," or scummy 3p, i.e. cannibals, and I think they potentially absorb the power of whomever they chow down on, hence seeing people's roles after they've eaten them.
I think zenge is one and he was hunting for a PR reveal. I think stoat is potentially one. I know how much she's wanted to be scum of some sort and I think her overreaction to kdswg's post was wanting to not get yoten early because she's finally scum.
Click to expand...
@potentialsheltervet are you still thinking along these lines? Or have other reads?

bluestoat said:
I'm changing my vote.

Story time: in my role PM, I mused that Samac's vote on Ace was interesting and I wrote a little tinfoil that when she's a wolf, she's likelier to vote on a noob. Samac tends to play with a little bit of psychology mixed into her game strategy, and she definitely must be considering the cognitive bias people have against the "other"; it makes her votes innocuous at the beginning, and noobs aren't very good at self-defense. They also don't have a meta or established group of peers to draw on for support. If she's village, she is likelier to circle around and possibly vote on established/veteran players. Also... I think Samac is smart enough to recognize that Ace was joking? And she is also smart enough to seize the opportunity a joke provides?
Click to expand...
Am I missing context? In every game I’ve played with her she’s been village and voted a noob D1
 
Animal Midwife said:
Is there anyone you're suspecting?
Click to expand...
Not people I'm suspecting, but people I've formed some thoughts about:

Stoat: I was rereading the kdswg and Stoat interaction. I don't see the tone thing kdswg mentioned. Stoat got upset but I can totally understand that it's now the 3rd time Kdswg votes for her D1, so its justified for her to be upset and "overreacting". Some here mentioned that with Genny last game it was different, but I was scared she was a wolf that game based on her reaction, but she wasn't. I've also really liked her questioning and thought process she's put on thread so far. Also, another thing, I don't think wolf!Stoat would be so enthusiastic to PM with you, samac or Zenge.

kdswg: I'd almost vote for Kdswg for her random stoat vote but her reaction afterwards made me feel like she's also village.

PSV: I feel PSV hasn't engaged much, except saying she has "thoughts" on people that she doesn't want to engage with and some tinfoils.

Cubs, Pleasy : I feel good about cubs, esp him voting samac. I feel good about pleasy too.

AM: I like your questioning people, and it seems very on brand with the way you play. I can't see how annoyance to Zenge's post would indicate wolfiness, but oh well.

alley: I don't like alley's questioning my posts all of a sudden, cause I felt we were on the same page about Zenge, so I'm sus about that.
 
alleycat03 said:
D1 probably crappy reads

Village lean
Pleasy
Samac

Slight village lean
AM
Stoat

Neutral
Fluffy
Ace
Zenge
Cubs

Slightly wolf lean
Kds

Wolfy
Fluff
Pshelty

Literally hasn’t made a post
@Ms Procrastinator
Click to expand...
If True was here and he and Ms. P were in a wolf pack, I'd just wait for him to defend the lowposter and say yeet them both lol

Waiting for True angeries
 
WildZoo said:
I was just messing with you guys. This game is actually like, so basic.
Click to expand...
I don't believe you.
lies-supernatural.gif
 
vetschoolsletmeinplease said:
Hi this is Tim on pleaseys phone she went to the eye doctor and got her pupils dismayed and she can’t read anything she’ll be back when she can see

Yeet ace

this is a weak lean but it’s the best she can do without rereading
Click to expand...
hi tim, can you ask for an expansion on this? we've got this:
samac said:
This post feels weird.
Yeet Ace
Click to expand...
a yeet because my attempt at a joke didn't get the vibe of everyone, and now you not giving much. I'd love to defend myself, but out of two votes all i can say is sorry it was a joke..
 
Zenge142 said:
I mean, the thing about Ace is that it’s his 2nd game. Noobs say weird things that ping me. But I’m not really feeling the Ace vote overall. I’m more, watching to see how Ace develops. Yeeting the game 2 noob day 1 seems…not good.
Click to expand...
See, it's relieving for me to hear you say this, because I don't feel very differently but I don't want to defend a wolf again

Wh... What! Zenge! You're not Truey! Don't angeries for his honour!
 
bluestoat said:
I'm changing my vote.

Story time: in my role PM, I mused that Samac's vote on Ace was interesting and I wrote a little tinfoil that when she's a wolf, she's likelier to vote on a noob. Samac tends to play with a little bit of psychology mixed into her game strategy, and she definitely must be considering the cognitive bias people have against the "other"; it makes her votes innocuous at the beginning, and noobs aren't very good at self-defense. They also don't have a meta or established group of peers to draw on for support. If she's village, she is likelier to circle around and possibly vote on established/veteran players. Also... I think Samac is smart enough to recognize that Ace was joking? And she is also smart enough to seize the opportunity a joke provides?

Then Zenge said he found that Ace's play pings him too and I was like "well nevermind, I don't think he's a wolf at all and I'm just being dumb/pro-noob again, better keep mum and ask about the Ace sus"

THEN Cub showed up on thread. He has a simpatico with Samac that far exceeds most players. If he comes in D1, reads the thread, and think "eesh this is weird, vote Samac" then tbh I'll sheep that.

Unvote kdswg
Vote Samac
Click to expand...
But Samac always votes for a noob D1 and that noob is usually a wolf
 
kdswg said:
@potentialsheltervet are you still thinking along these lines? Or have other reads?
Click to expand...
I'm keeping it in the back of my mind but I'm playing as though there's a wolfpack. It doesn't matter too much to me right now because D1 we don't have any flips to look at interactions anyway.
 
vetschoolsletmeinplease said:
Hi this is Tim on pleaseys phone she went to the eye doctor and got her pupils dismayed and she can’t read anything she’ll be back when she can see

Yeet ace

this is a weak lean but it’s the best she can do without rereading
Click to expand...
Hello, Tim. What made her choose him?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
74K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
WildZoo
Supernatural WW Shenanigans Part 5 Sign Ups [OPEN] - Game Start Sept 12th (tentative)
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
422
Views
24K
apoptosis09
apoptosis09
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
60K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
86 87 88 89 90
Replies
4K
Views
53K
katiemcat
katiemcat
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
45K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
Top